A18081:505
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]The rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: against Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: agaynst Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second ansvuer, touching the Church discipline
Basel: printed by Thomas Guarinus, 1577
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
In the next division, to divers reasons against this ceremony in Baptism, both simply, and in respect of the present time, he answereth not a word: only, he passeth the time, in showing how the papists used it otherwise, then we do, which is not in question. In the next, to that alleged of the signification, making it more popish: he answereth, that the papists did not declare the signification, and that they were therefore dumb with them: as though their pulpits rung not oftentimes, of such unsavoury voices, or that a number of the simpler papists, knew not this popish divinity. To that, that it bringeth in a new word into the church: he answereth, that there is nothing against it in the word, which is untrue. For, although the ceremony of crossing, were convenient, yet to raise a doctrine of it, is unlawful: forasmuch, as it is not enough to teach the truth, unless it be truly taught, and that is, only out of the word of god. Now, let him show a word of god, that two lines laid crosswise: signifieth, that we should not be ashamed, of the passion or cross of Christ.
In the next diuision, to diuers reasons against this ceremony in Baptim, boeth simply, and in respect of the present tyme, he answereth not a word: onely, he passeth the tyme, in shewing how the papistes vsed yt otherwise, then we doe, which is not in question. In the next, to that alledged of the signification, making yt more popish: he answereth, that the papistes did not declare the signification, and that they were therefore dumb with them: as thowgh their pulpites rung not oftentymes, of such vnsauory voices, or that a number of the simpler papistes, knw not this popish deuinity. To that, that yt bringeth in a nue vuord into the church: he answereth, that there is nothing against yt in the word, which is vntrue. For, althowgh the ceremony of crossing, were conuenient, yet to rayse a doctrine of yt, is vnlawful: for asmuch, as yt is not enowgh to teach the truth, vnles yt be truly tawght, and that is, onely owt of the word of god. Now, let hym shew a word of god, that two lynes laid croswise: signifieth, that we should not be ashamed, of the passion or cros of Christ.
Hitherto belongeth, that which he hath 291, touching the surplice: where it appeareth, that his defence in this cause, is speckled and of divers colours. For there, in the first section, he giveth plainly to understand, that he alloweth not, that a man should draw any such signification from the apparel, as the admonition doeth, from sitting at the lords supper. Now, the signification it bringeth, of rest, and of a full finishing, through Christ, of all the ceremonial law, and of a perfect redemption wrought, that giveth rest for ever: is a holy doctrine, therefore it followeth, that he will not have, so much as an holy and an agreeable doctrine, unto the rest of the scriptures, fetched out of the wearing of the apparel: which is the same thing, which I affirm: namely, that it is not enough, that the thing signified, be according to the scripture, onles the signification it self, be raised and grounded of the scripture.