A18081:548
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]The rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: against Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: agaynst Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second ansvuer, touching the Church discipline
Basel: printed by Thomas Guarinus, 1577
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Whether the Magistrate may command a several apparel, is another question from this, whether he may command the popish: considering, that he that getteth the first, hath not therefore won the second: whereunto, the D. beside words partly idle, of genus taken universaliter, partly both idle and fond, of Totum in modo &c, answereth not. But now, in stead of his former affirmation which was, that the Magistrate may appoint a several apparel: he hath set down that he may appoint any kind of apparel: As if these two, to appoint an apparel, and to appoint any apparel, were all one. In which dealing, let it be observed, that where in his first affirmation, he would have fain changed his question, of the popish apparel, for a better: now, to defend his wandering, he hath, for a cause which was not good before, gotten one which is a great deal worse: the nourishing whereof, will stand him in more, then did the other. So that, in stead of setting on a piece: he hath here made the rent, a great deal bigger. For, if the Magistrate may lawfully command the Ministers, any kind of apparel: he may command them to wear purple coloured garments, which being comely for c youth, should not be so for the Minister, that1 beareth the person of an ancient. Likewise, he might command them to wear (as dHippodamas did) furred clothes both winter, and summer: also a Soldiers weed, which M. Calvin (of whom he seeketh favour in this cause) e affirmeth ⟨p. 249⟩to be against common sense: how much more, if he should command them, to wear a woman's habit. If you except, that these things be not comely: nether is that required (for any thing that I can see) by your defence but only, that he propound it, as a thing for comeliness and orders sake, without any conscience of religion. Although, to answer, that these things are uncomely and unorderly, and that the surplice and cope &c are comely and orderly: is only, a bare demand of that in question: Beside that, when any of these kinds of apparel should be established, by the superior powers, as orderly and comely: you teach us, that it belongeth not unto us, which are private, to judg whether it be otherwise, but to them alone.
Vuhether the Magistrate may commād a seueral apparel, is another questiō frō this, vuhether he may cōmand the popish: considering, that he that getteth the first, hath not therefore won the second: whereunto, the D. beside wordes partly idle, of genus taken vniuersaliter, partly boeth idle and fond, of Totum in modo &c, answereth not. But now, in sted of his former affirmation which was, that the Magistrate may appoint a seueral apparel: he hath set down that he may appoint any kinde of apparel: As yf these two, to appoint an apparel, and to appoint any apparel, were al one. In which dealing, let yt be obserued, that where in his first affirmation, he would haue fayn changed his question, of the popish apparel, for a better: now, to defend his wandring, he hath, for a cause which was not good before, gotten one which is a great deal wors: the norishing whereof, wil stand hym in more, then did the other. So that, in sted of setting on a peece: he hath here made the rent, a great deal bigger. For, if the Magistrate may lawfully command the Ministers, any kinde of apparel: he may commād them to wear purple colored garmentes, which being comely for c youth, should not be so for the Minister, that