A18081:551
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]The rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: against Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: agaynst Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second ansvuer, touching the Church discipline
Basel: printed by Thomas Guarinus, 1577
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Howbeit, the Answ. which in delivering his reasons by tale, oftentimes giveth but eleven to the dozen: hath given us here at unawares, thirteen. For as for his former reasons, if it had not been, in such a slippery place of the obedience unto the Magistrate, with the contrary whereof, he so often and so unjustly chargeth us: I would not have once, vouchsafed to have named them. His reason, that other wise men may allege, that they need not to be prescribed in their apparel, which he counteth not: hath, of all other, the greatest colour, and yet it is answered before. For, although there be, which know how to wear their apparel, as well as the Ministers: yet by calling there is none, of whom it ought to be so much presumed, as of them: it being, as it was alleged, within the acompass of their charge, to teach the people to wear theirs: which charge of teaching the people, belongeth to no other estate. There being therefore, so good reason, why the Minister should be left unto his honest liberty, in this matter: it must needs seem hard, that his estate, should herein be inferior almost, nay altogether to all the orders and estates in the land. For, the Judges, Sergeants, and Aldermen's several apparel, is not (for any thing I could ever learn) so enjoined them: but that they may some times, and that in public places, use the apparel, which to them selves seemeth good. And, I would know of the Ans. which maketh such ado about this saying: whether he thinketh, that if the ⟨p. 251⟩Magistrate should appoint the Minister, a several and prescript diet from all other men, he should not do that, with some injury unto the ministry. And verily, the case is not unlike: especially, seeing in S. John Baptists ministry, which the lord would have discerned, he would have it aswell discerned, by a special diet, as by a special apparel. At the least, this is certain, that if it be well reasoned of him, that it is convenient, to appoint the Ministers of the gospel a several apparel, because John Baptist had so: it is as good a reason, that the Ministers, should have a several diet appointed them, because S. John had so.
Howbeit, the Answ. which in deliuering his reasons by tale, oftentymes giueth but eleuen to the dosen: hath giuen vs here at vnwares, thirten. For as for his former reasons, yf yt had not bene, in such a slippery place of the obedience vnto the Magistrate, with the contrary whereof, he so often and so vniustly chargeth vs: I would not haue once, vouchsafed to haue named them. His reason, that other wise men may alledg, that they nede not to be prescribed in their apparel, which he counteth not: hath, of al other, the greatest colour, and yet yt is answered before. For, althowgh there be, which know how to wear their apparel, as wel as the Ministers: yet by calling there is none, of whome yt owght to be so much presumed, as of them: yt being, as yt was alledged, vuithin the