A19142:1521
A fresh suit against human ceremonies in God's worship. Or a triplication unto. D.…A fresh suit against human ceremonies in God's vvorship. Or a triplication unto. D.…
A fresh suit against human ceremonies in God's worship. Or a triplication unto. D. Burgess his rejoinder for D. Morton The first partA fresh suit against human ceremonies in God's vvorship. Or a triplication unto. D. Burgesse his rejoinder for D. Morton The first part
Amsterdam: printed by the successors of Giles Thorp, 1633
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. The Defender his answer to the foresaid Assumption, was by the Replier thus collected: These Ceremonies are either generally, or individually, and numerally the same, that have been abused to Idolatry. If generally, then it hindereth not, but they may still be lawfully used, though they have been so abused: If individually, then it is not true, which is affirmed (in the Assumption) neither doeth it follow from thence, that they must be abolished, because they have been so abused, except they be the same formally, that is, in intention and opinion of those that impose & practise them. For this he is accused by the Rejoinder of doing no justice, but playing a thieves part, who changeth coats with an honest passenger. Now for this, to spare the labour of writing out again many lines, I desire the Reader to look upon the Defender his words as they are reprinted by the Rejoinder himself, pag. 561. & compare them with the Replier his sum. If he can discern any difference, let the Defender be the honest man, and the Replier, what it pleaseth the Rejoinder to make him. No material difference is noted by the Rejoinder but only that the Defender hath not those words (if generally, then it hindereth not, but they may still be lawfully used, though they have been so abused) nor any thing which will bear such a collection. To which I oppose those words of the Def. If you take it in the generality, then cannot you justify any one of your Ceremonies, belonging to Order and Decency. For they have been some way abused. Was it not his meaning, to say, that as other Ceremonies of Order, so these in question, if they be only generally the same with those ⟨p. 478⟩that have been abused, may be justified, that is, lawfully used? Let the Defender hold his own coat: then he cannot so easily escape, without being discerned, as the Rejoinder by changing, would have him. Certainly the Replier did not the evishly take his coat from him nor had he any cause to wish either it to himself, or his to the Defender for any advantage that he might get by that change.
2. The Defender his answer to the foresayd Assumption, was by the Replier thus collected: These Ceremonies are eyther generally, or individually, and numerally the same, that have been abused to Idolatrie. If generally, then it hindereth not, but they may still be lawfully used, though they have been so abused: If individually, then it is not true, which is affirmed (in the Assumption) neyther doeth it follow from thence, that they must be abolished, because they have been so abused, except they be the same formally, that is, in intention and opinion of those that impose & practise them. For this he is accused by the Rejoynder of doeing no justice, but playing a theefes part, whoe changeth coates with an honest passenger. Now for this, to spare the labor of writing out againe many lines, I desire the Reader to looke upon the Defender his wordes as they are reprinted by the Rejoynder himself, pag. 561. & compare them with the Replier his summe. If he can discerne any difference, let the Defender be the honest man, and the Replier, what it pleaseth the Rejoynder to make him. No material difference is noted by the Rejoynder but onely that the Defender hath not those words (if generally, then it hindereth not, but they may still be lawfuly used, though they have been so abused) nor any thing which will bear such a collection. To which I oppose those words of the Def. If you take it in the generalitie, then cannot you justifie any one of your Ceremonies, belonging to Order and Decencie. For they have been some way abused. Was it not his meaning, to say, that as other Ceremonies of Order, so these in quaestion, if they be onely generally the same with those