A19563:1766
An answerAn aunsvvere
An answer by the Reverend Father in God Thomas Archbishop of Canterbury, primate of all England and metropolitan, unto a crafty and sophistical cavillation, devised by Stephen Gardiner Doctor of Law, late Bishop of Winchester against the true and godly doctrine of the most holy sacrament, of the body and blood of our saviour Jesus Christ Wherein is also, as occasion serveth, answered such places of the book of Doct. Richard Smith, as may seem any thing worthy the answering. Here is also the true copy of the book written, and in open court delivered, by D. Stephen Gardiner ...An aunsvvere by the Reuerend Father in God Thomas Archbyshop of Canterbury, primate of all England and metropolitane, vnto a craftie and sophisticall cauillation, deuised by Stephen Gardiner Doctour of Law, late Byshop of Winchester agaynst the true and godly doctrine of the most holy sacrament, of the body and bloud of our sauiour Iesu Christ Wherein is also, as occasion serueth, aunswered such places of the booke of Doct. Richard Smith, as may seeme any thyng worthy the aunsweryng. Here is also the true copy of the booke written, and in open court deliuered, by D. Stephen Gardiner ...
London: printed by John Daye, 1580London: printed by Iohn Daye, 1580
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And all this that you have brought in here of these two heresies, although it be to no purpose in the principal matter, yet it serveth me to this purpose, that men may conjecture whose nature and wit is most like unto the description of Nestorius, & also how loth you be to come to the matter, & to make a direct answer to Gelasius words, who saith in plain terms, that substance or nature of bread & wine remaineth. Even as glad you be to come to this, as a Bear is to come to the stake, seeking to run out at this corner or that corner, if it were possible. But all will not help, for you be so fast tied in chains, that (will you, nill you) at length you must come to the stake, although you be never so loth. And Gelasius byteth so sore, & hath catched so hard hold of you, that you can never escape, although you attempt all manner of ways, by tooth and by nail, to shake him of.
And all this that you haue brought in here of these two heresies, although it be to no purpose in the principall matter, yet it serueth me to this purpose, that men may cōiecture whose nature and witte is most like vnto the description of Nestorius, & also how loth you be to come to the matter, & to make a direct aunswere to Gelasius wordes, who sayth in playne termes, that substaūce or nature of bread & wine remaineth. Euē as glad you be to come to this, as a Beare is to come to the stake, seeking to runne out at this corner or that corner, if it were possible. But all will not helpe, for you be so fast tyed in chaynes, yt (will you, nill you) at length you must come to the stake, although you be neuer so loth. And Gelasius byteth so sore, & hath catched so hard hold of you, that you cā neuer escape, although you attempt all maner of wayes, by tooth and by nayle, to shake him of.
First you would shake him of by this pretence that he useth his two Arguments of the two examples of man, and the Sacrament, against the Eutychians only. But Gelasius will not so easily leave his hold. For he speaketh indifferently as well against the Nestorians as the Eutychians, declaring by these two examples, how two different natures may remain in Christ, and that the integrity of Christ can not be, except both the different natures remain in their properties, which condemneth both the foresaid heresies, that affirmed but one nature to be in Christ, the Eutychians his divinity, and the Nestorians his humanity. And yet if he had used these examples against the Eutychians only, they byte you as sore, as if they were used against them both. For if he conclude by these two examples, against the Eutychians (as you say he doth) that the integrity of Christ can not be but both natures different, (that is to say, his manhood and Godhead) must remain in their property, then must it needs be so in the examples also. And then as Christ had in him two natures, with their natural properties, neither perishing, but both remaining, and as man hath in him two natures (the soul and the body) both remaining still, so