pp. 3941,982 passagespart 1 of 50
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
HERE before the beginning of your book, you have prefixed a goodly title, but it agreeth with the argument and matter thereof, as water agreeth with the fire. For your book is so far from an explication and assertion of the true catholic faith in the matter of the sacrament, that it is but a crafty cavillation and subtle sophistication, to obscure the truth thereof, and to hide the same, that it should not appear. And in your whole book, the reader (if he mark it well) shall easily perceive, how little learning is showed therein and how few authors you have alleged, other then such as I brought forth in my book, and made answer unto: but there is showed what may be done by fine wit, and new devises, to deceive the reader, and by false interpretations to avoid the plain words of scripture and of the old authors.
HERE before the beginning of your booke, you haue prefixed a goodly title, but it agreeth with the argument and matter therof, as water agreeth with the fire. For your booke is so farre from an explication and assertion of the true catholike fayth in the matter of the sacrament, that it is but a crafty cauillation and subtile sophisticatiō, to obscure the truth therof, and to hyde the same, that it should not appeare. And in your whole booke, the reader (if he marke it wel) shal easily perceiue, how little learning is shewed therin and how few authors you haue alleadged, other then such as I brought forth in my booke, and made aunswer vnto: but there is shewed what may be done by fine wit, and new deuises, to deceiue the reader, and by false interpretations to auoyde the plain wordes of scripture and of the old authors.
Wherefore in as much as I purpose God willing, in this defence of my former book, not only to answer you, but by the way also to touch D. Smith two things I would wish in you both: The one is truth with simplicity: the other is, that either of you both had so much learning as you think you have, or else that you thought of your self no more then you have in deed: but to aū swer both your books in few words: that one showeth nothing else, but what railing without reason or learning: the other what frowardness armed with wit and eloquence, be able to do against the truth. And Smith because he would be vehement, and show his heat in the manner of speech, where the matter is cold, hath framed in a manner all his sentences through out his whole book, by interrogations. But if the reader of both your books do no more, but diligently read over my book once again, he shall find the same not so slenderly made, but that I have foreseen all that […] ⟨p. 2⟩could be said to the contrary: and that I have fully answered before hand all that you both have said, or is able to say.
Wherfore in as much as I purpose God willing, in this defēce of my former book, not only to aunswer you, but by ye way also to touch D. Smith two things I would wish in you both: The one is truth wt simplicitie: the other is, yt either of you both had so much learning as you think you haue, or els yt you thought of your selfe no more then you haue in dede: but to aū swer both your bokes in few words: yt one sheweth nothing els, but what rayling without reason or learning: the other what frowardnes armed with wit and eloquence, be able to do against the truth. And Smith because he would be vehement, and shew his heat in the maner of speach, where the matter is cold, hath framed in a maner all his sentēces through out his whole booke, by interrogations. But if the reader of both your bookes do no more, but diligently read ouer my booke once agayn, he shal fynde the same not so slenderly made, but that I haue foreseene all that 〈…〉 ⟨p. 2⟩could be sayd to the contrary: and that I haue fully aunswered before hand all that you both haue sayd, or is able to say.
Forasmuch as among other mine allegations for defence of §1my self in this matter, moved against me by occasion of my Sermon made before the kings most excellent majesty, touching partly the catholic faith of the most precious sacrament of the altar, which I see §2now impugned, by a book set forth under the name of my lord of Canterburies grace: I have thought expedient for the better opening of the matter, and considering I am by name touched in the said book, the rather to utter partly that I have to say by confutation of that book, wherein I think nevertheless not §3requisite to direct any speech by special name to the person of him that is entitled author,1 because it may possible he that his name is abused, wherewith to set forth the matter being himself of such dignity and authority in the common wealth, as for that respect should be inviolable. For which consideration, I shall in my speech of such reproof as the untruth of the matter necessarily requireth, omitting the special title of the author of the book, speak only of the author in general, being a thing to me greatly to be marvelled at, that such matter should now be published out of my lord of Canterburies pen, but because he is a man, I will not wonder, and because he is such a man, I will reverently use him, and forbearing further to name him, talk only of the author by that general name.
FOrasmuch as amonge other myne allegations for defence of §1my selfe in this matter, moued against me by occasion of my Sermon made before the kinges most excellent maiestie, touching partly the catholike fayth of the most precious sacrament of the aulter, which I see §2now impugned, by a booke set forth vnder the name of my lord of Canterburies grace: I haue thought expedient for the better opening of the matter, and considering I am by name touched in the sayd booke, the rather to vtter partly that I haue to say by confutation of that booke, wherin I thinke neuerthelesse not §3requisite to direct any speach by speciall name to the person of him that is entituled author,1
The first entry of your book showeth to them that be wise, what they §1may look for in the rest of the same, except the beginning vary from all that followeth.1 Now the beginning is framed with such sleight & subtlety, that it may deceive the reader notably in two things. The one, that he should think you were called into judgement before the kings majesties commissioners at Lambeth for your catholic faith in the Sacrament: The other, that you made your book for your defence therein, which be both utterly untrue For your book was made or ever ye were called before the said commissioners, and after you were called, then you altered only two lines in the beginning of your book, and made that beginning which it hath now. This am I able to prove, as well otherwise, as by a book which I have of your own hand writing, wherein appeareth plainly the alteration of the beginning.
THe first entrie of your booke sheweth to them that be wise, what they §1may looke for in the rest of the same, except the beginning vary from all that followeth.1 Now the beginning is framed with such sleight & subtletie, that it may deceiue the reader notably in two thinges. The one, that he should thinke you were called into iudgement before the kinges maiesties commissioners at Lamhith for your catholike faith in the Sacrament: The other, that you made your booke for your defence therein, which be both vtterly vntrue For your booke was made or euer ye were called before the said commissioners, and after you were called, then you altered only two lines in the beginning of your booke, and made that beginning which it hath now. This am I able to proue, as well otherwise, as by a booke which I haue of your owne hand writing, wherin appeareth plainly the alteration of the beginning.
And as concerning the cause wherefore ye were called before the Commissioners, whereas by your own importune suit and procurement, and as it were enforcing the matter, you were called to justice for your manifest contempt and continual disobedience from time to time, or rather rebellion against the kings majesty, and were justly deprived of your estate for the same, you would turn it now to a matter of the sacrament, that the world should think your trouble rose for your faith in the sacrament, which was no matter nor occasion thereof, nor no such matter was objected against you, wherefore you need to make any such defence. And where you would make that matter the occasion of your worthy deprivation and punishment, (which was no cause thereof) and cloak your wilful obstinacy and disobedience (which was the only cause thereof) all men of judgement may well perceive, that you could mean no goodness thereby, neither to the kings majesty, nor to his realm.
And as concerning the cause wherfore ye were called before the Commissioners, whereas by your owne importune sute and procurement, and as it were enforcing the matter, you were called to iustice for your manifest contempt and continuall disobedience from tyme to tyme, or rather rebellion against the kinges maiestie, and were iustly depriued of your estate for the same, you would turne it now to a matter of the sacrament, that the world should thinke your trouble rose for your fayth in the sacrament, which was no matter nor occasion therof, nor no such matter was obiected against you, wherfore you nede to make any such defence. And where you would make that matter the occasion of your worthy depriuation and punishment, (which was no cause therof) and cloke your wilfull obstinacie and disobedience (which was the onely cause therof) all mē of iudgement may well perceiue, that you could meane no goodnes therby, neither to the kinges maiestie, nor to his realme.
But as touching the matter now in controversy, I impugn not the true §2catholic faith which was taught by Christ and his Apostles (as you say ⟨p. 3⟩I do) but I impugn the false Papistical faith, invented, devised, and imagined by Antichrist and his ministers.
But as touching the matter now in controuersie, I impugn not ye true §2catholike faith which was taught by Christ and his Apostles (as you say ⟨p. 3⟩I do) but I impugne the false Papisticall faith, inuented, deuised, and imagined by Antichrist and his ministers.
And as for further forbearing of my name, and talking of the Author in general (after that you have named me once, and your whole book is directed against my book, openly set out in my name) all men may judge that your doing herein, is not for reverence to be used unto me, but that by suppressing of my name, you may the more unreverently and unseemly use your scoffing, taunting, railing, and defaming of the author in general, and yet shall every man understand, that your speech is directed to me in especial, as well as if you had appointed me with your finger. And your reverent using of your self, before the kings highness commissioners of late, doth plainly declare, what reverent respect you have to them that be in dignity and authority in the common wealth.
And as for further forbearing of my name, and talking of the Author in generall (after that you haue named me once, and your whole booke is directed against my booke, openly set out in my name) all men may iudge that your doing herein, is not for reuerence to be vsed vnto me, but that by suppressing of my name, you may the more vnreuerently and vnseemely vse your scoffing, taunting, rayling, and defaming of the author in generall, and yet shall euery man vnderstand, that your speach is directed to me in especiall, as wel as if you had appointed me with your finger. And your reuerent vsing of your selfe, before the kings highnes commissioners of late, doth plainly declare, what reuerent respect you haue to them that be in dignitie and authoritie in the common wealth.
This author denieth the real presence of Christs most precious body and blood in the Sacrament.
THis author denieth the reall presence of Christes most precious body and bloud in the Sacrament.
The sum of the book.
The summe of the booke.
This author denieth Transubstantiation.
This author denieth evil men to eat and drink the body and blood of Christ in the Sacrament.
This author denieth euill men to eate and drinke the body and bloud of Christ in the Sacrament.
These three denials only impugn and tend to destroy that faith which this author fermeth the Popish to err in, calling now all popish that believe either of these three articles by him denied, the truth whereof shall hereafter be opened.
These thre denials only impugne and tend to destroy that faith which this author fermeth the Popish to erre in, calling now all popish that beleue either of these thre articles by him denied, the truth wherof shall hereafter be opened.
Now because faith affirmeth some certainty:1 if we ask this author what is his saith which he calleth true and catholic, it is only this, as we may learn by his book, that in our Lords supper be consecrate bread and wine, and delivered as tokens only to signify Christs body and blood, he calleth them holy tokens, but yet noteth that the bread and wine be never the holier, he saith nevertheless they be not bare tokens, and yet concludeth, §2Christ not to be spiritually present in them, but only as a thing is present in that which signifieth it (which is the nature of a bare token) saying in an other place,2 there is nothing to be worshipped, for there is nothing present, but in figure & in a sign: which who so ever saith, calleth the thing in deed absent. And yet the author saith: Christ is in §3the man that worthily receiveth, spiritually present, who eateth of Christs flesh and his §4blood reigning in heaven, whether the good believing man ascendeth by his faith. And as our body is nourished with the bread and wine received in the supper: so the true believing man is fed with the body and blood of Christ. And this is the sum of the doctrine of that faith, which this author calleth the true catholic faith.
Now because faith affirmeth some certaintie:1 if we aske this author what is his saith which he calleth true and catholike, it is onely this, as we may learne by his booke, that in our Lordes supper be consecrate bread and wyne, and deliuered as tokens only to signifie Christes body and bloud, he calleth them holy tokens, but yet noteth that the bread and wyne be neuer the holyer, he sayth neuerthelesse they be not bare tokens, and yet cō cludeth, §2Christ not to be spiritually present in them, but only as a thyng is present in that which signifieth it (which is the nature of a bare token) saying in an other place,2 there is nothing to be worshipped, for there is nothyng present, but in figure & in a signe: which who so euer saith, calleth the thyng in deede absent. And yet the author sayth: Christ is in
I Desire the Reader to judge my faith not by this short, envious, and untrue collection and report, but by mine own book, as it is at length set out in the first part, from the 8. unto the 16. chapter.
I Desire the Reader to iudge my faith not by this short, enuious, and vntrue collection and reporte, but by mine owne booke, as it is at length set out in the first part, from the 8. vnto the 16. chapter.
And as concerning holiness of bread and wine (whereunto I may add the water into baptism) how can a dumb or an insensible and lifeless creature receive into it self any food,1 and feed thereupon? No more is it possible that a spiritless creature should receive any spiritual sanctification or holiness. And yet do I not utterly deprive the outward sacraments of the name of holy things, because of the holy use whereunto they serve, & not because of any holiness that lieth hid in the insensible creature. Which although they have no holiness in them, yet they be signs and tokens of the marvellous works and holy effects, which god worketh in us by his omnipotent power.
And as concerning holynes of bread and wine (wherunto I may adde the water into baptisme) how can a dombe or an insensible and liuelesse creature receiue into it selfe any foode,1 and feede thereupon? No more is it possible that a spiritlesse creature should receiue any spirituall sanctification or holynes. And yet do I not vtterly depriue the outward sacramēts of the name of holy thinges, because of the holy vse wherunto they serue, & not because of any holynesse yt lyeth hid in the insensible creature. Which although they haue no holynes in them, yet they be signes and tokens of the meruailous workes and holy effects, which god worketh in vs by his omnipotent power.
1And they be no vain or bare tokens, as you would persuade (for a bare token is that which betokeneth only and geneth nothing, as a painted fire, which giveth neither light nor heat) but in the due ministration of the Sacraments God is present, working with his word and Sacraments.
1And they be no vayne or bare tokens, as you would perswade (for a bare token is that which betokeneth only and geneth nothing, as a painted fire, which geueth neither light nor heate) but in the due ministration of the Sacramentes God is present, working with his worde and Sacramentes.
And although (to speak properly) in the bread and wine be nothing in §3deed to be worshipped, yet in them that duly receive the sacraments is Christ himself inhabiting, and is of all creatures to be worshipped.
And although (to speake properly) in the bread and wine be nothing in §3dede to be worshipped, yet in them that duely receiue the sacramentes is Christ himself inhabiting, and is of all creatures to be worshipped.
1And therefore you gather of my sayings unjustly, that Christ is in deed §4absent, for I say (according to Gods word and the doctrine of the old writers) that Christ is present in his sacraments, as they teach also that he is present in his word, when he worketh mightily by the same, in the hearts of the hearers. By which manner of speech it is not meant that Christ is corporally present in the voice or sound of the speaker (which sound perisheth as soon as the words be spoken) but this speech meaneth that he worketh with his word, using the voice of the speaker, as his instrument to work by, as he useth also his sacraments whereby he worketh, & therefore is said to be present in them.
1And therfore you gather of my sayings vniustly, that Christ is in deede §4absent, for I say (according to Gods worde and the doctrine of the olde writers) that Christ is present in his sacramentes, as they teach also that he is present in his worde, when he worketh mightely by the same, in the hartes of the hearers. By which maner of speach it is not ment that Christ is corporally present in the voyce or sound of the speaker (which sound perisheth as soone as the wordes be spoken) but this speach meaneth that he worketh with his word, vsing the voyce of the speaker, as his instrument to worke by, as he vseth also his sacramentes wherby he worketh, & therfore is said to be present in them.
1Now a catholic faith, is an universal faith taught and preached through all, and so §1received and believed, agreeable and consonant to the scriptures, testified by such as by all ages have in their writings given knowledge thereof;2 which be the tokens and marks of a true catholic faith, whereof no one can be found in the faith this author calleth catholic.
1Now a catholike faith, is an vniuersall faith taught and preached through all, and so §1receiued and beleued, agreable and consonant to the scriptures, testified by such as by all ages haue in their writinges geuen knowledge therof;2 which be the tokens and markes of a true catholike faith, whereof no one can be found in the faith this author calleth catholike.
1First there is no scripture that in letter maintaineth the doctrine of this authors book. for Christ saith not that the bread doth o••ly signify his body absent, nor S Paul saith §2not so in any place, ne any other Canonical Scripture declareth Christs words so. As §3for the sense and understanding of Christs words, there hath not been in any age any one approved and known learned man, that hath so declared and expounded Christs words in his supper, that the bread did only signify Christs body, and the wine his blood as things absent.
1First there is no scripture that in letter maynteineth ye doctrine of this authors booke. for Christ sayth not that the bread doth o••ly signifie his body absent, nor S Paul saith §2not so in any place, ne any other Canonicall Scripture declareth Christes wordes so. As §3for the sence and vnderstanding of Christes wordes, there hath not bene in any age any one approued and knowen learned man, that hath so declared and expounded Christes wordes in his supper, that the bread did onely signifie Christes body, and the wyne his bloud as thinges absent.
The first part of your description of a catholic faith, is crafty and full §1of subtlety,1 for what you mean by (all) you do not express. The second part is very true, and agreeth fully with my doctrine in every thing, as well in the matter of transubstantiation, of the presence of Christ in the sacrament, and of the eating and drinking of him, as in the sacrifice propitiatory. For as I have taught in these 4. matters of controversy, so learned I the same of the holy scripture, so is it testified by all old writers & learned men of all ages, so was it universally taught and preached, received & believed, until the sea of Rome, the chief adversary unto Christ, corrupted all together, and by hypocrisy and simulation, in the stead of Christ, erected Antichrist, who being the son of perdition, hath extolled and advanced himself, and sitteth in the temple of God, as he were God himself, losing and binding at his pleasure, in heaven, hell, and earth: condemning, absolving, canonising & damning, as to his judgement he thinketh good.
THe first part of your description of a catholike faith, is crafty and full §1of subtletie,1 for what you meane by (all) you do not expresse. The secōd part is very true, and agreeth fully with my doctrine in euery thing, as wel in the matter of transubstantiation, of the presence of Christ in the sacrament, and of the eating and drinking of him, as in the sacrifice propitiatory. For as I haue taught in these 4. matters of controuersie, so learned I the same of the holy scripture, so is it testified by all olde writers & learned men of all ages, so was it vniuersally taught and preached, receiued & beleued, vntill the sea of Rome, the chiefe aduersary vnto Christ, corrupted all together, and by hypocrisie and simulation, in the stede of Christ, erected Autichrist, who being the sonne of perdition, hath extolled and aduanced himselfe, and sitteth in the temple of God, as he were God himselfe, losing and bynding at his pleasure, in heauen, hell, and earth: condemning, absoluing, canonising & damning, as to his iudgement he thinketh good.
But as concerning your doctrine of Transubstantiation, of the real, corporal and natural presence of Christs body in the bread, and blood in the wine: that ill men do eat his flesh and drink his blood: that Christ is ⟨p. 5⟩§2many times offered, there is no scripture that in letter maintaineth any of them (as you require in a catholic faith) but the scripture in the letter doth maintain this my doctrine plainly, that the bread remaineth, Panis quem frangimus, 1nonne communicatio corporis Christi est? Is not the bread which we break, the communion of Christs body? And that evil men do not eat Christ his flesh, nor drink his blood, for the scripture saith expressly: He that eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood,2 dwelleth in me and I in him, which is not true of ill men. And for the corporal absence of Christ, what can be more plainly said in the letter, then he said of himself, that he forsook the world?3 besides other scriptures which I have alleged in my 3. book, the 4. chapter. And the scripture speaketh plainly in the Epistle to the Hebrews,4 that Christ was never more offered then once.
But as concerning your doctrine of Transubstantiation, of the reall, corporall and naturall presence of Christes body in the bread, and bloud in the wyne: that ill men do eate his flesh and drinke his bloud: that Christ is ⟨p. 5⟩§2many tymes offred, there is no scripture that in letter mainteyneth any of them (as you require in a catholike faith) but the scripture in ye letter doth mainteine this my doctrine plainly, that the bread remaineth, Panis quem frangimus, 1nonne communicatio corporis Christi est? Is not ye bread which we breake, the communion of Christes body? And that euill men do not eate Christe his fleshe, nor drinke his bloud, for the scripture saith expressely: He that eateth my flesh and drinketh my bloud,
But here you take such a large scope that you flee from the four proper matters that be in controversy,1 unto a new scope devised by you, that I should absolutely deny the presence of Christ, and say: That the bread doth only signify Christs body absent, which thing I never said nor thought. And as Christ saith not so, nor Paul saith not so, even so like wise I say not so, and my book in divers places saith clean contrary, that Christ is with us spiritually present, is eaten & drunken of us, and dwelleth within us, although corporally he be departed out of this world, and is ascended up into heaven.
But here you take such a large scope that you flee from the foure proper matters that be in controuersie,1 vnto a new scope deuised by you, that I should absolutely deny the presence of Christ, and say: That the bread doth only signifie Christes body absent, which thing I neuer said nor thought. And as Christ sayth not so, nor Paule sayth not so, euen so like wise I say not so, and my booke in diuers places saith cleane contrary, that Christ is with vs spiritually present, is eaten & dronken of vs, and dwelleth within vs, although corporally he be departed out of this world, and is ascended vp into heauen.
And to the intent every notable disagreement from the truth may the more evidently appear.1 I will here in this place (as I will hereafter likewise when the case occurreth) join as it were an issue with this author, that is to say, to make a stay with him in this point triable (as they say) by evidence and soon tried. For in this point the scriptures be already by the author brought forth, the letter whereof proveth not his faith. And albeit he travaileth & bringeth forth the saying of many approved writers, yet is there no one of them that writeth in express words the doctrine of that faith, which this author calleth the faith catholic. And to make the issue plain, and to join it directly, thus I say.
And to the entent euery notable disagréement from the truth may the more euidently appeare.1 I will here in this place (as I will hereafter likewyse when the case occurreth) ioyne as it were an issue with this author, that is to say, to make a stay with him in this point triable (as they say) by euidence and soone tried. For in this point the scriptures bee already by the author brought forth, the letter wherof proueth not his fayth. And albeit he trauaileth & bringeth forth the saying of many approued writers, yet is there no one of them that writeth in expresse wordes the doctrine of that faith, which this author calleth the faith catholike. And to make the issue playne, and to ioyne it directly, thus I say.
No author known and approved,1 that is to say, Ignatius, Polycarp, Justine, Irene, Tertullian, Cyprian, Chrysostom, Hilary, Gregory Nazianzene, Basil, Emissen, Ambrose, Cyril, Hierome, Augustine, Damascene, Theophilast, none of these hath this doctrine in plain terms,2 that the bread only signifieth Christs body absent, nor this sentence, that the bread and wine be never the holier after consecration, nor that Christs body is none otherwise present in the Sacrament, but in a signification: nor this sentence, that the Sacrament is not to be worshipped, because there is nothing present but in a sign. And herein what the truth is, may soon appear, as it shall by their works never appear to have ben taught and preached, received and believed universally, and therefore can be called no catholic faith (that is to say) allowed in the whole, through and in outward teaching,3 preached and believed.
No author known and approued,1 that is to say, Ignatius, Polycarpe, Iustine, Irene, Tertullian, Cyprian, Chrysostome, Hilary, Gregory Nazianzene, Basill, Emissen, Ambrose, Cyrill, Hierome, Augustine, Damascene, Theophilast, none of these hath this doctrine in playne termes,2 that the bread onely signifieth Christes body absent, nor this sentence, that the bread and wyne be neuer the holyer after consecration, nor that Christes body is none otherwyse present in the Sacrament, but in a signification: nor this sentēce, that the Sacrament is not to be worshipped, because there is nothyng present but in a signe. And herein what the truth is, may soone appeare, as it shall by their workes neuer appeare to haue ben taught and preached, receiued and beleued vniuersally, and therfore can be called no catholike faith (that is to say) allowed in the whole, through and in outward teaching,3 preached and beleued.
IN your issues you make me to say what you list, and take your issue where you list, and then if xii. false varlets pass with you, what wonder is it?1 But I will join with you this issue, that neither scripture nor ancient author writeth in express words the doctrine of your faith. And to make the issue plain, & to join directly with you therein, thus I say: That no ancient and catholic author hath your doctrine in plain terms. And because I will not take my issue in bye matters (as you do) I will make if in the four principal points, wherein we vary, & whereupon ⟨p. 6⟩my book resteth.
IN your issues you make me to say what you list, and take your issue where you list, and then if xii. false varlets passe with you, what wonder is it?1 But I will ioyne with you this issue, that neither scripture nor aūcient author writeth in expresse wordes the doctrine of your faith. And to make the issue plaine, & to ioyne directly with you therin, thus I say: That no auncient and catholike authour hath your doctrine in playne termes. And because I will not take my issue in bye matters (as you do) I will make if in the foure principall pointes, wherin we vary, & wherupon ⟨p. 6⟩my booke resteth.
1This therefore shall be mine issue: That as no scripture, so no ancient §2author known and approved, hath in plain terms your Transubstantiation: nor that the body and blood of Christ be really, corporally, naturally, and carnally wider the forms of bread and wine: nor that evil men do eat the very body and drink the very blood of Christ: nor that Christ is offered every day by the priest a sacrifice propitiatory for sin. Wherefore by your own description and rule of a catholic faith, your doctrine and teaching in these 4. articles cannot be good and catholic except you can find it in plain terms, in the scripture and old catholic doctors, which when you do, I will hold up my hand at the bar, and say, guilty: And if you cannot, then it is reason that you do the like, per legem Talionis.
1This therfore shalbe mine issue: That as no scripture, so no auncient §2author known and approued, hath in plaine termes your Transubstantiation: nor that the body and bloud of Christ be really, corporally, naturally, and carnally wider the formes of bread and wine: nor that euil men do eate the very body and drinke the very bloud of Christ: nor that Christ is offered euery day by the priest a sacrifice propiciatorie for sinne. Wherfore by your owne description and rule of a catholike faith, your doctrine and teaching in these 4. articles cannot be good and catholike except you can finde it in plaine termes, in the scripture and old catholike doctors, which when you do, I will hold vp my hand at the barre, and say, giltie: And if you cannot, then it is reason that you do the lyke, per legem Talionis.
If this author setting apart the word (Catholic) would of his own will go about to §1prove. howsoever scripture hath been understanded hitherto, yet it should be understanded in deed as he now teacheth, he hath herein divers disadvantages and hindrances worthy consideration, which I will particularly note.
If this author setting apart the worde (Catholike) would of his owne wil go about to §1proue. howsoeuer scripture hath bene vnderstanded hitherto, yet it should be vnderstanded in dede as he now teacheth, he hath herein diuers disaduantages and hindrances worthy consideration, which I will particularly note.
1First, the prejudice and sentence, given as it were by his own mouth against himself,§2 now in the book called the Catechism in his name set forth.
1First, the preiudice and sentence, geuen as it were by his own mouth against himself,§2 now in the booke called the Catechisme in his name set forth.
Secondly, that about vij. C. year ago, one Bertram (if the book set forth in his name §3be his) enterprised secretly the like, as appeareth by the said book, & yet prevailed not.
Secondly, that about vij. C. yere ago, one Bertram (if the booke set forth in hys name §3be his) enterprised secretly the lyke, as appereth by the said booke, & yet preuayled not.