A19563:1931
An answerAn aunsvvere
An answer by the Reverend Father in God Thomas Archbishop of Canterbury, primate of all England and metropolitan, unto a crafty and sophistical cavillation, devised by Stephen Gardiner Doctor of Law, late Bishop of Winchester against the true and godly doctrine of the most holy sacrament, of the body and blood of our saviour Jesus Christ Wherein is also, as occasion serveth, answered such places of the book of Doct. Richard Smith, as may seem any thing worthy the answering. Here is also the true copy of the book written, and in open court delivered, by D. Stephen Gardiner ...An aunsvvere by the Reuerend Father in God Thomas Archbyshop of Canterbury, primate of all England and metropolitane, vnto a craftie and sophisticall cauillation, deuised by Stephen Gardiner Doctour of Law, late Byshop of Winchester agaynst the true and godly doctrine of the most holy sacrament, of the body and bloud of our sauiour Iesu Christ Wherein is also, as occasion serueth, aunswered such places of the booke of Doct. Richard Smith, as may seeme any thyng worthy the aunsweryng. Here is also the true copy of the booke written, and in open court deliuered, by D. Stephen Gardiner ...
London: printed by John Daye, 1580London: printed by Iohn Daye, 1580
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And what should you talk in vain of substance alone, to dazzle the eyes of the ignorant, when there is no such thing, nor never was sithens the world began? and seeing your question in that place is of common bread, where the substance is never alone without accidents? And if the substance of bread might be alone, yet your reason against the breaking of it, is so far from all reason, that it should prove aswell, that the substance joined to the quantity and accidents cannot be broken, as the substance alone. For in every piece of bread is a whole substance, and then by your argument, it cannot be broken.
And what should you talke in vayn of substaunce alone, to dasle the eies of the ignoraunt, when there is no such thing, nor neuer was sithens the world began? and seing your question in that place is of common breade, where the substaunce is neuer alone without accidentes? And if the substaunce of bread might be alone, yet your reason agaynst the breaking of it, is so far from all reason, that it should proue aswell, that the substaunce ioined to the quantity and accidentes cannot be broken, as the substaunce alone. For in euery peece of bread is a whole substaunce, and then by your argument, it cannot be broken.
And where you grant that accidents to be without substance, is against the common course of natural things, but it is done by a spiritual miracle, this is but a cloud to darken the light. For accidents to be without ⟨p. 350⟩substances, is not only against the common course of natural things, but also against the very nature of accidents (which have none other being, but in substances as they be defyned, accidentis esse, estinesse) and is also against all philosophy, reason and working of god sithens the world began. For God never created nor made (with miracle nor without miracle) substances without accidents, nor accidents without substances, as some vaynely phantasy de materia prima. It is against also the doctrine of the old catholic authors, for never none wrote that accidents were without substances, until the Bishop of Rome with his Monks and Fryers defined the contrary.