A19884:566
An apologetical reply to a book called an answer to the unjust complaint of VV.B. Also an answer to Mr. I.D. touching his report of some passages. His allegation of Scriptures against the baptising of some kind of infants. His protestation about the publishing of his writings. By John Davenport BD.An apologeticall reply to a booke called an ansvver to the unjust complaint of VV.B. Also an answer to Mr. I.D. touching his report of some passages. His allegation of Scriptures against the baptising of some kind of infants. His protestation about the publishing of his wrightings. By Iohn Davenporte BD.
Rotterdam: printed by Isaac van Waesberghe, 1636Rotterdam: printed by Isaack van Waesberghe, 1636
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But to administer baptism so promiscuously, as that writing requireth, giveth offence to all these.
But to administer baptisme so promiscuously, as that wrighting requireth, giveth offence to all these.
Therefore to administer baptism so promiscuously &c. is a sin.
Therefore to administer baptisme so promiscuously &c. is a sinne.
Reason. 3 The third Reason to prove it to be a sin, is, because it is a building again of that which these Churches, according to the Scripture, have destroyed.
Reason. 3 The third Reason to prove it to be a sinne, is, because it is a building againe of that which these Churches, according to the Scripture, have destroyed.
This is an Argument, ad hominem, which I restrain to these Churches, to show the evil of this practise from their own principles, which it doth, by consequence, supplant, and subvert, at least, in the judgment of many, whether necessarily or probably, and in what degree, I will leave to their wisdom to consider, contenting my self with a short proposal of some particulars which are considerable, especially that ground being laid which the Apostle maketh use of, in a like case,1 If I build again the things that I have destroyed I make my self a transgressor.
This is an Argument, ad hominem, which I restraine to these Churches, to shew the evill of this practise from their owne principles, which it doth, by consequence, supplant, and subvert, at least, in the judgment of many, whether necessarily or probably, and in what degree, I will leave to their wisdom to consider, contenting my selfe with a short proposall of some particulars which are considerable, especially that ground being layed which the Apostle maketh use of, in a like case,1 If I build againe the things that I have destroyed I make my selfe a transgressour.
First. That baptism is only a naked sign, 1or note of Segregation from other sects, and profession of true doctrine, is an error which these reformed Churches have destroyed, by professing in their ⟨p. 146⟩Confession,2 and Catechism that it is not only so, but also a testimony to us, and a symbol to assure us of remission of sins &c. according to the Scripture(a): But this practise buildeth it again, whilst a naked profession of assent to the doctrine and discipline of this Church is held sufficient to warrant their baptism, though it be made, many times, by such as are not known to have any right in the Covenant, whereof baptism is a seal, or at all to pertain to Christ, but may be any of those, who were spoken of in the first Argument, for aught any man knoweth: Hence some will collect that they do not account Baptism any more then a naked sign of profession. And not only so, but it justifieth that error, as Israel justified Samaria, by establishing a worse. For this practise seemeth to make baptism not so much as a profession of true doctrine, or a note of segregation from other sects, whilst it is appointed to be administered thus promiscuously in Amsterdam (where people of so many sects inhabit) to all infants that are presented, though they make no other show of profession, then by saying, yea, or nodding the head, when they understand not what is said to them, being of a different language, and are altogether unknown to the minister and to the Church.
First. That baptisme is only a naked signe, 1or noate of Segregation from other sects, and profession of true doctrine, is an errour which these reformed Churches have destroyed, by professing in theyr ⟨p. 146⟩Confession,2 and Catechisme that it is not only so, but also a testimony to us, and a symbol to assure us of remission of sinnes &c. according to the Scripture
1Secondly. That the grace of Christ is universal, wherein all have interest is an error which these reformed Churches have destroyed, restraining it only to the Elect, to believers, to the Church of God, according to the Scriptures(b): But this practise buildeth it up. For, if the seal appertain to all, why not the Covenant also? Why not the grace? And who will not suspect that the seal doth appertain to all, in their judgement, whose practise is to administer it to those infants, neither of whose parents are in the covenant, so much as externally, and, it may be, were never baptised, or, having been baptised, have, by their infidelity and other sins obstinately persisted in, (being, convicted thereof and cast out of the Church) or by their wilful Apostasy and forsaking the Religion which they professed, with themselves, broken off their seed, externally and actually from the communion of the Church, and holy things thereof. If they say; ⟨p. 147⟩their grandfather was a Christian, or great grandfather. I answer. Where must we stop at last? If not in the next parents, why in the grandfather, or great grandfather, till we come up as high as Noah himself? And so neither the children of Jews, nor Turks, nor heathen or infidels should be denied baptism.
1Secondly. That the grace of Christ is universall, wherein all have interest is an errour which these reformed Churches have destroyed, restrayning it only to the Elect, to beleivers, to the Church of God, according to the Scriptures(b): But this practise buildeth it up. For, if the seale appertaine to all, why not the Covenant also? Why not the grace? And who will not suspect that the seale doth appertaine to all, in theyr judgement, whose practise is to administer it to those infants, neither of whose parents are in the covenant, so much as externally, and, it may be, were never baptised, or, having bene baptised, have, by their infidelity and other sinnes obstinately persisted in, (being, convicted thereof and cast out of the Church) or by their willfull Apostasy and forsaking the Religion which they professed, with themselves, broken off their seed, externally and actually from the communion of the Church, and holy things thereof. Jf they say;
Thirdly. The absolute necessity of baptism to salvation; so that, 1not only those of years, that refuse or contemn it, are damned, but even infants also perish eternally, through the want of it, is an error which these Churches have destroyed, when they profess it to be of the same use to Christians, whereof circumcision was to the Jews, who being borne in the covenant, by their relation to their believing parents, by virtue of the promise, I will be thy God, and the God of thy seed, were accounted in the number of Abraham's children, before circumcision, without which, circumcision did not appertain to them. According to the Scriptures, which declare Davids confidence about the salvation of his infant that died before the eighth day,2 in which it should have been circumcised, and annexeth damnation to not believing, not, to not being baptised, as Luther acutely noted out of those words. He that believeth and is baptised, shall be saved, 3but he that believeth not, shall be damned. But this practise seemeth to build this up again, For, if the necessity of it be such, as Gods order must be violated rather then the infant not baptised, who will not suspect that they account it simply necessary to salvation? And, if the plea, which is ordinarily used by them,4 that Baptism is not of such necessity, as that Gods order should be broken for, it, be good against baptism by private persons, and by midwives and nurses &c. Why may it not serve in this case also?
Thirdly. The absolute necessity of baptisme to salvation; so that, 1not only those of yeares, that refuse or contemne it, are damned, but even infants also perish aeternally, through the want of it, is an errour which these Churches have destroyed, when they professe it to be of the same use to Christians, whereof circumcision was to the Iewes, who being borne in the covenant, by their relation to their beleiving parents, by vertue of the promise, I will be thy God, and the God of thy seed, were accounted in the number of Abrahams children, before circumcision, without which, circumcision did not appertaine to them. According to the Scriptures, which declare Davids confidence about the salvation of his infant that died before the eighth day,
Fourthly. The efficacy of Baptism,1 when it is made a natural cause or instrument sanctifying those that partake of it, by the work done, is an error, which these Churches have destroyed, when they ascribe the working of grace to God, as the sole efficient cause, and author of it, and account the Sacraments, signs and seals, and moral instruments signifying and sealing and so exhibiting it instrumentally, in the right use of them, which I will explain in the words of that learned Dr, ⟨p. 148⟩Whittaker,2 because his exposition seemeth to be more clear then many, in reference to the true state of the question between the Pontificians and the Orthodox. We say, they are instruments (taking the name largely) because God useth them in bestowing grace upon us: ye we do not mean that they are instruments, as our Adversaries do, as if God were so tied to them as not to confer grace without them, as an artificer cannot make a bed, or bench, without a saw, or hatchet, nor that they are able to work any thing of themselves by any hidden virtue proper to them and inherent in them, as is in a medicine for procuring bodily health, but because, in the right use of them, God worketh a nourishing and increasing of grace. Therefore the Sacraments work nothing by the thing done, no not in infants. For infants are not therefore partakers of grace only because they are baptised yet neither are they baptised in vain, because they are baptised, unto future faith & repentance, & because they are members of the Church, and holy by the Covenant, and therefore the sign of the Covenant is not to be denied them. Thus he witnesseth against that efficacy that papalls ascribe to the Sacrament, & joineth with these Churches in destroying it, according to the(a) Scripture. But this practise seemeth to build it up again. For, whereas our Divines say that baptism is profaned, when it is administered to the unclean the popish writers tell us, that baptism is not thereby profaned, but that it doeth sanctify them. And, upon this ground, Bellarmine saith, that baptism may be given to those that pertain not to Christ. To whom Dr. Whittaker answereth. This were true, if Baptism were a physical cause of grace: For grace is not profaned when it is given to the unclean, but it sanctifieth them, to whom it is given:
else (he demandeth of Bellarmine) why may not infidels of years be baptised, if they will suffer themselves to be baptised; yea though they should profess that they do not believe in Christ, if baptism will sanctify them? But all men deny that. And why so? Because they belong not to Christ: Therefore (saith he) Baptism aught not to be given to any that are not in Christ. I will not enlarge this point, by speaking of the ignorant conceit of some, that ⟨p. 149⟩baptism is their Christendom, and that they are made Christians by baptism, whereas we have shown that they must be Christians before baptism, else they may not be baptised.
else (he demandeth of Bellermine) why may not infidells of yeares be baptised, if they will suffer themselves to be baptised; yea though they should professe that they doe not beleive in Christ, if baptisme will sanctifye them? But all men deny that. And why so? Because they belong not to Christ: Therefore (sayth he) Baptisme aught not to be given to any that are not in Christ. I will not enlarge this point, by speaking of the ignorant conceit of some, that ⟨p. 149⟩baptisme is their Christendom, and that they are made Christians by baptisme, whereas we have shewen that they must be Christians before baptisme, else they may not be baptised.
Fifthly. The loose positions, whereby Libertines are hardened,1 in refusing to join themselves in doctrine and discipline with any visible Church, are errors which these Churches in their doctrine have destroyed, by professing, that every man that would be saved (of what rank or condition soever) is bound to join himself with the Church of God, and to subject himself to the doctrine and discipline thereof, though with hazard of his life &c. according to the Scriptures.(b) But this practise buildeth it up again. As appeareth in the example of that Libertine who took encouragement to persist in his course, by a sermon, wherein the Answerer affirmeth that the infants of such may lawfully be baptised, though the parents refused to join with any Church: whereupon he came home resolving, as himself told diverse, never to join with any Church, whilst he lived, though he had been, as he said, 20 years before, in doubts about his condition.
Fifthly. The loose positions, whereby Libertines are hardned,1 in refusing to joyne themselves in doctrine and discipline with any visible Church, are errours which these Churches in their doctrine have destroyed, by professing, that every man that would be saved (of what ranck or condition soever) is bound to joyne himselfe with the Church of God, and to subject himselfe to the doctrine and discipline thereof, though with hazzard of his life &c. according to the Scriptures.(b) But this practise buildeth it up againe. As appeareth in the exāple of that Libertine who tooke encouragment to persist in his course, by a sermon, wherein the Answerer affirmeth that the infants of such may lawfully be baptised, though the parents refused to joyne with any Church: whereupon he came home resolving, as himselfe told diverse, never to joyne with any Church, whilest he lived, though he had bene, as he said, 20 yeares before, in doubts about his condition.
Sixthly.1 The opinion of Erastus against Ecclesiastical excommunication, is an error which the doctrine of these Churches hath destroyed, by affirming that the power of excommunication belongeth to the Church, according(c) to the Scriptures.
Sixthly.1 The opinion of Erastus against Ecclesiasticall excommunicatiō, is an errour which the doctrine of these Churches hath destroyed, by affirming that the power of excommunication belongeth to the Church, according(c) to the Scriptures.
But this practise doth build it up again, when they, not only administer this Sacrament promiscuously to all that are brought, but also plead for it by some of the Arguments which Erastus produced against that.
But this practise doth build it up againe, when they, not only administer this Sacrament promiscuously to all that are brought, but also plead for it by some of the Arguments which Erastus produced against that.
For, First Erastus allegeth Johns admitting the very worst men to his baptism, viz, the Pharisees and Sadducees: whereunto both Beza and Mr. Cartwright answer, to the same purpose, as I did some with whom I argued against this custom, that John admitted none to his baptism, but those that professed repentance and amendment of life. Therefore they are said to be baptised of John in Jordan, confessing their sins, which,1 after the manner of the Hebrews, signifieth more then a bare acknowledgement that they were sinners, even a profession of their embracing the doctrine of remission of sins by Christ, ⟨p. 150⟩and a promise of amendment.2 Such confessions were Davids, Daniels, the Publicans, Prodigals. As for the Pharisees and Sadducees (saith Mr, Cartwright) which came in Hypocrisy to be baptised, deriding the grace of God, I utterly deny that John baptised them: yea, that he rejected them, it is evident by his sharp reprehension and terrible threatening of them with death and cutting off. Those that pretended repentance in words he admonished, that, if they would be baptised, they must bring forth fruits worthy of repentance, else they should be cut off.
For, First Erastus alleadgeth Iohns admitting the very worst men to his baptisme, viz, the Pharises and Sadduces: whereunto both Beza and Mr. Cartwright answer, to the same purpose, as I did some with whom I argued against this custom, that Iohn admitted none to his baptisme, but those that professed repentance and amendment of life. Therefore they are said to be baptised of Iohn in Iordan, confessing their sinnes, which,1 after the manner of the Hebrewes, signifyeth more then a bare acknowledgment that they were sinners, even a profession of their imbracing the doctrine of remission of sinnes by Christ, ⟨p. 150⟩and a promise of amendment.2 Such confessions were Davids, Daniels, the Publicans, Prodigalls. As for the Pharises and Sadduces (sayth Mr, Cartwright) which came in Hypocrisy to be baptised, deriding the grace of God, I utterly deny that Iohn baptised them: yea, that he rejected them, it is evident by his sharpe reprehension and terrible threatning of them with death and cutting off. Those that pretended repentance in words he admonished, that, if they would be baptised, they must bring forth fruits worthy of repentance, else they should be cut off.
Secondly. He allegeth that all the Israelites (as well rebellions as others) did eat the same spiritual meat, and drink the same spiritual drink. 1. Cor. 10.4.1 And, in effect, the same thing is objected by some, for the defence of this custom, when they plead, that they were all baptised unto Moses in the cloud, and in the sea. Therefore all infants that are presented, must be baptised. Bezaes answer to him, in that case, may serve these in this case, out of whom (and a learned Commentator upon that place joined together with him) 2 things may be answered.
Secondly. He alleadgeth that all the Israelites (as well rebellions as others) did eate the same sprirituall meate, and drinck the same spirituall drinck. 1. Cor. 10.4.1 And, in effect, the same thing is objected by some, for the defence of this custom, when they plead, that they were all baptised unto Moses in the cloud, and in the sea. Therefore all infants that are presented, must be baptised. Bezaes answer to him, in that case, may serve these in this case, out of whom (and a learned Commentatour upon that place joyned together with him) 2 things may be answered.
1. That the things, there spoken of, were not to be numbered amongst those things which are only Sacraments: however they were Sacraments, in a sense, yet they were not Sacraments in that signification of the the word [Sacraments] which is usually amongst Divines, when they call circumcision, and the passover, Baptism, and the Lords supper, Sacraments: for they were not by any solemn promulgation, expressed in the word, instituted & sanctified by God to be seals of the covenant to believers (as circumcision &c.) which is necessary to the constitution of a Sacrament. But as they were miraculous and admirable types of Christ, so they were common, and temporal benefits serving for the bodily refreshing and safety of the people of Israel in general, and therefore that all, even the most unworthy of them, partook of those, it was for a peculiar reason, which hath not place in the Sacraments. For the shadow of the cloud covering the whole army, as a shield, or buckler, received, and kept from them the beams of the sun, which else in, that dry and hot region, might have consumed them ⟨p. 151⟩with burning heat, especially they being wearied, and faint with journeying, therefore it was necessary, that it should be common to them all. The same reason might be given for their passing through the sea, to escape the rage of the tyrant that pursued them. But what is this to Baptism?
1. That the things, there spoken of, were not to be numbred amongst those things which are onely Sacraments: however they were Sacraments, in a sense, yet they were not Sacraments in that signification of the the word [Sacraments] which is usually amongst Divines, when they call circumcision, and the passover, Baptisme, and the Lords supper, Sacraments: for they were not by any solemne promulgation, expressed in the word, instituted & sanctified by God to be seales of the covenant to beleivers (as circumcision &c.) which is necessary to the constitution of a Sacrament. But as they were miraculous and admirable types of Christ, so they were common, and temporall benefites serving for the bodily refreshing and safety of the people of Israel in generall, and therefore that all, even the most unworthy of them, partaked of those, it was for a peculiar reason, which hath not place in the Sacraments. For the shadow of the cloud covering the wholl army, as a sheild, or buckler, received, and kept from them the beames of the sun, which else in, that dry and hot region, might have consumed them ⟨p. 151⟩
2. That the persons there spoken of were the Church of Israel, whom he calleth our fathers, because from them the Jews sprang which were the visible Church of God, whose children also the Corinthians and all the visible Churches of believers are amongst the Gentiles, who have received from them the privileges of the word, Sacraments, Covenant, and other spiritual good things, as their inheritance. But what are these to those Libertines and others, who cast off all communion with the Churches of Christ? To conclude this Argument in one Syllogism,
2. That the persons there spoken of were the Church of Israel, whom he calleth our fathers, because from them the Jewes sprang which were the visible Church of God, whose children also the Corinthians and all the visible Churches of beleivers are amongst the Gentiles, who have received from them the priviledges of the word, Sacraments, Covenant, and other spirituall good things, as their inheritance. But what are these to those Libertines and others, who cast off all communion whith the Churches of Christ? To conclude this Argument in one Syllogisme,
Fourthly. The efficacy of Baptisme,1 when it is made a naturall cause or instrument sanctifying those that partake of it, by the worke done, is an errour, which these Churches haue destroyed, when they ascribe the working of grace to God, as the sole efficient cause, and authour of it, and account the Sacraments, signes and seales, and morall instruments signifying and sealing and so exhibiting it instrumentally, in the right use of them, which I will explaine in the words of that learned Dr, ⟨p. 148⟩Whittaker,2 because his exposition seemeth to be more cleare then many, in reference to the true state of the question betweene the Pontificians and the Orthodox. We say, they are instruments (taking the name largely) because God useth them in bestowing grace upon us: ye we doe not meane that they are instrumēts, as our Adversaries doe, as if God were so tyed to thē as not to conferr grace without them, as an artificer cannot make a bed, or bench, without a saw, or hatchet, nor that they are able to worke any thing of themselves by any hiddē vertue proper to them and inhaerent in them, as is in a medicine for procuring bodily health, but because, in the right use of them, God worketh a nourishing and increasing of grace. Therefore the Sacraments worke nothing by the thing done, no not in infants. For infants are not therefore partakers of grace only because they are baptised yet neither are they baptised in vaine, because they are baptised, unto future fayth & repentance, & because they are members of the Church, and holy by the Covenant, and therefore the signe of the Covenant is not to be denyed them. Thus he witnesseth against that efficacy that papalls ascribe to the Sacrament, & joyneth with these Churches in destroying it, according to the(a) Scripture. But this practise seemeth to build it up againe. For, whereas our Divines say that baptisme is profaned, whē it is administred to the uncleane the popish wrighters tell us, that baptisme is not thereby profaned, but that it doeth sanctifye them. And, upon this ground, Bellarmine sayth, that baptisme may be given to those that pertaine not to Christ. To whom Dr. Whittaker answereth. This were true, if Baptisme were a physicall cause of grace: For grace is not profaned when it is given to the uncleane, but it sanctifyeth them, to whom it is given: