A19884:664
An apologetical reply to a book called an answer to the unjust complaint of VV.B. Also an answer to Mr. I.D. touching his report of some passages. His allegation of Scriptures against the baptising of some kind of infants. His protestation about the publishing of his writings. By John Davenport BD.An apologeticall reply to a booke called an ansvver to the unjust complaint of VV.B. Also an answer to Mr. I.D. touching his report of some passages. His allegation of Scriptures against the baptising of some kind of infants. His protestation about the publishing of his wrightings. By Iohn Davenporte BD.
Rotterdam: printed by Isaac van Waesberghe, 1636Rotterdam: printed by Isaack van Waesberghe, 1636
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Ans:1 Nathan dealt sincerely & with a good conscience (as he thought, and would have protested, if it had been required) when he advised David about building a Temple to the Lord, & encouraged him thereunto: Yet he erred. Peter thought he dealt sincerely and with a good conscience (and, before Paul had convinced him of his evil, it may be, would have protested it also) in his temporizing first with the Gentiles,2 and then with those of the Circumcision: yet he erred. Those famous lights, spoken of before, thought they dealt sincerely, and with a good conscience, in those opinions which they defended: yet they erred.
Ans:1 Nathan dealt sincerely & with a good conscience (as he thought, and would have protested, if it had bene required) when he advised David about building a Temple to the Lord, & incouraged him thereunto: Yet he erred. Peter thought he dealt sincerely and with a good conscience (and, before Paul had convinced him of his evill, it may be, would have protested it also) in his temporizing first with the Gentiles,2 and then with those of the Circumcision: yet he erred. Those famous lights, spoken of before, thought they dealt sincerely, and with a good conscience, in those opinions which they defended: yet they erred.
They desired nothing more then to further the promotion of Mr. D. 1to the ministry of the English Church?
Ans: 1. I do easily believe that the Dutch Ministers did really desire my settling there, and that, when they went to the Answerer, their purpose was to further it. And I am persuaded of them, that when they wrote to me, they did it, upon some encouraging intimations suggested by the Answerer, that a letter from them signifying the concurrence and consent of their judgment with him in this point would prevail to draw me to yield to it. I am also confident, they were the more apt to approve such courses of accommodation, as, they saw, would best please him, upon a conceit that the Answerer himself did much desire me, which also themselves did intimate in the writing subscribed by them. So that their miscarriage in this business was not from any disaffection to me, or desire of hindering my settling there, but from too much credulity and tractableness to comply with the Answerer, in his way, the issue of whose purpose, ⟨p. 174⟩they foresaw not. These things being premised, I proceed to show the reason, why I could not rest in their counsel, in this particular.
Ans: 1. I doe easily beleive that the Dutch Ministers did really desire my setling there, and that, when they went to the Answerer, their purpose was to further it. And I am perswaded of them, that when they wrote to me, they did it, upon some incouraging intimations suggested by the Answerer, that a letter from them signifying the concurrence and consent of theire judgment with him in this point would prevaile to draw me to yeeld to it. I am also confident, they were the more apt to approve such courses of accommodation, as, they saw, would best please him, vpon a conceit that the Answerer himselfe did much desire me, which also themselves did intimate in the wrighting subscribed by them. So that their miscarrage in this buisenes was not from any disaffection to me, or desire of hindring my settling there, but from too much credulity and tractablenes to complye with the Answerer, in his way, the issue of whose purpose, ⟨p. 174⟩they foresaw not. These things being premised, I proceed to shew the reason, why I could not rest in their conusaile, in this particular.
2. Two things, especially, hindered me from resting therein. 1. Because the same thing which they propounded, only as their private judgment, the Answered pressed as a law to me, wherein I must rest, that is, conform thereunto, and this my resting therein must be the condition, whereupon he would consent to my settling there, else not. So that his finger was heavier upon me, in this, then their loins, & he assumed a power to himself of prescribing rules to me, which the government of these churches hath not given him, yea, more then is given to the Classes themselves by any Synod, or to any Synod by the word of God, to enjoin this thing to a Minister as a condition of his call to a pastoral charge. 2. Because the five Ministers propounded their private judgment nakedly without showing their grounds from the Scripture, so that they seemed to me to deal by their authority, not by argument. Now the mere authority, that is, the bare affirmation of godly and learned men, is less to be regarded then their reasons, and yet their reasons, without the word, are of no value, in Divine matters. For all men are liars, apt to be deceived, and so to deceive, impossibility of erring being proper to the Scriptures, which therefore are only fit to be the Canon or rule for the ordering of Ministers concerning their whole behaviour in the house of God. 1Hence Christ and his Apostles, 1. reproved disorders by Scripture (so Christ did the profaning of the Temple) 2, justified things well done by Scripture (so Christ did the pulling of the ears of corn) 3. resolved & answered questions by Scripture (so Christ did,2 in the case of Divorce) 4. confuted errors by Scriptures (so Christ did the Pharisees and Sadducees) 5. confirmed and proved Doctrines by Scriptures (so Peter proved the resurrection and ascension of Christ &c.) 6. gave advice, and made orders, not by their own authority, but by the direction of the Holy Ghost, which immediate assistance seeing we want, light must be fetched from Scripture, if we will guide others safely by our counsel, without which learned men may err, have erred, and do err, &
This pretence the Answerer insinuateth in that which he said about the form of Mr. B. calling, Ans. which was to minister the word, and the dependences thereof, according to the order of these Reformed Churches, and especially with these which are combined with the Classis of Amsterdam, Concerning that expression some thing more may be noted, in the examination of the seventeenth Section, and when we come to the eight and twentieth Section.
This pretence the Answerer insinuateth in that which he sayd about the forme of Mr. B. calling, Ans. which was to minister the word, and the dependances thereof, according to the order of these Reformed Churches, and especially with these which are combined with the Classis of Amsterdam, Concerning that expression some thing more may be noated, in the examination of the seventeenth Section, and when we come to the eight and twentith Section.
For the present, Reply. we will oppose (besides all considerations which have been formerly alleged, or may be hereafter) two things to this custom, to prove that this cannot be the order of these Reformed Churches, but must be only a disorder crept in, and prevailing by mens oscitancy, and sleepiness, which is Satan's best opportunity for the sowing of tares, which I shall demonstrate thus.
For the present, Reply. we will oppose (besides all considerations which have bene formerly alleadged, or may be heareafter) two things to this custom, to prove that this cannot be the order of these Reformed Churches, but must be only a disorder crept in, and prevayling by mens ossitancie, and sleepines, which is Sathans best opportunity for the sowing of tares, which I shall demonstrate thus.
First, oppose the Confessions of the Reformed Churches to this custom,1 and it will be found that they cannot stand together, for, when they described, qui sunt baptisandi, who are to be baptised, speaking of infants; they say, they must be the children of persons that are in the Covenant (a)of the people of God (b)of holy parents(c), of those to whom the promises belong(d), who are inserted into the Church, and only them(e), the true children of Abraham (f)such as are in alike condition as they were who had right to Circumcision amongst the Jews. Now compare, with this doctrine of the Reformed Churches, the practise of that place, as it hath been declared, and it will appear that their own Confessions plead against this custom. And, how can that be called the order of these Reformed Churches, which agreeth not with the doctrine of these reformed Churches?
First, oppose the Confessions of the Reformed Churches to this custom,1 and it will be found that they cannot stand together, for, when they described, qui sunt baptisandi, who are to be baptised, speaking of infants; they say, they must be the children of persons that are in the Covenant (a)of the people of God (b)of holy parents(c), of those to whom the promises belong
Secondly, oppose the Canons of the Synods of these countries to this custom, and the thing will be manifested. In a ⟨p. 176⟩Synod held at Dort in the year 1578. Art. 59. It was referred to the judgment of the Ministers and Elders, whether there be any lawful cause brought by any, why the child to be baptised should be deferred from Baptism: and in Art. 61. It was ordered, that the fathers, before they bring their children to baptism, shall go to the Minister, or an Elder, that the Church may have notice of the parties that are to be baptised. And in Art. 62. They are appointed to acquaint the Minister what name they will give the child, and to show him how they will educate the child in that Religion.
Secondly, oppose the Canons of the Synods of these countryes to this custom, and the thing will be manifested. In a ⟨p. 176⟩Synod held at Dort in the yeare 1578. Art. 59. It was referred to the judgment of the Ministers and Elders, whether there be any lawfull cause brought by any, why the child to be baptised should be deferred from Baptisme: and in Art. 61. It was ordered, that the fathers, before they bring their children to baptisme, shall goe to the Minister, or an Elder, that the Church may have notice of the partyes that are to be baptised. And in Art. 62. They are appoynted to acquaint the Minister what name they will give the child, and to shew him how they will educate the child in that Religion.
In a Synod held at Middleborough in the year 1581. the 22. question. It is demanded, whether the parents of children do go first to the Minister, or Elders, and certify them, that they desire to have their children baptised before, to see whether they judge it meet to receive such witnesses or not? In Art. 75. It is questioned, whether the Minister should be rebuked, when he baptiseth children, whose parents appoint witnesses, which stand not for religion? Ans. The parents shall be wonted, as much as is possible, that they first speak with the Ministers before they present their children to baptism, &c.
In a Synod held at Middleborough in the yeare 1581. the 22. question. It is demanded, whether the parents of children doe goe first to the Minister, or Elders, and certify them, that they desire to have their children baptised before, to see whether they judge it meet to receive such witnesses or not? In Art. 75. It is questioned, whether the Minister should be rebuked, when he baptiseth children, whose parents appoynt witnesses, which stand not for religion? Ans. The parents shall be wonted, as much as is possible, that they first speake with the Ministers before they present their children to baptisme, &c.
In a Synod held at Utrecht, in the year 1590. Art 1. It is decreed, that Baptism is to be administered, according to the ordinance of Christ, without Godfathers to bind themselves, only the father and mother to promise to train it up in the Religion.
In a Synod held at Vtricht, in the yeare 1590. Art 1. It is decreed, that Baptisme is to be administred, according to the ordinance of Christ, without Godfathers to bind themselves, only the father and mother to promise to trayne it up in the Religion.
Now, compare the Canons of these Synods with the custom of that place, and they will be found so far to vary from it, that it will appear not to be the order of these reformed Churches, but a disorder crept in, as we have said before.
Now, compare the Canons of these Synods with the custom of that place, and they will be found so farr to varye from it, that it will appeare not to be the order of these reformed Churches, but a disorder crept in, as we have said before.
I will conclude this examination of pretences used in defence of this unwarrantable custom with the judicious censure of Dr. Ames, who knew well the miscarriage of this disorder, in these countryes.1 Incuria illa idcirco neutiquam potest excusari, quâ promiscuè, & sine disermine, admittuntur quicunque, et a quibuscunque offeruntur. Therefore that carelessness can by no means be excused, whereby all, promiscuously, and without difference, are admitted to baptism, by whomsoever they are presented. And so much shall suffice for the examination of the twelfth Section, and for declaration of the grounds, whereupon I durst not bind my self, by promise, or otherwise, to rest in the judgment of those ⟨p. 177⟩five Ministers, that is, to conform to the custom of this place in administering Baptism promiscuously to all that are presented, and by whomsoever.
I will conclude this examination of pretences used in defence of this unwarrantable custom with the judicious censure of Dr. Ames, who knew well the miscarriage of this disorder, in these countryes.1 Incuria illa idcirco neutiquam potest excusari, quâ promiscuè, & sine disermine, admittuntur quicunque, et a quibuscunque offeruntur. Therefore that carelesnes can by no means be excused, whereby all, promiscuously, and without difference, are admitted to baptisme, by whomsoever they are presented. And so much shall suffice for the examination of the twelfth Section, and for declaration of the grounds, whereupon I durst not bind my selfe, by promise, or otherwise, to rest in the judgment of those ⟨p. 177⟩five Ministers, that is, to conforme to the custom of this place in administring Baptisme promiscuously to all that are presensed, and by whomsoever.
That which here, he calleth an order, will, upon examination, be found very far from accommodating me. I will wright it down as I received it from the Elders, out of the note, which I have in keeping. Jan. 19. 1634. The Consistory being gathered, Elders, and Deacons together, it was demanded, whether that all persons being no members should be sent unto Mr. D. to desire the baptism of their children, and to make confession to him, for his satisfaction in his administration of that Sacrament? The answer was by all voices, yea, if Mr. D. can be persuaded thereunto. And for the better, and more convenient bringing of the parents or presenters of the children to the Minister, it is agreed, by most voices in Consistory, that Th: A. the Coster shall bring or direct the parties to the Ministers house. Afterward, this question was propounded by the Answerer, & written down in these words. Whether, if persons ignorant, being willing to receive instruction, although not presently able to render a reason, shall be sent away by him, or admitted, to wit, they approving of the doctrine of baptism taught in these Churches, and as by us usually is propounded? A Copy of this pretended order, with the questionw, as brought to me by some of the Elders to see what answer J would make to them both. Which when I had considered, I found the order too short, and the question captious.
THat which here, he calleth an order, will, upon examination, be found very farr from accommodating me. I will wright it downe as I received it from the Elders, out of the noate, which I have in keeping. Ian. 19. 1634. The Consistory being gathered, Elders, and Deacons together, it was demanded, whether that all persons being no members should be sent unto Mr. D. to desire the baptisme of their children, and to make confession to him, for his satisfaction in his administration of that Sacrament? The answer was by all voyces, yea, if Mr. D. can be persuaded thereunto. And for the better, and more convenient bringing of the parents or presenters of the children to the Minister, it is agreed, by most voyces in Consistory, that Th: A. the Coster shall bring or direct the partyes to the Ministers house. Afterward, this question was propounded by the Answerer, & written downe in these words. Whether, if persons ignorant, being willing to receive instruction, allthough not presently able to render a reason, shall be sent away by him, or admitted, to witt, they approving of the doctrine of baptisme taught in these Churches, and as by us usually is propounded? A Copy of this pretended order, with the questionw, as brought to me by some of the Elders to see what answer J would make to them boath. Which when I had considered, I found the order too short, and the question captious.
2. Two things, especially, hindred me from resting therein. 1. Because the same thing which they propounded, only as their private judgment, the Answered pressed as a law to me, wherein I must rest, that is, conforme thereunto, and this my resting therein must be the condition, whereupon he would consent to my setling there, else not. So that his finger was heavyer upon me, in this, then their loynes, & he assumed a power to himselfe of prescribing rules to me, which the government of these churces hath not given him, yea, more then is given to the Classes themselves by any Synod, or to any Synod by the word of God, to injoyne this thing to a Minister as a condition of his call to a pastorall charge. 2. Because the five Ministers propounded their private judgment nakedly without shewing their grounds from the Scripture, so that they seemed to me to deale by their authority, not by argument. Now the mere authority, that is, the bare affirmation of godly and learned men, is lesse to be regarded then their reasons, and yet their reasons, without the word, are of no value, in Divine matters. For all men are lyars, apt to be deceived, and so to deceive, impossibility of erring being proper to the Scriptures, which therefore are only fit to be the Canon or rule for the ordering of Ministers concerning their wholl behaviour in the house of God. 1Hence Christ and his Apostles, 1. reproved disorders by Scripture (so Christ did the profaning of the Temple) 2, justified things well done by Scripture (so Christ did the pulling of the eares of corne) 3. resolved & answered questions by Scripture (so Christ did,2 in the case of Divorce) 4. confuted errours by Scriptures (so Christ did the Pharisees and Sadduces) 5. confirmed and proved Doctrines by Scriptures (so Peter proved the resurrection and ascention of Christ &c.) 6. gave advice, and made orders, not by their owne authority, but by the direction of the Holy Ghoast, which immediate assistance seing we want, light must be fetched from Scripture, if we will guide others safely by our counsayle, without which learned men may erre, have erred, and doe erre, & ⟨p. 175⟩therefore their judgments must be tryed, and judged by it, and no further be rested in, then they agree with it. According to that of Ierom Quod ex Scripturâ non habet authoritatem câadem facilitate contemnitur, quâ acceptatur.