A26864:48
Rich. Baxters apology against the modest exceptions of Mr. T. Blake and the digression…
Rich. Baxters apology against the modest exceptions of Mr. T. Blake and the digression of Mr. G. Kendall whereunto is added animadversions on a late dissertation of Ludiomæus Colvinus, aliaà Ludovicus Molinæs̳, M. Dr. Oxon, and an admonition of Mr. W. Eyre of Salisbury : with Mr. Crandon's Anatomy for satisfaction of Mr. Caryl.
London: printed by A.M. for Thomas Underhill, 1654
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
In this case, I find many take it as if I spoke all this of the Person, and censured him as absurd, as I do his Opinion: which is an injurious charge; seeing a wise man may hold an absurd Opinion. And I think, as I must not speak contemptuously of my Brother for a lesser Error, so neither must I for his sake, speak lightly and favourably of his faults. Error is not like confessed sins, which none dare own, or encourage others in: but it is a Vice that disposeth men to Infect all they can; and emboldeneth them to defend it, and fearlessly to draw all others into the guilt. And therefore it needeth the most potent opposition, and the souls of our Brethren need the most effectual preservative: And that must not be only by a naked, dull Confutation; but also by a discovery of the foulness, the sinfulness and dangerousness of the Error. The Affections have need to be awaked, as well as the Understanding informed, in the present case, as well as against common moral Vices. I am sure Seducers make no small advantage, by moving the Affections, and why they that speak Truth should not do so, I cannot tell. If we must do so in Preaching, so must we in some Disputings, still supposing that Information go first, and exciting application be but subservient, and be not the leading, or the principal part. ••ose that take intellectual Error to be no sin, must deny the understanding to be under a Law, and its acts to be participativè voluntary, and being commanded by the Will. And if Error be sin, we may have leave to disgrace it and deal with it as sin; provided that we maintain our Charity to the erring Brother. I am bound not to hate my Brother in my heart, but plainly to Rebuke him, and not suffer sin to rest upon him. If he take it ill, that makes not me the offender, nor will discharge me from my duty. 3. I confess I think we are commonly too tender eared in such cases: of which I have spoken my mind already in the end of the Preface to my Book of Baptism. I have oft wondered to think what patience we expect (and justly) yea and find, in many of the worst of our hearers, when we speak to them as cuttingly as possibly we can (and all too little:) and how ⟨image 15⟩little we exercise or can allow to one another! and what silken ears the Preachers of humility have themselves? And I cannot but observe the strange partiality of the best:
In this case, I finde many take it as if I spoke all this of the Person, and censured him as absurd, as I do his Opinion: which is an injurious charge; seeing a wise man may hold an absurd Opinion. And I think, as I must not speak contemptuously of my Brother for a lesser Errour, so neither must I for his sake, speak lightly and favourably of his faults. Errour is not like confessed sins, which none dare own, or encourage others in: but it is a Vice that disposeth men to Infect all they can; and emboldneth them to defend it, and fearlesly to draw all others into the guilt. And therefore it needeth the most potent opposition, and the souls of our Brethren need the most effectual preservative: And that must not be only by a naked, dull Confutation; but also by a discovery of the foulness, the sinfulnes and dangerousness of the Errour. The Affections have need to be awaked, as well as the Understanding informed, in the present case, as well as against common moral Vices. I am sure Seducers make no small advantage, by moving the Affections, and why they that speak Truth should not do so, I cannot tell. If we must do so in Preaching, so must we in some Disputings, still supposing that Information go first, and exciting application be but subservient, and be not the leading, or the principall part. ose that take intellectuall Errour to be no sinne, must deny the understanding to be under a Law, and its acts to be participativè voluntary, and being commanded by the Will. And if Errour be sinne, we may have leave to disgrace it and deal with it as sinne; provided that we maintain our Charity to the erring Brother. I am bound not to hate my Brother in my heart, but plainly to Rebuke him, and not suffer sin to rest upon him. If he take it ill, that makes not me the offendor, nor will discharge me from my duty. 3. I confess I think we are commonly too tender ear'd in such cases: of which I have spoken my minde already in the end of the Preface to my Book of Baptism. I have oft wondered to think what patience we expect (and justly) yea and finde, in many of the worst of our hearers, when we speak to them as cuttingly as possibly we can (and all too little:) and how