A26886:1306
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Ans. 1. They may tell me so: but how will you prove that they tell me true? I see by you, that telling is easier then proving, and commoner then truth. 2. Your making this a door to Anabaptism, doth give them that which you cannot warrant them, and advantage the Anabaptists more under pretence of renouncing their advantages, than you desire: the common success of passionate oppositions. 3. Your feigning this to be new, and never or little spoken of before, in my understanding, importeth one of these consequences; either as if you had said [All History is false; believe nothing that ever you read in them; nay trust not your eyes and ears, that see and hear the contrary to what I say;] or else as if you had proclaimed. [Take heed how you credit even Godly Divines in the heat of their contention, even in the most palpable matters of fact.]
Ans. 1. They may tell me so: but how will you prove that they tell me true? I see by you, that telling is easier then proving, and commoner then truth. 2. Your making this a door to Anabaptism, doth give them that which you cannot warrant them, and advantage the Anabaptists more under pretence of renouncing their advantages, than you desire: the common success of passionate oppositions. 3. Your feigning this to be new, and never or little spoken of before, in my understanding, importeth one of these consequences; either as if you had said [All Historie is false; believe nothing that ever you read in them; nay trust not your eyes and ears, that see and hear the contrary to what I say;] or else as if you had proclaimed. [Take heed how you credit even Godly Divines in the heat of their contention, even in the most palpable matters of fact.]
Mr. Blake. When discovery shall be made that the Title when Baptism was administered was barely seeming, then all was Null ab initio in such proceedings: and as such persons always were in the eyes of God, so now in the eye of men they are unbaptized persons.] Ans. What proof of all this? but you say so? 1. Baptism is sometimes taken for the mere external Ordinance: sometime for that conjunct with the grace signified, or with the effects. As to the actual conveyance of pardon and life, I affirm that Sacraments are uneffectual to unbelievers; and so do you; If that be a Nullity, call them Null. But how prove you that the external Ordinance is a Nullity where there was no Title? The Title indeed was Null ab initio, but prove that the Ordinance was so too?