A26886:1319
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. 1. Do not those persons profess a Justifying faith? 2. Or is it Infallible symptoms of the contrary which you mean, or which are sufficient to nullify or invalidate that Profession? if not, you say nothing: if so, then 3. Dare you hold communion with no Church that hath some members that in your own Judgement are unfit to be there? How oft hath this opinion been confuted in the Separatists? But you add your reason.
Answ. 1. Do not those persons profess a Justifying faith? 2. Or is it Infallible symptoms of the contrary which you mean, or which are sufficient to nullifie or invalidate that Profession? if not, you say nothing: if so, then 3. Dare you hold communion with no Church that hath some members that in your own Judgement are unfit to be there? How oft hath this opinion been confuted in the Separatists? But you add your reason.
Mr. Blake. [Though this will not bear a separation, yet this consideration of their non-baptism will necessarily enforce it.—]
Answ. 1. The Enemy of the Church needs no hands to do a great part of his work, but our own. The Anabaptists take us to be all unbaptized, and thence infer a necessity of Separation. Their Separation troubleth the Church much more than their ⟨p. 395⟩opinion for re-baptizing. Our endeavour is, at least to bring them to this, that being re-baptized they would rest satisfied, and live in peaceable communion with the Church. Mr. Blake steps in and confirmeth them in their consequence, on supposition of the Antecedent which we cannot satisfy them in; and so frustrateth all our labour, and gives them the day, in that, and considereth not I fear the danger of promoting such a schism. But he would do well first to answer the many Reasons that Mr. John Goodwin hath brought against that opinion, and take his work clean before him. If I knew a Church or whole Nation of men that thought verily they were truly baptized, and I thought that it was not so, if yet they profest true Faith and Holiness, I durst not separate from them. 2. But how irksome must it needs be to your Judicious Readers, to have such conclusions tossed up and down with mere confidence, upon suppositions, which you disdain (or deign not) to prove? One Argument to have proved that our Principles infer the Nullity of the Baptism of the Unregenerate, had been more worth than all this kind of talk. I say that Deo Judice such men have no Title by any Grant or Gift of God to claim or receive the Sacraments, though the Minister have Commission to give it to some unjust claimers. This opinion professeth the Nullity of the Title which is denied. Do you prove that it also inferreth the Nullity of the external Baptism it self, which was justly administered, though unjustly demanded. Its tedious to read voluminous Disputes, where that which requireth proof is still taken for granted.