A26886:1492
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Disputation 5: The fifth Disputation.Disputation 5: The fift Disputation.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Mr. Blake. If such Equivocation be found in the word [Saint] then the like is to be affirmed of the word Believer; and Believers having their denomination from their faith, that is equivocal in like manner, and so the common Division of faith into Dogmatical or Historical, temporary, miraculous, and justifying is but a Division of an Aequivocum in sua Aequivocata, which I should think no man should affirm, much less Mr. Baxter, who makes common and special grace to differ only gradually; and then as cold in a remiss degree may grow to that which is intense; so one Aequivocatum may rise up to the Nature of another: animal terrestre, may become Sydus Coeleste.
Mr. Blake. If such Equivocation be found in the word [Saint] then the like is to be affirmed of the word Believer; and Believers having their denomination from their faith, that is equivocall in like manner, and so the common Division of faith into Dogmatical or Historical, temporary, miraculous, and justifying is but a Division of an Aequivocum in sua Aequivocata, which I should think no man should affirm, much less Mr. Baxter, who makes common and special grace to differ only gradually; and then as cold in a remiss degree may grow to that which is intense; so one Aequivocatum may rise up to the Nature of another: animal terrestre, may become Sydus Coeleste.
Ans. 1. Its no good consequence: because the word [Saint] is Equivocal, therefore the word [Believer] is so. 2. Our dispute is not about the sense of the word [Faith] or [Believer] in General: but about the [Christian Faith] in special, from whence a man is to be properly called a Christian, and upon the profession whereof he is to be baptized; for I told you once already, that as Faith is taken in General, so your lower ⟨p. 476⟩sort of faith is truly and properly Faith; and so is believing in Mahomet: To distinguish Faith into Divine and Humane, and into Christian and Mahometan &c, is not aequivoci in sua aequivocata divisio: But to distinguish the Christian Faith which entitleth to Baptism, into saving Faith, and that which is short of it, is aequivoci in sua aequivocata. 3. If you thought No man had been guilty of this conceit, whether that thought do more disparage the said assertion, or your self, I must not be judge; but I take it as if you had said, [I thought no man had written against Bellarmines definition of the Church] 4. As to your [No Man; much less Mr. Baxter] as I know not the reason of your thought, unless you indeed take me not only to be No Man, but to be somewhat distinct both from a man and no man; so I am as little satisfied with the Reason which you allege: For 1. It is a Gross untruth unworthy a Divine and a Brother, that I hold common and special Grace to differ only gradually. And that this should be deliberately published, even after I had given the world in print so full an account of the mistake of this accusation from another, once and again, this is yet less ingenuous, and doth but tell us what we must expect from Brethren when passion is predominant. I never affirmed any more than this, [that there is a Moral specific difference, between special and common Graces founded in a Natural Gradual difference.] I manifested in print that Dr. Kendall who writeth against me on this occasion, doth not only say the same thing, but profess that others differ not from me, and resolveth his dispute into a reprehension of me for pretending a difference. Yet after all these writings my reverend Brother Mr. Blake sticks not to affirm to this and future Ages in print that I hold [Only a Gradual difference,] without any more ado. And of such dealing I may say his Book is too full. 5. Your reason is no reason;