A26886:1505
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Disputation 5: The fifth Disputation.Disputation 5: The fift Disputation.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Pag. 156. I must profess that in perusing all Mr. Blake's book, I found but one place, that at the first reading might seem to an impartial man (of intellectuals no stronger than mine,) to be a successful confutation of any one of my Arguments, and that is the next, where repeating my Argument (that the distribution of the Church into visible and invisible, is but of a subject into diverse adjuncts; therefore the members that are merely visible, are indeed no part &c, because adjuncts are no part of the essence: he answers [The consequence might as fairly have bin that these members which are invisible, are no parts &c.] I confess at the first view its a plausible answer, but open it, and the inside is no better than the rest. For my argument takes the adjunct as conjunct with the reason of the denomination, and Invisible is not a real adjunct, but a negative denomination; and so the argument is thus [The Church is called Invisible from its internal essential form, which is invisible; and its called visible but from its external accidental form which is visible: therefore those Members that are merely visible (note; I said, Merely,) are but Equivocally called members of the Church, because they participate only of the accidental form, and not at all of the essential. Thus argue the Protestants ordinarily against Bellarmine. And now where is Mr. Blake's splendid answer, Invisibility is but an adjunct, no more than visibility; true; and not so much neither. But the Reason of the denomination, or the thing denominated Invisible, is that which Protestants call the essence, and that called visible is but an Accident in their account.
Pag. 156. I must profess that in perusing all Mr. Blake's book, I found but one place, that at the first reading might seem to an impartial man (of intellectuals no stronger than mine,) to be a successful confutation of any one of my Arguments, and that is the next, where repeating my Argument (that the distribution of the Church into visible and invisible, is but of a subject into diverse adjuncts; therefore the members that are meerly visible, are indeed no part &c, because adjuncts are no part of the essence: he answers [The consequence might as fairly have bin that these members which are invisible, are no parts &c.] I confess at the first view its a pausible answer, but open it, and the inside is no better than the rest. For my argument takes the adjunct as conjunct with the reason of the denomination, and Invisible is not a real adjunct, but a negative denomination; and so the argument is thus [The Church is called Invisible from its internal essential form, which is invisible; and its called visible but from its external accidental form which is visible: therefore those Members that are meerly visible (note; I said, Meerly,) are but Equivocally called members of the Church, because they participate only of the accidental form, and not at all of the essential. Thus argue the Protestants ordinarily against Bellarmine. And now where is Mr. Blakes splendid answer, Invisibility is but an adjunct, no more than visibility; true; and not so much neither. But the Reason of the denomination, or the thing denominated Invisible, is that which Protestants call the essence, and that called visible is but an Accident in their account.