A26886:1535
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Disputation 5: The fifth Disputation.Disputation 5: The fift Disputation.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And as to the main bulk of his Disputes against me, I must needs say that there is such ordinary mistaking the sense, or quite overlooking the drift of my Arguments and Answers, and obscuring the matter with mere shifts and confusions, that if I should give a punctual answer to such a book, I think the perusal of it would be ungrateful to the Reader. For what profit can it be to any man to be convinced at so dear a rate, how much Mr. Blake hath miscarried in his arguing? I know my censures of his labours are like to be provoking: But who can help that? Had I thought him in the right, I had never contradicted him. Or could I yet see that I have erred, I must needs approve that light which did reveal it: And if I be in the wrong, it is no news for an erring man to think that he doth not err; and if he think not so, he doth not err in mind, but in word. But if I prove in the right, if it will not excuse me that I do but ward off the blow that he giveth me, not that I plead for Gods truth, at least let it excuse me that some evidence is cogent, and some light so constraining that I cannot choose but think as I do think, till I have better evidence to the contrary than doth appear in Mr. Blake's Reply. And so little is my understanding at the disposal of my will, that if my life lay on it, I could not choose but be persuaded in my heart, that Mr. Blake's Reply is so full of mistakes, and built upon such misunderstanding of the words that he Replieth to, that it tendeth more to darken the truth than to clear it, and to pervert the inconsiderate that will take things on trust, or think his cause best that hath the last word to colour it, and put a gloss upon it: and that there needs no more with the judicious Reader that is willing to try before he trust, and thinks the truth is worth his labour, than impartially to read over the words that Mr. Blake doth Reply to, for the manifesting of the insufficiency of his Reply, as to the main of the cause. He will ⟨p. 492⟩think this is great confidence; but what Remedy? I think he is near as confident: though both be not in the right. And I doubt not but Dr. Owen can see the height of my Pride in this confidence. But certainly when ever I come to be so humble as to believe all that such Reverend Brethren say, I must needs be so Proud as to disbelieve those that contradict them;
And as to the main bulk of his Disputes against me, I must needs say that there is such ordinary mistaking the sence, or quite overlooking the drift of my Arguments and Answers, and obscuring the matter with meer shifts and confusions, that if I should give a punctual answer to such a book, I think the perusal of it would be ungratefull to the Reader. For what profit can it be to any man to be convinced at so dear a rate, how much Mr. Blake hath miscaried in his arguing? I know my censures of his labors are like to be provoking: But who can help that? Had I thought him in the right, I had never contradicted him. Or could I yet see that I have erred, I must needs approve that light which did reveal it: And if I be in the wrong, it is no news for an erring man to think that he doth not err; and if he think not so, he doth not err in minde, but in word. But if I prove in the right, if it will not excuse me that I do but ward off the blow that he giveth me, not that I plead for Gods truth, at least let it excuse me that some evidence is cogent, and some light so constraining that I cannot chuse but think as I do think, till I have better evidence to the contrary than doth appear in Mr. Blakes Reply. And so little is my understanding at the disposal of my will, that if my life lay on it, I could not choose but be perswaded in my heart, that Mr. Blakes Reply is so full of mistakes, and built upon such misunderstanding of the words that he Replyeth to, that it tendeth more to darken the truth than to clear it, and to pervert the inconsiderate that will take things on trust, or think his cause best that hath the last word to colour it, and put a gloss upon it: and that there needs no more with the judicious Reader that is willing to try before he trust, and thinks the truth is worth his labour, than impartially to read over the words that Mr. Blake doth Reply to, for the manifesting of the insufficiency of his Reply, as to the main of the cause. He will