A26886:1548
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Disputation 5: The fifth Disputation.Disputation 5: The fift Disputation.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And whereas he is so confident that according to my opinion, the Baptism of the unjustified is a Nullity, and that they must be Baptized again, and saith, that [its much to be feared, if not certainly to be concluded, that the Major part by far of the Worcestershire combination consists of unbaptized persons, &c.] pag. 142, 143. I answer 1. it is a mere naked unproved assertion, ⟨p. 500⟩that any such consequent doth follow on these grounds: Nor can he ever prove it. If the outward ordinance were rightly administered, and the inward covenanting of the heart were not performed, it is not that which was well done that must be done again, but that must be done which was at first omitted, even sincere internal covenanting or believing. 2. But it is much more disputable according to his principles, whether all that he should so Baptize, must not be rebaptized? For as the ancient Councils which were against Cyprian's and the rest of the Carthaginians Rebaptizing, did yet decree that all should be rebaptized that were Baptized by the Paulionists (not that they allowed really of twice Baptizing, but that the first was but Baptism Equivocally so called) because they Baptized not into the Name of the Trinity; so if we should upon the new Doctrine take up a new Baptism, upon a mere Dogmatical faith, which is not a believing in God the Father, Son and Holy Ghost, but only a Believing that there is a Father, Son and Holy Ghost, (and add, if you will, a Promise to believe in them hereafter) I should be hardly put to it to prove these persons truly Baptized, and, that it being a Nullity, all were not to be done again: and yet some Brethren of Mr. Blake's mind think, that my Judgement opens the way to Rebaptizing; when I doubt it will be hard to avoid it, as to every person, in the way that he disputeth for. Not that I think that any one should be rebaptized that is Baptized by Mr. Blake or any of them. For I am confident that neither he, nor they did ever practice their own doctrine, nor ever Baptized one person but upon the profession of justifying faith it self.
And whereas he is so confident that according to my opinion, the Baptism of the unjustifyed is a Nullity, and that they must be Baptized again, and saith, that [its much to be feared, if not certainly to be concluded, that the Major part by far of the Worcestershire combination consists of unbaptized persons, &c.] pag. 142, 143. I answer 1. it is a meer naked unproved assertion, ⟨p. 500⟩