A26886:1549
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Disputation 5: The fifth Disputation.Disputation 5: The fift Disputation.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
3. But why do they not see, that on their own grounds many of their own Baptizings would be Nullities, and the persons be Rebaptized. If a Dogmatical faith it self be of necessity to the Being of Baptism, then what shall be done with those many hundred Children among us, whose Parents discover to us that they have not that Dogmatical faith? How many have we oft occasion to speak with, that marvel when we tell them what Christ is, and hath done and suffered for us, as if they had never hard it before, when yet they sit under our teaching day by day? like Dr. John White's Catechumen, that being asked what ⟨p. 501⟩Jesus Christ was? answered that [she did not know; she was never taught so far; but sure enough it is some good thing, or it should never have been put into the Creed.] Would Mr. Blake have the Children of all these rebaptized, or not? If yea, then he is more than I for rebaptizing: if not, then how will it follow any more from my judgement that the Children of the unjustified must be Rebaptized? I cannot conceive what he can say (without going to the right of remote ancestors, or the Church which is no more for him than for me,) but only that it is the profession of a Dogmatical Faith, and not the Faith it self that is necessary to give this Right. But a man would think that if it be not enough for an evidence in our case of an Analogical Right Coram Ecclesiâ, that a man subscribe the Covenant of God (of which Mr. Blake pag. 143.) then it can be no good evidence in his cause of a Right Coram Deo & Ecclesiâ, that a man subscribe or speak that which he never understood: or if his Profession of Dogmatical Faith without the Faith itself be a good Title, then the Profession of a justifying Faith without the Faith it self, may so far serve turn as to justify the Baptizing, and to prohibit rebaptizing.
3. But why do they not see, that on their own grounds many of their own Baptizings would be Nullities, and the persons be Rebaptized. If a Dogmatical faith it self be of necessity to the Being of Baptism, then what shall be done with those many hundred Children among us, whose Parents discover to us that they have not that Dogmatical faith? How many have we oft occasion to speak with, that marvail when we tell them what Christ is, and hath done and suffered for us, as if they had never hard it before, when yet they sit under our teaching day by day? like Dr. John White's Catechumene, that being asked what ⟨p. 501⟩