A26886:1562
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Disputation 5: The fifth Disputation.Disputation 5: The fift Disputation.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And that you may see what impossibility there is of pleasing all men, see what he saith of my Apology against Mr Blake, which cost so much on the other side; p. 4, 5. [Though in the first three or four hours reading that morning, of the first part, of your Apology to Mr. Blake, I was very much taken with so much of a profound, deep & rational Judgement, with such a clear and solid understanding, & with so great a height of a piercing wit, as I did apprehend in some of your reasonings & explications of some points by you holden forth there, &c.] And so he goes on to show that in the afternoons Reading against Dr. Kendall, I struck down all the milk that I had given in the morning. Many men, many minds. Even fair fall you Sir, for I see you are a kind man when the fit comes on you; and when I please you, your commendations swell over the banks of common discretion. But what shall I give you to make Mr. Blake of your opinion? Or to teach me how I may please you both, with the rest of the offended?
And that you may see what impossibility there is of pleasing all men, see what he saith of my Apologie against Mr Blake, which cost so much on the other side; p. 4, 5. [Though in the first three or four hours reading that morning, of the first part, of your Apologie to Mr. Blake, I was very much taken with so much of a profound, deep & rational Judgement, with such a clear and solid understanding, & with so great a height of a piercing wit, as I did apprehend in some of your reasonings & explications of some points by you holden forth there, &c.] And so he goes on to shew that in the afternoons Reading against Dr. Kendall, I struck down all the milk that I had given in the morning. Many men, many minds. Even fair fall you Sir, for I see you are a kind man when the fit comes on you; and when I please you, your commendations swell over the banks of common discretion. But what shall I give you to make Mr. Blake of your opinion? Or to teach me how I may please you both, with the rest of the offended?
Another part of Mr. Robertson's task, is to satisfy the world how ignorant Mr. Hotchkis and I are of the Hebrew, and careless of it aswell as ignorant. And I may undo the man if I should confute him here: for he hath bound himself in a most solemn Obligation, p. 82. that if he [do not make it good what here is challenged, against all the four eyes of us both, (that both of us have no eyes at all to see with of our own, & therefore see nothing at all with our own eye in those points, but all the dim sight we have, its only by seeing with other mens eyes, &c.) then he promises to shut & turn away both his own eyes from ever looking upon a book again whilst he breaths, even the Bible it self, wch yet he would not do for a kingdom,