A26886:1551
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Disputation 5: The fifth Disputation.Disputation 5: The fift Disputation.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And whereas Mr. Blake doth instead of answering cast aside above twenty of my Arguments as not concerning him, and so put them off with a wet finger; I say, that's too easy a way of ⟨p. 502⟩answering to satisfy me, how ever it may do by those that are more easily satisfied? and with a word I shall restore and reinforce them, as with a word he puts them by.
And whereas Mr. Blake doth instead of answering cast aside above twenty of my Arguments as not concerning him, and so put them off with a wet finger; I say, that's too easie a way of ⟨p. 502⟩answering to satisfie me, how ever it may do by those that are more easily satisfied? and with a word I shall restore and reenforce them, as with a word he puts them by.
It is one thing to ask, whether the profession of justifying Faith be a duty to all that come to be Baptized? Another, whether it be so necessary, that they ought not to come nor we to admit them without it? and a third, whether Baptism without it be a Nullity? Mr. Blake's general assertion did in the proper sense express the first. And thereupon, because I took his words as he spoke them, he better expoundeth them, and confesseth that justifying Faith is a duty prerequisite to Baptism, but not such a duty, without which Baptism is Null, or we may not Baptize: and therefore he puts off above twenty Arguments at once, and saith that they make nothing against him. But I restore them all or most at once (though one is enough) by telling him, that they prove that the profession of a Faith that is justifying, must be expected by the Church and found in all that are admitted to Baptism, and that none ought to be Baptized upon the profession of any lower Faith. This they prove: and this is the controversy.
It is one thing to ask, whether the profession of justifying Faith be a duty to all that come to be Baptized? Another, whether it be so necessary, that they ought not to come nor we to admit them without it? and a third, whether Baptism without it be a Nullity? Mr. Blakes general assertion did in the proper sence express the first. And thereupon, because I took his words as he spoke them, he better expoundeth them, and confesseth that justifying Faith is a duty prerequisite to Baptism, but not such a duty, without which Baptism is Null, or we may not Baptize: and therefore he puts off above twenty Arguments at once, and saith that they make nothing against him. But I restore them all or most at once (though one is enough) by telling him, that they prove that the profession of a Faith that is justifying, must be expected by the Church and found in all that are admitted to Baptism, and that none ought to be Baptized upon the profession of any lower Faith. This they prove: and this is the controversie.