A26886:1564
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Disputation 5: The fifth Disputation.Disputation 5: The fift Disputation.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And is it not (think you) an honest and sober dispute upon which he brings out his Hebrew, when I had so fully explained myself in my Confession, of which he is pleased to take no notice? I still maintain that Punishment properly so called, hath (at least) two species, Paradeigmatical and strictly Vindictive, and Nouthetical or Castigatory: and so that Chastisement is truly and properly called punishment; but not of the same species, with the former vindictive or destructive punishment. Now what doth this Learned Brother but over and over again, so far lay by the ninth Commandment and the fear of God, as to face down me, and assure his Reader, that I affirm and maintain the sufferings of the Godly to be not only Chastisements, but proper Punishments, yea Revenging Punishments for the satisfaction of God as a Judge? And what should one say to such a man as this? and how is he to be dealt with? Proper Punishments (I say) they are; because I maintain that Castigations are proper paternal punishments. And are not all the Philosophers that ever defined punishment, (so far as I know) agreed in it? But is this to say, They are vindictive, satisfactory to Justice, or more than chastisements?
And is it not (think you) an honest and sober dispute upon which he brings out his Hebrew, when I had so fully explained myself in my Confession, of which he is pleased to take no notice? I still maintain that Punishment properly so called, hath (at least) two species, Paradeigmatical and strictly Vindictive, and Nouthetical or Castigatory: and so that Chastisement is truly and properly called punishment; but not of the same species, with the former vindictive or destructive punishment. Now what doth this Learned Brother but over and over again, so far lay by the ninth Commandement and the fear of God, as to face down me, and assure his Reader, that I affirm and maintain the sufferings of the Godly to be not only Chastisements, but proper Punishments, yea Revenging Punishments for the satisfaction of God as a Judge? And what should one say to such a man as this? and how is he to be dealt with? Proper Punishments (I say) they are; because I maintain that Castigations are proper paternal punishments. And are not all the Philosophers that ever defined punishment, (so far as I know) agreed in it? But is this to say, They are vindictive, satisfactory to Justice, or more than chastisements?