2. And for the next Conclusion, it cannot be proved by the Example of Judas that we must take a Profession simply for it self, and not respectively as a sign of the thing Professed; and so that we must admit a man upon a Profession which is known to us to be false. For, if you argue from Christs example and say, [Christ did so, therefore we must do so] I deny both the Antecedent and the Consequence. 1. As to the Antecedent: Christ Commanded and Required Judas his Profession as a sign of his mind and so of the thing professed; that is, as True▪ And he neither Required nor Accepted any other profession: But only he Permitted him to remain in his family, ⟨p. 526⟩though his profession was false, and not such as he required. 2. As to the Consequence: No man therefore can hence argue, that we may Require or Accept a profession which is not a sign (apparent) of the thing professed; for that Christ did not; nor yet that we must permit a known false professor because Christ did. But this will be proved under the next points to which it leads us. The other two depending on the same grounds may be dispatched together. And so I conclude, that it cannot be gathered from the example of Judas, that we must not excommunicate, or keep from the Lords Table, such as we can prove to the Church to be unregenerate, or to be such as Judas was. For 1. There may be Reasons to suspend the performance of that which ordinarily is to be done. And so Christ had special Reasons to forbear the excommunicating of Judas, till the last, because he was to be the Instrument of his suffering, that the Scripture might be fulfilled. When we are sure that we have as good a Reason to suspend an act of discipline, yet that will not be an excuse for our ordinary suspense, or a Rule for our ordinary practice. 2. The Lord Jesus would have Ministers lye under a double obligation, for their safe proceeding: The one is, to take seeming Believers and Penitent persons into the Church and to the Sacraments: The other is to take a Credible Profession for the Evidence of that Faith and Repentance. And accordingly he would teach us no more by his example. And therefore no wonder if he did not excommunicate Judas or keep him from the Sacrament: for it was by his Divine heart-searching power, and omniscience that Christ knew Judas to be an hypocrite: while he made a Profession that was Probable or Credible to a mere man.
2. And for the next Conclusion, it cannot be proved by the Example of Iudas that we must take a Profession simply for it self, and not respectively as a sign of the thing Professed; and so that we must admit a man upon a Profession which is known to us to be false. For, if you argue from Christs example and say, [Christ did so, therefore we must do so] I deny both the Antecedent and the Consequence. 1. As to the Antecedent: Christ Commanded and Required Iudas his Profession as a sign of his mind and so of the thing professed; that is, as True▪ And he neither Required nor Accepted any other profession: But only he Permitted him to remain in his famil•, ⟨p. 526⟩though his profession was false, and not such as he required. 2. As to the Consequence: No man therefore can hence argue, that we may Require or Accept a profession which is not a sign (apparent) of the thing professed; for that Christ did not; nor yet that we must permit a known false professor because Christ did. But this will be proved under the next points to which it leads us. The other two depending on the same grounds may be dispatcht together. And so I conclude, that it cannot be gathered from the example of Judas, that we must not excommunicate, or keep from the Lords Table, such as we can prove to the Church to be unregenerate, or to be such as Judas was. For 1. There may be Reasons to suspend the performance of that which ordinarily is to be done. And so Christ had special Reasons to forbear the excommunicating of Judas, till the last, because he was to be the Instrument of his suffering, that the Scripture might be fulfilled. When we are sure that we have as good a Reason to suspend an act of discipline, yet that will not be an excuse for our ordinary suspense, or a Rule for our ordinary practice. 2. The Lord Jesus would have Ministers lye under a double obligation, for their safe proceeding: The one is, to take seeming Believers and Penitent persons into the Church and to the Sacraments: The other is to take a Credible Profession for the Evidence of that Faith and Repentance. And accordingly he would teach us no more by his example. And therefore no wonder if he did not excommunicate Judas or keep him from the Sacrament: for it was by his Divine heart-searching power, and omniscience that Christ knew Judas to be an hypocrite: while he made a Profession that was Probable or Credible to a meer man.