A26886:1607
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
All therefore that can hence be gathered is, that if by heart-searching omniscience we knew a man to be an Hypocrite, we might not keep him back or excommunicate him: and yet that will not be proved from the Text neither; till you can prove that Christ might not have cast out Judas, as well as that he did not; for, as is said, he might forbear him for some special Cause; Though I grant that on other grounds it may possibly be proved, that we might not do it, because we cannot communicate our evidence to the Church. But there is no place ⟨p. 527⟩for this arguing, till men are omniscient. Christ is our pattern as he acteth as a man, and not when he exerciseth Divine omniscience.
3. Christ knew what was in man, and need not that any man should tell him, John 2.25. And yet he questioned with men in humane Language; he asketh some whether they believed, and Peter, whether he loved him? Did he expect an answer from men, for the bare words sake? or as a sign of their mind? Did he oblige them to a true answer, or to a false? The case is not doubtful. And if by his omniscience he knew that many of these answers were lies, (and yet he silently permitted the answerer to seem a Disciple) it will not hence follow, that we must accept a profession simply for it self, and when it is not credible, that is, that we must believe a known lye, or that we must use those that we have no cause to believe as if we did believe them.
3. Christ knew what was in man, and need not that any man should tell him, John 2.25. And yet he questioned with men in humane Language; he asketh some whether they believed, and Peter, whether he loved him? Did he expect an answer from men, for the bare words sake? or as a sign of their mind? Did he oblige them to a true answer, or to a false? The case is not doubtfull. And if by his omniscience he knew that many of these answers were lyes, (and yet he silently permitted the answerer to seem a Disciple) it will not hence follow, that we must accept a profession simply for it self, and when it is not credible, that is, that we must believe a known lye, or that we must use those that we have no cause to believe as if we did believe them.