A26974:708
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions…
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions of divers learned and reverend brethren / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
It seemeth to me so great a debasing of faith, as to make it to be no virtue at all, nor to have any moral good in it. For though I have read of Passio perfectiva in genere entis vel naturae, and conducible to virtue; Yet am I not convinced yet that any Passion as such, hath any moral virtue in it. Indeed Passion may be the quasi materiale, but the virtue is in Action. Yea, even in non-acting, (as silence) the virtue lies formally in the actual exercise of the Authority of Reason, and so obeying God in causing that silence. Sure if men shall be all judged according to their works, and according to what they have done, &c. then it will not be because they did either Pati vel non pati. And thus you have some of my reasons why I cannot believe that Believing is passion, nor shall believe it I think, till Credere be Pati, and then I may whether I will or no, because pati vel non pati are not in my choice. 3. The third Question is, Whether faith be passive in its instrumentality? And I think that is out of doubt, if my former arguing have proved that faith is not passive at all: or if I next prove that faith is no physical instrument. But yet if I should grant both that faith is passive, and that it is an Instrument, yet must I have either more or less Logic before I can believe that it is passive in its instrumentality. My reasons against it are these. 1. Every Instrumental cause is an efficient cause: but all true efficiency is by action: ⟨p. 208⟩therefore all instrumentality is by action. That causalitas efficientis est Actio; & haec est forma per quam denominatur efficiens; quia agens & efficiens sunt idem, &c. I have been taught so oft and so confidently that I believe it. (For oportet discentem credere): and that by Philosophers of no mean esteem, as Suarez Tom. 1. disp. 18. §. 10. Javel. Metaph l. 9. q. 16. Conim. Colleg. Phys. l. 2. q. 6. art. 2. & 7. Scaliger. Exerit. 254. Aquinas, Ruvio, Porrece, Melancth. Zanchius, Zabarel, Pererius, Schibler, Stierius, Gu. Temple. in Ram. with many more. And if there be no such thing in rerum natura as a Passive instrument, then faith is none such. I know Keckerm. Alsted. & Burgersdicius do talk of a Passive instrument; but I think in proper speech it is a contradiction, in adjecto and say as Schibler Metaphys. l. 1. cap. 22. Tit. 7. p. 319. Nisi Actionem propriam haberet Instrumentum, efficiens non esset;
It seemeth to me so great a debasing of faith, as to make it to be no vertue at all, nor to have any moral good in it. For though I have read of Passio perfectiva in genere entis vel naturae, and conducible to vertue; Yet am I not convinced yet that any Passion as such, hath any moral vertue in it. Indeed Passion may be the quasi materiale, but the vertue is in Action. Yea, even in non-acting, (as silence) the vertue lies formally in the actual exercise of the Authority of Reason, and so obeying God in causing that silence. Sure if men shall be all judged according to their works, and according to what they have done, &c. then it will not be because they did either Pati vel non pati. And thus you have some of my reasons why I cannot believe that Believing is passion, nor shall believe it I think, till Credere be Pati, and then I may whether I will or no, because pati vel non pati are not in my choice. 3. The third Question is, Whether faith be passive in its instrumentality? And I think that is out of doubt, if my former arguing have proved that faith is not passive at all: or if I next prove that faith is no physical instrument. But yet if I should grant both that faith is passive, and that it is an Instrument, yet must I have either more or less Logick before I can believe that it is passive in its instrumentality. My reasons against it are these. 1. Every Instrumental cause is an efficient cause: but all true efficiency is by action: