But to proceed, as these two Sanhedrins were instituted in the Law of Moses, so were they after decay or desuetude restored by Jehoshaphat,1, 2 Chro. 19.8. Sutlivius answereth, that we have here only one Sanhedrin which judged both the Lords matters, and the Kings matters, and that it was not an Ecclesiastical Court, because it judged causes of blood, and other civill causes wherein appellation was made from the Judges of the Cities. By the Lords matters, he saith, are meant criminal and civill causes, which were to be judged according to the Law of the Lord; and by the Kings matters are meant, his patrimony and domestic affairs. Answer 1. The Text distinguisheth two Courts, one which meddled with the Lords matters, whose president was Amariah, the chief Priest: another which meddled with the Kings matters, whose president was Zebadiah. This is so plain, that Bonfierius the Jesuit on Deut. 17. though he maketh the Priests to have been the Judges, yet acknowledgeth two distinct Courts, 2 Chron. 19. 2. The words vers. 8. must be understood respectively,2 as Didoclavius hath observed, which we explain thus, Moreover in Jerusalem did Jehoshaphat set of the Levites, ⟨p. 173⟩and of the Priests, and of the chief of the Fathers of Israel, for the judgement of the Lord, (that is for causes Ecclesiastical) and (repeat, of the Levites, of the Priests, and of the chief of the Fathers of Israel) for controversies (about civill matters, saith Piscator.) So that some of them were appointed to judge the one, and some of them to judge the other, which proveth not either that the Courts were one, or that the same men sate in both, but only that some of the Priests and some of the Fathers of Israel were in both. 3. The Lords matters Lavater and Piscator expound to be matters Ecclesiastical, the Kings matters to be things civill; and this exposition comprehendeth all things which did fall within the power of those Courts. But Sutlivius gloss doth not so, for there were sundry things to be judged which were neither the Kings domestic affairs, not yet causes criminal or civill, such as were questions about vows, questions about the meaning of the Law, and judging betwixt the holy and the profane, betwixt that which was clean and that which was unclean.
But to proceed, as these two Sanedrims were instituted in the Law of Moses, so were they after decay or desuetude restored by Iehoshaphat,1, 2 Chro. 19.8. Sutlivius answereth, that wee have here only one Sanedrim which judged both the Lords matters, and the Kings matters, and that it was not an Ecclesiasticall Court, because it judged causes of blood, and other civill causes wherein appellation was made from the Judges of the Cities. By the Lords matters, hee saith, are meant criminall and civill causes, which were to be judged according to the Law of the Lord; and by the Kings matters are meant, his patrimony and domesticke affaires. Answer 1. The Text distinguisheth two Courts, one which medled with the Lords matters, whose president was Amariah, the chiefe Priest: another which medled with the Kings matters, whose president was Zebadiah. This is so plaine, that Bonfierius the Jesuit on Deut. 17. though he maketh the Priests to have beene the Judges, yet acknowledgeth two distinct Courts, 2 Chron. 19. 2. The words vers. 8. must be understood respectively,2 as Didoclavius hath observed, which we explaine thus, Moreover in Ierusalem did Iehshoaphat set of the Levits, ⟨p. 173⟩and of the Priests, and of the chiefe of the Fathers of Israel, for the judgement of the Lord, (that is for causes Ecclesiasticall) and (repeat, of the Levits, of the Priests, and of the chiefe of the Fathers of Israel) for controversies (about civill matters, saith Piscator.) So that some of them were appointed to judge the one, and some of them to judge the other, which proveth not either that the Courts were one, or that the same men sate in both, but only that some of the Priests and some of the Fathers of Israel were in both. 3. The Lords matters Lavater and Piscator expound to be matters Ecclesiasticall, the Kings matters to be things civill; and this exposition comprehendeth all things which did fall within the power of those Courts. But Sutlivius glosse doth not so, for there were sundry things to be judged which were neither the Kings domesticke affaires, not yet causes criminall or civill, such as were questions about vowes, questions about the meaning of the Law, and judging betwixt the holy and the prophane, betwixt that which was cleane and that which was uncleane.
- 1U•i supra p. 20.
- 2Alt. dam. p. 24.