A42764:53
A late dialogue betwixt a civilian and a divine concerning the present condition of…
A late dialogue betwixt a civilian and a divine concerning the present condition of the Church of England in which, among other particulars, these following are especially spoken of ...
London: printed for Robert Bostock, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The persons judging, are not civill but Ecclesiastical, Tell it unto the Church, now in all the New Testament, the name of the Church is not given to any Civill Magistrate. Nay Christ himself doth immediately give us notice, that by the Church there he means the Ministers and Rulers of the Church, for thus he applieth it unto the Apostles, and their successors, Whatsoever ye shall bind, &c. and if two of you shall agree, &c. And here by the way, I must tell you, that if the Jewish Sanhedrin were here mean• (as it is not) you could not thence conclude that a civill Court is meant, for there was an Ecclesiastical Sanhedrin, distinct from the civill, as beside many other great Authors is proved by Constantinus, l' Emp. Annot. in C••. Middoth, p. 188. and de Rep. Jud. p. 389. Which Ecclesiastical Sanhedrin were the rather to be understood in this Text, because the other Sanhedrin was destroyed by Herod. ⟨p. 28⟩4. The way and manner of proceeding, is also Ecclesiastical, not civill; when Church Governors meet about those things, it must be with Prayer, vers. 19. and it must be in the Name of Christ, vers. 20. which places, though they well agree to all holy Assemblies and meetings for Worship, yet the context showeth, that they are principally intended concerning Assemblies for Discipline and Church censures; and so Tostatus, Hugo Cardinalis, with our own Divines, do expound the Text. 5. The censure is spiritual, as appeareth both by the •llusion to the Jewish Excommunication (of which I have spoken before) in those words, let him be unto thee as a Heathen, or a Publican, and by the phrase of binding the soul, or retaining of sins, vers. 18. which power, our Lord elsewhere giveth to his Apostles, Mat. 16.19. Jo. 20.23. forms of speech, which no where the Scripture useth of any civill power: only it is to be observed, that in these two places last cited, the Apostles get power to bind and loose by their Doctrine and Preaching, but here, Mat. 18. to bind and loose by Discipline, as appeareth by the use to be made of witnesses, vers. 16. that is, potestas clavium doctrinalis: this potestas clavium disciplinalis. That is mystical: this political. And whereas it is objected, that the Text saith not, let him be to the Church, but, let him be to thee as an Heathen and a Publican.