A42764:63
A late dialogue betwixt a civilian and a divine concerning the present condition of…
A late dialogue betwixt a civilian and a divine concerning the present condition of the Church of England in which, among other particulars, these following are especially spoken of ...
London: printed for Robert Bostock, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Divine. To me it is plain, that these things do as much concern us now, as the Jews of old, which whosoever denieth, must show, that either we may take no rules nor patterns from the Old Testament: or that the foresaid Laws and practises were not intended by the holy Ghost to bind us, (as other things in the Old Testament do) but were ceremonial and typical, intended to bind the Jews only. Mr. Williams in his bloody Tenant (though I do not remember that any where he answereth to those particular passages which I have cited, yet) perceiving that such arguments from the Old Testament can not be taken off without this answer, that all these were typical and figurative: he therefore goeth much upon that ground, and so deviseth more types and figures in the Old Testament then ever any body did before him, and pleaseth himself with such fancies and conjectures therein, as I dare say, will satisfy no indifferent Reader: and in effect making void by his principles all arguments from the Old Testament, so that we may not from the examples of the godly Kings of Judah, teach Christian Magistrates what their duty ⟨p. 34⟩is, nor argue thus, God commanded that the Kings of Judah should have a copy of the Book of the Law by them, and read therein, that they should not multiply wives, &c. Therefore Christian Princes should search the Scriptures,1 should not multiply wives, &c. or thus. The Priests and Levites had a sufficient maintenance. Therefore so should the Ministers of the Gospel: or thus; The Jews were commanded to rest from all servile labour on the Sabbath day. Therefore so should Christians on the Lords day: or thus; Wars were lawful in the old Testament; Therefore they are lawful still. Or the like. All these shall be cast aside, upon this ground, they were typical, therefore no patterns to us. But because you desire an Argument from the New Testament: I will convince your judgement from thence also: Sure I am, I have better grounds in the New Testament, against the Toleration now in question, then Master John Goodwin hath found for it, in his Text, Act. 5.38.39.
Divine. To me it is plaine, that these things doe as much concerne us now, as the Jewes of old, which whosoever denieth, must shew, that either we may take no rules nor patternes from the Old Testament: or that the foresaid Lawes and practises were not intended by the holy Ghost to binde us, (as other things in the Old Testament doe) but were ceremoniall and typicall, intended to bind the Jewes onely. Mr. Williams in his bloody Tenant (though I doe not remember that any where he answereth to those particular passages which I have cited, yet) perceiving that such arguments from the Old Testament can not be taken off without this answer, that all these were typicall and figurative: he therefore goeth much upon that ground, and so deviseth more types and figures in the Old Testament then ever any body did before him, and pleaseth himselfe with such fancies and conjectures therein, as I dare say, will satisfie no indifferent Reader: and in effect making void by his principles all arguments from the Old Testament, so that we may not from the examples of the godly Kings of Iudah, teach Christian Magistrates what their duty