5thly. Schismatical Separation is a breach of some Sacred Unity. The Schismatic adheres to the Church in part, but withal he breaks in part. He adheres in part, 1or else he would be an Apostate. Thus St. Austin saith of the Donatists, In quo nobiscum sentiunt, in co nobiscum sunt, In what they think with us, in that they are with us. Thus when the Donatists asked whether their Baptism did generate Sons to God; If it did not generate, why doth not the Catholic Church rebaptize them; but if it do generate, then ours (say the Donatists) is the Church. St. Austin makes this answer,2 That the Church of the Donatists doth generate, Unde conjuncta est, non unde Separata est. Separata est à vinculo, Charitatis, sed adjuncta est in uno Baptismate. It generates as it is joined to the Church Catholic, not as it is separated from it. It is separated from the bond of Charity, but it is joined in one Baptism. Thus the Donatists were •oined to the Church in part. Again, The Schismatic, though he adhere to the Church in part, yet withal ⟨p. 58⟩he breaks in part, or else he could be no Schismatic. Thus St. Austin saith of the Donatists, 3In eo à nobis recesserunt, in quo à nobis dissentiunt, In that they are departed from us in which they dissent from us. When Cresconius urged for the Donatists, that there was, una Religio, eadem Sacramenta, nihil in Christianâ observation diversum; 4That on both sides there was the same Religion, the same Sacraments, nothing in Christian observation diverse. (Which Plea by the way, had it been true, would have been good, there being no Schism where there is no breach of Unity.) St. Austin utterly denies it, and asks them, Quare rebaptizatis? Why do you rebaptize those that were baptized in the Catholic Church? Indeed they thought themselves the only Church, and so broke themselves off from the Church Catholic. Thus the Schismatic is partly in conjunction with the Church, and partly in separation from it; he adheres in one thing, and breaks off in another. But is it thus with the Nonconformists? Are not ⟨p. 59⟩they joined to the Church in all that which is truly Unity? Have not they in their Meetings the unity of Ordinances, the same pure Word preached, the same holy Sacraments administered, and this by true Ministers of Christ? And what other Unity is there in Visible Churches?
5thly. Schismatical Separation is a breach of some Sacred Ʋnity. The Schismatick adheres to the Church in part, but withal he breaks in part. He adheres in part, 1or else he would be an Apostate. Thus St. Austin saith of the Donatists, In quo nobiscum sentiunt, in co nobiscum sunt, In what they think with us, in that they are with us. Thus when the Donatists asked whether their Baptism did generate Sons to God; If it did not generate, why doth not the Catholick Church rebaptize them; but if it do generate, then ours (say the Donatists) is the Church. St. Austin makes this answer,2 That the Church of the Donatists doth generate, Ʋnde conjuncta est, non unde Separata est. Separata est à vinculo, Charitatis, sed adjuncta est in uno Baptismate. It generates as it is joined to the Church Catholick, not as it is separated from it. It is separated from the bond of Charity, but it is joined in one Baptism. Thus the Donatists were •oined to the Church in part. Again, The Schismatick, though he adhere to the Church in part, yet withal ⟨p. 58⟩he breaks in part, or else he could be no Schismatick. Thus St. Austin saith of the Donatists, 3In eo à nobis recesserunt, in quo à nobis dissentiunt, In that they are departed from us in which they dissent from us. When Cresconius urged for the Donatists, that there was, una Religio, eadem Sacramenta, nihil in Christianâ observatione diversum; 4That on both sides there was the same Religion, the same Sacraments, nothing in Christian observation diverse. (Which Plea by the way, had it been true, would have been good, there being no Schism where there is no breach of Unity.) St. Austin utterly denies it, and asks them, Quare rebaptizatis? Why do you rebaptize those that were baptized in the Catholick Church? Indeed they thought themselves the only Church, and so broke themselves off from the Church Catholick. Thus the Schismatick is partly in conjunction with the Church, and partly in separation from it; he adheres in one thing, and breaks off in another. But is it thus with the Nonconformists? Are not ⟨p. 59⟩they joined to the Church in all that which is truly Ʋnity? Have not they in their Meetings the unity of Ordinances, the same pure Word preached, the same holy Sacraments administred, and this by true Ministers of Christ? And what other Unity is there in Visible Churches?
- 1De Bapt. cont. Don. l. 1. c. 1.
- 2De Bapt. cont. Don. l. 1. c. 10.
- 3De Bapt. contr. Don. l. 1. c. 1.
- 4Contra Cresc. l. 2. cap. 3.