Chapter 3
pp. 48–10449 passagespart 1 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
CHAP. III.
The Separation of the N. C. is not Schism. Not voluntary. Not from want of Charity. Not from Pride and Contempt. Not attended with Error. No breach of Sacred Unity. Not for little or no Cause. The Rites and Ceremonies for which they separate no little things, as considered in themselves. Of the Sign of the Cross in Baptism. The Ceremonies, as terms of Communion, intrench on Christ's Kingly Office: Invert the Gospel; are against Christian Charity, Liberty and Unity. The Pleas for Ceremonies not satisfactory. Of Order and Decency. Whether the Ceremonies are parts of Worship. N. C. do not separate from the Catholic Church.
The Separation of the N. C. is not Schism. Not voluntary. Not from want of Charity. Not from Pride and Contempt. Not attended with Error. No breach of Sacred Ʋnity. Not for little or no Cause. The Rites and Ceremonies for which they separate no little things, as considered in themselves. Of the Sign of the Cross in Baptism. The Ceremonies, as terms of Communion, intrench on Christ's Kingly Office: Invert the Gospel; are against Christian Charity, Liberty and Ʋnity. The Pleas for Ceremonies not satisfactory. Of Order and Decency. Whether the Ceremonies are parts of Worship. N. C. do not separate from the Catholick Church.
I Now go on to consider the Separation of the Nonconformists, Ministers and People, whether that be Schism or not; in the doing of which I shall review the former Characters with respect to them.
1st. Schismatical Separation is intentional and perfectly voluntary; but quo animo, do the Dissenters separate? In our Law an entry shall not be called a disseisin, partibus invitis, against the will of the Agents. Neither should a Separation in such a Case be in Theology called a Schism. Is it imaginable that the intention or option of the Nonconformists should be to be out of the Church, rather than in it? It is easy to judge who they be that most intend and love Church-unity; those who would have the terms of it easy, plain and unquestionable, or those who would have them clogged with Scruples. The Nonconformists separate; but their parting from the Church, like the Merchant's parting with his Goods in a Storm, is not purely voluntary, but a mixed Action, done with an unwilling will, not out of love to Separation, but to salve Conscience. When the Papists charge Schism upon our Church, what saith Bishop Bramhall? 1Schism is a voluntary Separation; To be separated might be our Consequent will, because we could not help ⟨p. 50⟩it: but it was far enough from our Antecedent will, or that we did desire it. And a little after. If they did impose upon us a necessity of doing sinful things, and offending God, and wounding our Consciences, then we did not leave them, but they did drive us from them. And what saith Dr. Prideaux, Fugati potius quam fugientes, non tam à Roma ut est secessimus, quàm ad Roman ut erat, regressi sumus, We were rather driven away, than voluntarily flying; we are not so much departed from Rome as it is, as we are returned to Rome as it was. In like manner, the Nonconformists being charged with Schism, may say, To separate is not their Antecedent will, but Consequent; they depart from the Church, but it is by a kind of constraint; they had much rather be in the Church; they wish for it, pray for it, and salvâ conscientiâ, would do any thing for it, but there are some things which they cannot join in: Such a departure should not be called Schism.
1st. Schismatical Separation is intentional and perfectly voluntary; but quo animo, do the Dissenters separate? In our Law an entry shall not be called a disseisin, partibus invitis, against the will of the Agents. Neither should a Separation in such a Case be in Theology called a Schism. Is it imaginable that the intention or option of the Nonconformists should be to be out of the Church, rather than in it? It is easy to judge who they be that most intend and love Church-unity; those who would have the terms of it easy, plain and unquestionable, or those who would have them clogg'd with Scruples. The Nonconformists separate; but their parting from the Church, like the Merchant's parting with his Goods in a Storm, is not purely voluntary, but a mixt Action, done with an unwilling will, not out of love to Separation, but to salve Conscience. When the Papists charge Schism upon our Church, what saith Bishop Bramhall?
2dly. Schismatical Separation proceeds from hatred, 1or at least from a want of Charity; but do the Nonconformists thus separate? What is done out of Conscience to God, cannot be fairly interpreted hatred to our Brother. It is love to God that causes men to walk according to Conscience; but it is want of love to him that makes them hate their Brother. These two cannot stand together. If we call that hatred which indeed is Conscience, we forfeit our own Charity by misconstruing the Charity of others. It is the desire of the Nonconformists to live in charity with the Conforming Brethren. In the Council of Carthage St. Cyprian and his Fellow-Bishops, in the point of rebaptizing those that were baptized by Heretics, plainly erred and dissented from the rest of the Church; yet they were never charged with Schism for it, and why? Because they did it neminem judicantes, neo à jure communionis aliquem, si diversum senserit, amoventes: Judging none, ⟨p. 52⟩removing none, that thought otherwise, from the right of Communion. That Error of Rebaptization,2 which in the Donatists was, as St. Austin speaks, Fuligo in tartareâ faeditate, the smoke of their hellish filthiness, was in St. Cyprian but, naevus in candour sanctae Animae, a freckle in the candour of an holy Soul; and the reason was, because St. Cyprian had what they had not, Charitatis ubera, the breasts of Charity to cover his Defects. In respect of this Charity Bishop Davenant saith,3 Melius de Ecclesiâ meruit errans Cyprianus, quam Stephanus Romanus recte sentiens, & Ecclesias quantum in se fuit, Schismatico Spiritu dilacerans. Cyprian, erring, deserved better of the Church, than Stephen, Bishop of Rome, rightly thinking, but by a Schismatical Spirit, as much as he could renting the Churches. Charity is a great thing, and I hope it may be found among the Nonconformists; they leave the Church, neminem judicantes, judging none of their Conforming Brethren the breasts of their Charity may cover some defects. I hope therefore Schism ⟨p. 53⟩in this respect cannot be charged upon them. I am sure Charity is in all good men, Conforming or Nonconforming; but if we compare Parties together, that Party which binds burdens on Conscience, and leaves them there, seems to me to have less of Charity, than that which shrinks and withdraws the Shoulder from them.
3dly. Schismatical Separation issues out of pride and contempt. The Donatists thought themselves the only men; they boasted as if their Communion were the only Communion,1 as if their Baptism were the only Baptism.2 But do the Nonconformists separate thus? Do they say that they only are the Church, or that they only have the Ordinances? Do they despise their Conforming Brethren, or lift up themselves above them? No surely, they desire to be but as Brethren, and that one Brother might not Lord it over another. When our Divines charge ⟨p. 54⟩the Monasteries as Schismatical, because they have separate Meetings and Ordinances, Bellarmin answers thus.3 Soli Schismatici sunt qui ita erigunt altare proprium, ut altare aliorum prophanum censeant. They only are Schismatics, who so set up their own Altar, that they esteem the Altar of others profane. It is indeed one thing to have distinct Meetings for Worship, and another to have opposite ones. The Nonconformists have Meetings of their own, but without the contempt of others. The Jews say, he that contemns the Solemn Assemblies of the Church, hath no part in Seculo futuro. But where the distinct Meetings are without contempt, there, I suppose it is not to be called Schism. Here that may take place; he that is not against the Church, is for it. A candid Charity interprets all to the best.
3dly. Schismatical Separation issues out of pride and contempt. The Donatists thought themselves the only men; they boasted as if their Communion were the only Communion,1 as if their Baptism were the only Baptism.2 But do the Nonconformists separate thus? Do they say that they only are the Church, or that they only have the Ordinances? Do they despise their Conforming Brethren, or lift up themselves above them? No surely, they desire to be but as Brethren, and that one Brother might not Lord it over another. When our Divines charge ⟨p. 54⟩
4thly. Schismatical Separation is ordinarily, if not always, attended with some Error or other. 1The Novatians, Donatists, Luciferians, had their propria Dogmata, their proper ⟨p. 55⟩Errors. Their Separations were to set up their Errors; their Errors under pretence of Truth, were to justify their Separations. Hence St. Cyprian saith, that the Schismatics are,2 Pestes & lues Fidei, corrumpendae veritatis artifices, the Pests and Plagues of the Faith, the Artists in corrupting Truth. But as for the Nonconformists, what new Doctrine do they bring? what Error do they propagate? what deadly poison is under their Lips? Do they not fully and firmly adhere to the Church (as Optatus speaks) in una Fide, in one Faith? 3are they not joined together, ut in manu digiti, as the fingers in the hand pointing out the same pure Doctrine? Bishop Abbot, in his Book De gratiâ & perseverantiâ, tells us of some Corrupters,4 Qui veteres haereses denuo in Scenam producunt, & Pelagianâ lue correpti Gratiae Divinae vim nervosque succidunt, Who bring up the old Heresies upon the stage, and having caught the Pelagian Pestilence, cut asunder the strength and nerves of Divine Grace. Not only some of our men, but Foreigners ⟨p. 56⟩too, have taken notice that the Plague of Socinianism hath been creeping in among us.5 Mr. Rogers upon the Articles of our Church tells us, that he heard a great Learned man speaking of Zanchy's Book, De tribus Elohim, call him a Fool and an Ass. Arnoldus, in his Book against the Racovian Catechism, 6takes notice of the Socinian Heresy creeping up among us. But do the Nonconformists propagate these Errors? Do they spread abroad the poison? Do they not steadily stick to the true pure Doctrine of our Church? And is not conformity in Doctrine much more than conformity in Ceremonies? Surely it is. It seems therefore hard to charge Schism upon them. He indeed goes out of the Church, who goes out, not in Body, but in Faith. Hence it was the judgment of Gersom,
5thly. Schismatical Separation is a breach of some Sacred Unity. The Schismatic adheres to the Church in part, but withal he breaks in part. He adheres in part, 1or else he would be an Apostate. Thus St. Austin saith of the Donatists, In quo nobiscum sentiunt, in co nobiscum sunt, In what they think with us, in that they are with us. Thus when the Donatists asked whether their Baptism did generate Sons to God; If it did not generate, why doth not the Catholic Church rebaptize them; but if it do generate, then ours (say the Donatists) is the Church. St. Austin makes this answer,2 That the Church of the Donatists doth generate, Unde conjuncta est, non unde Separata est. Separata est à vinculo, Charitatis, sed adjuncta est in uno Baptismate. It generates as it is joined to the Church Catholic, not as it is separated from it. It is separated from the bond of Charity, but it is joined in one Baptism. Thus the Donatists were •oined to the Church in part. Again, The Schismatic, though he adhere to the Church in part, yet withal ⟨p. 58⟩he breaks in part, or else he could be no Schismatic. Thus St. Austin saith of the Donatists, 3In eo à nobis recesserunt, in quo à nobis dissentiunt, In that they are departed from us in which they dissent from us. When Cresconius urged for the Donatists, that there was, una Religio, eadem Sacramenta, nihil in Christianâ observation diversum; 4That on both sides there was the same Religion, the same Sacraments, nothing in Christian observation diverse. (Which Plea by the way, had it been true, would have been good, there being no Schism where there is no breach of Unity.) St. Austin utterly denies it, and asks them, Quare rebaptizatis? Why do you rebaptize those that were baptized in the Catholic Church? Indeed they thought themselves the only Church, and so broke themselves off from the Church Catholic. Thus the Schismatic is partly in conjunction with the Church, and partly in separation from it; he adheres in one thing, and breaks off in another. But is it thus with the Nonconformists? Are not ⟨p. 59⟩
Or what of true Unity is there between two Parochial Churches, which is not between their Meetings and Parochial Churches? Abate but Humane things, in which Church unity stands not, and they are not partially, but totally in conjunction with the Church of England; and if so, there is no breach of Unity, and by consequence no Schism in them.1 St. Austin lays down a notable Rule; That he that acts, Sicut in unitate agitur, as it is done in the unity; in eo manet atque conjungitur, in that he abides, and is joined, in all those things wherein Unity stands. The Nonconformists act as the Church doth, therefore they are in conjunction with it. St. Austin tells us,2 That the Church doth in the Donatists acknowledge, Omnia quae sua sunt, all ⟨p. 60⟩things that are its own. Let the Conforming Ministers acknowledge all that of true Unity which is in the Dissenters Meetings, and they may perceive that their Brethren are in conjunction with them. Where there is a total conjunction, there is no breach of true Unity; and where there is no such breach, there is no Schism. But you will say, their departure from the Congregations in public, is a Schism. I answer, Every local Separation is not a Schism there is more in Schism than so. Every departure is not Schism. It is hardly to be called such, when those that depart do yet remain in conjunction with them from whom they depart. And this I think is the Case of those that are Nonconformists.
Or what of true Unity is there between two Pararochial Churches, which is not between their Meetings and Parochial Churches? Abate but Humane things, in which Church unity stands not, and they are not partially, but totally in conjunction with the Church of England; and if so, there is no breach of Unity, and by consequence no Schism in them.1 St. Austin lays down a notable Rule; That he that acts, Sicut in unitate agitur, as it is done in the unity; in eo manet atque conjungitur, in that he abides, and is joined, in all those things wherein Ʋnity stands. The Nonconformists act as the Church doth, therefore they are in conjunction with it. St. Austin tells us,2
6thly. Schismatical Separation is a breach of sacred Unity for little or no cause at all. Hence Irenaeus saith o• the Schismatics, That propter modicas & quaslibet causas, magnum & gloriosum Corpus Christi conscindunt, for little and inconsiderable Causes they cu• ⟨p. 61⟩in pieces the great and glorious Body of Christ. The Professors of Leiden say,1 That a Schismatical Church is that, quae propter externos aliquos ritus, [Greek or Hebrew], Communionem Christianam abrumpit, which for some external indifferent Rites breaks Christian Communion. This Character seems prima facie to press upon the Separation of the Nonconformists. They separate for Rites and Ceremonies, which seem to be but minute and inconsiderable things; this therefore must be duly considered.
6thly. Schismatical Separation is a breach of sacred Unity for little or no cause at all. Hence Irenaeus saith o• the Schismaticks, That propter modicas & quaslibet causas, magnum & gloriosum Corpus Christi conscindunt, for little and inconsiderable Causes they cu• ⟨p. 61⟩in pieces the great and glorious Body of Christ. The Professors of Leyden say,1 That a Schismatical Church is that, quae propter externos aliquos ritus, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Communionem Christianam abrumpit, which for some external indifferent Rites breaks Christian Communion. This Character seems prima facie to press upon the Separation of the Nonconformists. They separate for Rites and Ceremonies, which seem to be but minute and inconsiderable things; this therefore must be duly considered.
- 1Synops. purr. Theol. Disp. 40.Synops. pur. Theol. Disp. 40.
The Ceremonies of our Church may be considered under a double notion; either as they are in themselves, or else as they are terms of Communion.
The Ceremonies, as considered in themselves, however innocent they seem to be to the Conformists, they are not so to the Nonconformists. To instance but in one of them. The Cross in Baptism is looked upon as a thing unlawful, or at least as a thing very ill-coloured, and suspected to be unlawful. To explain this I shall lay down some few things.
The Ceremonies, as considered in themselves, however innocent they seem to be to the Conformists, they are not so to the Nonconformists. To instance but in one of them. The Cross in Baptism is lookt upon as a thing unlawful, or at least as a thing very ill-coloured, and suspected to be unlawful. To explain this I shall lay down some few things.
1st. The Sign of the Cross was indeed used among the Ancient Fathers, but not without a mixture of Superstition. 1Tertullian will have Signaculum Crucis to be necessary in every part of our life. 2St. Cyprian saith, That in hoc Signo Crucis salus sit omnibus qui in frontibus notentur, in this Sign of the Cross there is Salvation to all who have this mark in their Foreheads. Origen saith,3 That fear and trembling falls upon the Devils, cum Signum Crucis in nobis viderint, when they see the Sign of the Cross in us. St. Ambrose saith,4 That all prosperity is in uno Signo Christi, in that one sign of Christ; he that sows in it, shall have a Crop of Eternal Life; he that jour mes in it, shall arrive at Heaven it self. St. Athanasius saith, That Signo• racis omnia magica compescuntur,5 all Conjurations are repressed by the Sign of the Cross. 6St. Chrysostom saith, That all Sacraments are perfected Signo Crucis, with the Sign of the Cross. St. Austin saith,7 That unless the Sign of the Cross be applied to the Forehead of the Believers, or to the Water of Regeneration, or to the Oil with which they ⟨p. 63⟩are anointed, or to the Sacrifice with which they are nourished, nihil eorum rite perficitur, none of these things are rightly performed. 8Such a use of the Cross as this is, Protestants cannot allow of. Only the Papists, who would have Humane Inventions do great things, make use of such Sayings in the Fathers.
1st. The Sign of the Cross was indeed used among the Ancient Fathers, but not without a mixture of Superstition.
2dly. The Sign of the Cross is an abominable Idol in the Popish Church. Bellarmine (who doth distinguish the Cross into three parts, the True Cross, the Image of the Cross, and the Sign of the Cross) lays down this general Doctrine. Omnes Cruces adoramus, 1We worship all Crosses: And particularly of the Sign of the Cross he saith, That it is, Signum sacrum & venerabile, a sacred and venerable Sign. Aquinas saith,2 That the Image of Christ is to be adored, cultu latriae, the Sign is to have the same adoration as the thing it self. And how? which way is it that such an horrible Idol should be retained in a Church Protestant, and pure from Idolatry? The ⟨p. 64⟩Brazen Serpent was ordained by God himself, and yet when it was abused to Idolatry, Hezekiah broke it to pieces, and called it Nehushtan, a piece of brass, 2 Kings 18.4. It was a singular Figure of Christ. The lifting of it up upon a pole for corporal Cures, did by Divine Ordination type out the lifting up of him upon the Cross for spiritual; yet becoming an Idol, it was no more to be endured: And why should the Cross, a mere Human Invention, being once so abused, ever be tolerated? The Children of Israel, Hos. 2.16, 17. were not to mention the names of Idols, that is, honoris gratiâ, in any way for their honour. 3The Fifth Council of Carthage, Can. 15. would have all Idolatrous Relics utterly extinguished. Constantine the Great would not suffer the least Rag or Memorial of Pagan Idolatry to remain: And it is very strange,4 that such an Idol as the Cross should be retained in a Church free from Idolatry.
2dly. The Sign of the Cross is an abominable Idol in the Popish Church. Bellarmine (who doth distinguish the Cross into three parts, the True Cross, the Image of the Cross, and the Sign of the Cross) lays down this general Doctrine. Omnes Cruces adoramus,
3dly. The Sign of the Cross in our own Church, though it be no Idol, yet is an Image; it is not indeed [Greek or Hebrew] a graven Image, but it is [Greek or Hebrew] a similitude of Christ crucified. Representation is the very essence of an Image; and the Sign of the Cross is intended to resemble Christ crucified.1 As the Sacraments are by God's Institution representative Images of Christ's Passion, so is the Cross by Man's; and what doth an Image do in Divine Worship? The Second Commandment shuts out all Images from it; nay, under that notion, it would shut out the very Sacraments, were they not of Divine Ordination. Anciently the Christians would not suffer Images to be in their Churches.2 When the Emperor Adrian commanded Temples to be made without Images, it was presently conceived hat he did prepare them for Christians. 3The Eliberine Council would not admit that Pictures should be in Churches. Epiphanius rent the Veil that hung in the Church of Anablatha, because it had the Image of Christ, or ⟨p. 66⟩some Saint in it. Serenus Bishop of Marseilles, brake down the Images in his Church. The Emperor Theodosius and Valentinian removed, quodcunque Signum Salvatoris, every Sign of a Saviour out of the way. Thus Images have not been admitted into Churches; and how then should they be brought into Ordinances, which are much more sacred than Places? The Image of the Cross should not appear in Divine Worship, in which no other Image is to be admitted, but that,4 quae ho• est quod Deus est, which is that which God is; that is, Jesus Christ the Image of the Invisible God.
3dly. The Sign of the Cross in our own Church, though it be no Idol, yet is an Image; it is not indeed 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 a graven Image, but it is 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 a similitude of Christ crucified. Representation is the very essence of an Image; and the Sign of the Cross is intended to resemble Christ crucified.
4thly. The Sign of the Cross is an addition to Baptism, and so utterly unwarrantable. Under the Old Testament it was unlawful to add to the Ceremonial Law of God, Deut. 4.2. And how should it be lawful under the New to add to the Ceremonial Law of Christ? Christ was as faithful in the House of God as Moses; his provision was as perfect for Rituals, as that […] Moses was. Nay, the Worship under ⟨p. 67⟩the Old Testament being more Shadowy and Ritual, and that under the New more pure and simple; an addition to this is less tolerable than to that, because the purer the Worship is, the more impure is the addition. The Prophet Ezekiel, speaking of the Glory of the Evangelical Church, that it was the place of God's Throne, and of the soles of his feet; adds this, That they should no more set their thresholds by God's, or their posts by his, Ezek. 43.7, & 8. they should not add their own Inventions to God's Precepts. When the Corinthians joined, [Greek or Hebrew], their own supper to the Lord's, it was unjustifiable; and the Apostle expostulates about it, Have ye not houses to eat and to drink in? or despise ye the Church of God? 1 Cor. 11.22. Are there not distinct Houses, and distinct Suppers? why do you join the Civil Supper to the Sacred? The Apostle against such mixtures allegeth that Institution,1 I have received of the Lord that which I delivered unto you, v. 23. Man may not add to what is from God. When the ⟨p. 68⟩Armenians added sod meat to the Lord's Supper, it was condemned by a General Council. When the Artotyritae brought in their bread and cheese into it,2 it was abominable; when they brought in their mulsum or mellitum into it,3 the Church calls it, aliud poculum, another cup; and that, ad grande peccatum & reatum pertinet, it amounts to a great sin and guilt, as being an addition to Christ's Institution. It's true, the Fathers in this Council did through infirmity admit, Vinum cum aquâ mixtum, a mixture of Water with Wine; but another Council will not admit, no not of a little water mixed with the Wine, and adds this reason for it;
When Duraeus cites many Fathers for the many Ceremonies added to Baptism, the Answer of the Learned Whitaker is very excellent.1 Meâ non interest qui• Clemens, quid Leo, quid Damasus ⟨p. 69⟩quid quisquam alius Pontifex ad Baptismi Sacramentum adjecerit; Christus Ecclesiae nihil de istis Ceremoniarum nugis mandavit. I am not concerned what Clemens, Leo, Damasus, or any other Pope hath added to the Sacrament of Baptism; Christ left to his Church nothing in command touching such trifling Ceremonies. 2Sadeel against the Monks of Bordeaux, speaking touching their many Ceremonies added to Baptism as an ornament to it, makes this Answer. Num igitur sunt prudentiores Jesu Christo, qui instituit Baptismum tantâ cum simplicitate & puritate, quique melius novit, quam omnes simul homines, quae illi conveniant ornamenta? Hominis licet pactionem (inquit Paulus) autoritate confirmatam nemo abrogat, aut quid ei super addit. Quae est ista arrogantia adjicere institutioni Jesu Christi? Are they wiser than Jesus Christ, who instituted Baptism with so great simplicity and purity, and who knows much better than all men put together what Ornaments are proper for it? Though it be but a man's Covenant (saith St. Paul) yet if it be confirmed, no man disannulleth ⟨p. 70⟩or addeth thereunto. What arrogance then is it to add to the Institutions of Jesus Christ? This is charged upon the Cross, it is an addition to Baptism; a Sign of Man's added to the Sign of Christ.
When Duraeus cites many Fathers for the many Ceremonies added to Baptism, the Answer of the Learned Whitaker is very excellent.1 Meâ non interest qui• Clemens, quid Leo, quid Damasus ⟨p. 69⟩quid quisquam alius Pontifex ad Baptismi Sacramentum adjecerit; Christus Ecclesiae nihil de istis Ceremoniarum nugis mandavit. I am not concerned what Clemens, Leo, Damasus, or any other Pope hath added to the Sacrament of Baptism; Christ left to his Church nothing in command touching such trifling Ceremonies.
5thly. The Sign of the Cross is not merely an addition to Baptism, but it is a mystical Teacher, and looks very like a Sacrament. It is a mystical Teacher; as the Sacraments teach Christ crucified by God's Ordination, so doth the Cross by Man's. But is not the Scripture sufficient, and Christ the great Prophet? And may Man invent new ways of teaching; or if he do, may any one look for the illuminating Spirit in such ways? Christ is the one Master, the one Teacher by way of excellency; all other Teachers that teach truly, do but teach ministerially under him;1 he hath ordained the perfect means of teaching the Church, and all other means are as none at all. The Cross not teaching under him, teacheth not truly; and being none of his means, hath none ⟨p. 71⟩of his blessing. If the Cross might be a true Teacher, then the standing Images of Christ might be so too, which though called by the Papists Lay-mens Books, do yet but make men forget God. Again, the Sign of the Cross looks very like a Sacrament. Baptism is a Symbol of our Christian Profession, so is the Cross. Baptism hath a word annexed to it; I baptize thee in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost. So hath the Cross, We sign this Child with the Sign of the Cross, in token that he shall not be ashamed to confess the faith of Christ crucified. Baptism points out Christ crucified, so doth the Cross. Baptism enters the baptized into the Church, so doth the Cross. We receive this Child into the Congregation of Christ's flock, and sign him with the sign of the Cross. As Baptism admits into the Church Catholic, so the Cross admits into a particular Church. Baptism dedicates the Infant unto Christ, so the Cross dedicates him to the service of him that died on the Cross.2 And what now is wanting to make it a Sacrament? It ⟨p. 72⟩is not vehicalum gratiae; It's very true, it is not: Neither can any Human Invention be such. It therefore looks as like a Sacrament as any Human thing can do, no such thing being capable of conveying Grace unto men.
5thly. The Sign of the Cross is not merely an addition to Baptism, but it is a mystical Teacher, and looks very like a Sacrament. It is a mystical Teacher; as the Sacraments teach Christ crucified by God's Ordination, so doth the Cross by Man's. But is not the Scripture sufficient, and Christ the great Prophet? And may Man invent new ways of teaching; or if he do, may any one look for the illuminating Spirit in such ways? Christ is the one Master, the one Teacher by way of excellency; all other Teachers that teach truly, do but teach ministerially under him;
In the next place the Ceremonies of our Church may be considered as terms of Communion with it: That is, there must be a Surplice, or no preaching; a Cross, or no baptizing; a kneeling posture, or no Lord's Supper. These things, though they are very light to the Conformists, are not so to the Nonconformists. I shall therefore consider them in some particulars.
1st. The Ceremonies thus taken do seem to intrench upon the Kingly Office of Christ. He is the one Lord and Lawgiver of his Church. 'Tis his Royal Prerogative to institute Sacraments. This is confessed by the Papists themselves.1 Aquinas (relating that some held their Sacrament of Confirmation was instituted in some Council, ⟨p. 73⟩and that others held it was instituted by the Apostles) saith, this cannot be, because to institute a new Sacrament, pertinet ad potestatem excellentiae, appertains to the power of excellency, which is in Christ alone.2 Bellarmin proves that Christ is the only Author of Sacraments. It is a flower of his Crown to institute Ordinances, no man may take this glory from him. The Apostles, the highest Officers in the Church, were not Lords of it, but Ministers and Stewards under Christ, 1 Cor. 4.1. to do his pleasure. They taught only what he commanded them, Matt. 28.20. St. Paul preached [Greek or Hebrew], nothing without Scripture, Act. 26.22. He would not go beyond his Commission.3 Non debent Episcopi (saith the Excellent Whitaker) suas traditions aut leges, aut contra, aut extra, aut praeter Evangelium obtrudere. The Bishops ought not to obtrude their Traditions or Laws, either against, or without, or besides the Gospel. That Gospel which is the Law of Christ, is the Canon that must rule all their Canons. Christ hath the full Royal ⟨p. 74⟩Power, the Church hath only a limited Power from him. Christ may make Laws of Institution, the Church can only make Laws of Execution, or Disposition, such as tend to the right and orderly disposing of those. Ordinances which were instituted by Christ. 4The Apostles did not institute any thing of Worship or Ordinances: But they did take care that the Ordinances should be used in a way suitable to their dignity. These things being so, the only Question is, Whether the Church hath any Patent or Commission from Christ to institute or impose mystical Ceremonies as terms of Communion? In answer to this, I take it, the Church hath no such Power or Commission. The Pattern of Christ and the Apostles is more to me than all the Human Wisdom in the world. It is the observation of St. Austin, That Christ's.
Yoke being easy,1 he did, Sacramentis numero paucissimis, observation facillimis, signification praestantissimis societatem novi populi colligare, Tie together the Society of a new People with Sacraments few in number, easy in observation, and ⟨p. 75⟩excellent in signification: And who would depart from this simplicity? I am sure the Apostles did not. They delivered only that which they received of the Lord, 1 Cor 11.23.2 Hoc fidei illorum er at, & officii, saith Bullinger. This was their faith and duty. They did believe. (saith the same Author) that Christ was the wisdom of God, ne in mentem ipsorum venit, it came not into their minds to add Ceremonies to Christ's Institutions. The Primitive Christians continued steadfastly in the Apostles Doctrine and fellowship, and in breaking of bread, and prayer, Acts 2.42. There was nothing but the pure Institutions of Christ, not an additional Ceremony to be seen among them. Nay, in Justin Martyr's time,3 we find the Lord's Supper used in pure simplicity; and why should we make our additions to the Sacraments? St. Cyprian contra Aquarios, 4expresses himself notably touching the Lord's Supper. Ab Evangelicis Praeceptis omnino recedendum non est. We must not depart from the Evangelical Precepts. And a little after, Non nisi Christus sequendus ⟨p. 76⟩est, solus Christus audiendus est. Christ only is to be followed, Christ alone to be heard. Again, Human Ceremonies are not congruous to the pure light of the Gospel. 5Num Divinae Figurae sublatae sunt, ut Humanae succederent? saith Learned Whitaker, Were the Divine Figures taken away, that Human might succeed? If the Divine Shadows under the Law did all vanish before the Sun, the pure and Evangelical Light; may Humane Umbra's come and overcloud it? Surely it cannot be. It was the saying of a great Doctor once in the Church of England, That in the morning of the Law the shadows were larger than the body; and it will be a sign of the evening and sun-set of Religion, if these shadows shall be stretched out again, and outreach the body. If the Church may institute or impose two or three Ceremonies, it may do more and more; till men under the pressure cry out,
he only hath authority over Religion, he only can bind the Conscience, he only can illustrate the mind, he only can give a blessing to such a Sign. Aquinas, speaking of the Sacraments, saith,1 That the Signifier should determine the Sign; and God is the Signifier, who signifies spiritual things to us by sensible things to us by sensible things, in Sacraments, and by similitudinary words in Scripture. If God be the great Signifier of Holy Mysteries, it is his right to determine the Signs of them. By these things it appears that the Church hath no power to impose Mystical Ceremonies; and by consequence in so doing she encroaches upon the Royal Prerogative of Christ.2 Edward the Second granted to the Nobles a power of making some Laws; but if they under colour of that had made other, they had invaded his Prerogative. The Lord Christ hath given the Church power to make Laws of Execution; but if ⟨p. 78⟩she go beyond her Line, and make Laws of Institution, she seems to encroach upon his Royalty.
he only hath authority over Religion, he only can bind the Conscience, he only can illustrate the mind, he only can give a blessing to such a Sign. Aquinas, speaking of the Sacraments, saith,1 That the Signifier should determine the Sign; and God is the Signifier, who signifies spiritual things to us by sensible things to us by sensible things, in Sacraments, and by similitudinary words in Scripture. If God be the great Signifier of Holy Mysteries, it is his right to determine the Signs of them. By these things it appears that the Church hath no power to impose Mystical Ceremonies; and by consequence in so doing she incroaches upon the Royal Prerogative of Christ.2 Edward the Second granted to the Nobles a power of making some Laws; but if they under colour of that had made other, they had invaded his Prerogative. The Lord Christ hath given the Church power to make Laws of Execution; but if ⟨p. 78⟩she go beyond her Line, and make Laws of Institution, she seems to encroach upon his Royalty.
2dly. The Ceremonies thus taken do seem to invert the Gospel. The Apostle tells the Galatians that they were removed to another Gospel, which was not another; but there were some that troubled them, and would pervert the Gospel of Christ, Gal. 1.6, 7. The word in the Original is not [Greek or Hebrew], to evert, but [Greek or Hebrew], to invert the Gospel. They did not deny the Gospel, but they added the Jewish Ceremonies to it, and so inverted it, and made it to be another Gospel; a Gospel mixed with Jewish Ceremonies, being not the same with it self in its purity. And as those Jewish Ceremonies did invert the Gospel, so do ours, tho upon a different reason, invert it also. Theirs did invert it, as being made necessary to Salvation; ours do it, as being made terms of Communion. In the pure Gospel Heaven and Ordinances do both stand open unto men in the Church. The Gospel is ⟨p. 79⟩inverted not only when men are barred out from Heaven, by making other necessaries to Salvation than are required therein, but also when men are barred out from Ordinances by making other terms of Communion than are commanded therein. This latter is that which I shall explain by Humane Instances. If a Prince grants a Charter of Franchises to a person, and, as it passes the Great Seal, the Chancellor of his own head adds a Condition to the Grant, the Charter is hereby inverted.1 When King Edward the First confirmed the English Charters with this addition, Salvo jure coronae nostrae, the Nobles were displeased, and would not be content, till their Charters were confirmed as they were at first granted, in an absolute manner. They were sensible that a new modus might make their Charters look like another thing than indeed they were. If a man covenant or article with another, that he shall enjoy such a thing, and without orders a Condition be superadded, the Covenant is inverted. When the Emperor Charles the Fifth ⟨p. 80⟩made an Agreement with the Duke of Saxony, 2and superadded a Condition that the Duke should be of his Religion, the Duke utterly refused it; the addition made the Covenant another thing. If a man make his Will, and the Scribe of his own head add a Condition to a Legacy, the Will is inverted; hence in the Civil Law the Falsarius is greatly punished.
Magna Charta gives unto the Church omnia sua jura integra, & libertates illaesas. Should a Judge tell Ecclesiastical Persons, that they should have all their Rights and Liberties, but upon a Condition of his own devising; who would not conclude that the great Charter was inverted? In all these Instances it is not material, whether the Condition be added to the thing in writing, and so embodied with it, or whether it be added to it by practical use; in both cases it inverts ⟨p. 81⟩the thing to which it is added. Now the Gospel is the Grant, Covenant, Testament, Law of our Lord Jesus Christ: In and by it he makes over Ordinances freely, absolutely, to all that will come to them. If men put in their own Conditions, and say, you shall have Sacraments, but upon these or those terms, which are unnecessary and unrequired by Christ, the Gospel is inverted, and made another thing than it was; an absolute free gift is one thing, and a limited conditional one is another. The first is the Gospel in its purity, as it comes from the hands of Christ; the last is the Gospel with a mixture, as it is inverted by men. Neither is it material, whether that which is added be a great thing, or a little; a little thing, if added as a Condition, inverts it; because it turns an absolute free disposition into a conditional one. I conclude with that of St. Chrysostom upon that Text, Gal. 1.7.1 They subvert the Gospel who bring in, [Greek or Hebrew], paululum quiddam, any little new thing into it; that is, if it be brought in as necessary ⟨p. 82⟩to Salvation, or as a Condition to any Ordinance of the Gospel.
Magna Charta gives unto the Church omnia sua jura integra, & libertates illaesas. Should a Judge tell Ecclesiastical Persons, that they should have all their Rights and Liberties, but upon a Condition of his own devising; who would not conclude that the great Charter was inverted? In all these Instances it is not material, whether the Condition be added to the thing in writing, and so imbodied with it, or whether it be added to it by practical use; in both cases it inverts ⟨p. 81⟩
3dly. The Ceremonies thus taken do seem to be against Christian Liberty, Charity and Unity. They seem to be against Christian Liberty. The Liberty which we have in Christ is a real one. Omnia (saith Tertullian) imaginaria in seculo; All things, even Liberty it self, are imaginary in the world; but the Liberty which we have in Christ is true. Our Christian Liberty stands in a spiritual manumission, not only from Sin, Satan, Death, but also from the Yoke of Ceremonies. In the Gospel we have a double Door open to us, one into Heaven, another into Ordinances, to fit us for that Blessed Region; both these open Doors were purchased by the precious Blood of Christ, neither of them may be shut by man. The Jewish Ceremonies, as made necessary to Salvation, did shut the first Door, because there more things were made necessary to Salvation than the Gospel made. Our Ceremonies, as made terms of Communion, seem to shut the second Door, ⟨p. 83⟩because thereby other Conditions of participation in Ordinances are put upon men than are to be found in the Gospel. A free access unto the Sacraments was not only purchased by Christ's precious Blood for us, but granted by his Evangelical Charter to us; and a choice, a rare Liberty it is; but if men may bar up, or conditionate this access, where is our Christian Liberty? How can we come to Ordinances, [Greek or Hebrew], as the Freemen of Christ? The Human Yoke of Ceremonies is upon us; and I wonder that it can enter into rational minds, that God should break off the Yoke of his own Ceremonies, as unsuitable to the Evangelical Liberty, and yet that a Yoke of Human Ceremonies should be put on as congruous to it. If Human Ceremonies may succeed in the room of Divine, then the Yoke is not removed, but changed, and that as much for the worse, as Human Ceremonies weigh heavier than Divine. Were it put to the option of any intelligent man, whether he would have a Ritual Burden of God's binding laid upon ⟨p. 84⟩him, or one of Man's: He would certainly choose to have it done rather by the God of Wisdom and Mercy, than by any Creature. We see clearly that God hath no where in the New Testament laid any such burdens, or set any such conditional bars to Ordinances; and how, or why should man do it? Or if he do it, how or which way is the Christian Franchise preserved?
3dly. The Ceremonies thus taken do seem to be against Christian Liberty, Charity and Ʋnity. They seem to be against Christian Liberty. The Liberty which we have in Christ is a real one. Omnia (saith Tertullian) imaginaria in seculo; All things, even Liberty it self, are imaginary in the world; but the Liberty which we have in Christ is true. Our Christian Liberty stands in a spiritual manumission, not only from Sin, Satan, Death, but also from the Yoke of Ceremonies. In the Gospel we have a double Door open to us, one into Heaven, another into Ordinances, to fit us for that Blessed Region; both these open Doors were purchased by the precious Blood of Christ, neither of them may be shut by man. The Jewish Ceremonies, as made necessary to Salvation, did shut the first Door, because there more things were made necessary to Salvation than the Gospel made. Our Ceremonies, as made terms of Communion, seem to shut the second Door,
The Church's Power is but subordinate, and subalternate to Christ, and how can it put bars or conditions to that Privilege which he hath granted to Christians? When a Church useth its Power according to the line and level of Scripture, then all is well; but when it overflows, and exceeds its Commission, then Christian Liberty goes to wreck.
The Church's Power is but subordinate, and subalternate to Christ, and how can it put bars or conditions to that Priviledge which he hath granted to Christians? When a Church useth its Power according to the line and level of Scripture, then all is well; but when it overflows, and exceeds its Commission, then Christian Liberty goes to wreck.
Again, They seem to be against Christian Charity, as being stumbling-blocks to doubting Souls, occasioning their fall into sin. Our Dear Lord Jesus left us the Sacraments pure, Divine, altogether free from any scruple. But now the mystical Ceremonies are so interwoven and coupled in use with ⟨p. 85⟩them, that Scrupulous Christians, in partaking of that which Christ institutes, run into that which Conscience scruples; and in following that which is lifted up in the Example of Pious and Learned Church-men, fall and wound their Souls. The law of Charity puts a restraint upon indifferent things in the case of Scandal. It is good neither to eat flesh, nor to drink wine, nor to do any thing whereby thy brother stumbleth, or is offended, or is made weak, saith the Apostle, Rom. 14.21. Indifferent things are in charity to be abstained from in case of scandal. The Apostle presseth this by very weighty Arguments. The kingdom of God is not meat and drink, v. 17. Religion doth not stand in such things. We must not in such things grieve or destroy our brother, v. 15. We must not for them destroy the work of God, v. 20. that is, our Brother's Soul, which is his work by way of eminency. We must not destroy him for whom Christ died, v. 15. Scandal in indifferent things is not a wounding only, but a killing of our Brother, a kind of Soul-murder. Now if indifferent ⟨p. 86⟩things, in case of scandal, are not to be admitted in common use, much less are those things (which have speciem mali, an appearance of evil) in such case to be admitted into holy Sacraments; thither we come by Christ's appointment, not to grieve and wound, but comfort and heal our Souls. Charity should not suffer any Stumbling-block or Scandal to be seen there, every thing there should minister comfort and edification. I know many Answers are given to this, but scarce any satisfactory ones. 'Tis said, that in case of scandal we must abstain from indifferent things, whilst they remain indifferent, but not after they are determined by Authority. But to me it sounds exceeding harsh, to say, that in case the Magistrate commands it, we may wound or destroy our Brother. A Scandal in its nature is spiritual Murder, which no Command of Man can make tolerable. Avoiding of Scandal is a main duty of Charity, which no Command of Man can dispense with.
Again, They seem to be against Christian Charity, as being stumbling-blocks to doubting Souls, occasioning their fall into sin. Our Dear Lord Jesus left us the Sacraments pure, Divine, altogether free from any scruple. But now the mystical Ceremonies are so interwoven and coupled in use with
'Tis said, that in conforming to the Ceremonies, there can be only a scandal to a ⟨p. 87⟩brother, but in nonconforming there is scandal to the Magistrate; and this indeed (if it be a Scandal of the same kind, is greater than the other. But (as Learned Mr. Jeans doth distinguish.)1 There is a two-fold acception of Scandal, primary and secondary; primary scandal is the occasioning the fall of another into sin. Secondary is the angering and displeasing of another. Conformity to the Ceremonies occasions our Brother to fall into sin, Nonconformity only occasions the displeasure of the Magistrate. Now to displease the Magistrate is surely more tolerable, than to occasion the poorest man to fall into sin. This is clear, because it is more dangerous to displease God than Man. 'Tis said further, Debts of Justice are to be paid before debts of Charity: Obedience to Superiors is a debt of Justice, a matter of right; but the not giving of offence is a debt of Charity, a matter of courtesy. But as Mr. Jeans hath fully answered, The Rule must be understood, caeteris paribus, when the terms of comparison are equal; and equal they are not, when the Minims of Justice are put into the Balance with the ⟨p. 88⟩weightiest duties of Charity; and so 'tis in the present comparison. Of what importance is the practise of a Ceremony, in comparison of not scandalizing our Brother? Who can imagine that the command of a Ceremony can bear proportion with the command of not destroying a Brother? The Commands of God touching the externals of Worship, are to give way to Mercy. I will have mercy, and not sacrifice, saith God, Hos. 6.6. much more must the Commands of Men do so. Besides, the care of not giving offence, tho to my Brother, it be but a debt of Charity, yet in regard of God, it is a debt of Justice; and woe to him through whom the offence cometh. Moreover, it is said, that the offence by the Ceremonies is only Scandalum acceptum, non datum, a Scandal taken, not given. But the Ceremonies being not merely things indifferent but having at least an appearance of evil, the Scandal is not taken only, but given. It is certainly our duty to abstain from all appearance of evil. The Nazarite was to abstain from the very Husk of the Grape. The Young ⟨p. 89⟩
Valentinian would not endure a little drop of Paganish Holy water. We must not dwell in the confines or neighbourhood of Sin. We should put away every shadow of Will-worship, every semblance of an addition to the holy Ordinances, every thing that looks like a conformity to the Romish Church; this were the way to be pure from giving offence to our Brethren.
Moreover, they seem to be against Christian Unity. The first step to that first sin which brought in enmity into the World, was an addition to God's Word. Ye shall not touch it, Gen. 3.3. This was that that divided God's Ancient People the Jews, the Karai adhered to the pure Scripture, but the Tal•udici brought in their Human Traditions, and cried them up as Lux illa •agna, the great Light. The Pharisees would have above the Law their own Ceremonies and Traditions, and so they came to separate and divide ⟨p. 90⟩themselves from others, calling the common people populum terrae, the people of the earth; and saying to Sinners, ne attingas me, touch me not. The Jewish Ceremonies troubled the Galatians, Gal. 1.7. Circumcision ceasing to be Divine any longer, became Concision, renting the Church; and the Doctors that mixed it with the Gospel, were as Dogs, tearing asunder the unity of it. When Victor urged a necessity of conformity in the observation of Easter-day, Irenaeus reproves him for this, tanquam pacis perturbatorem, as […] troubler of the Churches peace; and indeed there was a horrible breach between the Eastern and Western Churches about it. When Images, a mere Human Invention, were brought into the Church, what fierce Contentions were there about it? The Green Emperors, Leo Isaurus, Constantinu• and others, opposing them in the East. And on the other side, the Bishops of Rome, Gregory the Second Gregory the Third, and others stish upholding them in the West. In the Council at Constantinople they were solemnly ⟨p. 91⟩condemned;1 and the people cried out, hodie salus mundo. In the Council of Nice they were advanced again even to veneration; and Eusebius, for speaking against them, is said to be delivered over to a reprobate mind, and his Books are anathematized. What an [Greek or Hebrew], a vehement Contention was there between the Greek and Latin Churches about leavened and unleavened bread in the Eucharist; the Greeks calling the Latins Azymitae, and the Latins the Greeks, Fermentarii. Ceremonies and Human Inventions in Worship, however they may be intended for Unity, are the occasions of Contention. Hence Melancton, tho he conformed to the Rites and Ceremonies in the Interim, yet wished with tears that they were removed, because as long as they remained there would be contention in the Church;
and the reason of this is evident, The minds of men are not all alike, or of an equal temper. Some Pious and Learned Men allow of Ceremonies, other Pious and Learned Men cannot receive them: In such a ⟨p. 92⟩case as this,1 the urging of Uniformity is the loss of Unity. Anselm enquiring whence the various Customs in the Church arose, gives this Answer. Nihil aliud intelligo quam humanorum sensuum diversitates. I know nothing but this, that men have different sentiments of things; that which one man thinks very apt in the Worship of God, that another thinks is not so. When such a necessary thing as Unity is placed in unnecessaries, it is lost; but when it is placed in things like it self, I mean in necessary things, then it is preserved. The Apostles (who as well understood, and as much desired Unity in the Church as any) would lay no other burden on Christians than necessary things, Act. 15.28. St. Paul lays down a great many Unities, One body, one spirit, one hope, one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and father of all. Eph. 4.4, 5, 6. but there is not a word of one Ceremony. Those Bishops took the right course for Unity, who being met together in Council, made a Canon which they called Adiaphoron, 2because they left the observation of ⟨p. 93⟩Easter-day indifferent, as men would themselves. Were indifferent things left in their indifferency, the Unity of the Church would be much greater than it is.
and the reason of this is evident, The minds of men are not all alike, or of an equal temper. Some Pious and Learned Men allow of Ceremonies, other Pious and Learned Men cannot receive them: In such a ⟨p. 92⟩case as this,1 the urging of Uniformity is the loss of Unity. Anselm enquiring whence the various Customs in the Church arose, gives this Answer. Nihil aliud intelligo quam humanorum sensuum diversitates. I know nothing but this, that men have different sentiments of things; that which one man thinks very apt in the Worship of God, that another thinks is not so. When such a necessary thing as Unity is placed in unnecessaries, it is lost; but when it is placed in things like it self, I mean in necessary things, then it is preserved. The Apostles (who as well understood, and as much desired Unity in the Church as any) would lay no other burthen on Christians than necessary things,
Thus much may suffice touching the Ceremonies; only because there are two Pleas for their innocency, I must consider them.
The one is this; The Ceremonies are only for decency and order, and so within that Apostolical Precept, Let all things be done decently, and in order, 1 Cor. 14.40.
I answer, Were the Ceremonies within that Precept, I should beg my pardon, and pronounce them innocent; but I take it they are not within it, and to clear this, I offer these things.
The Evangelical Sacraments, which are God's own Ceremonies, are in themselves, and without any Human dress, worthy of all reverence,1 the Institution hath put a glory upon them. Human Ceremonies, which are as much below them, as a Cloud is ⟨p. 94⟩below the Sun, are more apt to darken than illustrate them. When Sacraments are in their pure simplicity, then the splendour of the Holy Signs shines forth; but when they are muffled up in Human Rites, then the Divine Beauty is obscured. And if Divine Ceremonies need Human to put a decorum upon them, much more do Human Ceremonies need an addition of further Ceremonies for that end, and so there may be Ceremonies upon Ceremonies in infinitum.
- 1Nostra Sacramenta tam praeclara sunt, ut etiamsi nuda & nullis Sacramentalibus suffulta proponerentur, omni essent veneratione digna. Medina in Aquin. 1, 2. Q. 108. Art. 2.
Our Lord Christ, who knew better than all men what Decency is, never instituted any such Ceremonies. The Apostles, who gave the Rule of Decency, never used them. They did administer Ordinances decently, but without them. Hence it appears that their Precept never extended to them; for had it done so, they would not have omitted them, but had practised that Precept which they had given. The Worship of the Apostles, which was without Ceremonies, was either decent, or undecent, (for Decency and Undecency are privatively opposite, and between ⟨p. 95⟩privative opposites there is no medium of abnegation in subjecto capaci.) If the Apostles Worship, void of all Ceremonies, be decent, then Decency doth not consist in Ceremonies; if undecent, they did not (which cannot be imagined) observe their own Rule of Decency, and act as they taught.
Order and Decency in the Worship of God are things necessary, not merely by a positive Law, but by a natural. Not only the Apostolical Precept, but the very dictate of Nature is, that the Service of God should be performed in an orderly and decent manner. The Heathen Oracle could say, That in the Worship of God men should follow, morem optimum, the best manner. 1Seneca out of Aristotle tells us, That when men have to do with the Gods, they should be, verecundiores & compositi, modest and composed in their demeanour. The Light of Nature teacheth us, that we should serve God in a way suitable and congruous to his Divine Majesty. Thus Order and Decency are necessary, but so are not Ceremonies. Hence it appears, that the difference between ⟨p. 96⟩them is as great, as between necessary and unnecessary.
- 1Nat. Quaest. l. 7. c. 30.
Order is nothing but a right disposition of things, Decency is nothing but the seemliness of Order. Order and Decency require not,1 that some Holy things should be newly ordained; but that those which are ordained by God, should be used in a way congruous to their dignity. The Ceremonies, which are new Appointments, appertain not to Order and Decency. The institution of somewhat new is one thing; and the right and seemly disposition of that which is instituted, is another.
- 1Vide Ames Medul. l. 2. c. 13.
The other Plea is this. The Ceremonies are not made by our Church any parts of Worship, and therefore there is no offence in them.
I answer, The Ceremonies seem to be parts of Worship several ways. They seem to be parts of Worship in themselves, as being an honouring of God, at least in some respect. It's true they are not parts of Worship, ratione principii, because they are not parts of Divine Institution: But they seem to be parts of Worship, ratione termini ⟨p. 97⟩as being an honour done to God. There may be a double honour done to God. There is an honour done to him as the Supreme Being, by subjection and resignation: And there is an honour done to him as the Fountain of Grace, by dependence upon him for some Spiritual Gift. Both these seem to be in the use of the Ceremonies. In the use of the Cross, the Infant is resigned to God, dedicated to him that died on the Cross, and this looks like Worship. Again, the Ceremonies are Mystical Teachers; not Supreme Teachers, for that were to turn them into Idols; but Under Teachers; and therefore in the regular use of them we must depend upon the great Teacher for illumination; and this also seems to be an act of Worship.
I answer, The Ceremonies seem to be parts of Worship feveral ways. They seem to be parts of Worship in themselves, as being an honouring of God, at least in some respect. It's true they are not parts of Worship, ratione principii, because they are not parts of Divine Institution: But they seem to be parts of Worship, ratione termini ⟨p. 97⟩as being an honour done to God. There may be a double honour done to God. There is an honour done to him as the Supream Being, by subjection and resignation: And there is an honour done to him as the Fountain of Grace, by dependance upon him for some Spiritual Gift. Both these seem to be in the use of the Ceremonies. In the use of the Cross, the Infant is resigned to God, dedicated to him that died on the Cross, and this looks like Worship. Again, the Ceremonies are Mystical Teachers; not Supream Teachers, for that were to turn them into Idols; but Ʋnder Teachers; and therefore in the regular use of them we must depend upon the great Teacher for illumination; and this also seems to be an act of Worship.