A55303:88
A discourse of schism
A discourse of schism by that learned gentleman Edward Polhill, Esq. ...
London: printed for Thomas Cockerill, 1694
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
'Tis said, that in conforming to the Ceremonies, there can be only a scandal to a ⟨p. 87⟩brother, but in nonconforming there is scandal to the Magistrate; and this indeed (if it be a Scandal of the same kind, is greater than the other. But (as Learned Mr. Jeans doth distinguish.)1 There is a two-fold acception of Scandal, primary and secondary; primary scandal is the occasioning the fall of another into sin. Secondary is the angering and displeasing of another. Conformity to the Ceremonies occasions our Brother to fall into sin, Nonconformity only occasions the displeasure of the Magistrate. Now to displease the Magistrate is surely more tolerable, than to occasion the poorest man to fall into sin. This is clear, because it is more dangerous to displease God than Man. 'Tis said further, Debts of Justice are to be paid before debts of Charity: Obedience to Superiors is a debt of Justice, a matter of right; but the not giving of offence is a debt of Charity, a matter of courtesy. But as Mr. Jeans hath fully answered, The Rule must be understood, caeteris paribus, when the terms of comparison are equal; and equal they are not, when the Minims of Justice are put into the Balance with the ⟨p. 88⟩weightiest duties of Charity; and so 'tis in the present comparison. Of what importance is the practise of a Ceremony, in comparison of not scandalizing our Brother? Who can imagine that the command of a Ceremony can bear proportion with the command of not destroying a Brother? The Commands of God touching the externals of Worship, are to give way to Mercy. I will have mercy, and not sacrifice, saith God, Hos. 6.6. much more must the Commands of Men do so. Besides, the care of not giving offence, tho to my Brother, it be but a debt of Charity, yet in regard of God, it is a debt of Justice; and woe to him through whom the offence cometh. Moreover, it is said, that the offence by the Ceremonies is only Scandalum acceptum, non datum, a Scandal taken, not given. But the Ceremonies being not merely things indifferent but having at least an appearance of evil, the Scandal is not taken only, but given. It is certainly our duty to abstain from all appearance of evil. The Nazarite was to abstain from the very Husk of the Grape. The Young ⟨p. 89⟩