Answ. This proveth not the point, for he condemneth the arrogance of some immediately inspired Prophets, Came the word of God from you? that is, are ye above the Apostle to whom the word of God was committed, that it may be preached to all the world, that it might come from the Apostles to others? Or came it to you only, as to the only Apostolic teachers, that you need no admonition? but hence it followeth not, but they were extraordinarily inspired Prophets, for Peter might be rebuked, though an Apostle & a chief one. Neither is it any imputation to Paul, or to any who hath received the Spirit in measure, to be censured. It is true, Canonic doctrine, as it is such, cannot be censured, but the teachers thereof, though infallible, even Paul, Act. 17. 10, 11. and every spirit is to be tried, whether they be of God or no, 1 Joh. 3. 1. yea to say that the Church cannot be builded upon the foundation of the Prophets and Apostles (as Mr. Robinson saith, pag. 68.) if these Prophets extraordinary can err, or can be subject to the censure and judgement of the Church, is the very argument of Papists; for they say, that the Word of God borroweth authority quoad nos, in respect of us, from the Church, and is to be believed, because Peter, Paul, the Prophets and Apostles, the then present Church, say it is the Word of God. So aStapleton (as Whittakerne teacheth) that Christ was the Son of God, dependeth to our faith upon the testimony of John Baptist. See Bellarmine, Gregorius de Valent. Gretser; So three famous commentators say, bJansenius, cCardinalis Cajetan, and dCardinalis Toletus. But our Divines answer, that the Word of God is true in it self, and the authentic ground of our faith, not because the Prophets and Apostles say it is the word of God, not because Paul or an Angel from heaven saith it is so, Gal. 1. 8. for even the Prophets and Apostles were but men, and so their testimony not infallible, but because God himself saith so. See for this eRivetus, fWhittakerus, gBucerus, hCalvinus, yea and the Fathers most expressly say, that the Prophets and Apostles are not the ⟨p. 305⟩foundation of our faith, nor their word, because they were infallible, but Gods word, by their mouths and pen.
Answ. This proveth not the point, for hee condemneth the arrogancie of some immediately inspired Prophets, Came the word of God from you? that is, are yee above the Apostle to whom the word of God was committed, that it may bee preached to all the world, that it might come from the Apostles to others? Or came it to you onely, as to the only Apostolick teachers, that you neede no admonition? but hence it followeth not, but they were extraordinarily inspired Prophets, for Peter might be rebuked, though an Apostle & a chief one. Neither is it any imputation to Paul, or to any who hath received the Spirit in measure, to be censured. It is true, Canonick doctrine, as it is such, cannot be censured, but the teachers thereof, though infallible, even Paul, Act. 17. 10, 11. and every spirit is to bee tried, whether they be of God or no, 1 Joh. 3. 1. yea to say that the Church cannot be builded upon the foundation of the Prophets and Apostles (as Mr. Robinson saith, pag. 68.) if these Prophets extraordinary can erre, or can bee subject to the censure and judgement of the Church, is the very argument of Papists; for they say, that the Word of God borroweth authoritie quoad nos, in respect of us, from the Church, and is to be beleeved, because Peter, Paul, the Prophets and Apostles, the then present Church, say it is the Word of God. So aStapleton (as Whittakerne teacheth) that Christ was the Sonne of God, dependeth to our faith upon the testimony of John Baptist. See Bellarmine, Gregorius de Valent. Gretser; So three famous commentators say, bJansenius, cCardinalis Cajetan, and dCardinalis Toletus. But our Divines answer, that the Word of God is true in it selfe, and the authentick ground of our faith, not because the Prophets and Apostles say it is the word of God, not because Paul or an Angel from heaven saith it is so, Gal. 1. 8. for even the Prophets and Apostles were but men, and so their testimony not infallible, but because God himselfe saith so. See for this eRivetus, f
- aStapleton apud Whittaker. de sac. Script. Authorit. l. 3. c. 3. arg. 3. sect. Bellarmine, Valentinian Gretserus.
- bTransenius harmon. c. 36.
- cCajetan come. in loan. 5. in hoc ab ho•nine non accipio.Cajetan com. in loan. 5. in hoc ab ho•nine non accipio.
- dToletus in. Joh. 5. tom. 1.Toletus in. Ioh. 5. tom. 1.
- eRivetus tom. 1. contrav. trac. 1. q. 6.
- fWhittakerus to. 2. desac. Scrip. authorit. lib. 3. c. •r. 5.
- gBucer in Joan. 5. de testimonio Baptistae.Bucer in Ioan. 5. de testimonio Baptistae.
- hCalvinus in art. 17. v. 10, 11.