A57969:2049
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the…
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
This is a very ill consequence, for a sleeping man is not certain whether he be dreaming or waking. Ergo, a waking man knoweth not whether he be waking, or not. So a distracted man hath no certainty that he is as wise as seven men who can render a reason; therefore a man sober in his wits knoweth not that he is in his sober wits: these be poor and loose consequences. It is true, when we believe some alterable circumstances of some things rather about, then in doctrine and discipline, which are disputable, and to us both sides have great probability, we have not certainty of faith, and possible here in our opinions learned and holy men; yea and whole Churches may look beside their book, and be deceived; and these we take not to be the subject of a sworn confession of faith, and here we grant a [non liquet] on both sides, and do allow some grain weights of reserve to persons and Churches, to retract in those things: but hence it is badly concluded that we believe these non-fundamentals of discipline, for which we have certainty of evidence from Gods Word, with a reserve, and with a looseness of assent and credulity to believe the contrary to morrow; for so the same argument should militate against the certainty of faith in some fundamentals: for a person, yea any particular Church may err in denying the resurrection of the dead, as some did in the Church of Corinth; and Christs Disciples, though true believers, doubted of his rising from the dead, John 20. 9. Peter and the disciples doubted of Christ dying for the loosed world, Mat. 16. 21, 22. Luke 24. 25, 26. and because any true believer may fall in that temptation and weakness, as to deny all the articles of faith, taken divisively, for they may deny this or this article fundamental, (though I do not think a regenerated person can deny the whole system and body of fundamentals collectively) it shall follow by this argument that regenerated persons ⟨p. 377⟩and particular Churches are to believe some fundamentals with a reserve, and keeping room for light to believe the contrary, and so if this argument be good, we have no certainty of faith in believing any one fundamental article its alone. Nor can Nathan or Samuel have certainty of faith in believing their own prophecies flowing from the immediate inspiration of the Spirit;