A57969:2062
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the…
The due right of presbyteries, or, A peaceable plea for the government of the Church of Scotland ... by Samuel Rutherfurd ...
London: printed by E. Griffin for Richard Whittaker and Andrew Crook, 1644
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
(as there be good store of consciences of this metal amongst the nation of Jesuits) if he kill him not be sinneth against God, because be sinneth against the light of his conscience by the sinful omitting of good service to God, and if be kill him […] sinneth also in committing murder, both against the sixth Commandment, and also against the fist, which commandeth to honour Kings▪ out of which it must follow that either an erring conscience, because it is conscience, obligeth us to do that, which because we do it, in obedience to an erring conscience, now leaveth off to be sin to the actor under this condition of conscience; or then that there may be such a perplexity wherein a man by way of contradiction, whether he do such •n all, or do it not, is necessitated by Gods providence to sin, which absurdity shall make God the author of sin.
(as there bee good store of consciences of this mettall amongst the nation of Jesui•es) if hee kill him not bee sinneth against God, because be sinneth against the light of his conscience by the sinfull omitting of good service to God, and if bee kill him 〈…〉 sinneth also in committing murther, both against the sixt Commandement, and also against the fist, which commandeth to honour Kings▪ out of which it must follow that either an erring conscience, because it is conscience, obliegeth us to doe that, which because wee doe it, in obedience to an erring consceence, now leaveth off to bee sinne to the actor under this condition of conscience; or then that there may bee such a perplexitie wherein a man by way of contradiction, whether hee doe such •n all, or doe it not, is necessitated by Gods providence to sinne, which absurdity shall make God the author of sinne.
Answ. There is no necessity by way of contradiction, that a man thus perplexed must sin, whether he do or not do such an action: for I give easily a third case different from both, for such a perplexed Jesuit is neither obliged to kill the Prince, nor yet to abstain from killing in such a perplexed manner; but he is obliged not to kill the Lords anointed, tali modo: he is obliged to abstinence, but not to abstinence tali modo,