3 Argument. To whomsoever Christ giveth the power of the Keys,1 to them he gave a ministerial spirit by way of special embassy to remit and to retain sins, as the Ambassadors of God in Christs stead, and them he sent, as the father sent him,2 as is clear in the Scripture, As the Father sent me, so send I you, &c. He breathed on them and said, receive the Holy Ghost: whosoever sins ye remit they are remitted. In which words, our Divines, Calvin, Bullinger, Musculus, Beza, yea and Papists, Cajetan, Toletus, teach that Christ here did inaugurate his Disciples to preach and exercise the censures ⟨p. 9⟩of the Church: so also Cyril, Chrysostom, Cyprian. But this ministerial spirit, Christ gave not to all the faithful, but only to the Apostles, for he sent not Mary Magdalene and Cleophas in this place, as M. Smith saith, and why? because it is gathered from Luk. 24. 33, 34, 36. That Magdalene and Cleophas were there, (saith he) when Christ said, As my Father sent me so send I you, 3Therefore Mary also, and Cleopha• received a ministerial power of the keys, all as well as […] Apostles. I answer, but this place is all one with Mat. 28. 18, 19. where they are commanded to preach and baptize, which is not lawful to women. 1 Cor. 14. 1 Tim. 2. And it is all one with the Commission, Mark 16 14. which is restruted to the eleven. Another weak ground he hath, that the eleven were not made Apostles, until Christs Ascension, Act. 2. when the spirit was sent, and until he led captivity captive, Ephes. 4. 11. but this power was given to all the Disciples before his ascension. Answer, a higher measure of the Spirit was poured on the Apostles at Christs Ascension, and by virtue of his Ascension, he ordained Apostles, Eph. 4. 11. but will it follow, none were made Apostles until he ascended? if this were good, by virtue of his death, we obtain forgiveness of sins, by his ascending to heaven, we also ascend. But hence it followeth not, that there is no forgiveness of sins while Christ die, and that there is no ascending to heaven of the spirits of the Patriarchs and Fathers, while Christ ascended. 2. That the Apostles were called, and received Apostleship from Christ in the days of his flesh, before his death, is clear, Matth. 10. 2, 3. and that they went out, and preached, and cast out devils.
3 Argument. To whomsoever Christ giveth the power of the Keyes,1 to them he gave a ministeriall spirit by way of speciall ambassage to remit and to retaine sins, as the Ambassadors of God in Christs stead, and them he sent, as the fathe• sent him,2 as is cleare in the Scripture, As the Father sent me, so send I you, &c. He breat•ed on them and said, receive the Holy Ghost: whosoever sinnes ye remit they are remitted. In which words, our Divines, Calvin, Bullinger, Musculus, Beza, yea and Papists, Cajetan, Toletus, teach that Christ here did inaugurate his Disciples to preach and exercise the censures ⟨p. 9⟩of the Church: so also Cyrill, Chrysostome, Cyprian. But this ministeriall spirit, Christ gave not to all the faithfull, but only to the Apostles, for he sent not Mary Magdalene and Cleophas in this place, as M. Smith saith, and why? because it is gathered from Luk. 24. 33, 34, 36. That Magdalene and Cleophas were there, (saith he) when Christ said, As my Father sent me so send I you, 3Therefore Mary also, and Cleopha• received a ministeriall power of the keyes, all as well as 〈…〉 Apostles. I answer, but this place is all one with Mat. 28. 18, 19. where they are commanded to preach and baptize, which is not lawfull to women. 1 Cor. 14. 1 Tim. 2. And it is all one with the Commission, Mark 16 14. which is restruted to the eleven. Another weake ground he hath, that the eleven were not made Apostles, untill Christs Ascension, Act. 2. when the spirit was sent, and untill he led captivitie captive, Ephes. 4. 11. but this power was given to all the Disciples before his ascension. Answer, a higher masure of the Spirit was powred on the Apostles at Christs Ascension, and by vertue of his Ascension, he ordained Apostles,
- 1Chrysost. Apostolos constituit hic legatos suos & vicarios.
- 2Cyril lib. 12. in Joan ca. 55. & Cyprian de unitate Eccles. prope initium. M•ttit hic (inquiunt) Apostolos cum • mni pote •ate Apostolico numeri convenient.Cyrill lib. 12. in Ioan ca. 55. & Cyprian de unitate Eccles. prope initium. M•ttit hic (inquiunt) Apostolos cum • mni pote •ate Apostolico numeri conveniente.
- 3Joh. Smith in his parallel. censures and observations. against M. Bernard, p. 52.Ioh. Smith in his parallel. censures and observations. against M. Bernard, p. 52.