A peaceable and temperate plea for Pauls presbytery in Scotland, or, A modest and…A peaceable and temperate plea for Pauls presbyterie in Scotland, or, A modest and…
A peaceable and temperate plea for Pauls presbytery in Scotland, or, A modest and brotherly dispute of the government of the Church of Scotland wherein our discipline is demonstrated to be the true apostolic way of divine truth, and the arguments on the contrary are friendly dissolved, the grounds of separation and the independency [sic] of particular congregations, in defence of ecclesiastical presbyteries, synods, and assemblies, are examined and tried / by Samuel Rutherfurd ...A peaceable and temperate plea for Pauls presbyterie in Scotland, or, A modest and brotherly dispute of the government of the Church of Scotland wherein our discipline is demonstrated to be the true apostolick way of divine truth, and the arguments on the contrary are friendly dissolved, the grounds of separation and the indepencie [sic] of particular congregations, in defence of ecclesiasticall presbyteries, synods, and assemblies, are examined and tryed / by Samuell Rutherfurd ...
Samuel Rutherford 1600?–1661London: printed for John Bartlet, 1642London: printed for Iohn Bartlet, 1642
[16], 326 [i.e. 334] p. · 119k words · Wing R2389 · ESTC R7368
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. Argument. 1If the word say that the power of the keys is given to certain select persons, and not to all believers, then is not this power given to all believers:2 but the word saith the former,3 er. The Assumption is thus proved, If these Offices that essentially include both the power and the exercise of the Keys,4 be given to some select persons and not to all the faithful,5 then are not the Keys given to all the faithful:6 but the Lord gave the office of Apostles,7 Prophets,8 &c. to some only. And God hath set some in the Church (then not all) first, Apostles, secondarily, Prophets, thirdly, Teachers, &c. And he gave some to be Apostles (not all) and some Prophets, &c. Are all Apostles? The major is proved, because to be an Apostle, a Pastor, &c. is to have a power given by Christ to use the keys by preaching, binding and loosing,9 by censures, as an Apostle, Pastor. &c. This cannot be answered,10 seeing there must be another power to bind and loose in Pastors, and Elders, than is in all believers,11 women, believing children, and many believers unapt to govern.12
If the word say that the power of the keyes is given to certaine select persons, and not to all believers, then is not this power given to all believers:
&c. to some only. And God hath set some in the Church (then not all) first, Apostles, secondarily, Prophets, thirdly, Teachers, &c. And hee gave some to be Apostles (not all) and some Prophets, &c. Are all Apostles? The major is proved, because to be an Apostle, a Pastor, &c. is to have a power given by Christ to use the keyes by preaching, binding and loosing,
3 Argument. To whomsoever Christ giveth the power of the Keys,1 to them he gave a ministerial spirit by way of special embassy to remit and to retain sins, as the Ambassadors of God in Christs stead, and them he sent, as the father sent him,2 as is clear in the Scripture, As the Father sent me, so send I you, &c. He breathed on them and said, receive the Holy Ghost: whosoever sins ye remit they are remitted. In which words, our Divines, Calvin, Bullinger, Musculus, Beza, yea and Papists, Cajetan, Toletus, teach that Christ here did inaugurate his Disciples to preach and exercise the censures ⟨p. 9⟩of the Church: so also Cyril, Chrysostom, Cyprian. But this ministerial spirit, Christ gave not to all the faithful, but only to the Apostles, for he sent not Mary Magdalene and Cleophas in this place, as M. Smith saith, and why? because it is gathered from Luk. 24. 33, 34, 36. That Magdalene and Cleophas were there, (saith he) when Christ said, As my Father sent me so send I you, 3Therefore Mary also, and Cleopha• received a ministerial power of the keys, all as well as […] Apostles. I answer, but this place is all one with Mat. 28. 18, 19. where they are commanded to preach and baptize, which is not lawful to women. 1 Cor. 14. 1 Tim. 2. And it is all one with the Commission, Mark 16 14. which is restruted to the eleven. Another weak ground he hath, that the eleven were not made Apostles, until Christs Ascension, Act. 2. when the spirit was sent, and until he led captivity captive, Ephes. 4. 11. but this power was given to all the Disciples before his ascension. Answer, a higher measure of the Spirit was poured on the Apostles at Christs Ascension, and by virtue of his Ascension, he ordained Apostles, Eph. 4. 11. but will it follow, none were made Apostles until he ascended? if this were good, by virtue of his death, we obtain forgiveness of sins, by his ascending to heaven, we also ascend. But hence it followeth not, that there is no forgiveness of sins while Christ die, and that there is no ascending to heaven of the spirits of the Patriarchs and Fathers, while Christ ascended. 2. That the Apostles were called, and received Apostleship from Christ in the days of his flesh, before his death, is clear, Matth. 10. 2, 3. and that they went out, and preached, and cast out devils.
3 Argument. To whomsoever Christ giveth the power of the Keyes,1 to them he gave a ministeriall spirit by way of speciall ambassage to remit and to retaine sins, as the Ambassadors of God in Christs stead, and them he sent, as the fathe• sent him,2 as is cleare in the Scripture, As the Father sent me, so send I you, &c. He breat•ed on them and said, receive the Holy Ghost: whosoever sinnes ye remit they are remitted. In which words, our Divines, Calvin, Bullinger, Musculus, Beza, yea and Papists, Cajetan, Toletus, teach that Christ here did inaugurate his Disciples to preach and exercise the censures ⟨p. 9⟩of the Church: so also Cyrill, Chrysostome, Cyprian. But this ministeriall spirit, Christ gave not to all the faithfull, but only to the Apostles, for he sent not Mary Magdalene and Cleophas in this place, as M. Smith saith, and why? because it is gathered from Luk. 24. 33, 34, 36. That Magdalene and Cleophas were there, (saith he) when Christ said, As my Father sent me so send I you, 3Therefore Mary also, and Cleopha• received a ministeriall power of the keyes, all as well as 〈…〉 Apostles. I answer, but this place is all one with Mat. 28. 18, 19. where they are commanded to preach and baptize, which is not lawfull to women. 1 Cor. 14. 1 Tim. 2. And it is all one with the Commission, Mark 16 14. which is restruted to the eleven. Another weake ground he hath, that the eleven were not made Apostles, untill Christs Ascension, Act. 2. when the spirit was sent, and untill he led captivitie captive, Ephes. 4. 11. but this power was given to all the Disciples before his ascension. Answer, a higher masure of the Spirit was powred on the Apostles at Christs Ascension, and by vertue of his Ascension, he ordained Apostles,
1Chrysost. Apostolos constituit hic legatos suos & vicarios.
2Cyril lib. 12. in Joan ca. 55. & Cyprian de unitate Eccles. prope initium. M•ttit hic (inquiunt) Apostolos cum • mni pote •ate Apostolico numeri convenient.Cyrill lib. 12. in Ioan ca. 55. & Cyprian de unitate Eccles. prope initium. M•ttit hic (inquiunt) Apostolos cum • mni pote •ate Apostolico numeri conveniente.
3Joh. Smith in his parallel. censures and observations. against M. Bernard, p. 52.Ioh. Smith in his parallel. censures and observations. against M. Bernard, p. 52.
A second exception there is of some, who say, a concionall or preaching power of forgiveness of sins is not given to all, to whom a loosing from sins by Church censures is given, as is clear in our Ruling Elders, who have not power to forgive sins by preaching, yet have power to forgive, bind and loose, by Church-censures. Answer, We may distinguish where the law distinguisheth,1 for howbeit the power of preaching be not given formally to ruling Elders, yet it is effectually in the fruit given to them, in ⟨p. 10⟩the judicial and authoritative application in the external court of Christs Church,2 but believers, as believers only, have neither power to preach formally,3 nor yet effectively to apply judicially the threatenings of the word in discipline,4 to the judicial correction of delinquents; now the keys in the word,5 and the keys in the discipline, are the same keys of Christs kingdom,6 as Amesius observeth, and the keys of the word are the keys of the kingdom,7 committed to all, either formally or effectively,8 to whom the keys of discipline are given,9 but they are never given to single believers who cannot lawfully preach.10 Therefore single believers are not the subject of the keys.11
A second exception there is of some, who say, a concionall or preaching power of forgivnesse of sinnes is not given to all, to whom a loosing from sins by Church censures is given, as is cleare in our Ruling Elders, who have not power to forgive sinnes by preaching, yet have power to forgive, binde and loose, by Church-censures. Answer, We may distinguish where the law distinguisheth,1 for howbeit the power of preaching be not given formally to ruleing Elders, yet it is effectually in the fruit given to them, in ⟨p. 10⟩the judiciall and authoritative applicatio• in the externall court of Christs Church,2 but believers, as believers only, have neither power to preach formally,3 nor yet effectively to apply judicially the threatnings of the word in discipline,4 to the judiciall correction of delinquents; now the keyes in the word,5 and the keyes in the discipline, are the same keyes of Christs kingdome,6 as Amesius observeth, and the keyes of the word are the keyes of the kingdome,7 committed to all, either formally or effectively,8 to whom the keyes of discipline are given,9 but they are never given to single believers who cannot lawfully preach.10 Therefore single believers are not the subject of the keyes.11
4. Argument. Such power of the keys, without the which the Church of Christ is perfect,1 and complete for government, is superfluous, and so not of Divine, but of humane Ordination. But the Church is complete and perfect in its government, in that there are in it believers, Pastors, Doctors, Elders, and Deacons, suppose no power of the keys, be in the community of believers. The proposition is Parkers; so reason the Fathers, Cyril, Chrysostom, Basil. Augustine, Bede: so William Best, M. Jacob, M Robinson. I prove the Assumption. The Eldership have no oversight in the Lord, and there is no necessity or exercise of the keys, as Elders, if all believers have a ministerial power to bind and loose: as M. Smith and others, teach: and if all edify by the keys,2 as Parker saith, and judicially censure, excommunicate,3 and ordain, or depose their rulers, as the English Puritanism, and authors of the presbytery examined do prove,4 from 1 Cor. 5. and Guide to Zion. For ten believers being nothing but believers by Divine right, or as well the governing Church without the Eldership, as having them,5 suppose all the Elders were believers. Where also there be twenty times three believers, they have all in their own families the power of the keys, and so there are twenty Churches, complete and independent within themselves, joined in twenty neighbour families, all under one covenant with God, and flying all known sins. Now when Christ saith, If thy brother offend thee, and obstinately refuse ⟨p. 11⟩to hear, tell the Church. Which of the twenty three shall the Brother wronged have recourse unto? (tell the Church) as reason would say, must be some visible Church, Senate or judicatory, but all these twenty threes met within their houses are independent Churches, if they be believers as we suppose, and all visible Churches. Shall we think that Christ hath left a grieved brother to a blind, Tell the Church? and yet who can know this Church? for all have alike interest in Christ, which of the twenty threes be the Church that Christ meant in these words, Tell the Church, by this doctrine none can dream.
4. Argument. Such power of the keyes, without the which the Church of Christ is perfect,1 and complete for government, is superfluous, and so not of Divine, but of humane Ordination. But the Church is complete and perfect in its government, in that there are in it believers, Pastours, Doctors, Elders, and Deacons, suppose no power of the keyes, be in the communitie of believers. The proposition is Parkers; so reason the Fathers, Cyrill, Chrysostome, Basil. Augustine, Beda: so William Best, M. Iacob, M Robinson. I prove the Assumption. The Eldership have no oversight in the Lord, and there is no necessitie or exercise of the keyes, as Elders, if all believers have a ministeriall power to bind and loose: as M. Smith and others, teach: and if all edifie by the keyes,2 as Parker saith, and judicially censure, excommunicate,3 and ordaine, or depose their rulers, as the English Puritanisme, and authors of the presbytery examined doe prove,4 from 1 Cor. 5. and Guide to Zion. For ten believers being nothing but believers by Divine right, or als well the governing Church without the Eldership, as having them,5 suppose all the Elders were believers. Where also there be twentie times three believers, they have all in their owne families the power of the keyes, and so there are twenty Churches, complete and independent within themselves, joyned in twentie neighbour families, all under one covenant with God, and flying all knowne sins. Now when Christ saith, If thy brother offend thee, and obstinately refuse ⟨p. 11⟩to heare, tell the Church. Which of the twenty three shall the Brother wronged have recourse unto? (tell the Church) as reason would say, must bee some visible Church, Senat or judicatorie, but all these twenty threes met within their houses are independent Churches, if they be believers as we suppose, and all visible Churches. Shall wee thinke that Christ hath left a grieved brother to a blind, Tell the Church? and yet who can know this Church? for all have alike interest in Christ, which of the twenty threes bee the Church that Christ meaned in these words, Tell the Church, by this doctrine none can dreame.
14. Argument.
2Parker de polit. eccles. l. 3. c. 2.
3English puritanism, 9.English puritanisme, 9.
4Presbyter. Govern. examined. p. 12. reas. 1, 2, 3 Guide to Zion, pos. 58. p. 31.
5 Argument. 1The multitude of believers hath either this power of the keys from Christ, and from heaven; or from the earth, and from men: for I think our brethren will not dream of any ecclesiastic positive law, not warranted in Gods word, for a third, for this Papists teach. This is Christs argument for John Baptists ministry. If from Christ and Heaven, it is either from the law of nature, or from some divine positive law: from nature it is not. For 1. the power is not natural, but supernatural, reaching a supernatural end, the gathering of the Saints, Eph 4. 11, 12. neither is this power such, as can have nature for its Author, as Almain saith,2 seeing it is above natures reach. And so also saith And▪ Duvallius. If happily they say, it is from good consequence natural, for because of the claim and interest that the faithful have in Christ, Christs keys are given to them,3 as God giving Christ, he giveth all other things with Christ.4 I Answer. This maketh no man, but a believer, yea no gifted pastor capable of the keys, except he have faith in Christ, which we shall hereafter refute, as contrary to Scripture.5 Neither can it be from any positive law, or grant, or promise in the new Testament, that all the members of the Church shall be Princes,6 Rulers, Commanders, that Christ hath left none to be over other in the Lord. If this be from men, it is a humane ordinance, and cannot stand. See what Bellarmine saith to this purpose.
5 Argument. 1The multitude of believers hath either this power of the keyes from Christ, and from heaven; or from the earth, and from men: for I thinke our brethren will not dreame of any ecclesiastick positive law, not warranted in Gods word, for a third, for this Papists teach. This is Christs argument for John Baptists ministerie. If from Christ and Heaven, it is either from the law of nature, or from some divine positive law: from nature it is not. For 1. the power is not naturall, but supernaturall, reaching a supernaturall end, the gathering of the Saints, Eph 4. 11, 12. neither is this power such, as can have nature for its Author, as Almain saith,2 seeing it is above natures reach. And so also saith And▪ Duvallius. If happily they say, it is from good consequence naturall, for because of the claime and interest that the faithfull have in Christ, Christs keyes are given to them,3 as God giving Christ, he giveth all other things with Christ.4 I Answer. This maketh no man, but a believer, yea no gifted pastour capable of the keyes, except hee have faith in Christ, which we shall hereafter refute, as contrary to Scripture.5 Neither can it bee from any positive law, or grant, or promise in the new Testament, that all the members of the Church shall be Princes,6 Rulers, Commanders, that Christ hath left none to be over other in the Lord. If this be from men, it is a humane ordinance, and cannot stand. See what Bellarmine saith to this purpose.
15. Argument.
2Almain de auth. eccles. c. 2. potestas ecclesiastica non est humanitus justituibilis.Almain de auth. eccles. c. 2. potestas ecclesiastica non est humanitus iustituibilis.
3Duvallius in 22.
4Thom. •om. 2. de sum. pontif. tract. 4. q. 3. p. 1.
6. Argument. 1The power of the Keys is either given to the believers as believers, or as they are such ⟨p. 12⟩whom God gifteth for government, selected from amongst others, if the later be said, we have our intent, and the keys must be given immediately to some selected guides: If the keys be given to believers, as they are such, and under this reduplication, Then 1. All believing women and children have authority in the Lord over the congregation, which, as Duvallius saith,2 is not to be admitted, for quod convenit [Greek or Hebrew] convenit [Greek or Hebrew]. Yea, 2. saith Paul Baynes, If the power of the keys and teaching had been given to all believers, all should have been made Pastors and Doctors, though not to continue so in exercising the power. 3And so all must have the power of seeing, as the Church eyes and Watchmen, and all the power of hearing,4 as the Church ears, and certainly,5 the second act must proceed from the essence and first act, as moving must proceed from a living soul, to laugh from a reasonable soul, so to excommunicate judicially, to judge, correct, cast out, bind and loose, (all which Parker and others prove to agree to believers from Matthew 18. and 1 Corinth. 5.) must flow from a ministerial principle, and so all must be eyes, and ears, which is against the variety of the gifts of the spirit. If the whole body were an eye, where were the hearing, if the whole were hearing, where were the smelling? v. 14. for the whole body is not one member, but many, yea, a collection of many members.
6. Argument. 1The power of the Keyes is either given to the believers as believers, or as they are such ⟨p. 12⟩whome God gifteth for government, selected from amongst others, if the later be said, we have our intent, and the keyes must be given immediately to some selected guides: If the keyes be given to believers, as they are such, and under this reduplication, Then 1. All believing women and children have authoritie in the Lord over the congregation, which, as Duvallius saith,2 is not to be admitted, for quod convenit 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 convenit 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Yea, 2. saith Paul Baynes, If the power of the keyes and teaching had beene given to all believers, all should have beene made Pastours and Doctours, though not to continue so in exercising the power. 3And so all must have the power of seeing, as the Church eyes and Watchmen, and all the power of hearing,4 as the Church eares, and certainely,5 the second act must proceed from the essence and first act, as moving must proceed from a living soule, to laugh from a reasonable soule, so to excommunicate judicially, to judge, correct, cast out, bind and loose, (all which Parker and others prove to agree to believers from Matthew 18. and 1 Corinth. 5.) must flow from a ministeriall principle, and so all must bee eyes, and eares, which is against the varietie of the gifts of the spirit. If the whole body were an eye, where were the hearing, if the whole were hearing, where were the smelling? v. 14. for the whole body is not one member, but many, yea, a collection of many members.
16 Argument.
2Duvallius 22. to. 2. tract. 4. de sum pontif. q. 3. Baines Dioce trial q. 3. concl. 3. p. 84.Duvallius 22. to. 2. tract. 4. de sum pontif. q. 3. Baines Dioce tryall q. 3. concl. 3. p. 84.
Hence,1 7. Argument. That is not to be admitted which overturneth the order established by Christ of commanding,2 and obeying,3 and which everteth the integral members and parts of a visible politic ministerial body of Christ,4 but to give the power of the keys to all,5 and every one,6 overturneth this order of Christs,7 Ergo, 8This doctrine is not to be admitted.9 The Major is undeniable.10 I prove the Minor. The ministerial Church is divided,11 as Junius saith, in Shepherds,12 and flock,13 some are [Greek or Hebrew] and [Greek or Hebrew] Overseers and Watchmen, 14others, such as are to submit and obey: 15some are Watchmen,16 then they have some that they watch over:17 Some Shepherds, ergo, they must have Sheep: Some Ambassadors in Christs stead, 18Ergo, They have some ⟨p. 13⟩to whom they carry the Embassage, Heralds, Witnesses, Stewards, Fathers, Saviours, Sowers, Reapers, builders, then they must have, a People, House, Sons, Ground, &c. upon whom they exercise their native operations. But if all have power of the keys, and power to edify by binding and loosing, all should be Overseers, Watchmen, Shepherds, Ambassadors,19 and if all were Fathers, where were the Sons? What a work would this be, that all Christians must leave their trading, husbandry, arts, sailing, and oversee the Church,20 and judge and determine Church matters betwixt brother and brother. So Francis Johnson reasoneth: Master Smith answereth two things to this.21 1. The Elders (saith he) shall obey the voice of the Church, in things commanded by God, and all the Saints are to obey the Elders in things commanded by God, and these may well stand together. I answer, If we speak of divers kinds of obedience, it is true, people is to obey the Pastors and Elders using the keys, here the sheep obey the Shepherds, and this is the obedience that Christ hath established in his house, and the Elders as Archippus, are to hear the flock admonishing, no commanding as Watchmen, Fathers, Pastors by the power of the keys, that they would take heed to the ministry, which they have received of the Lord, and this is but private admonition, that one man, one woman, may give to their Pastors. Now one man is not the Church bearing the keys, but this opinion maketh Archippus and all the faithful at Coloss to bear the keys, and command by power of the keys, so that all are Fathers, Pastors;
Hence,1 7. Argument. That is not to be admitted which overturneth the order established by Christ of commanding,2 and obeying,3 and which everteth the integrall members and parts of a visible politike ministeriall body of Christ,4 but to give the power of the keyes to all,5 and every one,6 overturneth this order of Christs,7 Ergo, 8This doctrine is not to be admitted.9 The Major is undenyable.10 I prove the Minor. The ministeriall Church is divided,11 as Junius saith, in Sheepeheards,12 and flock,13 some are 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Overseers and Watchmen, 14others, such as are to submit and obey: 15some are Watchmen,16 then they have some that they watch over:17 Some Shepheards, ergo, they must have Sheep: Some Ambassadors in Christs stead,
Pastors by one and the same power of the keys. His second answer is. All are not rulers: An incorporation may make a Major or Sheriffs, and yet the incorporation is not a Major and Sheriff: So the Church may make Ministers, and yet the Church it self is not properly an Elder, or a Deacon. Answer, It is not alike, An incorporation hath a privilege, but not any princely or magisterial authority to create a Major, but the Saints have the regal power of the keys from Christ, not only to make Elders, but also to judge authoritatively with coequal power with the Elders: by your doctrine, if the whole inhabitants ⟨p. 14⟩of a city may make a Major, and set themselves down in the Bench, as collateral Judges with the Major, then all the inhabitants indeed were Majors, as all the Saints in Corinth did judicially excommunicate, why are they not then all Elders and Pastors? Show us any authority that Pastors have in governing, which the meanest of the congregation hath not? And this maketh all Ministers, and all, to be Watchmen, Fathers, Overseers. This I take to have been the error of Tertullian, 1who will have Christ to have left all Christians with alike power.
Pastours by one and the same power of the keyes. His second answer is. All are not rulers: An incorporation may make a Major or Sheriffs, and yet the incorporation is not a Major and Sheriffe: So the Church may make Ministers, and yet the Church it selfe is not properly an Elder, or a Deacon. Answer, It is not alike, An incorporation hath a priviledge, but not any princely or magisteriall authoritie to create a Major, but the Saints have the regall power of the keyes from Christ, not only to make Elders, but also to judge authoritatively with coequall power with the Elders: by your doctrine, if the whole inhabitants ⟨p. 14⟩of a citie may make a Major, and set themselves down in the Bench, as collaterall Judges with the Major, then all the inhabitants indeed were Majors, as all the Saints in Corinth did judicially excommunicate, why are they not then all Elders and Pastours? Shew us any authoritie that Pastours have in governing, which the meanest of the congregation hath not? And this maketh all Ministers, and all, to be Watchmen, Fathers, Overseers. This I take to have beene the errour of Tertullian, 1who will have Christ to have left all Christians with alike power.
8. Argument. 1If there be a peculiar authority in Pastors over the flock,2 that is not in the flock, Then the keys are not both in the Pastors,3 and the people: but the first is said in Scripture,4 ergo, The later must also be said. I prove the Minor.5 What, will ye, that I come to you with a rod, or in love, or in the Spirit of meekness? also. Therefore I write these things being absent, lest being present I should use sharpness, according to the power that the Lord hath given me, to edification, and not to destruction. Hence it is that the Angels of the seven Churches in Asia are rebuked for not exercise sing discipline against Jezebel, and the holders of the Doctrine of Bal•m: which proveth the Angels had the keys, else all alike had been rebuked. Now that every one of Corinth hath the power of Pauls Rod, and his power given for edification, is most ridiculous. So Becanus the Jesuit. Can every believer say to a Church,6 Shall I come to you with the Rod? Yet if all have the keys, as the subject, all have the Rod also.
8. Argument. 1If there be a peculiar authoritie in Pastors over the flock,2 that is not in the flock, Then the keyes are not both in the Pastours,3 and the people: but the first is said in Scripture,4 ergo, The later must also be said. I prove the Minor.5 What, will ye, that I come to you with a rod, or in love, or in the Spirit of meeknesse? also. Therefore I write these things being absent, lest being present I should use sharpnesse, according to the power that the Lord hath given me, to edification, and not to destruction. Hence it is that the Angels of the seven Churches in Asia are rebuked for not exerc• sing discipline against Iezabel, and the holders of the Doctrine of Bal•m: which proveth the Angels had the keyes, els all alike had beene rebuked. Now that every one of Corinth hath the power of Pauls Rod, and his power given for edification, is most ridiculous. So Becanus the Jesuite. Can every believer say to a Church,6 Shall I come to you with the Rod? Yet if all have the keyes, as the subject, all have the Rod also.
9. Arg. 1That which Christ will have to be a ministerial power in the members of his Church,2 to the exercise thereof Christ giveth competent and answerable gifts to the foresaid effect.3 But God neither giveth,4 nor hath promised,5 nor requireth answerable gifts for using the keys in all believers.6 Therefore Christ willeth no ministerial power of the keys to be in all the members of the Church.7 The proposition I prove 1. God promiseth gifts to the priesthood of the new Testament.8 As 1. Diligence,9 Isaiah 61.10 That strangers shall stand and feed their flocks. 2. Zeal, Isaiah 62. That ⟨p. 15⟩they shall never give the Lord rest. 113. That they shall be clothed with salvation. 2. When God sendeth Moses, Isaiah, 12Jeremiah, he giveth them gifts and abilities for the calling.13 So (as the Treatist of Discipline observeth) it is oft said,14 The Spirit of the Lord came upon him, 15and he judged Israel. 16So also other places for this. 3. They are condemned who take on them a calling,17 and say, Thus saith the Lord, and yet the Lord sent them not, 18neither spake he to them, as in Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel. 4. Where the Lord giveth a calling or power, such as the keys of his Kingdom, the not improving and putting the Lords Talent to the bank, is a sinful digging of the Lords Talent in the earth. Hence I desire to know from Gods word, these four things, 1. If the power of the keys be given by Christ to all the faithful, this power is a ministerial calling. Where is there a promise for light, prudence for government, to go out and in before the Lords people, made to every one of the Lords people? 2. Where is the tongue promised to them all in judgement, that none shall resist, and the consolations promised to them, in the discharge of this power of the keys? 3. Where is the Spirit of the Lord coming upon them all, and every one, that they may judge the people? 4. Where are the believers condemned for usurping the keys, and because being ignorant they cannot discharge that calling? Where is the careless governing of all and every one of the faithful rebuked in the word of God, as a digging of the Lords talent in the earth? I add two things to confirm this. 1.
9. Arg. 1That which Christ will have to be a ministeriall power in the members of his Church,2 to the exercise therof Christ giveth competent and answerable gifts to the foresaid effect.3 But God neither giveth,4 nor hath promised,5 nor requireth answerable gifts for using the keyes in all believers.6 Therefore Christ willeth no ministeriall power of the keyes to be in all the members of the Church.7 The proposition I prove 1. God promiseth gifts to the priesthood of the new Testament.8 As 1. Diligence,9 Esay 61.10 That strangers shall stand and feed their flocks. 2. Zeale, Esay 62. That ⟨p. 15⟩they shall never give the Lord rest. 113. That they shall be cloathed with salvation. 2. When God sendeth Moses, Isaiah, 12Ieremiah, he giveth them gifts and abilities for the calling.13 So (as the Treatist of Discipline observeth) it is oft said,14 The Spirit of the Lord came upon him, 15and he judged Israel. 16
Our Divines disputing against the great Pope, the Bishop of Rome, and against the little Pope, the Prelate his god-son, and first born, come out of the Popes loins, as Calvin, Beza, Junius, Zanchius, Sadeel, Pareus, Ursine, Whitaker, Reynold, and Amesius, Baines, Parker, Didoclavius, &c. They prove, if such power of the keys and plenitude of order, and jurisdiction, were in these two creatures, the Pope and the Prelate, the wisdom of Christ in his Word, should have set down the canons for the regulating of the power, besides the canons that concerneth all other Bishops or Pastors, for the heads or Monarchs duty ⟨p. 16⟩in the common wealth, is carefully set down in the word, as what a man the King should be; but the word hath no canons for the power of the keys, and the regulating of that power, in all and every believer, man and woman. 2. If God set down a Canon, and requires abilities in the Church guides, as Elders labouring in the word and doctrine, and governing, and in Deacons, that, he requireth not in all believers, then the power of the keys is not in the Church guides, and in all believers also; but the former is said, 1 Tim. 3. for it is required in a Minister that his power of the keys may be said to be of God,1 that he should rule his own house well, 2else how should he [Greek or Hebrew],3 take care to govern the Church of God? 4One may be a believer,5 and yet this is not required of him,6 as he is a believer, an Elder should not be a Lord over the flock,7 it is required of a Steward, that he be faithful as a Steward, that he ordain Elders, and these men of good report, that he receive not an accusation against an Elder: Now I hope, these are not required of believers, as believers, neither were the Epistles to Timothy and Titus written so much to these men, as believers; as to them as holy Elders, and Pastors: And yet if the power of the keys be common to all the faithful, these Epistles are written to all believers, primly to men, and believing children, how they should use the keys, ordain Elders, receive Witnesses, govern the Church.8 Dear Brethren, see this and consider it for your good.
Our Divines disputing against the great Pope, the Bishop of Rome, and against the little Pope, the Prelate his god-son, and first born, come out of the Popes loynes, as Calvin, Beza, Iunius, Zanchius, Sadeel, Pareus, Vrsine, Whitaker, Reynold, and Amesius, Baines, Parker, Didoclavius, &c. They prove, if such power of the keyes and plenitude of order, and jurisdiction, were in these two creatures, the Pope and the Prelate, the wisedome of Christ in his Word, should have set downe the canons for the regulating of the power, besides the canons that concerneth all other Bishops or Pastours, for the heads or Monarchs dutie ⟨p. 16⟩in the common wealth, is carefully set downe in the word, as what a man the King should be; but the word hath no canons for the power of the keyes, and the regulating of that power, in all and every believer, man and woman. 2. If God set downe a Canon, and requires abilities in the Church guides, as Elders labou•ing in the word and doctrine, and governing, and in Deacons, that, he requireth not in all believers, then the power of the keyes is not in the Church guides, and in all believers also; but the former is said, 1 Tim. 3. for it is required in a Minister that his power of the keyes may be said to be of God,1 that he should rule his owne house well, 2else how should he 〈non-Latin alphabet〉,3 take care to governe the Church of God? 4One may be a believer,5 and yet this is not required of him,6 as he is a believer, an Elder should not be a Lord over the flock,7 it is required of a Steward, that hee bee faithfull as a Steward, that he ordaine Elders, and these men of good report, that he receive not an accusation against an Elder: Now I hope, these are not required of believers, as believers, neither were the Epistles to Timothy and Titus written so much to these men, as believers; as to them as holy Elders, and Pastours: And yet if the power of the keyes bee common to all the faithfull, these Epistles are written to all believers, primely to men, and believing children, how they should use the keyes, ordaine Elders, receive Witnesses, governe the Church.
10. Argument. That which maketh the government of Gods house Democratical and popular, is not to be taught: but this Opinion is such, as I hope to prove hereafter.
10. Argument. That which maketh the government of Gods house Democraticall and popular, is not to bee taught: but this Opinion is such, as I hope to prove hereafter.
11. Argument. If the power of the keys be given to believers,1 as believers, Then all, and only believers, have the power of the keys: Quod convenit [Greek or Hebrew] convenit [Greek or Hebrew], That which agreeth to any thing reduplicative, and for this formal reason, it agreeth to that subject only: But all and only believers have not the power of the keys. for the Major, Parker teacheth, The keys were given to Peter, as a believer, not as an Apostle. I prove the Assumption. ⟨p. 17⟩The believers three or four may be excommunicated, and that justly, in which case they remain believers, and yet being no members of the Church, cannot have the power of the keys: also many have the power of the keys, yea, and are pastors, that are not believers: as Christ saith, Have not I chosen you twelve, and yet one of you is a Devil? Many will say to me in that day, 2Lord, we have prophesied in thy name, 3and in thy name cast out Devils, &c. and yet they are workers of iniquity, 4never known of Christ as his elect. So some enemies to Paul and wicked men, Phil. 1. Haters of the Gospel, and yet preached it, in such sort that Paul rejoiced that Christ was preached. Now if they be not believers that are pastors, their pastoral acts of baptizing and administering the Sacraments are null, seeing they have no power of the keys, many shall doubt if they have been baptized, because they may happily doubt, yea, too justly doubt of the belief, and so of the pastors power of the keys. Yea, six or ten professors and visible Saints are an independent congregation, and so have the power of the Keys to appoint an Eldership, to Excommunicate, and yet these ten may be faithless hypocrites: hence all their acts of the keys are null. It is known, how Austin, Jerome and the Fathers contend that the Baptism of Heretics is lawful.
11. Argument. If the power of the keyes be given to believers,1 as believers, Then all, and only believers, have the power of the keyes: Quod convenit 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 convenit 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, That which agreeth to any thing reduplicative, and for this formall reason, it agreeth to that subject only: But all and only believers have not the power of the keyes. for the Major, Parker teacheth, The keyes were given to Peter, as a believer, not as an Apostle. I prove the Assumption. ⟨p. 17⟩The believers three or foure may be excommunicated, and that justly, in which case they remaine believers, and yet being no members of the Church, cannot have the power of the keyes: also many have the power of the keyes, yea, and are pastours, that are not believers: as Christ saith, Have not I chosen you twelve, and yet one of you is a Divell? Many will say to me in that day, 2Lord, we have prophefied in thy name, 3and in thy name cast out Divels, &c. and yet they are workers of iniquity, 4never knowne of Christ as his elect. So some enemies to Paul and wicked men, Phil. 1. Haters of the Gospell, and yet preached it, in such sort that Paul rejoyced that Christ was preached. Now if they bee not believers that are pastours, their pastorall acts of baptizing and administring the Sacraments are null, seeing they have no power of the keyes, many shall doubt if they have beene baptized, because they may happily doubt, yea, too justly doubt of the beliefe, and so of the pastours power of the keyes. Yea, six or ten professors and visible Saints are an independent congregation, and so have the power of the Keyes to appoint an Eldership, to Excommunicate, and yet these ten may be faithlesse hyppocrites: hence all their acts of the keyes are null. It is knowne, how Austin, Jerome and the Fathers contend that the Baptisme of Heretikes is lawfull.
12. If I shall once for all here clear from Antiquity, that the Eldership hath only the keys, I also prove from Antiquity, 1. A Presbyterial and representative Church. 2. That the congregation of believers, is not an independent Senate, to ordain an Eldership, and deprive them. 3. That the prime ground of an independent congregation hath no ground in Antiquity.
12. If I shall once for all here cleare from Antiquitie, that the Eldership hath only the keyes, I also prove from Antiquitie, 1. A Presbyteriall and representative Church. 2. That the congregation of believers, is not an independent Senate, to ordaine an Eldership, and deprive them. 3. That the prime ground of an independent congregation hath no ground in Antiquitie.
Polycarpus Pastor of Smyrna an hearer of the Apostles, 1as is thought, An. 143. willeth the Philippians to submit themselves to the Elders and Deacons,2 as to Christ. Irenaeus the Disciple of Polycarpus admonisheth the faithful of the same. Tertullian, An. 226. saith, The Elders had the charge of excommunication and censures.
Polycarpus Pastour of Smyrna an hearer of the Apostles, 1as is thought, An. 143. willeth the Philippians to submit themselves to the Elders and Deacons,2 as to Christ. Irenaeus the Disciple of Polycarpus admonisheth the faithfull of the same. Tertullian, An. 226. saith, The Elders had the charge of excommunication and censures.
1Polycarpus an. 143. praecipit Philippensibus ut presbyteris & diaconis, sicut Deo & Christo se subjiciant.
2Irenaus lib. 4. c. 43. & cap. 44. monet fideles ut cum presbyterii ordine Sermonem suum & conversationem sine offensa praestent. Tertullian apol. c. 39. ait, seniors excommunicationi & censuris praefuisse.Irenaus lib. 4. c. 43. & cap. 44. monet fideles ut cum presbyterii ordine Sermonem suum & conversationem sine offensa praestent. Tertullian apol. c. 39. ait, seniores excommunicationi & censuris praefuisse.
Ignatius very ancient,1 if we believe antiquity, describeth our very Scottish Presbytery, and calleth it, a Senate of Pastors and Elders, that was in the Church in his time. So Origen, who lived with Tertullian, resembleth the Presbytery to the Senate of a City, and Ruffinus agreeth with them. Cyprian, the presbyters and other officers have the power of the keys. So the Nicene Council saith (as the Mageburgen. and Socrates say) Aurelius was ordained by Cyprian and his colleagues: he requireth that the multitude he present to consent, but that the Presbyteries ordain.
Ignatius very ancient,1 if we believe antiquitie, describeth our very Scotish Presbyterie, and calleth it, a Senate of Pastours and Elders, that was in the Church in his time. So Origen, who lived with Tertullian, resembleth the Presbytery to the Senate of a Citie, and Ruffinus agreeth with them. Cyprian, the presbyters and other officers have the power of the keyes. So the Nicen Councell saith (as the Mageburgen. and Socrates say) Aurelius was ordained by Cyprian and his colleagues: he requireth that the multitude he present to consent, but that the Presbyteries ordaine.
1Ignatius epist. ad Tinllanos, presbyterium definit caeu•m sacrum consiliarios & confessors, [Greek or Hebrew], Episc. & ibid. [Greek or Hebrew] Dei & consociatum caetum Apostolorum, & ib. Sed & presbyteris subjects estote, tanquam Christi Apostolis. Origen. contra Cell vocat. [Greek or Hebrew] ecclesiarum. Ruffin. lib. 10. c. 5. hist. eccles. Cyprian. epist. 14. ep. 33. ep. 10. ep. 68. ut s•cerdos peebe praesente, sub omni um occulis deligatur, & dignis atque idoneus publico judicio ac testimo. comprobetur, omni a•m (inquit l. 3. ep. 11.) ad me perlato, placuit contrahi presbyterium: Fi• milianus Seniors & propositi ordimandi potestatem habent. Clem. Alex. s•ro•n. lib. 7. penes presbyteros est discipline quae homine m•liores fac•. Basil. ad Noe Caesu. ep. 75. Interrogate […] vesto•, & annunci•tibunt vobis, quod e•ia usi paroe•i• loci citu divisae esse videbantur, coron•mento […] unita erant & una senten i• guberna•antur. Ath•nas epist: • orthodox Hyeren Eccles habet senatum […] presbyterio•um, […] epist. •. ad Dunetria. […] in 1. Tim. A•equam diaboli instinctu communi presbytertorum consil•o ecclesia regebatur. Eusebias l. 1. de vita Constant. at the fa••ous Councell of N•e, Nar. 250. Bishops multitudes of Elders and Deacons. So the Magdeburg cent 1. de g•ber. eccles. c. 7. Socrat. l. 1. c. 8. showeth us that then Paph•utius, neither a Bishop nor yet a pastor opposed the single life of Church-men.Ignatius epist. ad Tinllanos, presbyterium definit caeu•m sacrum consiliarios & confessores, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Episc. & ibid. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Dei & consociatum caetum Apostolorum, & ib. Sed & presbyteris subjects estote, tanquam Christi Apostolis. Origen. contra Cell vocat. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 ecclesiarum. Ruffin. lib. 10. c. 5. hist. eccles. Cyprian. epist. 14. ep. 33. ep. 10. ep. 68. ut s•cerdos peebe praesente, sub omni um occulis deligatur, & dignis atque idoneus publico judicio ac testimo. comprobetur, omni a•m (inquit l. 3. ep. 11.) ad me perlato, placuit contrahi presbyterium: Fi• milianus Seniores & propositi ordimandi potestatem habent. Clem. Alex. s•ro•n. lib. 7. penes presbyteros est discipline quae homine m•liores fac•. Basil. ad Noe Caesu. ep. 75. Interrogate 〈…〉 vesto•, & annunci•tibunt vobis, quod e•ia usi paroe•i• loci citu divisae esse videbantur, coron•mento 〈…〉 unita erant & una senten i• guberna•antur. Ath•nas epist: • o•thodox Hyeren Eccles habet senatum 〈…〉 presbyterio•um, 〈…〉 epist. •. ad Dunetria. 〈…〉 in 1. Tim. A•equam diaboli instinctu communi presbytertorum consil•o ecclesia regebatur. Eusebias l. 1. de vita Constant. at the faous Councell of Ne, Nar. 250. Bishops multitudes of Elders and Deacons. So the Magdeburg cent 1. de gber.
The author
Samuel Rutherford 1600?–1661
PuritansScotland
Scottish theologian and commissioner to the Westminster Assembly.
. but will it follow, none were made Apostles untill he ascended? if this were good, by vertue of his death, wee obtaine forgivenesse of sinnes, by his ascending to heaven, we also ascend. But hence it followeth not, that there is no forgivenesse of sinnes while Christ die, and that there is no ascending to heaven of the spirits of the Patriarchs and Fathers, while Christ ascended. 2. That the Apostles were called, and received Apostleship from Christ in the dayes of his slesh, before his death, is cleare,
to whom they carry the Embassage, Heralds, Witnesses, Stewards, Fathers, Saviours, Sowers, Reapers, builders, then they must have, a People, House, Sonnes, Ground, &c. upon whom they exercise their native operations. But if all have power of the keyes, and power to edifie by binding and loosing, all should be Overseers, Watchmen, Sheepheards, Ambassadors,
and if all were Fathers, where were the Sons? What a worke would this be, that all Christians must leave their trading, husbandry, arts, sayling, and oversee the Church,
1. The Elders (saith he) shall obey the voice of the Church, in things commanded by God, and all the Saints are to obey the Elders in things commanded by God, and these may well stand together. I answer, If we speake of divers kindes of obedience, it is true, people is to obey the Pastours and Elders using the keyes, here the sheepe obey the Shepheards, and this is the obedience that Christ hath established in his house, and the Elders as Archippus, are to heare the flock admonishing, no commanding as Watchmen, Fathers, Pastours by the power of the keyes, that they would take heed to the ministerie, which they have received of the Lord, and this is but private admonition, that one man, one woman, may give to their Pastours. Now one man is not the Church bearing the keyes, but this opinion maketh Archippus and all the faithfull at Colosse to beare the keyes, and command by power of the keyes, so that all are Fathers, Pastours;
neither spake he to them, as in Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel. 4. Where the Lord giveth a calling or power, such as the keyes of his Kingdome, the not improving and putting the Lords Talent to the bank, is a sinfull digging of the Lords Talent in the earth. Hence I desire to know from Gods word, these foure things, 1. If the power of the keyes be given by Christ to all the faithfull, this power is a ministeriall calling. Where is there a promise for light, prudence for government, to goe out and in before the Lords people, made to every one of the Lords people? 2. Where is the tongue promised to them all in judgement, that none shall resist, and the consolations promised to them, in the discharge of this power of the keyes? 3. Where is the Spirit of the Lord comming upon them all, and every one, that they may judge the people? 4. Where are the believers condemned for usurping the keyes, and because being ignorant they cannot discharge that calling? Where is the carelesse governing of all and every one of the faithfull rebuked in the word of God, as a digging of the Lords talent in the earth? I adde two things to confirme this. 1.