A65962:1723
The whole trial of Mr. Christopher Love, before a pretended high court of justice…The whole triall of Mr. Christopher Love, before a pretended high court of justice…
The whole trial of Mr. Christopher Love, before a pretended high court of justice in Westminster Hall containing the charge of high treason against him ... with the relation of his suffering and his speech and prayer at his death on Tower-hill / published by John Farthing, citizen of London, who took the trial in the said court in short-writing for Mr. Love, and at his own request ; to which is added The tragedy of his trial and death in very elegant verses / by the acute author of Iter boreale.The whole triall of Mr. Christopher Love, before a pretended high court of justice in Westminster Hall containing the charge of high treason against him ... with the relation of his suffering and his speech and prayer at his death on Tower-hill / published by John Farthing, citizen of London, who took the triall in the said court in short-writing for Mr. Love, and at his own request ; to which is added The tragedy of his triall and death in very elegant verses / by the acute author of Iter boreale.
London : s.n., 1660
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Mr. Hale. If there be a substantial part of the Charge omitted, that ought to be alleged in fact, it is not the conclusion, that contrary to the form of the Statutes in this case made and provided, will help it. My Lord, (I come unprovided) the case of my Lord Dyer, that known case upon an Indictment for Recusancy, or for a wilful or knowing harbouring of a Jesuit, or Priest: Saith my Lord Dyer, It is not enough to say, he did harbour him contrary to the form of the Statute,▪ but he must say, he did it knowingly: he must allege and pursue the substantial words of the Act of Parliament. And so again, an Indictment for absenting from Church; it is not enough to say, he did it contrary to the form of the Statute: but that he did it obstinately. Therefore that general conclusion, that this was to the hazard of the Commonwealth (it is true, it is an ill thing for any man to do such a thing that is to the hazard of the Commonwealth) but those words serve not the Statute neither: and then to say at the conclusion, Contrary to the form of divers Statutes, that will not help it, under favour, in case of an Indictment. Then Mr. Attorney makes a difference between the case of an Indictment, and this Charge. I conceive that in this case there is no difference; the matter is the same, the one concerns the life of a person, and so doth the other; the offence is the same, the one is a charge of high Treason, and so is the other. It is true, those formalities that concern the manner of the Trial, those (it is true) are laid by, because here is no Jury to come before your Lordship; but your Lordship trieth upon the hearing of the testimony, and according to things alleged and proved: But for other matters that especially are substantially required by the Act of Parliament, we conceive that those shall be supplied no more by an intendment in case of a Charge before your Lordship, then in case of an Indictment for Treason: To this I shall say no more, but leave a word or two to your Lordships judgment. For the other thing (we are still but upon the first Charge, the first Article) it hath first of all been insisted upon, that an overt act is not necessary to be alleged, because supplied by the words of the conclusion, Contrary to the form of the Statute:
Mr. Hale. If there be a substantial part of the Charge omitted, that ought to be alledged in fact, it is not the conclusion, that contrary to the form of the Statutes in this case made and provided, will help it. My Lord, (I come unprovided) the case of my Lord Dyer, that known case upon an Indictment for Recusancy, or for a wilfull or knowing harbouring of a Jesuite, or Priest: Saith my Lord Dyer, It is not enough to say, he did harbour him contrary to the form of the Statute, but hee must say, he did it knowingly: he must alledge and pursue the substantiall words of the Act of Parliament. And so again, an Indictment for absenting from Church; it is not enough to say, he did it contrary to the form of the Statute: but that he did it obstinately. Therefore that generall conclusion, that this was to the hazard of the Commonwealth (it is true, it is an ill thing for any man to do such a thing that is to the hazard of the Commonwealth) but those words serve not the Statute neither: and then to say at the conclusion, Contrary to the form of divers Statutes, that will not help it, under favour, in case of an Indictment. Then Mr. Atturney makes a difference between the case of an Indictment, and this Charge. I conceive that in this case there is no difference; the matter is the same, the one concerns the life of a person, and so doth the other; the offence is the same, the one is a charge of high Treason, and so is the other. It is true, those formalities that concern the manner of the Triall, those (it is true) are laid by, because here is no Jury to come before your Lordship; but your Lordship tryeth upon the hearing of the testimony, and according to things alledged and proved: But for other matters that especially are substantially required by the Act of Parliament, wee conceive that those shall be supplyed no more by an intendment in case of a Charge before your Lordship, then in case of an Indictment for Treason: To this I shall say no more, but leave a word or two to your Lordships judgment. For the other thing (we are still but upon the first Charge, the first Article) it hath first of all been insisted upon, that an overt act is not necessary to be alledged, because supplyed by the words of the conclusion, Contrary to the form of the Statute: