Mr. Hales. My Lord, this is that we insist upon. It is true, we do conceive, though the promotion of the interest of Cha. Stewart is not consistent with the preservation of the interest of the Commonwealth; yet every destruction of the interest of the Commonwealth is not therefore a promotion of the interest of Charles Stewart; for then there could be no Treason against the Commonwealth, but it must be a promotion of the others interest. Now there may be a Treason against the Commonwealth without the ⟨p. 106⟩promotion of the others interest. I urge it to this purpose, to make it appear, that they are several Charges bottomed upon several Acts, and therefore the reference here made to promote the design aforesaid, is uncertain to which it shall relate; it may fall out the party may be guilty upon the first Article; it may fall out, he is not guilty upon the second Article, and then it is uncertain to which article it relates, that he is guilty of, or not guilty of: and here may be the consequence of it, then you will make a Treason, which to this third clause is a Substantive, and contained in it self, to be an overt act to another charge of Treason, and that you cannot do: you cannot make a Treason which is so charged, to be an overt act, or exposition, or a declaration of that which is contained in the former, like that case I instanced in before, of the 25 of Edward the 3d, That no man shall go about to destroy the person of the King, nor to raise war against his people: so that we use it not in any other reference, but only to explain and bring the reason of that ancient Law to this Law: In that case a man cannot charge the overt act of going about to destroy his person, which is a distinct Treason of it self, to be an overt act to the Charge of Levying war, which is another distinct Treason: And if he allege, such a one did go about to destroy the Prince, or the Consort of the King, or the King, and to make the levying of war to be an overt act to it, this he cannot do; because though it is true, it might be an overt act to it, yet notwithstanding, it being made a distinct treason, it cannot be an overt act to another treason: and so here, this very assisting and inviting of forces is made a distinct treason; and so if you take it substantively, it is insufficiently laid;
Mr. Hales. My Lord, this is that we insist upon. It is true, we do conceive, though the promotion of the interest of Cha. Stewart is not consistent with the preservation of the interest of the Commonwealth; yet every destruction of the interest of the Commonwealth is not therfore a promotion of the interest of Charles Stewart; for then there could be no Treason against the Commonwealth, but it must be a promotion of the others interest. Now there may be a Treason against the Commonwealth without the ⟨p. 106⟩promotion of the others interest. I urge it to this purpose, to make it appear, that they are severall Charges bottomed upon severall Acts, and therefore the reference here made to promote the designe aforesaid, is uncertain to which it shall relate; it may fall out the partie may be guilty upon the first Article; it may fall out, he is not guilty upon the second Article, and then it is uncertain to which article it relates, that hee is guilty of, or not guilty of: and here may be the consequence of it, then you will make a Treason, which to this third clause is a Substantive, and contained in it self, to be an overt act to another charge of Treason, and that you cannot do: you cannot make a Treason which is so charged, to be an overt act, or exposition, or a declaration of that which is contained in the former, like that case I instanced in before, of the 25 of Edward the 3d, That no man shall go about to destroy the person of the King, nor to raise war against his people: so that we use it not in any other reference, but onely to explain and bring the reason of that ancient Law to this Law: In that case a man cannot charge the overt act of going about to destroy his person, which is a distinct Treason of it self, to be an overt act to the Charge of Levying war, which is another distinct Treason: And if he alledg, such a one did go about to destroy the Prince, or the Consort of the King, or the King, and to make the levying of war to be an overt act to it, this he cannot do; because though it is true, it might be an overt act to it, yet notwithstanding, it being made a distinct treason, it cannot be an overt act to another treason: and so here, this very assisting and inviting of forces is made a distinct treason; and so if you take it substantively, it is insufficiently laid;