A65962:1724
The whole trial of Mr. Christopher Love, before a pretended high court of justice…The whole triall of Mr. Christopher Love, before a pretended high court of justice…
The whole trial of Mr. Christopher Love, before a pretended high court of justice in Westminster Hall containing the charge of high treason against him ... with the relation of his suffering and his speech and prayer at his death on Tower-hill / published by John Farthing, citizen of London, who took the trial in the said court in short-writing for Mr. Love, and at his own request ; to which is added The tragedy of his trial and death in very elegant verses / by the acute author of Iter boreale.The whole triall of Mr. Christopher Love, before a pretended high court of justice in Westminster Hall containing the charge of high treason against him ... with the relation of his suffering and his speech and prayer at his death on Tower-hill / published by John Farthing, citizen of London, who took the triall in the said court in short-writing for Mr. Love, and at his own request ; to which is added The tragedy of his triall and death in very elegant verses / by the acute author of Iter boreale.
London : s.n., 1660
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
To that I have answered, I conceive, it is not, nor can it be supplied, because it is a substantial thing in the very words and bowels of the Act, and cannot be supplied by a general conclusion. Then it hath been said by Sir Thomas Withrington the States Serjeant, that in this case those subsequent matters and charges shall be an overt act within the Statute; that is that which he hath read to you; It is in the fourth Article (as I take it) That Christopher Love, divers times between the 29 of March 1650. and the first of June 1651. did traitorously and maliciously hold and use correspondence and intelligence by letters and messages. But that cannot be; I may say it, that is not a sufficient manifestation of an overt Act, because there do precede it these particular Charges of Treason within particular Acts of Parliament; why then, if so be (to maintain his design, for the carrying on of his design aforesaid) this should be said to relate to the first design, why not to the second design, of promoting Charles Stewart to be King? And why not to the third design? So that where there are three several designs before, all made Treason by the Acts of Parliament, that cannot be an overt act to make good the first part of the Charge, with submission to your Lordships judgment. And then another thing we say, That this Charge which Sir Thomas would carry up to the first Charge, and make it as an enforcing and overt act within the first Charge, that cannot be, for this other reason; because it is charged as a traitorous distinct act in him. Now we have this learning delivered by Sir Edward Cook in his Comment upon this, in the 25 year of Edward the third: That is, where there are several acts made Treason; the one is an act for levying of war: Now there the case was Treason against the person of the King, Queen, Prince, &c. that one part shall not be an overt act in case of Indictment, shall not be construed as an overt act for the making good of another part; because where all are made equally traitorous, and all are charged as equally traitorous, we think, with submission, those parts shall not be made an overt act to another Treason.
To that I have answered, I conceive, it is not, nor can it be supplyed, because it is a substantiall thing in the very words and bowels of the Act, and cannot be supplyed by a generall conclusion. Then it hath been said by Sir Thomas Withrington the States Serjeant, that in this case those subsequent matters and charges shall be an overt act within the Statute; that is that which hee hath read to you; It is in the fourth Article (as I take it) That Christopher Love, divers times between the 29 of March 1650. and the first of June 1651. did traiterously and malicously hold and use correspondence and intelligence by letters and messages. But that cannot be; I may say it, that is not a sufficient manifestation of an overt Act, because there do precede it these particular Charges of Treason within particular Acts of Parliament; why then, if so be (to maintain his designe, for the carrying on of his designe aforesaid) this should be said to relate to the first designe, why not to the second designe, of promoting Charls Stewart to be King? And why not to the third designe? So that where there are three severall designes before, all made Treason by the Acts of Parliament, that cannot be an overt act to make good the first part of the Charge, with submission to your Lordships judgment. And then another thing wee say, That this Charge which Sir Thomas would carry up to the first Charge, and make it as an inforcing and overt act within the first Charge, that cannot be, for this other reason; because it is charged as a traiterous distinct act in him. Now we have this learning delivered by Sir Edward Cook in his Comment upon this, in the 25 yeer of Edward the third: That is, where there are severall acts made Treason; the one is an act for leavying of warr: Now there the case was Treason against the person of the King, Queen, Prince, &c. that one part shall not be an overt act in case of Indictment, shall not be construed as an overt act for the making good of another part; because where all are made equally traiterous, and all are charged as equally traiterous, wee think, with submission, those parts shall not be made an overt act to another Treason.