I answer, that he should take most 1harm that believed there were a Purgatory, if his opinion were wrong and could not be proved by the Scripture (as M. More supposed) for he should sin and transgress against the law of God which saith. Deut. xij. That I command thee that only do unto the Lord, neither add any thing nor diminish. And before in the iiij. chap. of the same book, ye shall not add unto the word that I speak unto you neither shall ye take any thing from it. And again in the v. chapter ye shall not decline neither to the left hand (doing that which is good in your own sight) neither yet unto the right hand, doing that which I manifestly forbid you as though he should say, do that only which I command thee. And where M. More saith that he can not lose the reward of his good will, although his opinion be untrue. I answer yes for it is but chosen holiness which Paul condemn neth. ⟨p. 50⟩Collos. 2. which surely shall rather be imputed unto him for sin then for any good work. And because 2(as I said before) it can not be done through faith. I say that it is utterly reproved of God. And on the other side he that believeth it not, sith it can not be proved by Scripture, can catch no harm at all, although his opinion were false, but rather much good and praise both of God and all good men: because he feareth to swerve from the word of God, and had lever not to be leve that thing which is true (be it in case that purgatory were) and not set forth in Scripture, for so shall he be sure not to sin: then to believe for an article of yt faith that thing which is false in deed, for so should he surely sin and transgress against God and his holy word. And so is there great peril to believe a thing for an article of the faith which is not opened nor spoken of in Scripture: But if I believe it not (although it were true) yet is there no right nor law that can condemn me. Now may you see, that to believe for an article of the faith that there is a Purgatory, sith it can not be proved by Scripture, may condemn a man and make him lye for ever in the pains of hell, where as the other should but a little longer lye in the pains of Purgatory (if there were one) and so shall he be sure to catch most harm that believeth there is a Purgatory.
I aūswere, that he should take most 1harme that beleued there were a Purgatory, if his opiniō were wrong and could not be proued by the Scripture (as M. More supposed) for he should sinne and transgresse agaynst the law of God which sayth. Deut. xij. That I commaunde thée that onely do vnto the Lord, neither adde any thyng nor diminish. And before in the iiij. chap. of the same booke, ye shall not adde vnto the woorde that I speake vnto you neither shall ye take any thyng from it. And agayne in the v. chapter ye shall not decline neither to the left hād (doyng that which is good in your owne sight) neither yet vnto the right hand, doyng that which I manifestly forbyd you as though he should say, doe that onely whiche I commaunde thée. And where M. More sayth that hee can not lese the rewarde of hys good will, although his opinion be vntrue. I aunswere yes for it is but chosen holynesse which Paule condē neth. ⟨p. 50⟩Collos. 2. which surely shall rather be imputed vnto hym for synne then for any good worke. And because 2(as I sayd before) it can not be done through fayth. I say that it is vtterly reproued of God. And on the other side he that beleueth it not, sith it can not be proued by Scripture, cā catch no harme at all, although his opinion were false, but rather much good and prayse both of God and all good men: because he feareth to swerue frō the word of God, and had leuer not to be leue that thyng which is true (be it in case that purgatory were) and not set forth in Scripture, for so shall he be sure not to sinne: then to beleue for an article of yt fayth that thyng which is false in déede, for so should he surely sinne and transgresse agaynst God and his holy woorde. And so is there great perill to beleue a thyng for an article of the fayth whiche is not opened nor spoken of in Scripture: But if I beleue it not (although it were true) yet is there no ryght nor law that can condemne me. Now may you sée, that to beleue for an article of the fayth that there is a Purgatory, sith it can not be proued by Scripture, may condemne a man and make hym lye for euer in the paynes of hell, where as the other shoulde but a litle lenger lye in the paynes of Purgatory (if there were one) and so shal he be sure to catch most harme that beleueth there is a Purgatory.
- 1Frith.
- 2It is better not to believe that which the scripture alloweth not, thē to make a faith where we should not.It is better not to beleue that which the scripture aloweth not, thē to make a fayth where we should not.