A68831:3839
The whole works of W. Tyndall, John Frith, and Doct. Barnes, three worthy martyrs, and principal teachers of this Church of England collected and compiled in one tome together, being before scattered, [and] now in print here exhibited to the Church. To the praise of God, and profit of all good Christian readers.The vvhole workes of W. Tyndall, Iohn Frith, and Doct. Barnes, three worthy martyrs, and principall teachers of this Churche of England collected and compiled in one tome togither, beyng before scattered, [and] now in print here exhibited to the Church. To the prayse of God, and profite of all good Christian readers.
London: printed by John Daye, 1573London: printed by Iohn Daye, 1573
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1. Our Prelates believe that in the Sacrament remaineth no bread, but 1that it is turned into the natural body of Christ both flesh, blood, and bones. Frith saith that it is no article of our Creed: and therefore let 2them believe it that will. And he thinketh that there remaineth bread still, and that he proveth three manner of ways. First by the scripture of Paul, which calleth it bread, saying: the 3bread which we break, is it not the fellowship of the body of Christ? For ⟨p. 165⟩we though we be many, are yet one body and one bread, as many as are partakers of one bread. And again he saith: as often as ye eat of this bread or drink of this cup, you shall 4show the Lords death until he come. Also Luke calleth it bread, saying in the Acts: they continued in the fellowship of the Apostles, and in the 5breaking of the bread & prayer. Also Christ called the cup the fruit of a 6vine, saying: I shall not from hence forward drink of the fruit of the vine, until I drink that new in the kingdom of my father.
1. Our Prelates beléeue that in the Sacrament remaineth no bread, but 1that it is turned into the naturall body of Christ both fleshe, bloud, and bones. Frith sayth that it is no article of our Crede: and therefore let 2them beléeue it that will. And he thinketh that there remayneth bread still, and that he proueth thrée maner of wayes. First by ye scripture of Paule, whiche calleth it bread, saying: the 3bread which we breake, is it not the fellowship of the body of Christ? For ⟨p. 165⟩we though we bee many, are yet one body and one bread, as many as are partakers of one bread. And againe he sayth: as often as ye eate of thys bread or drinke of thys cup, you shall 4shew the Lordes death vntil he come. Also Luke calleth it bread, saying in the Actes: they continued in the fellowship of the Apostles, and in the 5breaking of the bread & prayer. Also Christ called the cup the fruite of a 6vyne, saying: I shall not from hence forward drinke of the fruite of the vyne, vntill I drinke that new in the kingdome of my father.
Furthermore nature doth teach 1you that both the bread and wine continue in their nature. For the bread mouldeth if it be kept long, yea and worms breed in it: and the poor mouse will run away with it and eat it', which are evidence enough that there remaineth bread. Also the wine if it were reserved, would wax sower, as they confess them selves, and therefore they housell the lay people but with one kind only, because the wine can not continue nor be reserved to have ready at hand when need were. And surely as if there remained no bread, it could not mould nor wax full of worms: even so if there remained no wine, it could not wax sower. And therefore it is but false doctrine that our prelates so long have taught and published.
Furthermore nature doth teache 1you that both the bread and wine cō tinue in their nature. For the bread mouldeth if it be kept long, yea and wormes bréede in it: and the poore mouse will runne away with it and eate it', which are euidence inough that there remayneth bread. Also the wine if it were reserued, would waxe sower, as they confesse them selues, and therefore they housell the lay people but with one kinde onely, because the wine can not continue nor be reserued to haue ready at hand when néede were. And surely as if there remayned no bread, it could not mould nor waxe full of wormes: euen so if there remayned no wine, it could not waxe sower. And therefore it is but false doctrine that our prelates so lōg haue taught and published.
Finally yea there remaineth bread, might be proved by the authority of 1many Doctors which call it bread and wine, even as Christ and his Apostles did. And though some sophisters would wrest their saying, and expound them after their own fantasy, yet shall I allege them one Doctor which was Pope, that maketh so plain with us, that they shall never be able to avoid them.
Finally ye there remayneth bread, might be proued by the authoritie of 1many Doctors which call it bread and wine, euen as Christ and hys Apostles did. And though some sophisters would wrest their saying, and expoūd them after their owne phantasie, yet shall I alleage thē one Doctor which was Pope, that maketh so playne with vs, that they shall neuer bee able to auoyde them.
For Pope Gelasius writeth on this manner: Certe sacramenta quae sumimus 1corporis & sanguinis Christi, divinae res sunt, propter quod & per eadem divinae efficimur consortes naturae. Et tamen non desinit esse substantia vel natura panis & vini, sed permanet in suae proproprietate naturae. Et certe imago & similitudo corporis & sanguinis Christi in actione mysteriorum celebrantur. That is to say. Surely the Sacrament of the body and blood of Christ which we receive, are a godly thing, and therefore through them are we made partakers of the godly nature. And yet doth it not cease to be the substance or nature of bread and wine, but they continue in the property of their own nature. And surely the image and similitude of the body and blood are celebrated in the act of the mysteries. This I am sure, that no man can avoid it, nor so wrest it, but that all men shall soon espy his folly, and therefore I may conclude that there remaineth the substance and nature of bread and wine.
For Pope Gelasius writeth on thys maner: Certe sacramenta quae sumimus 1corporis & sanguinis Christi, diuinae res sunt, propter quod & per eadem diuinae efficimur consortes naturae. Et tamen non desinit esse substantia vel natura panis & vini, sed permanet in suae proproprietate naturae. Et certe imago & similitudo corporis & sanguinis Christi in actione mysteriorum celebrantur. That is to say. Surely the Sacrament of the body and bloud of Christ which we receaue, are a godly thing, and therefore through them are we made partakers of the godly nature. And yet doth it not cease to bee the substance or nature of bread and wine, but they continue in the propertie of their owne nature. And surely the image and similitude of the body and bloud are celebrated in the acte of the mysteryes. Thys I am sure, that no man can auoyde it, nor so wrest it, but that all men shall soone espye hys folly, and therefore I may conclude that there remayneth the substaunce and nature of bread and wine.
The Prelates believe that his very flesh is present to the teeth of 1them that eat the sacrament, and that the wicked eat his very body. Frith saith that it is no article of our 2Creed, and therefore he reckoneth that he is in no jeopardy though he believe it not. And he thinketh that his flesh is not present unto the teeth of them that receive the Sacrament. For his flesh is only in one place at once: And that he proveth both by yt authority of S. Austen ad Dardanum, and also by the authority of Fulgentius ad Thrasuvandum lib. 20. as before appeareth in yt book. And Frith saith that the wicked eat not his very flesh, although they receive the sacrament: And that he proveth by the Scripture, Doctors, and good reason grounded upon the scriptures.
THe Prelates beléeue that hys very fleshe is present to the téeth of 1them that eate the sacrament, and that the wicked eate hys very body. Frith sayth that it is no article of our 2Créede, and therefore hée reckoneth that hee is in no ieoperdy though hee beleeue it not. And hee thinketh that his fleshe is not present vnto the téeth of them that receaue the Sacrament. For hys flesh is onely in one place at once: And yt hée proueth both by yt authoritie of S. Austen ad Dardanum, and also by the authoritie of Fulgentius ad Thrasuuandum lib. 20. as before appeareth in yt booke. And Frith sayth that the wicked eate not hys very fleshe, although they receaue the sacrament: And that hée proueth by the Scripture, Doctors, and good reason grounded vpon the scriptures.
The Scripture is this: he that eateth 1Christs body hath everlasting life, but the wicked hath not everlasting life, ergo then the wicked eat not his body. Again the Scripture saith: he that eateth Christs flesh and drinketh his blood, abideth in Christ and Christ in him, but yt wicked abide not in Christ, nor Christ in him, ergo the wicked eat not his ⟨p. 166⟩flesh nor drink his blood.
The Scripture is this: hée that eateth 1Christes body hath euerlasting life, but the wicked hath not euerlasting life, ergo then the wicked eate not his body. Agayne the Scripture sayth: hée that eateth Christes fleshe and drinketh hys bloud, abydeth in Christ and Christ in hym, but yt wicked abyde not in Christ, nor Christ in him, ergo the wicked eate not hys ⟨p. 166⟩fleshe nor drinke hys bloud.
This may also be confirmed by 1good authority. For S. Austen saith: he that abideth not in Christ, and in whom Christ abideth not, without doubt he eateth not his flesh, nor drinketh his blood, although he eat and drink the sacrament of so great a thing unto his damnation.
Thys may also bée confirmed by 1good authoritie. For S. Austen sayth: hée that abydeth not in Christ, and in whom Christ abydeth not, without doubt hée eateth not hys fleshe, nor drinketh hys bloud, although hée eate and drinke the sacrament of so great a thing vnto hys damnation.
Again S. Austen saith: he that abideth not in me, and in whom I abide 1not, let him not say nor think, that he eateth my body or drinketh my blood. And even the same words hath Bede upon the vi. chapter of the first Epistle to the Corinthians. And even the same sentence hath Ambrose, and Prosper, and Bede upon the xi. chapter of the first Epistle to the Corinthians.
Agayne S. Austen sayth: hée that abydeth not in me, and in whom I abyde 1not, let hym not say nor thinke, that hée eateth my body or drinketh my bloud. And euē the same wordes hath Beda vpon the vi. chapter of the first Epistle to the Corinthians. And euen ye same sentēce hath Ambrose, and Prosper, and Beda vpon the xi. chapter of the first Epistle to the Corinthians.
Finally this may be proved by good reason grounded upon the scripture. Christ would not suffer Mary (though she loved him well) to touch him, because she lacked one point of faith, and did not believe that he was equal with his father. And therefore by reason it must follow, that he 1will not suffer the wicked (which neither have good faith nor love towards him) both to touch him and eat him into their unclean bodies.
Finally thys may bée proued by good reason grounded vpon the scripture. Christ would not suffer Mary (though shée loued hym well) to touch hym, because shée lacked one poynt of fayth, and dyd not beléeue that hée was equall with his father. And therfore by reason it must follow, that hée 1will not suffer the wicked (which neither haue good faith nor loue towards hym) both to touch hym and eate him into their vncleane bodyes.
Now sith this is proved true, that the wicked eat not his body, it must also thereof needs follow, that the sacrament is not his natural body. For they do eat the sacrament as all men know. Besides that the faithful do not eat Christs body with their teeth. And therefore it must follow that the wicked do not eat it with their teeth. The antecedent or first part of the reason is proved by the words of Christ, which saith, that the flesh profiteth nothing at all, 1meaning that it doth not profit as they understood him, that is to say, it profiteth nothing to be eaten carnally with their teeth and belly, as they understood him. For else it profiteth much to be eaten spiritually, that is to say, to believe that through his body breaking & blood shedding our sins are purged. And thus doth Origene, S. Austen, Bede, Chrysostom, and Athanasius expound it, as appeareth in the book before. And therefore Frith saith that only faithful 2men eat his body, not with their teeth and mouth, but with their faith and hart, that digest it into the bowels of their souls through believing that it was broken on the cross, to wash away their sins. And the wicked eat not his body but only the bread and their damnation, because they eat him not spiritually, that is, because they believe not in his body breaking and blood shedding.
Now sith thys is proued true, that the wicked eate not hys body, it must also thereof néedes followe, that the sacrament is not hys naturall bodye. For they doe eate the sacrament as all mē know. Besides that the faythfull doe not eate Christes body with their téeth. And therefore it must followe that the wicked doe not eate it with their téeth. The antecedent or first part of the reason is prooued by the wordes of Christ, which sayth, that the flesh profiteth nothyng at all, 1meaning that it doth not profite as they vnderstoode hym, that is to say, it profiteth nothyng to bée eaten carnally with their téeth and belly, as they vnderstoode hym. For els it profiteth much to bée eaten spiritually, that is to say, to beléeue that through hys body breakyng & bloud shedding our sinnes are purged. And thus doth Origene, S. Austen, Beda, Chrysostome, and Athanasius expound it, as appeareth in the booke before. And therfore Frith sayth that onely faythfull
3. The Prelates believe that men ought to worship the sacrament. 1But Frith saith nay, and affirmeth that it is Idolatry to worship it. And he saith that Christ and his Apostles taught us not so to do: neither did the holy fathers so teach us. And Frith saith, that the authors of this 2worshipping are the children of perdition which have overwhelmed this world with sin. Nevertheless we must receive it reverently, because of the doctrine that it bringeth us. For it preacheth Christs death unto us, and describeth it before our eyes, even as a faithful preacher by the word doth instill it into us by our ears and hearing. And that it supplieth the room of a preacher is evident by the words of S. Austen which saith. Paulus quamuis portaret farcinam corporis quod aggravat animā, potuit tamen significando predicare Dominum Jesum Christum, aliter per linguam suam, aliter per epistolam, aliter per sacramentum corporis Christi. That is to fail, though Paul did bear the burden of the body which doth honorate the soul, yet was he able in signifying to preach the lord Jesus Christ, one way by his tongue, and an other way by an epistle, & an other way by the sacrament of Christs body. &c. ⟨p. 167⟩For as the people by understanding the signification of the words which he spake did hear the glorious Gospel of God, and as by the reading of his pistle they understood his mind and received the word of the souls health, so by the ministration of the sacrament they might see with their eye the thing which they heard & read and so have their senses occupied about the mystery, that they might the more earnestly print it in their mind. As by example: The Prophet Jeremiah being in Jerusalem in the time of Sedechias king of the Jews, prophesied 3and preached unto them, that they should be taken prisoners of Nebuchadnezzar the king of Babylon, & the Jews were angry with him and would not believe his words. And therefore be made a chain or fetters of wood and put them about his neck and prophesied again and preached that they should be taken prisoners & led captive into Babylon. And as his words did certify their ears that they should be subdued, so the chain did represent their captivity even before their eye. Which thing did more vehemently work in them then the bare words could do, and even so it is in the Sacrament.
For likewise as the words did instill into our ears, that his body was given for 1us, and his blood shed for the remission of our sins, even so did the ministration of the sacrament express the same thing unto our sight, and doth more effectually move, then the bare words might do and make us more attent unto the thing, that we may wholly give thanks unto God and praise him for his bounteous benefits. And therefore seeing it is a preacher, expressing unto our sight the same thing that the words do to our ears represent you must receive it with reverence & sober behaviour, advertising that thing, that it representeth unto you. And even the same honour is dew unto it which is given unto the scripture that is the word of God. For unto it must a man devoutly give ear and reverently take the book in his hand: yea and if he kiss yt book for the doctrines sake that he learneth thereout, he is to be commended, Nevertheless if he should go sense his book, men might well think that he were very childish. But if he should kneel down and pray to this book then he did commit plain Idolatry Consider dear brethren what I say and avoid this Jeopardy. which thing avoided, I care not as touching the presence of his body, though you believe that his natural flesh be there in deed (and not only in a mystery as I have taught) For when yt Jeopardy is past, he were a fool that would be contentious for a thing as long as there cometh no hurt thereby.
For likewise as the woordes dyd instill into our eares, that his body was geuen for 1vs, and his bloud shed for the remission of our sinnes, euen so did the mynistration of the sacrament expresse ye same thing vnto our sight, and doth more effectuously moue, then the bare wordes might doe and make vs more attent vnto the thing, that we may wholye geue thankes vnto God and prayse him for his bounteous benefites. And therfore seyng it is a preacher, expressing vnto our sight ye same thing that ye wordes doe to our eares represēt you must receyue it with reuerence & sober behauiour, aduertising yt thing, that it representeth vnto you. And euen ye same honour is dew vnto it which is geuen vnto the scripture that is the word of God. For vnto yt must a man deuoutlye geue eare and reuerently take the booke in hys hande: yea and if he kisse yt booke for the doctrines sake that he learenth thereout, he is to bée cōmended, Neuerthelesse if he should goe sence hys booke, men might well thinke that he were very childishe. But if he should knéele downe and pray to this booke then he dyd commyt playne Idolatrye Consider deare bretheren what I say and auoyde this Ieoperdye. which thing auoyded, I care not as touching the presence of his body, though you beléeue that hys naturall flesh be there in déede (and not onely in a misterye as I haue taught) For when yt Ieoperdye is past, he were a foole that would bee contētious for a thing as long as there cōmeth no hurt therbye.
The Germans which believe the presence of his body, do not worship it, but plainly teach the contrary and in that point (thanks be to God) all they whom you call heretics, do agree full well. Only avoid this Idolatry and I desire no more.
The Germanes which beléeue the presence of his body, do not worshyp it, but playnly teach the contrary and in that poynt (thankes be to God) all they whom you call heretickes, do agrée fulwell. Onely auoyde this Idolatry and I desire no more.
3. THe Prelates beléeue that men ought to worship the sacramēt. 1But Frith sayth nay, and affirmeth that it is Idolatry to worship it. And hée sayth that Christ and his Apostles taught vs not so to doe: neither did the holy fathers so teach vs. And Frith sayth, that the authors of thys 2worshipping are the children of perdition which haue ouerwhelmed this world with sinne. Neuerthelesse we must receaue it reuerently, because of the doctrine that it bringeth vs. For it preacheth Christes death vnto vs, and describeth it before our eyes, euen as a faythfull preacher by the worde doth instill it into vs by our eares and hearing. And that it supplyeth the roome of a preacher is euident by the woordes of S. Austen which sayth. Paulus quamuis portaret farcinam corporis quod aggrauat animā, potuit tamen significando predicare Dominum Iesum Christum, aliter per linguam suam, aliter per epistolam, aliter per sacramentum corporis Christi. That is to fay, though Paule did bere the burthen of the body which doth honorate the soule, yet was he able in signifiyng to preach ye lord Iesus Christ, one way by his tonge, and an other way by an epistle, & an other way by the sacrament of Christes body. &c. ⟨p. 167⟩For as the people by vnderstanding the fignification of the wordes which he spake did heare the glorious Gospell of God, and as by the reading of his pistle they vnderstoode his minde and receiued the word of the soules health, so by the ministration of the sacrament they might sée with their eye the thing which they heard & read and so haue their sences occupied about the mistery, that they might the more earnestly print it in their minde. As by example: The Prophet Hieremie being in Hierusalem in the tyme of Sedechias king of the Iewes, prophesyed 3and preached vnto them, yt they should be takē prisoners of Nabugodonesar the king of Babilon, & the Iewes were angry with him and woulde not beléeue his wordes. And therfore be made a chayne or fetters of wood and put them about his neke and prophesied agayne and preached that they should be taken prisoners & led captiue into Babilon. And as his wordes did certifie their eares yt they should be subdued, so the chayne dyd represent their captiuitie euen before their eye. Whiche thyng did more vehemently woorke in them then the bare wordes could doe, and euen so it is in the Sacrament.