Gods eye on His Israel, or, A passage of Balaam, out of Numb. 23,…
Gods eye on His Israel, or, A passage of Balaam, out of Numb. 23, 21 containing matter very seasonable and suitable to the times : expounded and cleared from antinomian abuse, with application to the present estate of things with us / by Tho. Gataker ...
Thomas Gataker 1574–1654London: printed by E. G. for Folk Clifton, 1645London: printed by E. G. for Foulke Clifton, 1645
[36], 99, [1] p. · 49k words · Wing G321 · ESTC R7798
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
First, that this can not be the meaning of the place,1 because it evidently crosseth the main tenor of the story, and the truth of Gods Word. For how could God but see those sins in that people, which so oft he grievously ocomplaineth of, professeth to take pnotice of, and to be highly displeased with, threateneth to avenge, yea not threatened alone so to do, but severely, and that frequently also,qspunished by plagues and judgements of sundry sorts; yea for which he destroyed in the wilderness the main body of that people which he brought out of Egypt,r reserving only their issue, to enter upon, and enjoy the Land promised them, in their stead? Or what reasonable creature can be induced to believe, that all this should by God be done, when he had so hoodwinked and blindfolded himself, that he neither did nor could see that, for which he did all this?t
First, that this can not be the meaning of the place,1 because it evidently crosseth the main tenor of the story, and the truth of Gods Word. For how could God but see those sinnes in that people, which so oft he grievously ocomplaineth of, professeth to take pnotice of, and to be highly displeased with, threatneth to avenge, yea not threatned alone so to do, but severely, and that frequently also,qs
punished by plagues and judgements of sundry sorts; yea for which he destroyed in the wildernesse the main body of that people which he brought out of Egypt,
reserving onely their issue, to enter upon, and enjoy the Land promised them, in their stead? Or what reasonable creature can be induced to beleive, that all this should by God be done, when he had so hoodwinked and blindfolded himself, that he neither did nor could see that, for which he did all this?
1Secondly, that Balaam, who uttered these words unto Balak, did not so understand them, nor was of any such mind. That which appears by the advise that he gave unto Balak. For as the Nobles of Babylon, being well assured that athey should never be able to get any advantage against Daniel, whereby to ensnare him, and bring him into danger, save in something that might concern him in his duty to his God, bsolicited Darius to enact and publish such an edict as might straiten him that way: cso Balaam well wotting, that no advantage could be gotten against that people, whereby the enemy might be enabled to have the better of them, but by making a breach between them and their God; cadvised Balak therefore by the enticements of the daughters of his people to endeavour to induce them to fornication and superstition, to adultery and idolatry, (two sins that are dwont to go hand in hand together) that so the wrath of God being incensed against them, and his protection withdrawn from them, they might either lie eopen to the enemy, or be fdelivered up by God unto them, to be scourged and punished for their sin. But in vain had it been for Balaam to give such counsel to Balak, or for Balak to have practised what Balaam suggested, had God been so affected towards this people, that he could not, or would not see, or take notice of what was done amiss, either in that, or in any other kind, by them, nor would be displeased at all with them for it.
1Secondly, that Balaam, who uttered these words unto Balak, did not so understand them, nor was of any such mind. That which appeares by the advise that he gave unto Balak. For as the Nobles of Babylon, being well assured that athey should never be able to get any advantage against Daniel, whereby to ensnare him, and bring him into danger, save in something that might concern him in his duty to his God, bsolicited Darius to enact and publish such an edict as might straiten him that way: cso Balaam well wotting, that no advantage could be gotten against that people, whereby the enemy might be enabled to have the better of them, but by making a breach between them and their God; cadvised Balak therefore by the enticements of the daughters of his people to endeavour to enduce them to fornication and superstition, to adultery and idolatry, (two sinnes that are dwont to goe hand in hand together) that so the wrath of God being incensed against them, and his protection withdrawn from them, they might either ly eopen to the enemy, or be fdelivered up by God unto them, to be scourged and punished for their sinne. But in vain had it been for Balaam to give such counsell to Balak, or for Balak to have practised what Balaam suggested, had God been so affected towards this people, that he could not, or would not see, or take notice of what was done amisse, either in that, or in any other kind, by them, nor would be displeased at all with them for it.
1Thirdly, that this sense of the words will not stand with other their own principles, but directly crosseth that which themselves otherwhiles aver. For when we object unto them, against this their position, the examples of holy men recorded in Scripture; as of Moses, of whom it is said, that God was gangry, yea very angry with him,h for his flinching and hanging back, when he was to go on Gods errand to Pharaoh; had like to have slain him in his Inn by the way for the neglect of his child's circumcision; was idispleased with him and Aaron for their incredulity and failings in some unadvised carriages; kwith Aaron also for having an hand in the calf; and punished them both with lexclusion from possession and enjoyment of the promised Land: of David, concerning whom it is affirmed, that the thing he did in his folly with Bathsheba, and in the murder of Uriah, was mevil ⟨p. 5⟩in Gods eyes; himself also confessing, that those his sins were committed nin Gods sight, as also that his other sins, such as he had (for some he was ofalsely charged with) were pnot hidden from him; and that God by Nathan sharply qreproved him for the same; threatening withal to rrepay his sin in either kind by the like; which saccordingly also he did: and again that upon the numbering of his people, which tSatan and his own corrupt heart had put him upon, uhis conscience smote him, as having done that, which he knew God would take notice of, and take to heart, as the event showeth that he did; for God not only signified so much to him by xGad, but made him ysmart for it in his people: of Jehoshaphat, whom for his assistance of Ahab, God aby Jehu •s messenger summoned to answer it, and gave him notice of his wrath incensed against him for it; Of Hezekiah, with whom for a vain bostentation of his wealth and state to the Babylonian Ambassadors, he was not a little displeased, and in displeasure, to his no small grief (no doubt) made known unto him, cwhat in after times should become, not of all his treasures only, but of his posterity. When, I say, we object unto them these and the like examples of Gods people, recorded in Gods Book, whose excesses and oversights God beheld, and that also with an angry and wrathful eye; they use to tell us, that these persons were under the cloud, dthey lived in the times of the Old Testament: that it is not now as it was then;
1Thirdly, that this sense of the words will not stand with other their own principles, but directly crosseth that which themselves otherwhiles averre. For when we object unto them, against this their position, the examples of holy men recorded in Scripture; as of Moses, of whom it is said, that God was gangry, yea very angry with him,h for his flinching and hanging back, when he was to go on Gods errand to Pharaoh; had like to have slain him in his Inne by the way for the neglect of his childs circumcision; was idispleased with him and Aaron for their incredulity and failings in some unadvised carriages; kwith Aaron also for having an hand in the calf; and punished them both with lexclusion from possession and enjoyment of the promised Land: of David, concerning whom it is affirmed, that the thing he did in his folly with Bathsheba, and in the murther of Vriah, was mevill ⟨p. 5⟩in Gods eys; himself also confessing, that those his sinnes were committed nin Gods sight, as also that his other sinnes, such as he had (for some he was ofalsly charged with) were pnot hidden from him; and that God by Nathan sharply qreproved him for the same; threatning withall to rrepay his sinne in either kind by the like; which saccordingly also he did: and again that upon the numbring of his people, which
God saw that in them then, which he seeth not in us now: It is true, that in those times God saw sin, and took notice of it, and punished it, even in his own justified ones; but he doth not so now adays. For, not to insist on that, which in way of reply might be returned hereunto, to wit, that the Apostle Paul acknowledgeth no other kind or manner of justification, then that, whereby eAbraham, and fDavid were justified; from whose examples he draweth an argument to prove, men to be in these times gjustified freely by faith, as they also in their times were: as also that the Apostle Peter affirmeth▪ that those that lived in those times were hsaved by the grace, yea the free grace (for ⟨p. 6⟩(i)unless free, it is no (k)Grace) of God in Christ Jesus, as well as we that live in these days. Not to insist, I say, and stay hereupon; but to turn them over to their own tenets; these men herein deal with us in this argument, as the Papists do in some others. For as they to make good, that Priests under the Gospel have a power to hear confessions and remit sins, produce some places out of the Old Testament to prove it; whereas yet they themselves confess that (l)the Priests in those times had no such power: and to confirm invocation and intercession of Saints deceased, they produce likewise some passages (m)out of those Scriptures; when as yet being pressed with the practise of the holy men that then lived, who used no such invokements of any deceased, they are wont to answer, that (n)the Saints in those times deceased could not hear prayers, or be prayed to, because they remained shut up in limbo, and were not gotten yet into heaven. In like manner do these men, To prove that God seeth no sin now in his justified ones, (o)they allege these words of Balaam, spoken of the Israel that then was, as affirming that God saw no sin in them; and other places likewise, where he is said upon their repentance to have (p)hidden all their sins; (as also to the same purpose they (q)produce those passages, where God is said, to have (r)removed their sins as far from them, as the East is from the West; & to have (s)taken them, and cast them into the bottom of the sea:) whereas yet they are enforced by evidence of truth to confess, that (t)in those times God might and did see, take notice of, and punish sin, even in the best that then were;
God saw that in them then, which he seeth not in us now: It is true, that in those times God saw sinne, and took notice of it, and punished it, even in his own justified ones; but he doth not so now adaies. For, not to insist on that, which in way of reply might be returned hereunto, to wit, that the Apostle Paul acknowledgeth no other kind or manner of justification, then that, whereby eAbraham, and fDavid were justified; from whose examples he draweth an argument to prove, men to be in these times gjustified freely by faith, as they also in their times were: as also that the Apostle Peter affirmeth▪ that those that lived in those times were hsaved by the grace, yea the free grace (for ⟨p. 6⟩(i)unlesse free, it is no (k)Grace) of God in Christ Iesus, as well as we that live in these dayes. Not to insist, I say, and stay hereupon; but to turn them over to their own tenents; these men herein deale with us in this argument, as the Papists doe in some others. For as they to make good, that Preists under the Gospel have a power to heare confessions and remit sinnes, produce some places out of the Old Testament to prove it; whereas yet they themselves confesse that (l)the Preists in those times had no such power: and to confirme invocation and intercession of Saints deceased, they produce likewise some passages (m)out of those Scriptures; when as yet being pressed with the practise of the holy men that then lived, who used no such invokements of any deceased, they are wont to answer, that (n)the Saints in those times deceased could not heare prayers, or be prayed to, because they remained shut up in limbo, and were not gotten yet into heaven. In like manner doe these men, To prove that God seeth no sinne now in his justified ones,
(i)Rom. 11.5, 6 Nullo modo est gratia, qe non est omni modo gratuita. Aug. de Pecc. mer. & rem. l· 4. c. 24.
(k)Promissio de remittendis peccatis, ei• qi confientur Deo p•ccata sua, non videtur ulla extare in divinis literis Bellarm. de poenit. l. 2.• 4▪ loc. 4 Locus ille Prov. 28.13. loqitur de confessione, qae fit hominibus, Jdem ibid. c. 11. except. 3. qi & cap 3. eodem trahit illa Lev. 5.5Num. 5.7. sicut & Annot. Duac. in Num.
(l)Nondum data erat sacerdetibus potestas remittendi peccata Bellar. ib. 3.•.3
(m)Job 5.1. Annotat. on Douai Bible. Genes. 48.16. Bellar. de sanct. beatit. l. 1. c. 20. Alfons. de Castr. apud Chamier panstr. l. 20. c. 2. Sect. 10. The triple Cord, • 16.95.
and this cannot therefore be Balaam's meaning in this place, if what themselves hold be true: nor can they allege this place for the proof of what they herein maintain, without crossing and contradicting that which otherwhiles they acknowledge.
and this cannot therefore be Balaams meaning in this place, if what themselves hold be true: nor can they alledge this place for the proofe of what they herein maintaine, without crossing and contradicting that which otherwhiles they acknowledge.
1Fourthly, that this (t)burden lies upon them, who undertake to ground such a point as this upon this place, to prove, that this, ⟨p. 7⟩not only in probability may be, but of necessity must be, the true sense of the words, which they give; for if the words will bear any other sense as well as that which they assign, then cannot the Doctrine, which thence they endeavour to deduce, be raised necessarily from the place.
1Fourthly, that this (t)burden lies upon them, who undertake to ground such a point as this upon this place, to prove, that this, ⟨p. 7⟩not onely in probability may be, but of necessity must be, the true sense of the words, which they give; for if the words will bear any other sense as well as that which they assigne, then cannot the Doctrine, which thence they endeavour to deduce, be raised necessarily from the place.
1Exception 4.
(t)Affirmanti in cumbit onus probandi. Paul. in Digest. l. 22. tit. 3. leg. 2. & Ulp•an. ibid. leg. 24.Affirmanti in cumbit onu• probandi. Paul. in Digest. l. 22. tit. 3. leg. 2. & Vlp•an. ibid. leg. 24.
But that the words of the Text may well admit and bear some other orthodox sense, then this which they strive and contend (all they can) to fasten upon it; and that very aptly also agreeing with the drift and course of the context; shall by Gods assistance be showed in the ensuing discourse.
But that the words of the Text may well admit and bear some other orthodox sense, then this which they strive and contend (all they can) to fasten upon it; and that very aptly also agreeing with the drift and course of the context; shall by Gods assistance be shewed in the ensuing discourse.
Which yet before I come to make manifest in that,1 which is herein principally intended; I shall crave leave to spend some time in considering and discussing the divers versions and expositions, that I find given of the same by others.
And here my purpose is not to make any long stay upon such of them, as depart much, either from the Original, 1or from the Translations with us commonly received, which alone may seem to intimate some such thing as these men, whom at present we deal with, would have them to hold out: Those of this sort may well be referred to two principal heads. 2The former is of the Chaldee Paraphrast, who rendereth the Text thus, He beholdeth no (a) worshippers of Idols in Jacob, nor seeth any (b) workers of falsehood in Israel, and the Vulgar Latin, that giveth it much to the same purpose, (c)There is no Idol in Jacob, nor Image seen in Israel; of which we shall, God willing, say somewhat more hereafter: for as for that of (d)a learned writer, (who would look also that way,) (e)Vanity shall not decline unto Jacob, nor workmanship be seen in Israel; it runs so far wide from the Originals, that it is scarce worth the taking notice of.
And here my purpose is not to make any long stay upon such of them, as depart much, either from the Originall, 1or from the Translations with us commonly received, which alone may seem to intimate some such thing as these men, whom at present we deale with, would have them to hold out: Those of this sort may well be referred to two principal heads. 2The former is of the Chaldie Paraphrast, who rendreth th Text thus, He beholdeth no (a) worshippers of Idols in Jacob, nor seeth any (b) workers of falshood in Israel, and the Vulgar Latine, that giveth it much to the same purpose, (c)There is no Idol in Jacob, nor Jmage seene in Israel; of which we shall, God willing, say somewhat more hereafter: for as for that of (d)a learned writer, (who would look also that way,) (e)Vanity shall not decline unto Iacob, nor workmanship be seene in Israel; it runs so far wide from the Originals, that it is scarce worth the taking notice of.
1Translations and Exposition less common.Translations and Exposition les common.
2Chaldee. [Greek or Hebrew] Latin.Chaldee. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Latine.
(c)Non est Idolum in Jacob, nec videtur simulacrum in Israel.
(d)Aug. Steuchius in Pentateuch.
(e)Non declinabit vanitas ad Jacob. (qod [Greek or Hebrew] potius esset, qam [Greek or Hebrew]) nec videtur opificium in Jsrael. Greek.Non declinabit vanitas ad Iacob. (qod 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 potius esset, qam 〈non-Latin alphabet〉) nec videtur opificium in Jsrael. Greek.
The latter head is of the Greek Interpreters, who thus yield them, (f)No toilsome travel shall be in Jacob, nor pain, or painful labour seen in Israel. Which version both the (g)Greek Interpreters, and the (h)Latin also divers, as well ancient, as modern, either in whole or in part, following; expound ⟨p. 8⟩(i)some of Gods providence over the people of Israel in keeping them from being over-toiled and tired out in their tedious passage through the wilderness; or his (k)powerful assistance in enabling them with ease, to subdue their enemies and surprise their Cities: others (l)of the state and condition of Gods elect in the life to come, wherein there shall be no pain, nor travel; the glorified Saints then (m)being freed from all grievance, and (n)resting wholly from their labours. And true it is that the words here used signify affliction and vexation, as we shall hereafter at large show. But neither do the versions come exactly home to the Original, nor do the interpretations of them suit well with Balaam's intendments; Nor shall we need to be over-solicitous about them; because tho admitted, they would not afford the least colour, for the maintenance of that erroneous conceit, that these men would thence assert. They may serve only to show, that the words have not anciently, or generally been taken, either in such a sense, the latter, or in such a latitude of sense, the former, as is now usually given them.
The latter head is of the Greek Interpreters, who thus yeeld them, (f)No toilsome travell shall be in Iacob, nor paine, or painfull labour seene in Israel. Which version both the (g)Greek Interpreters, and the (h)Latine also divers, as well ancient, as moderne, either in whole or in part, following; expound ⟨p. 8⟩(i)some of Gods providence over the people of Jsrael in keeping them from being over-toiled and tired out in their tedious passage through the wildernesse; or his (k)powerfull assistance in enabling them with ease, to subdue their enemies and surprise their Cities: others (l)of the state and condition of Gods elect in the life to come, wherein there shall be no pain, nor travell; the glorified Saints then (m)being freed from all grievance, and (n)resting wholly from their labours. And true it is that the words here used signifie affliction and vexation, as we shall hereafter at large shew. But neither doe the versions come exactly home to the Originall, nor doe the interpretations of them suit well with Balaams intendements; Nor shal we need to be over-solicitous about them; because tho admitted, they would not afford the least colour, for the maintenance of that erroneous conceit, that these men would thence assert. They may serve onely to shew, that the words have not anciently, or generally been taken, either in such a sense, the latter, or in such a latitude of sense, the former, as is now usually given them.
(f)[Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
(g)Philo▪ in vita Mosis, Origen. in Num. Latin.Philo▪ in vita Mosis, Origen. in Num. Latine.
(h)Non est labor in Jacob, neqe dolour in Israel. Ambr. l. 6▪ Epist. 37. Non erit, &c. Hieron. in Eccles. 3. Hugo Ca•din▪ & alii. Non est labor in Jacob, nec afflictio in Israel, Ferus.Non est labor in Jacob, neqe dolor in Israel. Ambr. l. 6▪ Epist. 37. Non erit, &c. Hieron. in Eccles. 3. Hugo Ca•din▪ & alii. Non est labor in Iacob, nec afflictio in Israel, Ferus.
(i)Hieron. ab Oleastr. Non videre fecit fatigationem in I. & non vidit laberem in I. non permisit eum plus aeqo in itinere laborare, neqe fatigari. Videre pro sentire, pati▪Jer. 20.18. Psal. 89.48. Sed [Greek or Hebrew] est intueri; non sacere ut qis intue aturHieron. ab Oleastr. Non videre fecit fatigationem in I. & non vidit laberem in I. non permisit eum plus aeqo in itinere laborare, neqe fatigari. Videre pro sentire, pati▪Jer. 20.18. Psal. 89.48. Sed 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 est intueri; non sacere ut qis intue atur
1Pass we on therefore to consider of the several interpretations of the words so read as we have them in our English translations, and as before we have in part related.
1Passe we on therefore to consider of the severall interpretations of the words so read as we have them in our English translations, and as before we have in part related.
In the exposition hereof Interpreters (none that I have seen, taking them simply, as they may seem at first reading to sound) distinguish, some of the object or thing seen; some of the act, the sight, or manner of seeing here mentioned.
In the exposition hereof Interpreters (none that I have seene, taking them simply, as they may seeme at first reading to sound) distinguish, some of the object or thing seene; some of the act, the sight, or manner of seeing here mentioned.
his conscience smote him, as having done that, which he knew God would take notice of, and take to heart, as the event sheweth that he did; for God not onely signified so much to him by
ostentation of his wealth and state to the Babylonian Ambassadors, he was not a little displeased, and in displeasure, to his no small grief (no doubt) made known unto him,
what in after times should become, not of all his treasures onely, but of his posterity. When, I say, we object unto them these and the like examples of Gods people, recorded in Gods Book, whose excesses and oversights God beheld, and that also with an angry and wrathfull eye; they use to tell us, that these persons were under the cloud,
they alledge these words of Balaam, spoken of the Israel that then was, as affirming that God saw no sinne in them; and other places likewise, where he is said upon their repentance to have
in those times God might and did see, take notice of, and punish sinne, even in the best that then were;
Job 5.1. Annotat. on Doway Bible. Genes. 48.16. Bellar. de sanct. beatit. l. 1. c. 20. Alfons. de Castr. apud Chamier panstr. l. 20. c. 2. Sect. 10. The triple Cord, • 16.95.
(n)Bellar. de Christ. l. 4. c. 10. & de purgat. l. 2. c. 6. & de Sanct. beat. l. 1. c. 20.
(o)Eaton Honeycomb, c. 3. p. 35, 37. &c. 4. p. 57.Eaton Honycomb, c. 3. p. 35, 37. &c. 4. p. 57.
(t)Honeycomb. c. 6. p. 98, 99.Honycomb. c. 6. p. 98, 99.
Ferus. Promittitur facilis victoria contra hosts. [Greek or Hebrew] Cajetan. qia non erat iniqitas in Jacob; factum est, ut non esset labor in Israel, ad hostes debellandos, & terram eorum possidend•m
Ferus. Promittitur facilis victoria contra hostes. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Cajetan. qia non erat iniqitas in Jacob; factum est, ut non esset labor in Israel, ad hostes debellandos, & terram eorum possidend•m
(l)Origen. in Num. hom. 16. Futurae vitae statum denunciat. Hieron. in Eccl. 3. cum de his nos. Dominus in futuro liberaverit.