A85312:41
Of schism. Parochial congregations in England, and ordination
Of schism. Parochial congregations in England, and ordination by imposition of hands. Wherein Dr. Owen's discovery of the true nature of schism is briefly and friendly examined, together with Mr. Noyes of New England his arguments against imposition of hands in ordination. / By Giles Firmin, sometime of new England, now pastor of the Church at Shalford in Essex.
London: printed by T.C. for Nathanael Webb, 1658
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
I thought by one passage in the Doctor's Pre-view, p. 54. I had mistaken him; for thus he speaks to Mr. C. If he suppose that I deny that to be Schism where there is a separation, and that because there is a separation, as though Schism were in its whole nature exclusive of all separation, and lost its being when separation ensued; he hath taken my mind as rightly as he hath done the whole design of my book. But adds withal, Because this is not proved, I shall desire him not to make use of it for the future, as though it were so. These words I did not observe till I had done.
I thought by one passage in the Doctor's Pre-view, p. 54. I had mistaken him; for thus he speaks to Mr. C. If he suppose that I deny that to be Schism where there is a separation, and that because there is a separation, as though Schism were in its whole nature exclusive of all separation, and lost its being when separation ensued; he hath taken my mind as rightly as he hath done the whole design of my book. But adds withall, Because this is not proved, I shall desire him not to make use of it for the future, as though it were so. These words I did not observe till I had done.
1. If Schism in its whole nature will include causeless separation from a particular Church, and this according to Scripture warrant, then the false plea of an erroneous conscience for causeless separation from a Church, upon pretence of serving God in his Institutions, according to its light, must be Schism whether it ⟨p. 4⟩be called so or not, unless you can tell us how else it is called.
2. Why then doth the Doctor pass by the definition of Schism so generally received? for he knows this is the thing which hath given that great offence, separation from true Churches; and that which must satisfy here must be to prove that all this separation is just and warrantable by Scripture; and if so, I know not who can charge these men with Schism, nor any thing else in so separating: so that there was no need of departing from the definition generally received, and giving a new one, of which I know no use: unless, First, To show there can be no Schism in the Catholic Church: And secondly, To show that Church-Members may be guilty of Schism, though they do not separate into parties, and so show that our Churches are more guilty of Schism then we are aware of, which I believe to be true; but this will bring no honour I doubt to some Congregational Churches. Alas, what Schisms have we known? this is so common a thing that a Divine whom I know, [and so doth the Doctor] once a high Congregational man, suffered much under that name, for whom my principles were not strait enough, [but now he looks on me as erroneous, and too strait, though I am the same I was then] being now turned about, and against all Congregational Churches, saith this of them, they will all break in pieces and come to nothing.