A85312:54
Of schism. Parochial congregations in England, and ordination
Of schism. Parochial congregations in England, and ordination by imposition of hands. Wherein Dr. Owen's discovery of the true nature of schism is briefly and friendly examined, together with Mr. Noyes of New England his arguments against imposition of hands in ordination. / By Giles Firmin, sometime of new England, now pastor of the Church at Shalford in Essex.
London: printed by T.C. for Nathanael Webb, 1658
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
What then the Doctor means by his words to Mr. Ca. I know not; these grounds I have laid down will clear that I am not mistaken in what I gather from him.
I see in his Rev. p. 85. he finds fault with Mr. Ca. because he had said that he delivered himself obscurely. But Mr. Ca. is not the first man whom I have heard complain of obscurity in his book, but divers others; I could set down their expressions, but forbear. In several places I observe things are not clear, and should have taken some things in the same sense Mr. Ca. hath done, for which the Doctor blames him. The Doctor then must pardon us though poor country-Ministers are not so quick of understanding to find out his meaning.
So far then as I understand the Doctor, I am not in divers things satisfied, and in particular not with his definition, which I do not look upon as Logical. For, one rule of Definition is this. Definition-sit angustior, neve latior suo definito, but the Doctors definition is angustior suo definito. Therefore not logical. It is angustior in two respects. 1. It takes not in causeless separation from a Church, which I doubt not may be Schism. 2. It takes not in the Schism in the Catholic Church. The Doctor saith there can be none. Whether there ⟨p. 8⟩can be no Schism from the Catholic Church, is a harder question, it would seem rather to be Apostasy, as saith the Doctor; yet I do almost think we may suppose Schism to be from the Catholic Church. But that there is Schism in the Catholic Church, I doubt not. Now if these two can be made good, then the Doctors definition is not logical. Every definition must exhaurire totam naturam [specificam saltem] sui definiti, else not adequate, nor reciprocal, which must be.
So far then as I understand the Doctor, I am not in divers things satisfied, and in particular not with his definition, which I doe not look upon as Logical. For, one rule of Definition is this. Definitio ne-sit angustior, neve latior suo definito, but the Doctors definition is angustior suo definito. Therefore not logical. It is angustior in two respects. 1. It takes not in causelesse separation from a Church, which I doubt not may be Schism. 2. It takes not in the Schism in the Catholick Church. The Doctor saith there can be none. Whether there