A85312:67
Of schism. Parochial congregations in England, and ordination
Of schism. Parochial congregations in England, and ordination by imposition of hands. Wherein Dr. Owen's discovery of the true nature of schism is briefly and friendly examined, together with Mr. Noyes of New England his arguments against imposition of hands in ordination. / By Giles Firmin, sometime of new England, now pastor of the Church at Shalford in Essex.
London: printed by T.C. for Nathanael Webb, 1658
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
If causeless separation from a Church be a solution of that unity God requireth in his body, then causeless separation from a Church is Schism.
If causelesse separation from a Church be a solution of that unity God requireth in his body, then causelesse separation from a Church is Schism.
But the Antecedent is true: Ergo, the Consequent is true. The Consequence is clear.
2. In case these who made the Division in Corinth had separated from the other members, the Doctor grants it had been a greater sin, Rev. p. 68. Since then we must not call it Schism, let the Doctor give us another Scripture name for that sin; let him set down the opposite affirmative precept, and see if Union will not be found in it. I doubt he will hardly find another Scripture-name, for I think he will hardly find in all the Bible where godly men, or such as appeared so, dared ever to make a causeless separation from a Church. To say it is Apostasy, no stay; I will suppose those members who thus divide, to be persons sound in the main points of faith, in their conversation visibly godly, such as maintain the Ordinances of God amongst themselves [the very case of divers of ours] but corruption and error in this point hath divided Cephas and his company; now here is no Apostasy: And though it be a Church guilty of Schism, and so far a schismatical Church, yet a true Church. Hence I said a causeless separation, &c may ⟨p. 14⟩be Schism, i. e. supposing they hold to what before I mentioned, else it fell from the faith, &c. it had been Apostasy, and not properly Schism, unless you will say both. Hence
2. In case these who made the Division in Corinth had separated from the other members, the Doctor grants it had been a greater sin, Rev. p. 68. Since then we must not call it Schism, let the Doctor give us another Scripture name for that sin; let him set down the opposite affirmative precept, and see if Union will not be found in it. I doubt he will hardly find another Scripture-name, for I think he will hardly find in all the Bible where godly men, or such as appeared so, dared ever to make a causelesse separation from a Church. To say it is Apostacie, no stay; I will suppose those members who thus divide, to be persons sound in the main points of faith, in their conversation visibly godly, such as maintain the Ordinances of God amongst themselves [the very case of divers of ours] but corprution and errour in this point hath divided Cephas and his company; now here is no Apostasie: And though it be a Church guilty of Schism, and so far a schismatical Church, yet a true Church. Hence I said a causelesse separation, &c may