A85314:160
Separation examined
Separation examined: or, a treatise wherein the grounds for separation from the ministry and churches of England are weighed, and found too light. The practise proved to be not only unwarrantable, but likewise so hurtful to the churches, that church-reformation cannot with any comfort go forward, so long as such separation is tolerated. Also an humble request presented to the congregational divines, that since the differences between them and the classical-divines are very small they would please to strike in with the classical-divines in carrying on the work of reformation, before the inundation of these corrupt opinions, have destroyed both ordinances and religion. / By Gi. Firmin minister to the church in Shalford in essex.Separation examined: or, a treatise vvherein the grounds for separation from the ministry and churches of England are weighed, and found too light. The practise proved to be not onely unwarrantable, but likewise so hurtful to the churches, that church-reformation cannot with any comfort go forward, so long as such separation is tolerated. Also an humble request presented to the congregational divines, that since the differences between them and the classical-divines are very small they would please to strike in with the classical-divines in carrying on the worke of reformation, before the inundation of these corrupt opinions, have destroyed both ordinances and religion. / By Gi. Firmin minister to the church in Shalford in essex.
London: printed by R.I. for Stephen Bowtell, 1652
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
6 There is a maxim taken up among the Independents, 1(yea and others) and it goeth for as good Divinity as any the Gospel hath, viz. That errors in Non-fundamentals must be borne withal in Churches, we must labour indeed to convince people of such, but if they will not be so convinced, we must not proceed any further to cast them out. I have heard the New England Ministers sharply censured, because they have excommunicated for some errors, (i.e. denying of some Ordinances) which are supposed to fall within the compass of Non-fundamentals; This maxim is cried up among the Separatists. For the Thesis it self (considering into what a narrow compass Fundamentals are pent up) I think it to be Apocryphal Divinity, and just it is with God to let in errors in Fundamentals, when such Church, and Truth-destructive Principles are drunk in by godly Christians; yet let us bring this rule, and lay it to the case in hand: I hope they do not make rules for themselves, if it be a true Christian Rule, it is for all Christians; Here then we have men qualified by God with Ministerial, and (abundance of them) personal gifts, they have the election or consent of the people, they are separated to the work of the Ministry by persons, who were Ministers, but did erroneously assume too much to themselves, now grant that here is an error, yet I hope it is not in a fundamental point. Some great Divines call Ordination but an Adjunct, and your selves less, you think it a Toy: so then if you must not be separated from a Church for errors in Non-fundamentals, then neither ought you to separate from a true Church for an error, which is not fundamental. Certainly if that rule hath place any where, then here: you will by this rule keep Anabaptists, Anti-Sabbatarians, Antinomians, (truly such) Anti-Psalmists, Arminians, &c. within your Churches, and not cast them out; but (forsooth) a little error (in comparison of them) and that acknowledged, in the Ministers, that is ground sufficient to cast off them, and call them Antichristians, &c. yet there are no conscientious men but these; the Separatists Gospel will afford Rules for them, but not for other Christians.
6 There is a maxime taken up among the Independents, 1(yea and others) and it goeth for as good Divinity as any the Gospel hath, viz. That errours in Non-fundamentals must be borne withall in Churches, we must labour indeed to convince people of such, but if they will not be so convinced, we must not proceed any further to cast them out. I have heard the New England Ministers sharply censured, because they have excommunicated for some errours, (i.e. denying of some Ordinances) which are supposed to fall within the compasse of Non-fundamentals; This maxime is cryed up among the Separatists. For the Thesis it selfe (considering into what a narrow compasse Fundamentals are pent up) I thinke it to be Apocryphall Divinity, and just it is with God to let in errours in Fundamentals, when such Church, and Truthdestructive Principles are drunke in by godly Christians; yet let us bring this rule, and lay it to the case in hand: I hope they doe not make rules for themselves, if it be a true Christian Rule, it is for all Christians; Here then we have men qualified by God with Ministeriall, and (abundance of them) personal gifts, they have the election or consent of the people, they are separated to the worke of the Ministry by persons, who were Ministers, but did erroneously assume too much to themselves, now grant that here is an errour, yet I hope it is not in a fundamentall point. Some great Divines call Ordination but an Adjunct, and your selves lesse, you thinke it a Toy: so then if you must not be separated from a Church for errours in Nonfundamentals, then neither ought you to separate from a true Church for an errour, which is not fundamentall. Certainly if that rule hath place any where, then here: you will by this rule keepe Anabaptists, Anti-Sabbatarians, Antinomians, (truly such) Anti-Psalmists, Arminians, &c. within your Churches, and not cast them out; but (forsooth) a little errour (in comparison of them) and that acknowledged, in the Ministers, that is ground sufficient to cast off them, and call them Antichristians, &c. yet there are no conscientious men but these; the Separatists Gospel will afford Rules for them, but not for other Christians.