Separation Examined.
pp. 1–111539 passagespart 4 of 14
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
So the Pharisees, a Generation that God never instituted, their School ⟨p. 26⟩began, some say, two hundred and forty years, some say more, before Christ, and for their Superstitious inventions they were not barren in them: but did Christ, so soon as he came to Preach call away the people, and bid them separate? here are corrupt Officers, &c. No, we find no such word; nay, he bids then hear, Matth. 23. After Christ, I pray tell me, how long did the Churches continue without Superstitious mixtures, I doubt you will find the Church hath not been long free, but we do not find separation presently, and nulling of Ministers, as now Men should do well to give us a precept, or example out of the Word, where Ordinances have been dispensed true for the substance, though some humane mixtures have been joined to them, that therefore they were iterated. If they cannot give us a direct precept or example, show us it by a necessary consequence from Scripture. I wonder men should be so forward to iterate Baptism, and Ordination, as these Separatists call for, without Scriptural grounds.
So the Pharisees, a Generation that God never instituted, their Schoole ⟨p. 26⟩began, some say, two hundred and forty yeares, some say more, before Christ, and for their Superstitious inventions they were not barren in them: but did Christ, so soon as he came to Preach call away the people, and bid them separate? here are corrupt Officers, &c. No, we finde no such word; nay, he bids then heare, Matth. 23. After Christ, I pray tell me, how long did the Churches continue without Superstitious mixtures, I doubt you will finde the Church hath not been long free, but we doe not finde separation presently, and nulling of Ministers, as now Men should doe well to give us a precept, or example out of the Word, where Ordinances have been dispensed true for the substance, though some humane mixtures have been joyned to them, that therefore they were iterated. If they cannot give us a direct precept or example, shew us it by a necessary consequence from Scripture. I wonder men should be so forward to iterate Baptisme, and Ordination, as these Separatists call for, without Scripturall grounds.
9 There are hundreds of Ministers in England, who were not Ordained by Bishops, but you separate from those also; they had the election of the people first, then with fasting and prayer, solemnly set apart to the work by divers godly and learned Divines, who were against Bishops, yet these are also scorned by your selves, as much as the others; but (forsooth) because they were Ordained by Bishops, and had not renounced their Ordination, and taken their Ordination from you, therefore that infection spreads even to all Generations. Out of what I have said, I may pick up some answers to this, but for troubling the Reader; and the truth is, they are in some sense unreasonable men I deal with; but this let me say, it is strange, that when an Ordinance is purged in it self, and those who administer it, renounce what defects have cleaved to their own Ordination, only for the substance owning it (as another Ordinance may be corrupted, or rather have corruptions annexed to it, but not nulled by those accidental corruptions) that this infection should adhere so strongly, that it cannot be mended, but by nulling of it. Friends, this cavilling will not do in the Day of Judgement. Besides, I pray give me an instance where it was ever practised, that persons, that were not Baptised, did Ordain a Minister? If you ask me, What need that question, for we are Baptised, therefore it doth not concern us? By whom I ⟨p. 27⟩pray? If you say, by the Ministers, then I desire no more; if they were so far Ministers as to administer Baptism to you, then they may well administer Ordination to us; renounce therefore the Baptism you had by them, so I am sure you cannot ordain; and when you are regularly re-baptised, and can warrant your Act, and prove that you have the power to Ordain, then we will listen to you.
9 There are hundreds of Ministers in England, who were not Ordained by Bishops, but you separate from those also; they had the election of the people first, then with fasting and prayer, solemnly set apart to the worke by divers godly and learned Divines, who were against Bishops, yet these are also scorned by your selves, as much as the others; but (forsooth) because they were Ordained by Bishops, and had not renounced their Ordination, and taken their Ordination from you, therefore that infection spreads even to all Generations. Out of what I have said, I may pick up some answers to this, but for troubling the Reader; and the truth is, they are in some sence unreasonable men I deale with; but this let me say, it is strange, that when an Ordinance is purged in it selfe, and those who administer it, renounce what defects have cleaved to their owne Ordination, only for the substance owning it (as another Ordinance may be corrupted, or rather have corruptions annexed to it, but not nulled by those accidentall corruptions) that this infection should adhere so strongly, that it cannot be mended, but by nulling of it. Friends, this cavilling will not doe in the Day of Judgement. Besides, I pray give me an instance where it was ever practised, that persons, that were not Baptised, did Ordaine a Minister? If you aske me, What need that question, for we are Baptised, therefore it doth not concerne us? By whom I
For my own Ordination, it was in the face of my people, the day was spent in fasting, and Prayer, those who carried on the work were Mr. Dan. Rogers, Mr. Marshall, Mr. Ranew, with other godly Ministers, who joined with them in the imposing of hands (the Ministers lived about me) I never saw that Ordinance carried on with more solemnity in my life, the people showed their election by suffrage, holding up their hands; all was done according to the Pattern; but yet I am a man as much scorned as other men, who were Ordained by Bishops. (I can submit to God in that scorn that these cast upon me, for I deserve it at his hands;) only there was a foul error committed at my Ordination, and it is told up and down by some of this kind, against whom I write, and I pray what is it? This, The Ministers imposed hands in my Ordination; this hath been talked of as a strange thing; but let me answer for the Ministers, it was no error, much less such a great one as you make it.
For my owne Ordination, it was in the face of my people, the day was spent in fasting, and Prayer, those who carried on the worke were Mr. Dan. Rogers, Mr. Marshall, Mr. Ranew, with other godly Ministers, who joyned with them in the imposing of hands (the Ministers lived about me) I never saw that Ordinance carried on with more solemnity in my life, the people shewed their election by suffrage, holding up their hands; all was done according to the Pattern; but yet I am a man as much scorned as other men, who were Ordained by Bishops. (I can submit to God in that scorne that these cast upon me, for I deserve it at his hands;) only there was a foule errour committed at my Ordination, and it is told up and downe by some of this kinde, against whom I write, and I pray what is it? This, The Ministers imposed hands in my Ordination; this hath been talked of as a strange thing; but let me answer for the Ministers, it was no errour, much lesse such a great one as you make it.
1 If private men, Carpenters and Tailors may impose hands, why may not Ministers? but the former have done it. Ergo.
1 If private men, Carpenters and Taylors may impose hands, why may not Ministers? but the former have done it. Ergo.
2 All the Ordinations that ever I saw in New England were performed with imposition of hands; I have seen Deacons ordained thus.
2 All the Ordinations that ever I saw in New England were performed with imposition of hands; I have seene Deacons ordained thus.
3 If you be wiser then the Elders in New England, 1and Master Hooker, then over-throw them, for they conceive it nearest to the institution.
- 1Answ. to the 32. que. p. 67. Survey of Church Dise. p. 2. p. 74.
4 If you observe the examples in the New Testament, which are our Guides in Church affairs, we shall find Ordinations have been thus performed; as Acts 6.6. Act. 13.3. 1 Tim. 4.14. 1 Tim. 5.22. Heb. 6.2. Laying on of hands; Which place, by Classical men, Congregational men, and Separatists, is interpreted of Ordination. I do not here bring in the practise of Churches in former times, because I intend not to handle the controversy, Whether imposition of hands be necessarily required in ordination? ⟨p. 28⟩but bring you in as many examples from Scripture, where there were Ministers Ordained without imposition of hands; as also the practise of other true Churches Orthodox and sound, who do Ordain without, &c. or else be ashamed of your ignorance, and charge not those men with error where none was, but a true following the pattern.
4 If you observe the examples in the New Testament, which are our Guides in Church affaires, we shall finde Ordinations have been thus performed; as Acts 6.6. Act. 13.3. 1 Tim. 4.14. 1 Tim. 5.22. Heb. 6.2. Laying on of hands; Which place, by Classicall men, Congregationall men, and Separatists, is interpreted of Ordination. I doe not here bring in the practise of Churches in former times, because I intend not to handle the controversie, Whether imposition of hands be necessarily required in ordination? ⟨p. 28⟩
The substance and essence then of Ordination being this, That persons qualified Ministerially be set apart, or separated for the work of the Ministry by persons in Office [ordinarily it must be thus, what may be done extraordinarily, when no Officers can be had is another case] the Ministers in England have that Ordinance for the substance, and they have the election and consent of the people, (it is hardly to be supposed that every individual person in a Parish will consent to every godly Minister, but consent there is) hence these two concurring to the Call, which is the form of a Minister, many Presbyterial Ministers are true Ministers. I dare say more, but I am sure now I save my self. But I have not done with Ordination yet, I shall meet with it once again afterwards. Let us now come and try the second ground for separation, scil. The Worship of God; the fault here must be reduced to one of these three heads; either;
The substance and essence then of Ordination being this, That persons qualified Ministerially be set apart, or separated for the worke of the Ministry by persons in Office [ordinarily it must be thus, what may be done extraordinarily, when no Officers can be had is another case] the Ministers in England have that Ordinance for the substance, and they have the election and consent of the people, (it is hardly to be supposed that every individuall person in a Parish will consent to every godly Minister, but consent there is) hence these two concurring to the Call, which is the forme of a Minister, many Presbyteriall Ministers are true Ministers. I dare say more, but I am sure now I save my selfe. But I have not done with Ordination yet, I shall meet with it once againe afterwards. Let us now come and try the second ground for separation, scil. The Worship of God; the fault here must be reduced to one of these three heads; either;
1 Because they cannot enjoy all the Ordinances of God in these Churches. Or,
2 Because the Ordinances of God are mixed with humane inventions, that they cannot partake of them without sin. Or,
2 Because the Ordinances of God are mixed with humane inventions, that they cannot partake of them without sinne. Or,
3 Because here are other Ordinances set up in the Churches then ever Christ did institute. I cannot conceive any more.
For the first; Suppose it were so, that there were a defect of some Ordinances, is that a sufficient ground for separation? Mr. Hooker saith no. If a Father of a Family wants a Rod in his house, 1is it ergo no family? there may be some disorder in the house for want of good Government, yet a family. Divers Divines of great note conceive by that text, Nehem. 8.17, 18. That the Church of the Jews did omit the celebration of the Feast of Tabernacles almost the space of a thousand years, the Ark was absent from the Tabernacle from the time of Eli, to the time of David, 1 Sam. 4.11. compared with, 2 Sam. 6, 17. and it was a great fault; the Scribes rejected the Baptism of John, ⟨p. 29⟩but where do you find any separation all this while, that the godly should not join with that Church, and partake in what Ordinances they had? But this objection hath no place in these Churches, for Prayer, Preaching, Administration of the Sacraments, yea, Discipline they had in the Episcopal days, they did suspend from the Lords Supper, and the Bishops gave the Ministers power, but suspension is the lesser Excommunication, and now to be sure there are none wanting (at least should not be,) if the Ministers were not hindered in setting up all the Ordinances.
For the first; Suppose it were so, that there were a defect of some Ordinances, is that a sufficient ground for separation? Mr. Hooker saith no. If a Father of a Family wants a Rod in his house, 1is it ergo no family? there may be some disorder in the house for want of good Government, yet a family. Divers Divines of great note conceive by that text, Nehem. 8.17, 18. That the Church of the Jewes did omit the celebration of the Feast of Tabernacles almost the space of a thousand yeares, the Arke was absent from the Tabernacle from the time of Eli, to the time of David,
Obj. No, say you, the Classical Churches have no explicit Covenant for the form of them, they will not admit it into their Churches, therefore we separate.
Obj. No, say you, the Classicall Churches have no explicite Covenant for the forme of them, they will not admit it into their Churches, therefore we separate.
I shall meet with this in another place, only for the present disprove what Mr. Hooker hath said, and the former examples I have given you; but yet you will have a hard piece of work, to prove this to be a sufficient ground for your separation, as afterwards I hope I shall make good.
I shal meet with this in another place, only for the present disprove what Mr. Hooker hath said, and the former examples I have given you; but yet you will have a hard peece of work, to prove this to be a sufficient ground for your separation, as afterwards I hope I shall make good.
For the second, Humane mixtures in Ordinances.
This indeed was the ground of the old Separatists, yet in those days many holy and learned Divines wrote against the Separation; but in these days that stumbling block is removed; and this let me say, that if you read over all the Church-stories, since there was a Church upon the earth, there cannot be found any example of such separatists, as are now amongst us; the old Donatists had their Ministers, yea, Bishops as well as Presbyters; the separate Churches of later days had their Ministers, and how strictly did they maintain and practise all those Ordinances, which ours laugh at, as singing of Psalms, Infant-Baptism, observation of the Sabbath, and such opinions as those learned and godly men, Mr. Ainsworth, Robinson, Johnson, did abhor, are swallowed down among ours; so that these men cannot ground their practice from any example heretofore; and as for the Scripture, if they can find any grounds there, I must confess I am altogether ignorant in the Scripture.
This indeed was the ground of the old Separatists, yet in those dayes many holy and learned Divines wrote against the Separation; but in these dayes that stumbling blocke is removed; and this let me say, that if you read over all the Church-stories, since there was a Church upon the earth, there cannot be found any example of such separatists, as are now amongst us; the old Donatists had their Ministers, yea, Bishops as well as Presbyters; the separate Churches of later dayes had their Ministers, and how strictly did they maintaine and practise all those Ordinances, which ours laugh at, as singing of Psalmes, Infant-Baptism, observation of the Sabbath, and such opinions as those learned and godly men, Mr. Ainsworth, Robinson, Johnson, did abhorre, are swallowed downe among ours; so that these men cannot ground their practice from any example heretofore; and as for the Scripture, if they can finde any grounds there, I must confesse I am altogether ignorant in the Scripture.
Suppose there should be some human mixtures (though for my part I know of none) are all the Ordinances so polluted: preaching and prayer were kept pure in the Episcopal days; why do you not communicate with them in those Ordinances, which are pure?
Suppose there should be some human mixtures (though for my part I know of none) are all the Ordinances so polluted: preaching and prayer were kept pure in the Episcopall dayes; why doe you not communicate with them in those Ordinances, which are pure?
If you object, The Ordinances indeed are pure, but those who join in those Ordinances are not pure, therefore we separate.
If you object, The Ordinances indeed are pure, but those who joyne in those Ordinances are not pure, therefore we separate.
This properly belongs to the third head (the Congregation) I shall there answer to this Cavil.
This properly belongs to the third head (the Congregation) I shall there answer to this Cavill.
Thirdly, for the setting up such Ordinances as Christ never did, I cannot imagine where you will be, unless you mean Infant-baptism, and singing of Psalms, for I find these are spoken against very much. But are these fundamental errors, if they be errors, have you been forced to baptise your Infants, or sing Psalms? are you not at your choice whether you will or not? do not many people sit in Congregations, and not sing at all? not but that I conceive Church-members ought to be regarded in this, and called to an account, though they had need be handled tenderly, if otherwise they seem to be godly, yet their being hopefully godly, is not a sufficient ground to keep them from Church-censures, unless all circumstances being considered they appear to be truly conscientious, men of humble spirits, not self-willed, and desiring forbearance and patience in clearing of the point, then I know Ministers would bear with such a long time; but to have persons run into these errors, and let alone, as if they were things of no concernment; truly by what rules you will loose two Ordinances, you may loose four; Official preaching is cried down, and Church Discipline also, by the Erastians, no outward form of Government, which I suppose was the scope of Mr. Dells Sermon before the Parliament; and so I think it is that which Rob. Purnell in his short Prophecy of the down-fall of Presbytery and Independency aims at, that there should be no external form of Church-Government, but only the government of the spirit within; and for all Ordinances, some are above them, who have been Members of Congregational Churches, insomuch that when the Brethren came to choose an Officer, a Mason rose up and opposed it, professing he lived immediately upon Christ, and he owned none; neither was he alone I believe: but if you take away all the Ordinances, how we shall know there is a God in the world, I know not; to be sure, we shall not know by the dealings of these men: I know so much by them, that one had as good deal with the Indians as with some of them, so that in conclusion we shall have brave Churches without ordinances.
Thirdly, for the setting up such Ordinances as Christ never did, I cannot imagine where you will be, unlesse you meane Infant-baptisme, and singing of Psalmes, for I finde these are spoken against very much. But are these fundamental errors, if they bee errours, have you beene forced to baptise your Infants, or sing Psalmes? are you not at your choice whether you will or not? do not many people sit in Congregations, and not sing at all? not but that I conceive Church-members ought to be regarded in this, and called to an account, though they had need be handled tenderly, if otherwise they seeme to be godly, yet their being hopefully godly, is not a sufficient ground to keep them from Church-censures, unlesse all circumstances being confidered they appeare to be truly conscientious, men of humble spirits, not selfe-willed, and desiring forbearance and patience in clearing of the point, then I know Ministers would beare with such a long time; but to have persons runne into these errours, and let alone, as if they were things of no concernment; truly by what rules you will loose two Ordinances, you may loose foure; Officiall preaching is cryed downe, and Church Discipline also, by the Erastians, no outward forme of Government, which I suppose was the scope of Mr. Dells Sermon before the Parliament; and so I thinke it is that which Rob. Purnell in his short Prophesie of the down-fall of Presbytery and Independency aimes at, that there should be no externall forme of Church-Government, but only the government of the spirit within; and for all Ordinances, some are above them, who have been Members of Congregationall Churches, insomuch that when the Brethren came to chuse an Officer, a Mason rose up and opposed it, professing he lived immediatly upon Christ, and he owned none; neither was he alone I beleeve: but if you take away all the Ordinances, how we shall know there is a God in the world, I know not; to be sure, we shall not know by the dealings of these men: I know so much by them, that one had as good deale with the Indians as with some of them, so that in conclusion we shall have brave Churches without ordinances.
As for Infant-baptism, this is not a place for me to prove it to be an Ordinance of God; what the Adversaries can say is summed up in Mr. Tombs, a man, I hear, esteemed truly godly on all hands, and for his Learning he shows himself to be a Scholar, it is pity the mans parts were defiled in maintaining such a wretched opinion, as Mr. Hooker calls it. I confess, Master Tombs's abilities are such, that I may hold the Candle to him, but yet let me say this, I can easily discern Mr. Tombs to dispute more like a Sophister, then a Christian, that did desire to see truth. Mr. Marshall tells him, and not without cause, 1Your faculty is far better in darkening, slurring, and plundering the Arguments of your Adversary, then in making good your own. It is the happiness Mr. Marshall hath above many, that in his preaching, and so in printing, he can convey his mind to his Hearer, or Reader so, as the weakest may understand; how then his Arguments come to be so dark, to so learned a man, as Mr. Tombs, I cannot conceive, if he had dealt candidly; but when Master Tombs hath answered Mr. Marshall, Cotton, Baxter, Cobbet, Hooker, Holmes, Geree, &c. then we shall bethink our selves of new Arguments, but these Worthies have maintained that Ordinance with that strength, that I believe the contrary opinion will rarely, or never take with an intelligent head, and a sober, godly heart.
As for Infant-baptisme, this is not a place for me to prove it to be an Ordinance of God; what the Adversaries can say is summed up in Mr. Tombes, a man, I heare, esteemed truly godly on all hands, and for his Learning he shewes himselfe to be a Schollar, it is pitty the mans parts were defiled in maintaining such a wretched opinion, as Mr. Hooker calls it. I confesse, Master Tombes's abilities are such, that I may hold the Candle to him, but yet let me say this, I can easily discerne Mr. Tombes to dispute more like a Sophister, then a Christian, that did desire to see truth. Mr. Marshall tells him, and not without cause, 1Your faculty is farre better in darkening, slurring, and plundering the Arguments of your Adversarie, then in making good your owne. It is the happinesse Mr. Marshall hath above many, that in his preaching, and so in printing, he can convey his minde to his Hearer, or Reader so, as the weakest may understand; how then his Arguments come to be so darke, to so learned a man, as Mr. Tombes, I cannot conceive, if he had dealt candidly; but when Master Tombes hath answered Mr. Marshall, Cotton, Baxter, Cobbet, Hooker, Holmes, Geree, &c. then we shall bethinke our selves of new Arguments, but these Worthies have maintained that Ordinance with that strength, that I beleeve the contrary opinion will rarely, or never take with an intelligent head, and a sober, godly heart.
For singing of Psalms, this is not a place neither to follow that Question: whether it be an Ordinance of God, I never heard of any that writ against it, except one, whom Mr. Cotton hath answered, and I think sufficiently enough. When Master Cotton is silenced, then we shall bethink our selves concerning that Ordinance: I hear of others that have printed for it, but Master Cottons piece is all I have seen concerning that subject, Pro or con.
For singing of Psalmes, this is not a place neither to follow that Question: whether it be an Ordinance of God, I never heard of any that writ against it, except one, whom Mr. Cotton hath answered, and I thinke sufficiently enough. When Master Cotton is silenced, then we shall bethinke our selves concerning that Ordinance: I heare of others that have printed for it, but Master Cottons peece is all I have seene concerning that subject, Pro or con.
Only because there was a Sectary, 1that in a Shop scoffingly asked me, To what purpose singing of Psalms was? the mans spirit I saw very unsavoury, and the place not convenient to discourse; I gave him no answer, but shall now give him the grounds that lead me to believe it is an Ordinance of Christ, and let him confute them. I cannot avoid it, but I must touch divers things that have been touched before, but what I do, shall be very brief.
Only because there was a Sectary, 1that in a Shop scoffingly asked me, To what purpose singing of Psalmes was? the mans spirit I saw very unsavoury, and the place not convenient to discourse; I gave him no answer, but shall now give him the grounds that lead me to beleeve it is an Ordinance of Christ, and let him confute them. I cannot avoyd it, but I must touch divers things that have been touched before, but what I doe, shall be very briefe.
- 1In Colchester.
1. If singing of Psalms were an Ordinance under the Old ⟨p. 32⟩Testament, and not repealed in the New Testament [being not Typical, or Ceremonial, &c.] then it is also an Ordinance under the New Testament.
1. If singing of Psalmes were an Ordinance under the Old ⟨p. 32⟩Testament, and not repealed in the New Testament [being not Typicall, or Ceremoniall, &c.] then it is also an Ordinance under the New Testament.
But the Antecedent is true, ergo the Consequent is true.
For the Antecedent, that it was an ordinance then, the Adversaries deny not, and as other ordinances, which then were in use, and not repealed (as Prayer, Preaching, &c.) are ordinances now under the New Testament, why should not singing of Psalms also be continued an ordinance still?
For the Antecedent, that it was an ordinance then, the Adversaries deny not, and as other ordinances, which then were in use, and not repealed (as Prayer, Preaching, &c.) are ordinances now under the New Testament, why should not singing of Psalmes also be continued an ordinance still?
They object, Singing of Psalms with the voice, is but a type of singing Psalms with the heart.
They object, Singing of Psalmes with the voyce, is but a type of singing Psalmes with the heart.
I answer; If indeed it were typical, then it were some ground to believe it was repealed; we read your Dictates, but we read no proofs, give us your texts to prove it was typical, else your Dictates will not take with us; That which makes me strongly to believe the contrary is this, That Paul, and Silas, when none but they were in the Prison, yet they sang, Act. 16.25. now this was ill done of them, if it were Typical, yet to keep it in practise, when they were alone, however in other points and Ceremonies the Apostles did condescend as far as they could to the Jews, 1giving the Ceremonies (being now dead) as Augustine saith, an honourable burial, yet that Paul and Silas being now alone without Jews, having no such temptation, but may keep their liberty, should practise a Typical ordinance, believe it who will, for I cannot. When I had framed my answer, looking into Mr. Cotton, I perceived that he mentions this of their singing in answer to this Cavil, 2and giveth more answers, whither I refer the Reader.
I answer; If indeed it were typicall, then it were some ground to beleeve it was repealed; we read your Dictates, but we read no proofes, give us your texts to prove it was typicall, else your Dictates will not take with us; That which makes me strongly to beleeve the contrary is this, That Paul, and Silas, when none but they were in the Prison, yet they sang, Act. 16.25. now this was ill done of them, if it were Typicall, yet to keep it in practise, when they were alone, however in other points and Ceremonies the Apostles did condescend as farre as they could to the Jewes, 1giving the Ceremonies (being now dead) as Augustine saith, an honourable buriall, yet that Paul and Silas being now alone without Jewes, having no such temptation, but may keep their liberty, should practise a Typicall ordinance, beleeve it who will, for I cannot. When I had framed my answer, looking into Mr. Cotton, I perceived that he mentions this of their singing in answer to this Cavill, 2and giveth more answers, whither I referre the Reader.
2 The second ground that moves me is the express Scripture, Ephes. 5.19. & Col. 3.16. speaking one to another in Psalms, [Greek or Hebrew] i.e. [Greek or Hebrew] saith Beza, as the word is used, Ephes. 4. ult. [Greek or Hebrew] forgiving one another; so in Col. 3. [Greek or Hebrew] our Translation there renders it, one another: Loquentes inter vos mutuò, Beza, so Piscator, so Zanchy: When drunkards are full of wine, then they begin to sing their Songs, saith he; so Christians filled with this wine, have these Spiritual Songs, Psalms, &c. to sing; for the difference between these, see our English Annotations, or Hiero. in Loc.
2 The second ground that moves me is the expresse Scripture, Ephes. 5.19. & Col. 3.16. speaking one to another in Psalmes, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 i.e. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 saith Beza, as the word is used, Ephes. 4. ult. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 forgiving one another; so in Col. 3. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 our Transtation there renders it, one another: Loquentes inter vos mutuò, Beza, so Piscator, so Zanchy: When drunkards are full of wine, then they begin to sing their Songs, saith he; so Christians filled with this wine, have these Spirituall Songs, Psalmes, &c. to sing; for the difference between these, see our English Annotations, or Hiero. in Loc.
Several Objections are here made, which I shall not study to answer, only in a word.
Severall Objections are here made, which I shall not study to answer, only in a word.
1 They say, The text doth not say, sing one to another, but speak one to another; the Psalms dwelling in their hearts, they were to dispense them in way of teaching; but as for singing, he maketh no mention of that until he came to teach them, the manner of dispensing the Word of Christ [a dark expression] unto God in the end of the verse, and that is making melody in the heart.
1 They say, The text doth not say, sing one to another, but speake one to another; the Psalmes dwelling in their hearts, they were to dispense them in way of teaching; but as for singing, he maketh no mention of that untill he came to teach them, the manner of dispensing the Word of Christ [a darke expression] unto God in the end of the verse, and that is making melody in the heart.
Master Cotton answers with a grave reproof; That men should rather bow their judgements and practises to Scripture Language, then bow the sense of the Scripture to their own conceptions against the Language of the Scripture; for saith he, it is one thing to speak one to another in Psalms, and Hymns, and spiritual Songs, as is done in singing, and another thing to teach one another out of Psalms, &c. It is true, they were to teach one another out of the Psalms, and the scope of Paul will reach that; but if he had meant only so, he would not have said, Speak ye one to another, In Psalms, but Out of the Psalms, as is the Scripture phrase, &c.
Master Cotton answers with a grave reproofe; That men should rather bow their judgements and practises to Scripture Language, then bow the sence of the Scripture to their owne conceptions against the Language of the Scripture; for saith he, it is one thing to speake one to another in Psalmes, and Hymnes, and spirituall Songs, as is done in singing, and another thing to teach one another out of Psalms, &c. It is true, they were to teach one another out of the Psalmes, and the scope of Paul will reach that; but if he had meant only so, he would not have said, Speake yee one to another, In Psalmes, but Out of the Psalmes, as is the Scripture phrase, &c.
2 To me it seemeth strange, if that were all Pauls meaning, why should Paul mention only those parts of the Word which use to be sung? Why doth he not mention the Prophets, Isaiah, &c. as also the New Testament, to teach one another out of them? Are there not as excellent Truths, gracious Promises, to be found in those Prophets, and worthy for Christians to be instructed in, as in the Psalms, or other Songs that we find of Moses, Deborah, &c? but for Isaiah, Jeremiah, and all those Prophets, besides other parts of the Old and New Testament, they were never wont to be sung in the Church, but only these which Paul mentions in both places, not adding any portion of Scripture more in the Epist. to the Colossians, then to the Ephesians, therefore I cannot believe that should be the meaning, as the Objector saith.
2 To me it seemeth strange, if that were all Pauls meaning, why should Paul mention only those parts of the Word which use to be sung? Why doth he not mention the Prophets, Isaiah, &c. as also the New Testament, to teach one another out of them? Are there not as excellent Truths, gracious Promises, to be found in those Prophets, and worthy for Christians to be instructed in, as in the Psalmes, or other Songs that we finde of Moses, Deborah, &c? but for Isaiah, Jeremiah, and all those Prophets, besides other parts of the Old and New Testament, they were never wont to be sung in the Church, but only these which Paul mentions in both places, not adding any portion of Scripture more in the Epist. to the Colossians, then to the Ephesians, therefore I cannot beleeve that should be the meaning, as the Objector saith.
3 The Apostle mentions singing we see presently, now if any thing can be made out of what the Objector saith, it may possibly be this; That Paul would have them teach one another the sense and scope of a Psalm, that all may understand the meaning of the Psalm they sing [as is the practise of some Ministers, if they be to sing a Psalm that is more dark, then in a few words they give the people to understand the meaning of the Psalm they sing] and so sing with understanding, 1 Cor. 14, 15. I say, Why may not this be something of the meaning? I leave ⟨p. 34⟩it to more able heads to judge. But this doth not exclude singing
3 The Apostle mentions singing we see presently, now if any thing can be made out of what the Objector saith, it may possibly be this; That Paul would have them teach one another the sence and scope of a Psalme, that all may understand the meaning of the Psalme they sing [as is the practise of some Ministers, if they be to sing a Psalme that is more darke, then in a few words they give the people to understand the meaning of the Psalme they sing] and so sing with understanding, 1 Cor. 14, 15. I say, Why may not this be something of the meaning? I leave ⟨p. 34⟩it to more able heads to judge. But this doth not exclude singing
But whereas he conceives singing should be only the making melody in the heart, 1I pray let him hear what an old Commentator said long ago, upon the words; We read no where that any one sung without a voice, wherefore it is necessary that in the Heart here, he understood from the Heart. viz. That we sing not only with the mouth, but with the heart, So Beza, In your heart, i. e. Serio cordis affectu, non autem linguâ duntaxat, neque enim in corde idem hic declarat atque intus & apud se, cum mentio fiat canendi in caetu. So other Divines, as Calvin, Zanchy, &c. whom I forbear to name.
But whereas he conceives singing should be only the making melody in the heart, 1I pray let him heare what an old Commentator said long agoe, upon the words; We read no where that any one sung without a voyce, wherefore it is necessary that in the Heart here, he understood from the Heart. viz. That we sing not only with the mouth, but with the heart, So Beza, In your heart, i. e. Serio cordis affectu, non autem linguâ duntaxat, neque enim in corde idem hic declarat atque intus & apud se, cum mentio fiat canendi in caetu. So other Divines, as Calvin, Zanchy, &c. whom I forbeare to name.
- 1Hieron, in Colos. 3. Nusquam legimus aliquem sine voce cantasse, unde necesse est hic, in corde, ex corde, intelligi, &c.
The same text also affords a good ground for singing Davids Psalms, with other spiritual Songs recorded in Scripture; or else I desire them to give me a reason, why Paul should direct us to the very Titles of Davids Psalms, and yet not mean Davids Psalms, any one that hath the least taste of the Hebrew Language knows this. Some of them are called [Greek or Hebrew] Psalms, the word [Greek or Hebrew] is used about forty times in Davids Psalms, I do not stand upon the exact number. [Greek or Hebrew] Hymns, the Book of Davids Psalms is named by this word [Greek or Hebrew] so [Greek or Hebrew] Spiritual Songs, 1this is frequent in Davids Psalms; also Deborah useth this word, Judg. 5.12. so now it seems strange that Paul should point us to these, and yet we must not sing them, which were sung before.
The same text also affords a good ground for singing Davids Psalmes, with other spirituall Songs recorded in Scripture; or else I desire them to give me a reason, why Paul should direct us to the very Titles of Davids Psalmes, and yet not meane Davids Psalmes, any one that hath the least taste of the Hebrew Language knowes this. Some of them are called 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Psalms, the word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 is used about forty times in Davids Psalmes, I doe not stand upon the exact number. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Hymnes, the Book of Davids Psalmes is named by this word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 so 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Spirituall Songs, 1this is frequent in Davids Psalms; also Deborah useth this word, Judg. 5.12. so now it seemes strange that Paul should point us to these, and yet we must not sing them, which were sung before.
The third ground that moves me, is the example I find in the New Testament, of Christ himself, with his Apostles, Matth. 26.30. they sung a Hymn; he did not sing it between the Passover and the institution of the Supper, as being a Typical thing, and so let it be joined to the Passover, as the Jews did; but after he had instituted that Ordinance, which must last to the end of the world, and they received the Bread and Wine, then he and they sung, as some conceive six Psalms, 1beginning at 112. to 117. whence it is the practise of Churches, following the pattern, to sing after the receiving of the Supper.
The third ground that moves me, is the example I finde in the New Testament, of Christ himselfe, with his Apostles, Matth. 26.30. they sung a Hymne; he did not sing it between the Passeover and the institution of the Supper, as being a Typicall thing, and so let it be joyned to the Passeover, as the Jewes did; but after he had instituted that Ordinance, which must last to the end of the world, and they received the Bread and Wine, then he and they sung, as some conceive six Psalmes, 1beginning at 112. to 117. whence it is the practise of Churches, following the patterne, to sing after the receiving of the Supper.
- 1Beza in Loc.
So the example of Paul and Silas, Act. 16, 25. [Greek or Hebrew] Hymnos canebant Deo, saith Beza, or Hymnis laudabant Deum, Piscator, and Pasor, they praised God with Hymns; that which some object, the text saith, they sang praises, not Psalms; this is very poor, besides the original word, how should one sing praises to God but in some Psalm, spiritual Sons, &c. for Praise, if ⟨p. 35⟩you take it properly as distinct from honour and glory, is but the honourable making mention of another, and that externally by tongue or pen; also that text, Heb. 13.15. by him therefore let us offer the sacrifice of praise to God continually, that is, the fruit of our lips, &c. intimates as much.
So the example of Paul and Silas, Act. 16, 25. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Hymnos canebant Deo, saith Beza, or Hymnis laudabant Deum, Piscator, and Pasor, they praised God with Hymnes; that which some object, the text saith, they sang praises, not Psalmes; this is very poore, besides the originall word, how should one sing praises to God but in some Psalme, spirituall Sons, &c. for Praise, if ⟨p. 35⟩you take it properly as distinct from honour and glory, is but the honourable making mention of another, and that externally by tongue or pen; also that text, Heb. 13.15. by him therefore let us offer the sacrifice of praise to God continually, that is, the fruit of our lips, &c. intimates as much.
And this text over-throws that conceit of singing only in the heart, which one that was a member of the Church of Rowley in New England had taken up, and upon that ground, and some other notions he had, denied singing, and maintained (as well as he could) that singing of Psalms was no Ordinance of God. I do not know how this mans opinion came to be known, for had he kept his own counsel, I suppose none should much have taken notice of him, which makes me think it was of his own venting at first; our Elders laboured with him to convince him (the Elders of Ipswich, besides his own Pastor) this text was alleged to prove singing with an Audible voice, for they sang, and the Prisoners heard him: yet this man could not [or rather would not, for the thing is plain as any one may understand] be convinced of the thing; the man after long labouring with him, but to no purpose, for he was tenacious in his own opinion, and as Hieron. said of Jovinianus, Non est contentus nostro, i. e. humano more loqui, altius quiddam aggreditur; High flown in his notions. The Elders seeing that obstinacy was joined to his error, they concluded, that either they must cast that Ordinance out of the Church, or else cast him out of the Church, and so the Church of Rowley did cast him out. I know they have been censured for this Act by some here, but at the Day of Judgement they will give as comfortable an account for maintaining of the Ordinances of Christ, as they shall do, who through their maxim of errours in Non-fundamentalls, make way to loose all the Ordinances, and then where is the Church?
And this text over-throws that conceit of singing only in the heart, which one that was a member of the Church of Rowly in New England had taken up, and upon that ground, and some other notions he had, denied singing, and maintained (as well as he could) that singing of Psalmes was no Ordinance of God. I doe not know how this mans opinion came to be knowne, for had he kept his owne counsell, I suppose none should much have taken notice of him, which makes me thinke it was of his owne venting at first; our Elders laboured with him to convince him (the Elders of Ipswich, besides his owne Pastor) this text was alledged to prove singing with an Audible voyce, for they sang, and the Prisoners heard him: yet this man could not [or rather would not, for the thing is plaine as any one may understand] be convinced of the thing; the man after long labouring with him, but to no purpose, for he was tenacious in his owne opinion, and as Hieron. said of Jovinianus, Non est contentus nostro, i. e. humano more loqui, altius quiddam aggreditur; High flowne in his notions. The Elders seeing that obstinacy was joyned to his errour, they concluded, that either they must cast that Ordinance out of the Church, or else cast him out of the Church, and so the Church of Rowley did cast him out. I know they have been censured for this Act by some here, but at the Day of Judgement they will give as comfortable an account for maintaining of the Ordinances of Christ, as they shall doe, who through their maxime of errours in Non-fundamentalls, make way to loose all the Ordinances, and then where is the Church?
From this example of Paul and Silas we may argue, if two may sing Hymns or Psalms together, then four may, so forty, the number hinders not, for the voices here of many are no hinderance to the Ordinance, but rather they help to stir up the affections one of another; as in those, who are filled with wine, two singing together, or four, do not hinder their conceited mirth. So Christ and his eleven Apostles sang together.
From this example of Paul and Silas we may argue, if two may sing Hymnes or Psalmes together, then foure may, so forty, the number hinders not, for the voyces here of many are no hinderance to the Ordinance, but rather they help to stirre up the affections one of another; as in those, who are filled with wine, two singing together, or foure, doe not hinder their conceited mirth. So Christ and his eleven Apostles sang together.