A85314:235
Separation examined
Separation examined: or, a treatise wherein the grounds for separation from the ministry and churches of England are weighed, and found too light. The practise proved to be not only unwarrantable, but likewise so hurtful to the churches, that church-reformation cannot with any comfort go forward, so long as such separation is tolerated. Also an humble request presented to the congregational divines, that since the differences between them and the classical-divines are very small they would please to strike in with the classical-divines in carrying on the work of reformation, before the inundation of these corrupt opinions, have destroyed both ordinances and religion. / By Gi. Firmin minister to the church in Shalford in essex.Separation examined: or, a treatise vvherein the grounds for separation from the ministry and churches of England are weighed, and found too light. The practise proved to be not onely unwarrantable, but likewise so hurtful to the churches, that church-reformation cannot with any comfort go forward, so long as such separation is tolerated. Also an humble request presented to the congregational divines, that since the differences between them and the classical-divines are very small they would please to strike in with the classical-divines in carrying on the worke of reformation, before the inundation of these corrupt opinions, have destroyed both ordinances and religion. / By Gi. Firmin minister to the church in Shalford in essex.
London: printed by R.I. for Stephen Bowtell, 1652
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
4. We find the word calling upon all sorts of persons to praise God, Psal. 96.1. Sing unto the Lord all the earth, Psal. 68.32. Sing unto the Lord all the Kingdoms of the earth, &c. Several such texts we find.
4. We finde the word calling upon all sorts of persons to praise God, Psal. 96.1. Sing unto the Lord all the earth, Psal. 68.32. Sing unto the Lord all the Kingdomes of the earth, &c. Severall such texts we finde.
I might add more Arguments, and answer to some objections, but I content my self with these.
I might adde more Arguments, and answer to some objections, but I content my selfe with these.
Object. But they mix with us in the Lords Supper.
Object. But they mixe with us in the Lords Supper.
Answ. That the presence of others defile you [especially if you have done your duty to keep that Ordinance clear] is a thing that our Congregational men utterly deny; those who are acquainted with their works, may see it often mentioned, therefore I quote none.
Answ. That the presence of others defile you [especially if you have done your duty to keepe that Ordinance cleare] is a thing that our Congregational men utterly deny; those who are acquainted with their workes, may see it often mentioned, therefore I quote none.
2. I will be bold to say there are many Presbyterial Ministers, who have as few wicked men, at that Ordinance, as were in the Church of Corinth. There were more matters of exception in that Church for the Sacrament of the Lords Supper, then are in abundance of these Churches; besides, you see what course they did take to keep that Ordinance clear, and when they could not obtain what they desired of the Civil power, yet they resolved to go further, which gave Mr. Prynne occasion to write against them.
2. I wil be bold to say there are many Presbyterial Ministers, who have as few wicked men, at that Ordinance, as were in the Church of Corinth. There were more matters of exception in that Church for the Sacrament of the Lords Supper, then are in abundance of these Churches; besides, you see what course they did take to keep that Ordinance clear, and when they could not obtain what they desired of the Civil power, yet they resolved to goe further, which gave Mr. Prynne occasion to write against them.
3. I doubt if we examine things well, your selves are most to blame in that for which you separate. Suppose you be in a Congregational Church, and have all things, as you desire; if there be any person there, who falls scandalously, that he deserves to be suspended from the Ordinance, I pray tell me, what method will you take? I am sure the method is this, If thy Brother offend, tell him, if he hear thee not, take two, if not, tell the Church, Matth. 18. What shall the Minister alone suspend him [it may be he knows not of it] when no Witness comes in against him? No sure; yea, suppose a Minister saw a man drunk, one of his Members, and none saw him, or knew it but himself; he deals indeed with this Member, but the man denieth it, he said he was not; the Minister is sure he was drunk but wants witness; the man comes to the Supper [denying the thing though the Minister had wished him privately to forbear] shall the Minister now debar him? No sure, the text lays another method, the Minister must not be the sole Witness and Judge too; For if Ministers may debar upon their own heads without Witness, they may soon do strange things; now have you done thus, dealt with the Person, or two of you gone to the Minister, and told him, you know such things by such persons, which you can and will prove, such things, as if not repented of, make him unfit for the Ordinance? 1and hath the Minister yet received him [if he hath, you have discharged your duty, and no guilt lieth on you, you may partake] I doubt there are few have done-thus, but if they be persons of quality (especially) then you pull in your horns, afraid to appear, but yet you will have the Minister to suspend him, when no Witness comes in (contrary to the rule) or else you separate; this blame will lye on your own heads.
3. I doubt if we examine things well, your selves are most to blame in that for which you separate. Suppose you be in a Congregationall Church, and have all things, as you desire; if there be any person there, who falls scandalously, that he deserves to be suspended from the Ordinance, I pray tell me, what method will you take? I am sure the method is this, If thy Brother offend, tell him, if he heare thee not, take two, if not, tell the Church, Matth. 18. What shall the Minister alone suspend him [it may be he knows not of it] when no Witnesse comes in against him? No sure; yea, suppose a Minister saw a man drunke, one of his Members, and none saw him, or knew it but himselfe; he deales indeed with this Member, but the man denyeth it, he said he was not; the Minister is sure he was drunke but wants witnesse; the man comes to the Supper [denying the thing though the Minister had wished him privately to forbeare] shall the Minister now debarre him? No sure, the text laies another method, the Minister must not be the sole Witnesse and Judge too; For if Ministers may debarre upon their own heads without Witnesse, they may soone doe strange things; now have you done thus, dealt with the Person, or two of you gone to the Minister, and told him, you know such things by such persons, which you can and will prove, such things, as if not repented of, make him unfit for the Ordinance? 1and hath the Minister yet received him [if he hath, you have discharged your duty, and no guilt lyeth on you, you may partake] I doubt there are few have done-thus, but if they be persons of quality (especially) then you pull in your hornes, afraid to appeare, but yet you will have the Minister to suspend him, when no Witnesse comes in (contrary to the rule) or else you separate; this blame will lye on your owne heads.
- 1See Master Barro, Hos. cap. 5. v. 3.
All your shift here is, we have no power to deal with men, we want an explicit Covenant.
All your shift here is, we have no power to deale with men, we want an explicite Covenant.
Though I could heartily wish all our Ministers would follow the practise of the Holland Churches, who cause all, 1who come to the Sacrament, to promise to subject to Discipline, yet for the present I say this, there is an implicit Covenant in all these Churches, and if you be afraid to speak to these persons first, whom you would have suspended, then go to the Minister, and carry sufficient Witnesses [as you must do in any Church] and ⟨p. 44⟩I am confident, without satisfaction given [no more can be required in any Church] thousands of the Presbyterial Ministers will keep away scandalous persons; [at least you are clear as I said before] yet to see these men separate for that, in which themselves are most to blame.
Though I could heartily wish all our Ministers would follow the practise of the Holland Churches, who cause all, 1who come to the Sacrament, to promise to subject to Discipline, yet for the present I say this, there is an implicite Covenant in all these Churches, and if you be afraid to speake to these persons first, whom you would have suspended, then goe to the Minister, and carry sufficient Witnesses [as you must doe in any Church] and ⟨p. 44⟩I am confident, without satisfaction given [no more can be required in any Church] thousands of the Presbyteriall Ministers will keepe away scandalous persons; [at least you are cleare as I said before] yet to see these men separate for that, in which themselves are most to blame.
- 1Apollon.
Obj. But they baptize all Children, making no difference though never so scandalous.
A. Though this is very seldom urged, yet because I would draw out all that can be said, I add this.
A. Though this is very seldome urged, yet because I would draw out all that can be said, I adde this.
For my own practise, I confess in this I differ from other men far better then my self, but yet were I a Member of some other Presbyterial Congregation, I should not dare to separate upon this ground.
For my owne practise, I confesse in this I differ from other men farre better then my selfe, but yet were I a Member of some other Presbyteriall Congregation, I should not dare to separate upon this ground.
1 It is granted by our Congregational men, 1that though persons be very wicked, yet so long as they live in visible Churches, and are not proceeded against, they may justly challenge the privileges of Church-Members: but I dare not deny them to be true visible Churches, in which there are many such, for there are many both real and visible Saints in such Churches, where these wicked men are.
1 It is granted by our Congregationall men, 1that though persons be very wicked, yet so long as they live in visible Churches, and are not proceeded against, they may justly challenge the priviledges of Church-Members: but I dare not deny them to be true visible Churches, in which there are many such, for there are many both reall and visible Saints in such Churches, where these wicked men are.
- 1Mr. Hook Survey, p. 3 p. 11.
Obj. But then this makes against your self, in denying some children Baptism.
Obj. But then this makes against your selfe, in denying some children Baptisme.
A. 1I answer; [as I have declared in that little Tract upon this question, which the uncivil carriage of some in the Congregation, when I had dealt lovingly with them in private before, forced me to print] I deny not them Baptism absolutely, but as I suspend them from one of the Seals, so I do from this also, till they will labour to get out of their gross ignorance, and scandalous conversations, and will subject themselves to Church-Discipline; so that I do [as say the London Ministers] separate in the Church, but not from the Church; as ⟨p. 45⟩the state of our lapsed Churches will give us leave: I desire to proceed against such, yet but gently, [as for Excommunication, that is a great work] having the advantage in the Church, that many good Ministers [better then my self] have not, viz. That the strongest Party in the Town is religious; but had many Presbyterial men the same advantage, I believe you should see they would be more strict then now they are. Congregations must be mended by degrees: to purge per vices in foul bodies, is better then at first to give Hellebore, Scammony, and such strong workers; it will cost abundance of prayer, wisdom, labour, meekness, to bring these Congregations fallen into this ignorance and profaneness for want of Catechizing, and Discipline; let the Bishops look to their account.
A. 1I answer; [as I have declared in that little Tract upon this question, which the uncivill carriage of some in the Congregation, when I had dealt lovingly with them in private before, forced me to print] I deny not them Baptisme absolutely, but as I suspend them from one of the Seales, so I doe from this also, till they will labour to get out of their grosse ignorance, and scandalous conversations, and will subject themselves to Church-Discipline; so that I doe [as say the London Ministers] separate in the Church, but not from the Church; as ⟨p. 45⟩the state of our lapsed Churches will give us leave: I desire to proceed against such, yet but gently, [as for Excommunication, that is a great worke] having the advantage in the Church, that many good Ministers [better then my selfe] have not, viz. That the strongest Party in the Towne is religious; but had many Presbyteriall men the same advantage, I beleeve you should see they would be more strict then now they are. Congregations must be mended by degrees: to purge per vices in foule bodies, is better then at first to give Hellebore, Scammony, and such strong workers; it will cost abundance of prayer, wisdome, labour, meeknesse, to bring these Congregations fallen into this ignorance and prophanenesse for want of Catechizing, and Discipline; let the Bishops looke to their account.
- 1Learned Mr. Cawdrey came to my hand, after I had printed my little Treatise, had I seen him before, I should have humbly presented some answer to some things, which I see the•e, so far as concerned my question [the question about Confederacy doth not concern me] also I would have propounded some Reasons, why his third way i. e. Adoption, I should not so easily admit under the New Testament, till those Reasons were removed. I perceive he admires at them who deny the Children of Excommunicated Parents Baptism, I have no place now to answer but only this; I say, it is not good to put too much upon Baptism, nor too little upon that dreadful ordinance of Excommunication. What he saith, p. 202. about the impotence to reject profane persons through the iniquity of the times, which implies what he would do, if he had power, confirms my practise.Learned Mr. Cawdrey came to my hand, after I had printed my little Treatise, had I seene him before, I should have humbly presented some answer to some things, which I see the•e, so farre as concerned my question [the question about Confederacy doth not concern me] also I would have propounded some Reasons, why his third way i. e. Adoption, I should not so easily admit under the New Testament, till those Reasons were removed. I perceive he admires at them who deny the Children of Excommunicated Parents Baptisme, I have no place now to answer but only this; I say, it is not good to put too much upon Baptisme, nor too little upon that dreadfull ordinance of Excommunication. What he saith, p. 202. about the impotence to reject prophane persons through the iniquity of the times, which implyes what he would doe, if he had power, confirmes my practise.
Besides, divers Presbyterial Ministers do examine their people before they will Baptize, yea, and I have heard one who is esteemed a rigid Presbyterian say, That if the Presbyterial Government were settled, they would Baptize none, but they would have the parents; 1. Examined in point of knowledge. 2. If they were scandalous, that they should confess their sin. 3. Promise for the time to come to reform. 4. That if persons would refuse to submit to Church-Discipline, they would deny them the Lords Supper.
Besides, divers Presbyteriall Ministers doe examine their people before they will Baptize, yea, and I have heard one who is esteemed a rigid Presbyterian say, That if the Presbyteriall Government were setled, they would Baptize none, but they would have the parents; 1. Examined in point of knowledge. 2. If they were scandalous, that they should confesse their sinne. 3. Promise for the time to come to reforme. 4. That if persons would refuse to submit to Church-Discipline, they would deny them the Lords Supper.
Since then it is in the hearts of many to reform, and it is the thing they would gladly have power to do, I think it is very unwarrantable upon this ground to separate from them; besides, there are many reasons they give for Baptizing of all that do but profess Christ, which though they are not satisfactory unto me, so as to give the Seal of the Govenant to one, who saith, He believes in Christ, but yet is grossly ignorant, scandalous, &c. yet their reasons prevail with me so, as to be very charitable to those, who do Baptize upon those grounds; if there be any sin in it, let the Minister look to that, that is not your fault.
Since then it is in the hearts of many to reforme, and it is the thing they would gladly have power to doe, I thinke it is very unwarrantable upon this ground to separate from them; besides, there are many reasons they give for Baptizing of all that doe but professe Christ, which though they are not satisfactory unto me, so as to give the Seale of the Govenant to one, who saith, He beleeves in Christ, but yet is grosly ignorant, scandalous, &c. yet their reasons prevaile with me so, as to be very charitable to those, who doe Baptize upon those grounds; if there be any sinne in it, let the Minister looke to that, that is not your fault.