Separation Examined.
pp. 1–111539 passagespart 5 of 14
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Whether will these men allow one Christian to sing a Psalm ⟨p. 36⟩alone by himself, methinks the texts and examples mentioned, together with Jam. 5.13. Is any man merry, [Greek or Hebrew] let him sing Psalms, are so plain, as no rational man can deny it; But if one may, then the Church may. There is no act of Worship which any member of the Church is bound to perform, but the Church is bound to perform; but on the contrary it is not true, that what worship the Church doth perform, a member of Church can, or may; for instance for the first part, Meditation needs no Organ of the body, and therefore I leave that. But doth a Member of the Church Pray, so doth the whole Church: doth he read the Scriptures? so they are read in the Church; doth he fast and pray? so doth the Church; doth he sing a Psalm? so doth the Church; but it is not true on the contrary, as appears in the Sacraments, Preaching, Discipline, &c. Neither is that place, Revel. 15.2, 3. of small force, to prove singing to be an Ordinance, 1Those who overcame the Beast, sung the Song of Moses; This saith Mr. Burroughs I note, because hereby we may see that singing is an Ordinance in the Church of God, not only in the time of the Law, but in the time of the Gospel, &c. he was speaking of the text before.
Whether will these men allow one Christian to sing a Psalme ⟨p. 36⟩alone by himselfe, methinkes the texts and examples mentioned, together with Jam. 5.13. Is any man merry, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 let him sing Psalmes, are so plaine, as no rationall man can deny it; But if one may, then the Church may. There is no act of Worship which any member of the Church is bound to performe, but the Church is bound to performe; but on the contrary it is not true, that what worship the Church doth performe, a member of Church can, or may; for instance for the first part, Meditation needs no Organ of the body, and therefore I leave that. But doth a Member of the Church Pray, so doth the whole Church: doth he read the Scriptures? so they are read in the Church; doth he fast and pray? so doth the Church; doth he sing a Psalme? so doth the Church; but it is not true on the contrary, as appeares in the Sacraments, Preaching, Discipline, &c. Neither is that place,
4 The fourth ground that moves me is this [I know not how it will take with others, but with me it is something] Psal 92. The title saith, it is a Psalm, or Song for the day of Sabbath; it is clear, that one way of sanctification of the Sabbath was by singing of Psalms; two of the words that Paul uses in Ephes. 5.19. are in this Title [Greek or Hebrew] Psalm, Spiritual Songs; will any say, this Psalm was only for those times, but now is abolished with the Jewish Sabbath? what, is that admirable promise, in the thirteenth, and fourteenth verses vanished, and of no use to us? Should not Christians apply it, and plead it now, when as they are planted in Gods house, and attending on him on our Christian Sabbath? have not we as much need of the Promise as they? this with me hath much prevailed; if we own a Christian Sabbath, singing of Psalms may well be owned also for an Ordinance of God now, as well as then.
4 The fourth ground that moves me is this [I know not how it will take with others, but with me it is something] Psal 92. The title saith, it is a Psalme, or Song for the day of Sabbath; it is cleare, that one way of sanctification of the Sabbath was by singing of Psalmes; two of the words that Paul uses in Ephes. 5.19. are in this Title 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Psalme, Spirituall Songs; will any say, this Psalme was only for those times, but now is abolished with the Jewish Sabbath? what, is that admirable promise, in the thirteenth, and fourteenth verses vanished, and of no use to us? Should not Christians apply it, and plead it now, when as they are planted in Gods house, and attending on him on our Christian Sabbath? have not we as much need of the Promise as they? this with me hath much prevailed; if we owne a Christian Sabbath, singing of Psalmes may well be owned also for an Ordinance of God now, as well as then.
5 The fifth is the presence of the Spirit of God with his people in the use of this Ordinance; for the proof of what I say, let thousands of Gods people speak, if they have not found God in the Ordinance; I will not go so far as Augustin, ⟨p. 37⟩but our Fathers, 1who used it in their families more then some of us do, I am sure they found God, and so have many now in these days; those who have not found God in it, they may cavil indeed, but let them be rather humbled, that God hath not given them, what others have tasted; those who do frequently find God in this Ordinance, they will not so slightly, and scornfully speak of it, as that Sectary did to me; but if God had usually manifested his presence with his Churches under the Old and New Testament, in the using of this Ordinance, this with the former Scriptures alleged prevail with me, to believe it is a Gospel ordinance still.
5 The fifth is the presence of the Spirit of God with his people in the use of this Ordinance; for the proofe of what I say, let thousands of Gods people speake, if they have not found God in the Ordinance; I will not goe so farre as Augustin, ⟨p. 37⟩but our Fathers, 1who used it in their families more then some of us doe, I am sure they found God, and so have many now in these dayes; those who have not found God in it, they may cavill indeed, but let them be rather humbled, that God hath not given them, what others have tasted; those who doe frequently finde God in this Ordinance, they will not so slightly, and scornfully speake of it, as that Sectary did to me; but if God had usually manifested his presence with his Churches under the Old and New Testament, in the using of this Ordinance, this with the former Scriptures alledged prevaile with me, to beleeve it is a Gospel ordinance still.
- 1Confess. l. 9 c. 6. & l. 10. c. 33.Confes. l. 9 c. 6. & l. 10. c. 33.
6 The last ground that moves me, is the practise of the Primitive Churches: Antiquity after Scripture is as a Cypher after a Figure, and doth increase the number; that singing was frequent among those Christians I find it recorded.
6 The last ground that moves me, is the practise of the Primitive Churches: Antiquity after Scripture is as a Cypher after a Figure, and doth increase the number; that singing was frequent among those Christians I finde it recorded.
1 Eusebius reporteth out of Philo, the Lives, manners, &c. of the religious men in Egypt; Mark being sent into Egypt, 1as saith the story, to preach Christ, he there converted many, whose conversation (as I said) Philo Judaeus, a very learned man at that time, sets forth in commendation of the Christians: 2among other things this he reporteth; They contemplate not only Divine things, but they make grave Canticles, and Hymns unto God, in a more sacred rime of every kind of meter and verse. This Philo (a Hebrew) flourished about the year forty, being sent of an Embassage to Caius Caligula about that time; so then this was their practise in the Apostles times, Philo must needs be borne, and well grown in Christs time.
1 Eusebius reporteth out of Philo, the Lives, manners, &c. of the religious men in Aegypt; Marke being sent into Aegypt, 1as saith the story, to preach Christ, he there converted many, whose conversation (as I said) Philo Judaeus, a very learned man at that time, sets forth in commendation of the Christians: 2among other things this he reporteth; They contemplate not only Divine things, but they make grave Canticles, and Hymnes unto God, in a more sacred rime of every kind of meeter and verse. This Philo (a Hebrew) flourished about the yeare forty, being sent of an Embassage to Caius Caligula about that time; so then this was their practise in the Apostles times, Philo must needs be borne, and well growne in Christs time.
- 1Eccles. hist. lib. 2. c. 17
- 2Hierom also relates this out of Philo Orationi vacatur & Psalmis. Catal. script. Ecclesiast.
2 For Tertullian, 1there are two Testimonies brought out of him for singing of Psalms, the one is out of Apol. c. 2. the Letter which Plinius Secundus wrote to Trajan in behalf of the Church, where he mentions the practise; the other is out of Cap. 39. Apol. showing the Discipline of the Christians, and there it is mentioned; but I find two other places in him besides these as clear as those; one is, l. 2. ad uxorem, having spoken strongly against Christians marrying with Infidels, he shows the contrary, how good it is for Christians to marry with Christians, and among other things this he mentions; Sonant inter Duos Psalmi & Hymni, & mutuò provocant quis melius Deo sua canet; but most clear is that place, Cap. 3. De Animâ, as for his opinion De effigie animae, I leave that; but there he makes ⟨p. 38⟩mention of a Sister of their Church, who had the gifts of Revelations, which it seems she had in the Church on the Lords Day, As the Scriptures are read, or Psalms are sung, he reckons up other Ordinances, Prayer, &c. then matter for visions were administered, &c. Now this is most clear, it was in the Congregation, for when the people were gone (exercises being finished) then it seems she was wont to tell (the officers I suppose he means) what revelations she had, which they noted exactly. Tertullian then is so plain and full for this practise, that none can doubt whether the Churches used this Ordinance or no.
2 For Tertullian, 1there are two Testimonies brought out of him for singing of Psalmes, the one is out of Apol. c. 2. the Letter which Plinius Secundus wrote to Trajan in behalfe of the Church, where he mentions the practise; the other is out of Cap. 39. Apol. shewing the Discipline of the Christians, and there it is mentioned; but I finde two other places in him besides these as cleare as those; one is, l. 2. ad uxorem, having spoken strongly against Christians marrying with Infidels, he shewes the contrary, how good it is for Christians to marry with Christians, and among other things this he mentions; Sonant inter Duos Psalmi & Hymni, & mutuò provocant quis melius Deo sua canet; but most cleare is that place, Cap. 3. De Animâ, as for his opinion De effigie animae, I leave that; but there he makes ⟨p. 38⟩
Socrates Scholast. speaking of the Hymns, which Chrysost. appointed his own people to sing in opposition to the Arians, 1in the end of the Chapter tells us that Ignatius, a man very familiar with the Apostles, saw a vision of Angels which extolled the blessed Trinity with Hymns, that were sung interchangeably, and delivered unto the Church of Antioch, the order and manner of singing expressed in the vision; so he would make Ignatius the Author of Anthems: I somewhat doubt whether that manner of singing was so ancient, but that singing was, I doubt not, then in practise.
Socrates Scholast. speaking of the Hymns, which Chrysost. appointed his own people to sing in opposition to the Arians, 1in the end of the Chapter tells us that Ignatius, a man very familiar with the Apostles, saw a vision of Angels which extolled the blessed Trinity with Hymnes, that were sung interchangeably, and delivered unto the Church of Antioch, the order and manner of singing expressed in the vision; so he would make Ignatius the Author of Anthemes: I somewhat doubt whether that manner of singing was so ancient, but that singing was, I doubt not, then in practise.
- 1Eccles. Hist. l. 6. c. 8.
4. 1Just. Martyr (or whosoever was the Author of that book) shows it was in use in that time, setting down with all the benefit that comes by singing.
4. 1Just. Martyr (or whosoever was the Authour of that booke) shews it was in use in that time, setting downe with all the benefit that comes by singing.
- 1Quest. & Resp. Orth. q. 107.
So that in the Apostles times, and the ages next to the Apostles, we find singing was in use.
So that in the Apostles times, and the ages next to the Apostles, we finde singing was in use.
If we come a little lower to the year three hundred sixty four I find in 15. Canon, Concil. Laodic. none were allowed to sing praeter Canonicos Psaltes; here was a corruption got in by this time, cross to the command of Paul in his Epistles to the Ephes. and Coloss. but this implies that singing had been before in use in the Churches, and that the people were wont to sing, that now they limit singing to the Canonical Psalmists.
If we come a little lower to the year three hundred sixty four I finde in 15. Canon, Concil. Laodic. none were allowed to sing praeter Canonicos Psaltes; here was a corruption got in by this time, crosse to the command of Paul in his Epistles to the Ephes. and Coloss. but this implies that singing had beene before in use in the Churches, and that the people were wont to sing, that now they limit singing to the Canonicall Psalmists.
That Athanasius used singing in his Church, appears also in August. Confess. l. 10. c. 33. also that the Psalms of David were sung then appears in the same place, and in his 119. Epist. c. 18. where he affirms, that for singing of Psalms and Hymns, we have the examples and precepts of Christ, and the Apostles, blaming withal the Donatists, that learning Davids Psalms, they sung Hymns of their own inventing, &c.
That Athanasius used singing in his Church, appeares also in August. Confess. l. 10. c. 33. also that the Psalmes of David were sung then appeares in the same place, and in his 119. Epist. c. 18. where he affirmes, that for singing of Psalmes and Hymnes, we have the examples and precepts of Christ, and the Apostles, blaming withall the Donatists, that learning Davids Psalmes, they sung Hymnes of their owne inventing, &c.
As for those, who would allow singing, if it might be of some spiritual song composed by some Saint now upon some occasions, I do not now trouble my self about them, only I wish them to make better songs, then that brother of one of the Churches in London [I do forbear to name whose Church it was] who composed a song to be sung on the day of Thanksgiving for the overthrow of the Scots at Dunbar; I heard the Song read over, and the party who read it, told me it was sung in the Church: I deny not but the man who composed it, might have an honest heart, but sure he had but a shallow head, in comparison of what men should have, that compose such Songs.
As for those, who would allow singing, if it might be of some spirituall song composed by some Saint now upon some occasions, I doe not now trouble my selfe about them, onely I wish them to make better songs, then that brother of one of the Churches in London [I doe forbeare to name whose Church it was] who composed a song to be sung on the day of Thanksgiving for the overthrow of the Scots at Dunbar; I heard the Song read over, and the party who read it, told me it was sung in the Church: I deny not but the man who composed it, might have an honest heart, but sure he had but a shallow head, in comparison of what men should have, that compose such Songs.
If these be not grounds sufficient to answer that scoffer, let him give me better grounds to prove singing of Psalms is no Gospel Ordinance.
If these be not grounds sufficient to answer that scoffer, let him give me better grounds to prove singing of Psalmes is no Gospel Ordinance.
So much for the second branch, the worship can be no ground of separation. Now I come to the third.
Let us see if there be sufficient ground for separation in respect of the Congregation. The Congregations are very corrupt they say, hence they think they are bound to separate, and allege these places, 2 Cor. 6.17. Revel. 18.4.
Let us see if there be sufficient ground for separation in respect of the Congregation. The Congregations are very corrupt they say, hence they thinke they are bound to separate, and alleadge these places, 2 Cor. 6.17. Revel. 18.4.
1. That there are very many corrupt persons in the Presbyterial Congregations, there are none deny it (and I wish the Independent Churches have not some corrupt persons also amongst them) you do not hear them justify all their Churchmembers, but you shall find them complaining of this corruption, and endeavouring by degrees to correct it, yea, I believe, had they power in their hands, they would soon show what they would do: I pray hear some of their words, 1the London Ministers, Though we dare not make separation from a true Church, yet we do make separation in a true Church. Read over the whole Answer, and you may perceive their minds, 2before this in their exhortation to the Ministers and Elders, you have this one branch of their exhortation, That they would labour to make their Congregations pure as well as peaceable, following after piety, as much as after verity and unity, that all your people under your charge, may be visible Saints at least, 3you may feel how the pulses of these men beat. I observe also Mr. Cawdry differing very little from Mr. Hooker, in this point about visible Saints, being the material cause of a Church; where you may see what he would have, if Discipline were once stablished; that the Congregations are ⟨p. 40⟩thus corrupt, 4the fault is not in them, but in the old Hierarchy, whose Errors while they go about to mend, you go away from them.
1. That there are very many corrupt persons in the Presbyteriall Congregations, there are none deny it (and I wish the Independent Churches have not some corrupt persons also amongst them) you doe not heare them justifie all their Churchmembers, but you shall finde them complaining of this corruption, and endeavouring by degrees to correct it, yea, I beleeve, had they power in their hands, they would soone shew what they would doe: I pray heare some of their words, 1the London Ministers, Though we dare not make separation from a true Church, yet we doe make separation in a true Church. Read over the whole Answer, and you may perceive their mindes,
2. I am sure, very many Parochial Congregations in England, have both visible and real Saints: must these and the Ministry be cast off for the sake of other corrupt ones? whom they would gladly also mend, if they could, or else purge them out.
2. I am sure, very many Parochiall Congregations in England, have both visible and reall Saints: must these and the Ministry be cast off for the sake of other corrupt ones? whom they would gladly also mend, if they could, or else purge them out.
3. I wish you would give us precept or example, where there have been Churches with so many visible Saints, and such Ministers, and these Ministers desiring and labouring to reform as they do, and yet that Christians have done, or should separate from them. Those Texts above mentioned, and often alleged, if you please to view them well again, are very far from proving it: Corrupt members there were enough in the Jewish Church, and so in the Christian Churches soon after, and in the Apostles times; but you have no example of separating from them, but in them, say the London Ministers, we do separate,
3. I wish you would give us precept or example, where there have beene Churches with so many visible Saints, and such Ministers, and these Ministers desiring and labouring to reforme as they doe, and yet that Christians have done, or should separate from them. Those Texts above mentioned, and often alleadged, if you please to view them well againe, are very far from proving it: Corrupt members there were enough in the Jewish Church, and so in the Christian Churches soone after, and in the Apostles times; but you have no example of separating from them, but in them, say the London Ministers, we doe separate,
4. But I pray wherein do these wicked men trouble you? I hope you will give men leave to hear the word, be they never so wicked, but many of you come not so much as to hear.
4. But I pray wherein doe these wicked men trouble you? I hope you will give men leave to heare the word, be they never so wicked, but many of you come not so much as to heare.
Object. But they trouble us, because they mix with us in prayer.
Object. But they trouble us, because they mixe with us in prayer.
Answ. No mixtures ever troubled me in Ordinances, so much as my own heart, 1if I could separate from that I should be happy.
Answ. No mixtures ever troubled me in Ordinances, so much as my owne heart, 1if I could separate from that I should bee happy.
- 1The Grecians before they went to kill the sacrifice, used to cry out to the people, [Greek or Hebrew] Let us pray, Rous. Arch. At. l. 2. c. 9 They prayed also in the Temple. c. 7.The Grecians before they went to kill the sacrifice, used to cry out to the people, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Let us pray, Rous. Arch. Att. l. 2. c. 9 They prayed also in the Temple. c. 7.
But for Prayer, why would not you have them join in prayer? when as,
But for Prayer, why would not you have them joyne in prayer? when as,
First, Prayer is a part of natural worship, the light of nature dictates this to every man, if he own a God, then pray unto him, Jonah 1.6. Call upon thy God, &c. but I hope none in your Congregations, but own even the true God, therefore they are bound to pray to him.
First, Prayer is a part of naturall worship, the light of nature dictates this to every man, if he owne a God, then pray unto him, Jonah 1.6. Call upon thy God, &c. but I hope none in your Congregations, but owne even the true God, therefore they are bound to pray to him.
Thirdly, Prayer God hath used to be a converting Ordinance; I have known one my self that now is in heaven, but was at first a notorious wretch', a mock-God, Captain of ⟨p. 41⟩Drunkards, who coming into the Church as the Minister was in prayer, God brake his heart, and followed it on so, as he became an eminent Saint.
Thirdly, Prayer God hath used to be a converting Ordinance; I have knowne one my selfe that now is in heaven, but was at first a notorious wretch', a mock-God, Captaine of ⟨p. 41⟩Drunkards, who coming into the Church as the Minister was in prayer, God brake his heart, and followed it on so, as he became an eminent Saint.
Object. They mix with us in our singing, mixed worship we cannot join in.
Object. They mixe with us in our singing, mixed worship we cannot joyne in.
Answ. I cannot conceive what harm this can do to you; is the mixing of your own corruption in your service less prejudicial to the acceptance of it with God, then the presence of wicked men joining in the service?
Answ. I cannot conceive what harm this can do to you; is the mixing of your owne corruption in your service lesse prejudiciall to the acceptance of it with God, then the presence of wicked men joyning in the service?
If indeed you can prove to me that God will not have wicked men sing, but if they do, he will not accept of the service of his people, this is some ground for your exception; but I conceive you will not be able to prove the former, much less the latter.
If indeed you can prove to me that God will not have wicked men sing, but if they doe, he will not accept of the service of his people, this is some ground for your exception; but I conceive you will not be able to prove the former, much lesse the latter.
That wicked men may sing, I prove thus:
First, If wicked men may pray unto God (as the light of nature teaches) then they may praise God; the light of nature teaches this also: nature teaches me to pray to God for what I want, and nature teaches me to praise God for what I receive. If then natural men may praise God with their mouths [for praise must be expressed with tongue or pen, if you take it properly, as I said before] why not by singing? God hath given this gift to them, as well as to others. But that to praise God is a part of natural worship, and belongs to all men, we may conceive by the example of the Philistines, Judg. 16.23. They met to offer a great sacrifice to Dagon, and to rejoice (because of Sampson.) Here is a day of Thanksgiving; so 1 Chron. 10.9. because Saul was slain, &c.
First, If wicked men may pray unto God (as the light of nature teaches) then they may praise God; the light of nature teaches this also: nature teaches me to pray to God for what I want, and nature teaches me to praise God for what I receive. If then naturall men may praise God with their mouths [for praise must bee expressed with tongue or pen, if you take it properly, as I said before] why not by singing? God hath given this gift to them, as well as to others. But that to praise God is a part of naturall worship, and belongs to all men, we may conceive by the example of the Philistims, Judg. 16.23. They met to offer a great sacrifice to Dagon, and to rejoyce (because of Sampson.) Here is a day of Thanksgiving; so 1 Chron. 10.9. because Saul was slaine, &c.
If we go to the Romans, we shall find nature had taught them to sing to their feigned gods, 1not to transcribe their rites in their sacrifices, After the portion laid out for the gods had been burnt, then did all the people repair to a common feast; where, as they were eating, they sung hymns and songs in the praise of their gods, and playing on Cymbals, they danced about the Altars, intimating thereby, that there was no part of their body, but should be employed in the service of their gods, &c. If nature taught the Romans to sing hymns and songs to their feigned and foolish gods, why should wicked men be debarred from singing to the true God?
If we goe to the Romans, we shall finde nature had taught them to sing to their feigned gods, 1not to transcribe their rites in their sacrifices, After the portion layed out for the gods had beene burnt, then did all the people repaire to a common feast; where, as they were eating, they sung hymnes and songs in the praise of their gods, and playing on Cymbals, they danced about the Altars, intimating thereby, that there was no part of their body, but should be imployed in the service of their gods, &c. If nature taught the Romans to sing hymnes and songs to their feigned and foolish gods, why should wicked men be debarred from singing to the true God?
- 1Godw. Rom. Ant. l. 2. s. 2. c. 19
2. We find Exod. 15.1. Moses and the sons of Israel, sang a song to the Lord, in v. 12. Miriam bids the women sing; I doubt not but among these sons and daughters of Israel, ⟨p. 42⟩there were persons as corrupt as any in our Congregations: then the presence of wicked men do not so defile you, or the Ordinance, as is supposed; to themselves indeed it was polluted, as are all other things, but this hindered not Moses, nor Miriam, they did not separate all those, who were godly, from the rest, and sing only with them; I doubt they should have had but few songsters.
2. We finde Exod. 15.1. Moses and the sonnes of Israel, sang a song to the Lord, in v. 12. Miriam bids the women sing; I doubt not but among these sonnes and daughters of Israel, ⟨p. 42⟩there were persons as corrupt as any in our Congregations: then the presence of wicked men doe not so defile you, or the Ordinance, as is supposed; to themselves indeed it was polluted, as are all other things, but this hindred not Moses, nor Miriam, they did not separate all those, who were godly, from the rest, and sing onely with them; I doubt they should have had but few songsters.
3. May a wicked man read a Psalm, or one of those songs? give me a reason why not? Will you debar a wicked man from reading the word? If he may read a Psalm, why may not he sing the Psalm? To read the word is worship, so to sing the Psalm is worship: It is true, he cannot sing as he should, no more he cannot read the Psalm as he should, nor hear, &c. therefore he must not read nor hear the word: To sing, is we see taught by the light of nature, as well as the other, to pray, read, or hear the word. This Ordinance is not, as the Sacraments, which we do not see so by natures light, but have them by divine Institution revealed, having also a sealing nature annexed to them.
3. May a wicked man read a Psalme, or one of those songs? give me a reason why not? Will you debarre a wicked man from reading the word? If he may read a Psalme, why may not he sing the Psalme? To read the word is worship, so to sing the Psalme is worship: It is true, he cannot sing as hee should, no more he cannot read the Psalme as he should, nor heare, &c. therefore he must not read nor heare the word: To sing, is we see taught by the light of nature, as well as the other, to pray, read, or heare the word. This Ordinance is not, as the Sacraments, which we doe not see so by natures light, but have them by divine Institution revealed, having also a sealing nature annexed to them.
4. We find the word calling upon all sorts of persons to praise God, Psal. 96.1. Sing unto the Lord all the earth, Psal. 68.32. Sing unto the Lord all the Kingdoms of the earth, &c. Several such texts we find.
4. We finde the word calling upon all sorts of persons to praise God, Psal. 96.1. Sing unto the Lord all the earth, Psal. 68.32. Sing unto the Lord all the Kingdomes of the earth, &c. Severall such texts we finde.
I might add more Arguments, and answer to some objections, but I content my self with these.
I might adde more Arguments, and answer to some objections, but I content my selfe with these.
Object. But they mix with us in the Lords Supper.
Object. But they mixe with us in the Lords Supper.
Answ. That the presence of others defile you [especially if you have done your duty to keep that Ordinance clear] is a thing that our Congregational men utterly deny; those who are acquainted with their works, may see it often mentioned, therefore I quote none.
Answ. That the presence of others defile you [especially if you have done your duty to keepe that Ordinance cleare] is a thing that our Congregational men utterly deny; those who are acquainted with their workes, may see it often mentioned, therefore I quote none.
2. I will be bold to say there are many Presbyterial Ministers, who have as few wicked men, at that Ordinance, as were in the Church of Corinth. There were more matters of exception in that Church for the Sacrament of the Lords Supper, then are in abundance of these Churches; besides, you see what course they did take to keep that Ordinance clear, and when they could not obtain what they desired of the Civil power, yet they resolved to go further, which gave Mr. Prynne occasion to write against them.
2. I wil be bold to say there are many Presbyterial Ministers, who have as few wicked men, at that Ordinance, as were in the Church of Corinth. There were more matters of exception in that Church for the Sacrament of the Lords Supper, then are in abundance of these Churches; besides, you see what course they did take to keep that Ordinance clear, and when they could not obtain what they desired of the Civil power, yet they resolved to goe further, which gave Mr. Prynne occasion to write against them.
3. I doubt if we examine things well, your selves are most to blame in that for which you separate. Suppose you be in a Congregational Church, and have all things, as you desire; if there be any person there, who falls scandalously, that he deserves to be suspended from the Ordinance, I pray tell me, what method will you take? I am sure the method is this, If thy Brother offend, tell him, if he hear thee not, take two, if not, tell the Church, Matth. 18. What shall the Minister alone suspend him [it may be he knows not of it] when no Witness comes in against him? No sure; yea, suppose a Minister saw a man drunk, one of his Members, and none saw him, or knew it but himself; he deals indeed with this Member, but the man denieth it, he said he was not; the Minister is sure he was drunk but wants witness; the man comes to the Supper [denying the thing though the Minister had wished him privately to forbear] shall the Minister now debar him? No sure, the text lays another method, the Minister must not be the sole Witness and Judge too; For if Ministers may debar upon their own heads without Witness, they may soon do strange things; now have you done thus, dealt with the Person, or two of you gone to the Minister, and told him, you know such things by such persons, which you can and will prove, such things, as if not repented of, make him unfit for the Ordinance? 1and hath the Minister yet received him [if he hath, you have discharged your duty, and no guilt lieth on you, you may partake] I doubt there are few have done-thus, but if they be persons of quality (especially) then you pull in your horns, afraid to appear, but yet you will have the Minister to suspend him, when no Witness comes in (contrary to the rule) or else you separate; this blame will lye on your own heads.
3. I doubt if we examine things well, your selves are most to blame in that for which you separate. Suppose you be in a Congregationall Church, and have all things, as you desire; if there be any person there, who falls scandalously, that he deserves to be suspended from the Ordinance, I pray tell me, what method will you take? I am sure the method is this, If thy Brother offend, tell him, if he heare thee not, take two, if not, tell the Church, Matth. 18. What shall the Minister alone suspend him [it may be he knows not of it] when no Witnesse comes in against him? No sure; yea, suppose a Minister saw a man drunke, one of his Members, and none saw him, or knew it but himselfe; he deales indeed with this Member, but the man denyeth it, he said he was not; the Minister is sure he was drunke but wants witnesse; the man comes to the Supper [denying the thing though the Minister had wished him privately to forbeare] shall the Minister now debarre him? No sure, the text laies another method, the Minister must not be the sole Witnesse and Judge too; For if Ministers may debarre upon their own heads without Witnesse, they may soone doe strange things; now have you done thus, dealt with the Person, or two of you gone to the Minister, and told him, you know such things by such persons, which you can and will prove, such things, as if not repented of, make him unfit for the Ordinance?
All your shift here is, we have no power to deal with men, we want an explicit Covenant.
All your shift here is, we have no power to deale with men, we want an explicite Covenant.