A85314:273
Separation examined
Separation examined: or, a treatise wherein the grounds for separation from the ministry and churches of England are weighed, and found too light. The practise proved to be not only unwarrantable, but likewise so hurtful to the churches, that church-reformation cannot with any comfort go forward, so long as such separation is tolerated. Also an humble request presented to the congregational divines, that since the differences between them and the classical-divines are very small they would please to strike in with the classical-divines in carrying on the work of reformation, before the inundation of these corrupt opinions, have destroyed both ordinances and religion. / By Gi. Firmin minister to the church in Shalford in essex.Separation examined: or, a treatise vvherein the grounds for separation from the ministry and churches of England are weighed, and found too light. The practise proved to be not onely unwarrantable, but likewise so hurtful to the churches, that church-reformation cannot with any comfort go forward, so long as such separation is tolerated. Also an humble request presented to the congregational divines, that since the differences between them and the classical-divines are very small they would please to strike in with the classical-divines in carrying on the worke of reformation, before the inundation of these corrupt opinions, have destroyed both ordinances and religion. / By Gi. Firmin minister to the church in Shalford in essex.
London: printed by R.I. for Stephen Bowtell, 1652
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
If the Lord Christ in his infinite Wisdom, and Kingly care, conceived it necessary for the honour of the place, and the execution of the work of a Deacon, to appoint choice men, and solemn Ordination to Authorize them to the work, &c.
If the Lord Christ in his infinite Wisdome, and Kingly care, conceived it necessary for the honour of the place, and the execution of the worke of a Deacon, to appoint choice men, and solemne Ordination to Authorize them to the worke, &c.
The sum is, the practise is but loathsome, and the Acts of such men are void, who do such things as properly belong to a Church-Officer, and are not called to the Office; thus Mr. Hooker.
The summe is, the practise is but loathsome, and the Acts of such men are voyd, who doe such things as properly belong to a Church-Officer, and are not called to the Office; thus Mr. Hooker.
Mr. 1Cotton he speaks against such practices, so doth the stream of all Divines, Calvin, Zanchy, Perkins, Ames, &c.
Mr. 1Cotton he speakes against such practices, so doth the streame of all Divines, Calvin, Zanchy, Perkins, Ames, &c.
- 1Keys, p. 6 Inst. l. 4 c. 15. s. 20 In par. 2. 1. Vol. p. 766. Bell. ever. to. 3. l. 2. c. 2.Keys, p. 6 Inst. l. 4 c. 15. s. 20 In par. 2. 1. Vol. p. 766. Bell. ener. to. 3. l. 2. c. 2.
Hence then if you null their Call, you must null all the Acts they have done as Ministers, and you will be troubled (as I said before) which way to come into order; you had better therefore be quiet, and if you will needs quarrel with their Ordination, yet content your selves with their election, which you say is the chief.
Hence then if you null their Call, you must null all the Acts they have done as Ministers, and you will be troubled (as I said before) which way to come into order; you had better therefore be quiet, and if you wil needs quarrell with their Ordination, yet content your selves with their election, which you say is the chiefe.
Before I pass on to my last answer, let me a little examine this Thesis, viz. Election gives the essentials, and Ordination is but an Adjunct. Heretofore I have indeed been of this opinion, never much weighing the thing, being wholly carried away with the Authority of Dr. Ames, and Mr. Hooker, and others, admiring their learning and holiness, seeing my self but a mere babe in comparison of these men, and so I judge of my self still; but I remember a passage of Mr. Hookers in his conference with forty Ministers, said he, We see things fall cut in our Churches, which puts us upon further searches; so when I observed what use is made of this Thesis in England amongst our Sectaries, and what confusion is brought upon us, for any number of Sectaries will elect one (be he what he will) but Election gives the essence, Ordination is but an Adjunct, therefore may be left out; these practises have made me to search further into this opinion, this being my greatest trouble, that if I cast off the opinion, I must go cross to such men, whom I do so much admire and reverence; I am apt to think our holy Men did in this as our first ⟨p. 51⟩Reformers did in other points; Luther let some words fall against the Law, which might have been spared; so our Divines in their definition of saving Faith, in opposition to the Papists; so in this point the Papists cried up ordination too high, ours now are run on the other side, and cry up popular election as high, and cry down Ordination, but surely a medium might have been found out, which had come nearer to the rule (with submission I speak it.)
Before I passe on to my last answer, let me a little examine this Thesis, viz. Election gives the essentials, and Ordination is but an Adjunct. Heretofore I have indeed been of this opinion, never much weighing the thing, being wholly carried away with the Authority of Dr. Ames, and Mr. Hooker, and others, admiring their learning and holinesse, seeing my selfe but a meere babe in comparison of these men, and so I judge of my selfe still; but I remember a passage of Mr. Hookers in his conference with forty Ministers, said he, We see things fall cut in our Churches, which puts us upon further searches; so when I observed what use is made of this Thesis in England amongst our Sectaries, and what confusion is brought upon us, for any number of Sectaries will elect one (be he what he will) but Election gives the essence, Ordination is but an Adjunct, therefore may be left out; these practises have made me to search further into this opinion, this being my greatest trouble, that if I cast off the opinion, I must go crosse to such men, whom I doe so much admire and reverence; I am apt to thinke our holy Men did in this as our first ⟨p. 51⟩Reformers did in other points; Luther let some words fall against the Law, which might have beene spared; so our Divines in their definition of saving Faith, in opposition to the Papists; so in this point the Papists cryed up ordination too high, ours now are runne on the other side, and cry up popular election as high, and cry downe Ordination, but surely a medium might have beene found out, which had come nearer to the rule (with submission I speake it.)
Reverend Mr. Hooker lays down his Thesis thus, 1Election of the people rightly ordered by the rule of Christ (I wish he had set down this right order) gives the essentials to an officer, &c. but I doubt (with honour to this choice Saint) he hath not laid down his Thesis so clear, as Dr. Ames (whom he quotes after) I presume he intends the acceptation of the person elected must concur; nay, I will affirm the acceptation is as essential, as their election, for what if this, or that, or four Churches more choose I will refuse them all, if I please; if election gives the essentials, then it seems I must be a Pastor to that people, who elects me, will I, nill I; but this reverend Mr. Hooker will not own: then I say election doth not give the essentials. Secondly, I say my own acceptation, is as essential to my Call, as their election, therefore Dr. Ames lays it thus, 2Vocationis essentia est in electione Ecclesiae, & acceptation electi; but this is not material, for our Sectaries are forward enough to accept, if any will elect.
Reverend Mr. Hooker layes downe his Thesis thus, 1Election of the people rightly ordered by the rule of Christ (I wish he had set downe this right order) gives the essentials to an officer, &c. but I doubt (with honour to this choice Saint) he hath not layed downe his Thesis so cleare, as Dr. Ames (whom he quotes after) I presume he intends the acceptation of the person elected must concurre; nay, I will affirme the acceptation is as essential, as their election, for what if this, or that, or foure Churches more chuse I will refuse them all, if I please; if election gives the essentials, then it seems I must be a Pastor to that people, who elects me, wil I, nill I; but this reverend Mr. Hooker will not owne: then I say election doth not give the essentialls. Secondly, I say my own acceptation, is as essentiall to my Call, as their election, therefore Dr. Ames layes it thus, 2Vocationis essentia est in electione Ecclesiae, & acceptatione electi; but this is not material, for our Sectaries are forward enough to accept, if any will elect.
- 1Survey part. 2. pag. 66.
- 2Medul. Th. l. 1. c. 39. s. 32.
In searching out this truth, I shall desire to set by all men, and consult with the Scriptures; I will first search what texts we have for Election, then what for Ordination, and this I set down with my self, that if Ordination be but an Adjunct, & the election so essential, then the Texts for Election are far more clear, full; and those for Ordination more dark and rare; for an Adjunct, the meanest Logician knows, is but little in comparison of an essential cause; it doth consentire, but modo quodam; 2. It supposeth the subject complete in its essence before; 3. Therefore potest abesse; much might be spoken this way.
In searching out this truth, I shall desire to set by all men, and consult with the Scriptures; I wil first search what texts we have for Election, then what for Ordination, and this I set down with my self, that if Ordination be but an Adjunct, & the election so essentiall, then the Texts for Election are farre more cleare, full; and those for Ordination more dark and rare; for an Adjunct, the meanest Logician knowes, is but little in comparison of an essentiall cause; it doth consentire, but modo quodam; 2. It supposeth the subject compleat in its essence before; 3. Therefore potest abesse; much might be spoken this way.
The Texts I find for Election are three; neither do I observe our Divines to quote any more.
The Texts I finde for Election are three; neither doe I observe our Divines to quote any more.
1. The first is, Act. 1.23. where we have these things observable, as here are eleven Apostles in this election, but we allow those to choose, where there is no officer to guide them, and many times very weak persons.
2. It is very easy to choose one of these, for v. 21. It was one who had accompanied them from the time, &c. This was easy for the meanest to know, but to choose a man fit for a Pastor, requires more skill then so.
2. It is very easie to choose one of these, for v. 21. It was one who had accompanied them from the time, &c. This was easie for the meanest to know, but to choose a man fit for a Pastor, requires more skill then so.
3. If we observe it narrowly, they did not so properly elect the Apostle, for when they had appointed two, Joseph and Matthias suppose one should have asked Peter, or the rest, which of these is the Apostle? he must have said he could not tell, properly God made the election: then they knew who was the Apostle, like to some Corporations in the choice of a Mayor, the floor nominate two, but the Aldermen choose which they will have, whence the people say, The Aldermen choose the Mayor. 1. Something may here be gathered for popular election, but very different is this practise from ours; I could add other scruples, but I forbear.
3. If we observe it narrowly, they did not so properly elect the Apostle, for when they had appointed two, Joseph and Matthias suppose one should have asked Peter, or the rest, which of these is the Apostle? he must have said he could not tell, properly God made the election: then they knew who was the Apostle, like to some Corporations in the choice of a Mayor, the floore nominate two, but the Aldermen choose which they will have, whence the people say, The Aldermen choose the Mayor. 1. Something may here be gathered for popular election, but very different is this practise from ours; I could adde other scruples, but I forbeare.
2 The second place is Act. 6.3. a very clear place for the popular election of a Deacon, but the last words of the verse do very much shake this notion of Ordination, being but an adjunct, yea, it shakes the essential causality of popular election, Do ye look on, &c. but they add, whom We may appoint over this business. How do the Apostles appoint them over the business? It is by Ordination vers. 16. Those that do authoritatively appoint another, or others over some business, they put forth a causal virtue surely in that appointing; these appointed by this Act of Ordination [the Apostles did not not meddle here with the election] then the Apostles Ordination was more then an Adjunct.
2 The second place is Act. 6.3. a very cleare place for the popular election of a Deacon, but the last words of the verse do very much shake this notion of Ordination, being but an adjunct, yea, it shakes the essentiall causality of popular election, Doe yee looke on, &c. but they adde, whom Wee may appoint over this businesse. How doe the Apostles appoint them over the businesse? It is by Ordination vers. 16. Those that doe authoritatively appoint another, or others over some businesse, they put forth a causall vertue surely in that appointing; these appointed by this Act of Ordination [the Apostles did not not meddle here with the election] then the Apostles Ordination was more then an Adjunct.
From this place Divines argue commonly, If they may choose Deacons, then much more Pastors, to whom they are more engaged, must honour, maintain them, &c.
From this place Divines argue commonly, If they may choose Deacons, then much more Pastors, to whom they are more engaged, must honour, maintaine them, &c.
Thus we argue one while a majori, the people elected an Apostle, ergo, they may elect a Pastor; here now a minori, the people elect a Deacon, ergo, they may elect a Pastor, but then those Axioms one of them must be false, a majori licet [Greek or Hebrew] solummodo, & à minori solùm [Greek or Hebrew], both which experience proves to be false, and Logicians observe it; but put the case we should question this argument; The people may elect a Deacon, ergo, their Pastor; election followeth the judgement, and is guided by it, but must we needs suppose the people to be as able to judge, who is fit for a Pastor, as who is fit for a ⟨p. 53⟩Deacon? Dr. Ames saith, à minori ad majus, si quantitas probabilitatis intelligatur, semper concluditur affirmatè. Is this as probable? 1Sure it is less probable, that the people should be fit to judge of the fitness of a Pastor, then a Deacon. I am confident there are hundreds of Congregations in England, in which there are many real Saints, yet all the Jesuits in Rome might scatter themselves into these Congregations, and not be discerned, if the people were left alone to their own election: 2Hence therefore our Divines dare not trust the people alone with the election of an officer, but tells us they must have the counsel of the Presbyters, as Dr. Ames, and Mr. Cartwright upon Act. 14.23. Rhem. Test. We do not only give unto the Bishops (Scripture Bishops) Ordination, but also we make them the chief, and directors in the election, saith he, where is this practised?
Thus we argue one while a majori, the people elected an Apostle, ergo, they may elect a Pastor; here now a minori, the people elect a Deacon, ergo, they may elect a Pastor, but then those Axioms one of them must bee false, a majori licet 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 solummodo, & à minori solùm 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, both which experience proves to be false, and Logicians observe it; but put the case we should question this argument; The people may elect a Deacon, ergo, their Pastor; election followeth the judgement, and is guided by it, but must we needs suppose the people to be as able to judge, who is fit for a Pastor, as who is fit for a ⟨p. 53⟩Deacon? Dr. Ames saith, à minori ad majus, si quantitas probabilitatis intelligatur, semper concluditur affirmatè. Is this as probable? 1Sure it is lesse probable, that the people should be fit to judge of the fitnesse of a Pastor, then a Deacon. I am confident there are hundreds of Congregations in England, in which there are many reall Saints, yet all the Jesuits in Rome might scatter themselves into these Congregations, and not be discerned, if the people were left alone to their owne election: 2Hence therefore our Divines dare not trust the people alone with the election of an officer, but tells us they must have the counsell of the Presbyters, as Dr. Ames, and Mr. Cartwright upon Act. 14.23. Rhem. Test. We do not onely give unto the Bishops (Scripture Bishops) Ordination, but also we make them the chiefe, and directors in the election, saith he, where is this practised?
- 1Thes. log 143.
- 2Medul. l. 1. c. 39. s. 31. & Bel. ever, To. 2. l. 3. c. 2. s. 23.Medul. l. 1. c. 39. s. 31. & Bel. ener, To. 2. l. 3. c. 2. s. 23.
The third is that of Act. 14.23. [Greek or Hebrew], but certainly if we come to find out the substantives to this participle, they must be the same which were substantives to [Greek or Hebrew], and they were Paul and Barnabas: I know what is said about [Greek or Hebrew] to defend the peoples election, as the custom was taken from the Grecians; Dr. 1Ames saith [Greek or Hebrew] apud veteres idem sepe sonant, so it appears by that passage of Basil quoted by Chamier to prove, that no private person may baptise [Greek or Hebrew], but if it it be taken in that sense here, I do not know how it will pleasure the people, unless we should go cross to the grammatical construction.
The third is that of Act. 14.23. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, but certainly if we come to find out the substantives to this participle, they must be the same which were substantives to 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and they were Paul and Barnabas: I know what is said about 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 to defend the peoples election, as the custome was taken from the Grecians; Dr. 1Ames saith 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 apud veteres idem sepe sonant, so it appears by that passage of Basil quoted by Chamier to prove, that no private person may baptise 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, but if it it be taken in that sense here, I doe not know how it will pleasure the people, unlesse we should goe crosse to the gramaticall construction.
- 1To. 4. l. 5. c. 14. s. 65.
The sum is, 1there are no places brought for the peoples election, but those who are but shallow, will find enough from the Texts to wrangle very hard, though I am for the peoples election my self.
The summe is, 1there are no places brought for the peoples election, but those who are but shallow, will finde enough from the Texts to wrangle very hard, thouh I am for the peoples election my selfe.
- 1Zanchy in 4 praec. Calvin in loc. Piscat. in loc. obs. 2 Malcol. in loc. Diodat. in loc. English Annot. &c expound it of the ordination of Paul & Barnabas