Separation Examined.
pp. 1–111539 passagespart 6 of 14
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Though I could heartily wish all our Ministers would follow the practise of the Holland Churches, who cause all, 1who come to the Sacrament, to promise to subject to Discipline, yet for the present I say this, there is an implicit Covenant in all these Churches, and if you be afraid to speak to these persons first, whom you would have suspended, then go to the Minister, and carry sufficient Witnesses [as you must do in any Church] and ⟨p. 44⟩I am confident, without satisfaction given [no more can be required in any Church] thousands of the Presbyterial Ministers will keep away scandalous persons; [at least you are clear as I said before] yet to see these men separate for that, in which themselves are most to blame.
Though I could heartily wish all our Ministers would follow the practise of the Holland Churches, who cause all, 1who come to the Sacrament, to promise to subject to Discipline, yet for the present I say this, there is an implicite Covenant in all these Churches, and if you be afraid to speake to these persons first, whom you would have suspended, then goe to the Minister, and carry sufficient Witnesses [as you must doe in any Church] and ⟨p. 44⟩I am confident, without satisfaction given [no more can be required in any Church] thousands of the Presbyteriall Ministers will keepe away scandalous persons; [at least you are cleare as I said before] yet to see these men separate for that, in which themselves are most to blame.
- 1Apollon.
Obj. But they baptize all Children, making no difference though never so scandalous.
A. Though this is very seldom urged, yet because I would draw out all that can be said, I add this.
A. Though this is very seldome urged, yet because I would draw out all that can be said, I adde this.
For my own practise, I confess in this I differ from other men far better then my self, but yet were I a Member of some other Presbyterial Congregation, I should not dare to separate upon this ground.
For my owne practise, I confesse in this I differ from other men farre better then my selfe, but yet were I a Member of some other Presbyteriall Congregation, I should not dare to separate upon this ground.
1 It is granted by our Congregational men, 1that though persons be very wicked, yet so long as they live in visible Churches, and are not proceeded against, they may justly challenge the privileges of Church-Members: but I dare not deny them to be true visible Churches, in which there are many such, for there are many both real and visible Saints in such Churches, where these wicked men are.
1 It is granted by our Congregationall men, 1that though persons be very wicked, yet so long as they live in visible Churches, and are not proceeded against, they may justly challenge the priviledges of Church-Members: but I dare not deny them to be true visible Churches, in which there are many such, for there are many both reall and visible Saints in such Churches, where these wicked men are.
- 1Mr. Hook Survey, p. 3 p. 11.
Obj. But then this makes against your self, in denying some children Baptism.
Obj. But then this makes against your selfe, in denying some children Baptisme.
A. 1I answer; [as I have declared in that little Tract upon this question, which the uncivil carriage of some in the Congregation, when I had dealt lovingly with them in private before, forced me to print] I deny not them Baptism absolutely, but as I suspend them from one of the Seals, so I do from this also, till they will labour to get out of their gross ignorance, and scandalous conversations, and will subject themselves to Church-Discipline; so that I do [as say the London Ministers] separate in the Church, but not from the Church; as ⟨p. 45⟩the state of our lapsed Churches will give us leave: I desire to proceed against such, yet but gently, [as for Excommunication, that is a great work] having the advantage in the Church, that many good Ministers [better then my self] have not, viz. That the strongest Party in the Town is religious; but had many Presbyterial men the same advantage, I believe you should see they would be more strict then now they are. Congregations must be mended by degrees: to purge per vices in foul bodies, is better then at first to give Hellebore, Scammony, and such strong workers; it will cost abundance of prayer, wisdom, labour, meekness, to bring these Congregations fallen into this ignorance and profaneness for want of Catechizing, and Discipline; let the Bishops look to their account.
A. 1I answer; [as I have declared in that little Tract upon this question, which the uncivill carriage of some in the Congregation, when I had dealt lovingly with them in private before, forced me to print] I deny not them Baptisme absolutely, but as I suspend them from one of the Seales, so I doe from this also, till they will labour to get out of their grosse ignorance, and scandalous conversations, and will subject themselves to Church-Discipline; so that I doe [as say the London Ministers] separate in the Church, but not from the Church; as ⟨p. 45⟩the state of our lapsed Churches will give us leave: I desire to proceed against such, yet but gently, [as for Excommunication, that is a great worke] having the advantage in the Church, that many good Ministers [better then my selfe] have not, viz. That the strongest Party in the Towne is religious; but had many Presbyteriall men the same advantage, I beleeve you should see they would be more strict then now they are. Congregations must be mended by degrees: to purge per vices in foule bodies, is better then at first to give Hellebore, Scammony, and such strong workers; it will cost abundance of prayer, wisdome, labour, meeknesse, to bring these Congregations fallen into this ignorance and prophanenesse for want of Catechizing, and Discipline; let the Bishops looke to their account.
Besides, divers Presbyterial Ministers do examine their people before they will Baptize, yea, and I have heard one who is esteemed a rigid Presbyterian say, That if the Presbyterial Government were settled, they would Baptize none, but they would have the parents; 1. Examined in point of knowledge. 2. If they were scandalous, that they should confess their sin. 3. Promise for the time to come to reform. 4. That if persons would refuse to submit to Church-Discipline, they would deny them the Lords Supper.
Besides, divers Presbyteriall Ministers doe examine their people before they will Baptize, yea, and I have heard one who is esteemed a rigid Presbyterian say, That if the Presbyteriall Government were setled, they would Baptize none, but they would have the parents; 1. Examined in point of knowledge. 2. If they were scandalous, that they should confesse their sinne. 3. Promise for the time to come to reforme. 4. That if persons would refuse to submit to Church-Discipline, they would deny them the Lords Supper.
Since then it is in the hearts of many to reform, and it is the thing they would gladly have power to do, I think it is very unwarrantable upon this ground to separate from them; besides, there are many reasons they give for Baptizing of all that do but profess Christ, which though they are not satisfactory unto me, so as to give the Seal of the Govenant to one, who saith, He believes in Christ, but yet is grossly ignorant, scandalous, &c. yet their reasons prevail with me so, as to be very charitable to those, who do Baptize upon those grounds; if there be any sin in it, let the Minister look to that, that is not your fault.
Since then it is in the hearts of many to reforme, and it is the thing they would gladly have power to doe, I thinke it is very unwarrantable upon this ground to separate from them; besides, there are many reasons they give for Baptizing of all that doe but professe Christ, which though they are not satisfactory unto me, so as to give the Seale of the Govenant to one, who saith, He beleeves in Christ, but yet is grosly ignorant, scandalous, &c. yet their reasons prevaile with me so, as to be very charitable to those, who doe Baptize upon those grounds; if there be any sinne in it, let the Minister looke to that, that is not your fault.
Certainly, people think it is a very easy thing to reform Churches, it may be done with a wet finger; but if they were in the place of Ministers, and had what knowledge is fit for the place, they would find it a hard Work, especially some Churches.
Certainly, people thinke it is a very easie thing to reforme Churches, it may be done with a wet finger; but if they were in the place of Ministers, and had what knowledge is fit for the place, they would finde it a hard Worke, especially some Churches.
So then as yet we find no grounds warrantable for this Separation: I come to the last; The place of meeting, it is Idolatrous, and I know not what.
So then as yet we finde no grounds warrantable for this Separation: I come to the last; The place of meeting, it is Idolatrous, and I know not what.
I thought here to have given in some answers to this absurd cavil, but the practise of this generation hath given in a full answer; for it was observed in a neighbour Town, the Minister not preaching upon a day of Thanksgiving, a Trooper got into the Pulpit, and did, &c. This was such a pretty thing, that divers of the Separatists in the Town, who had not been in the Steeple-house for some years before, ran in haste, and became Auditors of the Trooper. Another of them, who called himself the King of England, came to me, and offered to supply my place [the man was mad, as error had made him mad, but for all civill actions sober enough:] now from these practises I gather, that either it is no sin to meet in a Steeple-house [as they call it] or else they have no good consciences, these practises are frequent, if Troopers get into Pulpits.
I thought here to have given in some answers to this absurd cavill, but the practise of this generation hath given in a full answer; for it was observed in a neighbour Towne, the Minister not preaching upon a day of Thanksgiving, a Trooper got into the Pulpit, and did, &c. This was such a pretty thing, that divers of the Separatists in the Towne, who had not beene in the Steeple-house for some yeares before, ranne in haste, and became Auditors of the Trooper. Another of them, who called himselfe the King of England, came to me, and offered to supply my place [the man was mad, as errour had made him mad, but for all civill actions sober enough:] now from these practises I gather, that either it is no sinne to meet in a Steeple-house [as they call it] or else they have no good consciences, these practises are frequent, if Troopers get into Pulpits.
As yet then we have found no sufficient ground for separation; I shall desire yet to come nearer, and request of these persons, what it is they would have, which way may we be brought to an union; if what they propound be rational, and will be borne out by Scripture, we shall desire to come up to them; for I am sure in that posture we now stand, nothing can go forward. I have not their proposals before me, only I may surmise what they would have, and accordingly I will set them down, and examine them.
As yet then we have found no sufficient ground for separation; I shall desire yet to come nearer, and request of these persons, what it is they would have, which way may wee bee brought to an union; if what they propound bee rationall, and will be borne out by Scripture, wee shall defire to come up to them; for I am sure in that posture wee now stand, nothing can goe forward. I have not their proposals before me, onely I may surmise what they would have, and accordingly I will set them downe, and examine them.
First, 1We would have Ministers lay down their former Ordination, and come join with us in an explicit Covenant, then we will call them and ordain them, and this will be one great way to union.
First, 1We would have Ministers lay downe their former Ordination, and come joyne with us in an explicite Covenant, then wee will call them and ordaine them, and this will be one great way to union.
- 1The Separatists first proposal.The Separatists first proposall.
Very good, but are all the Separatists of this mind, do they require no more of their Ministers? I doubt you should have put in one clause more, i.e. They must not expect any maintenance, but preach &c. freely. What else is the reason that many of you do so cry out of Ministers, because they require maintenance of the people, when as the Spirit of God hath left so many express Texts in the Scripture for it [foreseeing this generation, who run upon express Texts.] What is the reason ⟨p. 47⟩divers of you keep back your tithes (the maintenance the State for present allows) from the Ministers in the places where you live? but if you be real, 1that you would according to the Word, allow honourable maintenance, 1 Tim. 5.17, 18. Then I shall come to your proposal.
Very good, but are all the Separatists of this minde, doe they require no more of their Ministers? I doubt you should have put in one clause more, i.e. They must not expect any maintenance, but preach &c. freely. What else is the reason that many of you do so cry out of Ministers, because they require maintenance of the people, when as the Spirit of God hath left so many expresse Texts in the Scripture for it [foreseeing this generation, who runne upon expresse Texts.] What is the reason ⟨p. 47⟩divers of you keepe backe your tythes (the maintenance the State for present allows) from the Ministers in the places where you live? but if you be reall, 1that you would according to the Word, allow honourable maintenance, 1 Tim. 5.17, 18. Then I shall come to your proposall.
- 1They often allege Act. 20.35. &c. Briefly I answer, 1. These Elders coming but lately out of heathenism, could not in an ordinary way attain to Ministerial abilities in so short a time, therefore God did in an extraordinary way help them. 2. Before they were converted, they had other trades, whereby they lived in their heathenism, so they could follow other trades, if need were, but we have not other trades. 3. Our Churches are not so poor, so there is no such need. I could add more, but this is enough. But these ignorant men know not the weight of the work of the Ministry.
Answ. 1. As I made use of one of your principles before, so now I will make use of another; you admit nothing for which you have not express Scripture. Hence you throw away Infant-baptism, Sabbath, &c. Now I pray give us an express Text [precept or example] where we have it proved, That Ministers first chosen by the people [or had the consent of the people freely afterwards, though most of ours were elected at their first coming.] 2. Have Ordination for the substance, freely acknowledging the accidental corruptions. 3. Men very well qualified, as any since the Apostles days. 4. Whom God hath used instrumentally to convert divers, or to build up those who were converted: 5. Have administered the Ordinances for many years; that yet after all this, they must lay down their Ministerial call, join with you, &c.
Answ. 1. As I made use of one of your principles before, so now I wil make use of another; you admit nothing for which you have not expresse Scripture. Hence you throw away Infant-baptisme, Sabbath, &c. Now I pray give us an expresse Text [precept or example] where we have it proved, That Ministers first chosen by the people [or had the consent of the people freely afterwards, though most of ours were elected at their first coming.] 2. Have Ordination for the substance, freely acknowledging the accidentall corruptions. 3. Men very well qualified, as any since the Apostles dayes. 4. Whom God hath used instrumentally to convert divers, or to build up those who were converted: 5. Have administred the Ordinances for many yeares; that yet after all this, they must lay downe their Ministeriall call, joyne with you, &c.
I say, I challenge all the Separatists in England to give me one express Text: when you have done this, we shall bethink our selves.
I say, I challenge all the Separatists in England to give me one expresse Text: when you have done this, we shall bethinke our selves.
I call now for express Texts, for such is your own principle; if that be a true principle, then I hope it is one for us, as well as for you. I put this once to a Separatist, who told me, this it was they required of Ministers: but the poor man could not bring one, and because he had held me to this rule of express Texts in another case [though I soon made him confess, that necessary consequence would hold, by an instance I gave him; Suppose it had not been recorded of Christ, that ever he ate or drank, yet being it is recorded in Scripture, that he was true man, like to us in all things, but sin; hence I would argue, If so, then he did eat and drink, I believe that though it be not expressly written, the man yielded] I held him to his own principle here, but the man seeing himself so foiled, grew froward and angry, so I left him. To see the ⟨p. 48⟩frame of these mens spirits, we may soon answer their reasons, but their wills they hold: It is no disputing against mens wills.
I call now for expresse Texts, for such is your owne principle; if that be a true principle, then I hope it is one for us, as well as for you. I put this once to a Separatist, who told me, this it was they required of Ministers: but the poore man could not bring one, and because he had held me to this rule of expresse Texts in another case [though I soone made him confesse, that necessary consequence would hold, by an instance I gave him; Suppose it had not beene recorded of Christ, that ever he ate or dranke, yet being it is recorded in Scripture, that he was true man, like to us in all things, but sinne; hence I would argue, If so, then he did eat and drinke, I beleeve that though it be not expresely written, the man yeelded] I held him to his owne principle here, but the man seeing himselfe so foiled, grew froward and angry, so I left him. To see the ⟨p. 48⟩frame of these mens spirits, we may soone answer their reasons, but their wills they hold: It is no disputing against mens wills.
2. 1Dr. Ames, Mr. Hooker, and many of our Congregational men affirm, That the election of the people gives the essentials to an officer, and that ordination is but an adjunct: And though there may be some defect in the peoples election at first, yet there may be the substance of it, and that will save it, or an after consent. See the places before quoted, pag. 5. If so, then there will be few of the Ministers of England excepted, who are not true Ministers: This I am sure you freely assent to, and make Ordination a thing not worth the regarding; why then do you keep such a stir at that, which you look upon as little, when as they have that, which you say, gives the essentials to an officer; what have they the essentials of an officer, and must they go and lay down their call? you must rather say, Let them lay down their election, then their ordination; but in saying so, you cut the throat of your own Objection; for if they have election, then they have the essentials of a Minister, and then they are Ministers, your own selves being judges. You would make Ministers very simple men to lay down their former Call, and you would give them a Call, which they had before, elected before, and no more now.
2. 1Dr. Ames, Mr. Hooker, and many of our Congregationall men affirme, That the election of the people gives the essentialls to an officer, and that ordination is but an adjunct: And though there may bee some defect in the peoples election at first, yet there may be the substance of it, and that will save it, or an after consent. See the places before quoted, pag. 5. If so, then there will be few of the Ministers of England excepted, who are not true Ministers: This I am sure you freely assent to, and make Ordination a thing not worth the regarding; why then doe you keepe such a stirre at that, which you looke upon as little, when as they have that, which you say, gives the essentials to an officer; what have they the essentials of an officer, and must they go and lay downe their call? you must rather say, Let them lay downe their election, then their ordination; but in saying so, you cut the throat of your owne Objection; for if they have election, then they have the essentials of a Minister, and then they are Ministers, your owne selves being judges. You would make Ministers very simple men to lay downe their former Call, and you would give them a Call, which they had before, elected before, and no more now.
Obj. But what we judge is one thing, they look upon their Ordination as chief, and think they stand by that.
Obj. But what we judge is one thing, they looke upon their Ordination as chiefe, and thinke they stand by that.
Ans. What is that to you what they think, they have that which, your selves say, gives the essence, so that they are Ministers, you cannot deny it, unless you will cross your own Position; and let them think so, why should this trouble you? Suppose a Deacon thinks his Ordination gives him the essentials of his Office, the people think their election doth; what then, will you separate from him, and not go to him for relief in case of want? he hath Election and Ordination, so that to be sure a Deacon he is: the case is the same with our Ministers, 1see Mr. Burroughs urging this instance.
Ans. What is that to you what they thinke, they have that which, your selves say, gives the essence, so that they are Ministers, you cannot deny it, unlesse you will crosse your owne Position; and let them thinke so, why should this trouble you? Suppose a Deacon thinkes his Ordination gives him the essentials of his Office, the people thinke their election doth; what then, will you separate from him, and not goe to him for reliefe in case of want? he hath Election and Ordination, so that to be sure a Deacon he is: the case is the same with our Ministers, 1see Mr. Burroughs urging this instance.
- 1Iren. p. 183 184.
To cavil here, they were indeed elected, but not by the godly Party, it is very false, first of hundreds of the Ministers, some visible Saints had their Vote, or gave after their consent; I believe many of you, who now separate, did join in the Call of the Minister, from whom you now separate, which is worse; but however this is a feeble Objection.
To cavill here, they were indeed elected, but not by the godly Party, it is very false, first of hundreds of the Ministers, some visible Saints had their Vote, or gave after their consent; I beleeve many of you, who now separate, did joyne in the Call of the Minister, from whom you now separate, which is worse; but however this is a feeble Objection.
3 Before they renounce their Ordination, you must prove they have not so much as the substance, and essence of that Ordinance; they will acknowledge accidental corruptions, but still affirm they have the essence, and this none of you all have disproved.
3 Before they renounce their Ordination, you must prove they have not so much as the substance, and essence of that Ordinance; they will acknowledge accidentall corruptions, but still affirme they have the essence, and this none of you all have disproved.
4 In this which you require you intimate, that they are no Ministers at all, for if they be true Ministers, though there were something humane mixed in their Call, their work must be to renounce those humane mixtures [which they do] but if they be not true Ministers, have not so much as the essentials of the Office, then they are no Ministers at all; Consequently, we have had no ordinances at all; if you say, Yes, I pray tell me, how may any one, who is not an Officer dispense the Seals, preach Authoritatively, &c? You practise indeed some of you as if he might, but it is a thing abhorred of all men, both Classical, and Congregational; God is a God of order in his House, as well as in the world: In the Civill State none must be Justices of Peace, unless set apart to the Office, 1every man cannot make Warrants, nor execute Justice [yet some men have as much knowledge in the Law, as many Justices have] but in the Church of God, there must be no order. Our Ministers then have been but private men, all this while they have dispensed the Ordinances: it is the Call to a Place, or Office, that makes men Officers or public persons, but Call they have none by your esteem.
4 In this which you require you intimate, that they are no Ministers at all, for if they be true Ministers, though there were something humane mixed in their Call, their worke must be to renounce those humane mixtures [which they doe] but if they be not true Ministers, have not so much as the essentials of the Office, then they are no Ministers at all; Consequently, wee have had no ordinances at all; if you say, Yes, I pray tell me, how may any one, who is not an Officer dispense the Seales, preach Authoritatively, &c? You practise indeed some of you as if hee might, but it is a thing abhorred of all men, both Classicall, and Congregationall; God is a God of order in his House, as well as in the world: In the Civill State none must be Justices of Peace, unlesse set apart to the Office, 1every man cannot make Warrants, nor execute Justice [yet some men have as much knowledge in the Law, as many Justices have] but in the Church of God, there must be no order. Our Ministers then have been but private men, all this while they have dispensed the Ordinances: it is the Call to a Place, or Office, that makes men Officers or publick persons, but Call they have none by your esteeme.
Mr. Hooker speaks home to this point: he laid down this conclusion; That there is a causal virtue put forth in a subordinate way under Christ, to bring in the specific being of an Ecclesiastical Office to a person, &c. After three things premised he comes to a fourth, viz. Persons though gifted and fitted every way, be they never so many, they are not therefore Officers.
Mr. Hooker speakes home to this point: he layed downe this conclusion; That there is a causall vertue put forth in a subordinate way under Christ, to bring in the specificall being of an Ecclesiasticall Office to a person, &c. After three things premised he comes to a fourth, viz. Persons though gifted and fitted every way, be they never so many, they are not therefore Officers.
A call they must have, without which none can warrantably do any act, which belongs to an Officer.
A call they must have, without which none can warrantably doe any act, which belongs to an Officer.
Without this, whatever is done in that behalf is void, and of none effect.
Without this, whatever is done in that behalfe is voyd, and of none effect.
The validity of an outward Call appears in this, if it proceeds from such, who may give it by rule, because whosoever hath regularly received this Call, he is then a true Officer, though not inwardly graced, and fitted worthily to such a place, &c.
The validity of an outward Call appeares in this, if it proceeds from such, who may give it by rule, because whosoever hath regularly received this Call, he is then a true Officer, though not inwardly graced, and fitted worthily to such a place, &c.
Afterwards he speaks to this purpose again; 1It is a Frenzy of the Anabaptists, which begins to labour with the loathsomeness of it self, that any Christian gifted, who can teach, or administer a word of instruction to win a Disciple after him, that he in a corner may Baptize him; but as Paul said of Jannes and Jambres, their madness is made to appear to all, &c.
Afterwards he speakes to this purpose againe; 1It is a Frenzie of the Anabaptists, which begins to labour with the loathsomenesse of it selfe, that any Christian gifted, who can teach, or administer a word of instruction to win a Disciple after him, that he in a corner may Baptize him; but as Paul said of Jannes and Jambres, their madnesse is made to appeare to all, &c.
- 1Pag. 3. p. 9
If the Lord Christ in his infinite Wisdom, and Kingly care, conceived it necessary for the honour of the place, and the execution of the work of a Deacon, to appoint choice men, and solemn Ordination to Authorize them to the work, &c.
If the Lord Christ in his infinite Wisdome, and Kingly care, conceived it necessary for the honour of the place, and the execution of the worke of a Deacon, to appoint choice men, and solemne Ordination to Authorize them to the worke, &c.
The sum is, the practise is but loathsome, and the Acts of such men are void, who do such things as properly belong to a Church-Officer, and are not called to the Office; thus Mr. Hooker.
The summe is, the practise is but loathsome, and the Acts of such men are voyd, who doe such things as properly belong to a Church-Officer, and are not called to the Office; thus Mr. Hooker.
Mr. 1Cotton he speaks against such practices, so doth the stream of all Divines, Calvin, Zanchy, Perkins, Ames, &c.
Mr. 1Cotton he speakes against such practices, so doth the streame of all Divines, Calvin, Zanchy, Perkins, Ames, &c.
- 1Keys, p. 6 Inst. l. 4 c. 15. s. 20 In par. 2. 1. Vol. p. 766. Bell. ever. to. 3. l. 2. c. 2.Keys, p. 6 Inst. l. 4 c. 15. s. 20 In par. 2. 1. Vol. p. 766. Bell. ener. to. 3. l. 2. c. 2.
Hence then if you null their Call, you must null all the Acts they have done as Ministers, and you will be troubled (as I said before) which way to come into order; you had better therefore be quiet, and if you will needs quarrel with their Ordination, yet content your selves with their election, which you say is the chief.
Hence then if you null their Call, you must null all the Acts they have done as Ministers, and you will be troubled (as I said before) which way to come into order; you had better therefore be quiet, and if you wil needs quarrell with their Ordination, yet content your selves with their election, which you say is the chiefe.
Before I pass on to my last answer, let me a little examine this Thesis, viz. Election gives the essentials, and Ordination is but an Adjunct. Heretofore I have indeed been of this opinion, never much weighing the thing, being wholly carried away with the Authority of Dr. Ames, and Mr. Hooker, and others, admiring their learning and holiness, seeing my self but a mere babe in comparison of these men, and so I judge of my self still; but I remember a passage of Mr. Hookers in his conference with forty Ministers, said he, We see things fall cut in our Churches, which puts us upon further searches; so when I observed what use is made of this Thesis in England amongst our Sectaries, and what confusion is brought upon us, for any number of Sectaries will elect one (be he what he will) but Election gives the essence, Ordination is but an Adjunct, therefore may be left out; these practises have made me to search further into this opinion, this being my greatest trouble, that if I cast off the opinion, I must go cross to such men, whom I do so much admire and reverence; I am apt to think our holy Men did in this as our first ⟨p. 51⟩Reformers did in other points; Luther let some words fall against the Law, which might have been spared; so our Divines in their definition of saving Faith, in opposition to the Papists; so in this point the Papists cried up ordination too high, ours now are run on the other side, and cry up popular election as high, and cry down Ordination, but surely a medium might have been found out, which had come nearer to the rule (with submission I speak it.)
Before I passe on to my last answer, let me a little examine this Thesis, viz. Election gives the essentials, and Ordination is but an Adjunct. Heretofore I have indeed been of this opinion, never much weighing the thing, being wholly carried away with the Authority of Dr. Ames, and Mr. Hooker, and others, admiring their learning and holinesse, seeing my selfe but a meere babe in comparison of these men, and so I judge of my selfe still; but I remember a passage of Mr. Hookers in his conference with forty Ministers, said he, We see things fall cut in our Churches, which puts us upon further searches; so when I observed what use is made of this Thesis in England amongst our Sectaries, and what confusion is brought upon us, for any number of Sectaries will elect one (be he what he will) but Election gives the essence, Ordination is but an Adjunct, therefore may be left out; these practises have made me to search further into this opinion, this being my greatest trouble, that if I cast off the opinion, I must go crosse to such men, whom I doe so much admire and reverence; I am apt to thinke our holy Men did in this as our first
Reverend Mr. Hooker lays down his Thesis thus, 1Election of the people rightly ordered by the rule of Christ (I wish he had set down this right order) gives the essentials to an officer, &c. but I doubt (with honour to this choice Saint) he hath not laid down his Thesis so clear, as Dr. Ames (whom he quotes after) I presume he intends the acceptation of the person elected must concur; nay, I will affirm the acceptation is as essential, as their election, for what if this, or that, or four Churches more choose I will refuse them all, if I please; if election gives the essentials, then it seems I must be a Pastor to that people, who elects me, will I, nill I; but this reverend Mr. Hooker will not own: then I say election doth not give the essentials. Secondly, I say my own acceptation, is as essential to my Call, as their election, therefore Dr. Ames lays it thus, 2Vocationis essentia est in electione Ecclesiae, & acceptation electi; but this is not material, for our Sectaries are forward enough to accept, if any will elect.
Reverend Mr. Hooker layes downe his Thesis thus, 1Election of the people rightly ordered by the rule of Christ (I wish he had set downe this right order) gives the essentials to an officer, &c. but I doubt (with honour to this choice Saint) he hath not layed downe his Thesis so cleare, as Dr. Ames (whom he quotes after) I presume he intends the acceptation of the person elected must concurre; nay, I will affirme the acceptation is as essential, as their election, for what if this, or that, or foure Churches more chuse I will refuse them all, if I please; if election gives the essentials, then it seems I must be a Pastor to that people, who elects me, wil I, nill I; but this reverend Mr. Hooker will not owne: then I say election doth not give the essentialls. Secondly, I say my own acceptation, is as essentiall to my Call, as their election, therefore Dr. Ames layes it thus, 2Vocationis essentia est in electione Ecclesiae, & acceptatione electi; but this is not material, for our Sectaries are forward enough to accept, if any will elect.
- 1
In searching out this truth, I shall desire to set by all men, and consult with the Scriptures; I will first search what texts we have for Election, then what for Ordination, and this I set down with my self, that if Ordination be but an Adjunct, & the election so essential, then the Texts for Election are far more clear, full; and those for Ordination more dark and rare; for an Adjunct, the meanest Logician knows, is but little in comparison of an essential cause; it doth consentire, but modo quodam; 2. It supposeth the subject complete in its essence before; 3. Therefore potest abesse; much might be spoken this way.
In searching out this truth, I shall desire to set by all men, and consult with the Scriptures; I wil first search what texts we have for Election, then what for Ordination, and this I set down with my self, that if Ordination be but an Adjunct, & the election so essentiall, then the Texts for Election are farre more cleare, full; and those for Ordination more dark and rare; for an Adjunct, the meanest Logician knowes, is but little in comparison of an essentiall cause; it doth consentire, but modo quodam; 2. It supposeth the subject compleat in its essence before; 3. Therefore potest abesse; much might be spoken this way.
The Texts I find for Election are three; neither do I observe our Divines to quote any more.
The Texts I finde for Election are three; neither doe I observe our Divines to quote any more.
1. The first is, Act. 1.23. where we have these things observable, as here are eleven Apostles in this election, but we allow those to choose, where there is no officer to guide them, and many times very weak persons.