A85314:37
Separation examined
Separation examined: or, a treatise wherein the grounds for separation from the ministry and churches of England are weighed, and found too light. The practise proved to be not only unwarrantable, but likewise so hurtful to the churches, that church-reformation cannot with any comfort go forward, so long as such separation is tolerated. Also an humble request presented to the congregational divines, that since the differences between them and the classical-divines are very small they would please to strike in with the classical-divines in carrying on the work of reformation, before the inundation of these corrupt opinions, have destroyed both ordinances and religion. / By Gi. Firmin minister to the church in Shalford in essex.Separation examined: or, a treatise vvherein the grounds for separation from the ministry and churches of England are weighed, and found too light. The practise proved to be not onely unwarrantable, but likewise so hurtful to the churches, that church-reformation cannot with any comfort go forward, so long as such separation is tolerated. Also an humble request presented to the congregational divines, that since the differences between them and the classical-divines are very small they would please to strike in with the classical-divines in carrying on the worke of reformation, before the inundation of these corrupt opinions, have destroyed both ordinances and religion. / By Gi. Firmin minister to the church in Shalford in essex.
London: printed by R.I. for Stephen Bowtell, 1652
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
By this time, I hope I shall be no rank Independent: But where is then my thanging of my principles? let these men prove it, for I am the same still, only since I read Mr. Hudson, I do somewhat waver about the first subject of the Keys and this is all my change.
By this time, I hope I shall be no ranke Independent: But where is then my thanging of my principles? let these men prove it, for I am the same still, onely since I read Mr. Hudson, I doe somewhat waver about the first subject of the Keyes and this is all my change.
That my mind may be cleared against whom I write; I observe Separatists are not all of a size; some separate from Ministers & Churches, and get into their private houses, own no officers, but please themselves with their own gifts and opinions; these are the persons whom I chiefly aim at, as such that so trouble us, that no Church-discipline can hold so long as they stand.
That my minde may be cleared against whom I write; I observe Separatists are not all of a size; some separate from Ministers & Churches, and get into their private houses, owne no officers, but please themselves with their owne gifts and opinions; these are the persons whom I chiefly aime at, as such that so trouble us, that no Church-discipline can hold so long as they stand.
Others live in places where there are visible and real Saints, the Ministry godly, and able, yea, it may be called to the place by these persons, but because they cannot have all they would picking a quarrel with the Ordination of their Minister, &c. they choose some other Minister in some other Town, and so depart from the Presbyterial to a Congregational Church, continuing still in the same Parish; It is well these men hold up Ordinances and Officers, yet the grounds of their practice the ensuing Discourse will try. I am sure, peace and unity among Churches cannot possibly stand with this practice; it is very sad that we should not yield a little, where we may, nay where we ought, for peace with our brethren whom we cannot but judge holy and sincere.
Others live in places where there are visible and reall Saints, the Ministry godly, and able, yea, it may be called to the place by these persons, but because they cannot have all they would picking a quarrell with the Ordination of their Minister, &c. they choose some other Minister in some other Towne, and so depart from the Prebyterial to a Congregational Church, continuing still in the same Parish; It is well these men hold up Ordinances and Officers, yet the grounds of their practice the ensuing Discourse will try. I am sure, peace and unity among Churches cannot possibly stand with this practice; it is very sad that we should not yeeld a little, where we may, nay where we ought, for peace with our brethren whom we cannot but judge holy and sincere.
If there should sometimes fall out a quotation somewhat sharp, yet I pray do not think that I apply it to all Separatists, but to some among them, who may deserve it.
If there should sometimes fall out a quotation somewhat sharp, yet I pray doe not thinke that I apply it to all Separatists, but to some among them, who may deserve it.
What success my poor endeavours shall find, I know not, I look for little good they shall do amongst the Separatists, who with an imperious scorn neglect to listen to, or read any thing, which tends to overthrow their practice; and though they be so confuted, as they are not able to answer a word, yet they scorn to acknowledge their error, and return to the Congregations, from which they have separated, which to me is a clear demonstration, that however these men pretend conscience, yet it is no such thing; for were these men lead by a pure conscience, considering how they separate from holy men, such also as have been instruments of their souls good, considering also how they weaken their hands, grieve their spirits, they would hear, read, pray, take any course, that they might be sure to be found in the truth. 1But I leave the success to God, my desire was, to serve my Generation, and there I rest.
What successe my poore endeavours shall finde, I know not, I looke for little good they shall doe amongst the Separatists, who with an imperious scorn neglect to listen to, or read any thing, which tends to overthrow their practice; and though they be so confuted, as they are not able to answer a word, yet they scorne to acknowledge their error, and returne to the Congregations, from which they have separated, which to me is a clear demonstration, that however these men pretend conscience, yet it is no such thing; for were these men lead by a pure conscience, considering how they separate from holy men, such also as have beene instruments of their soules good, considering also how they weaken their hands, grieve their spirits, they would heare, read, pray, take any course, that they might be sure to be found in the truth. 1But I leave the successe to God, my desire was, to serve my Generation, and there I rest.
Separation Examined.
I Will not trouble my self to prove that there is a visible Church upon the Earth, or true visible Churches in England, I think there are none that own the Scriptures, who will deny the former, though there are some who deny the latter, unless I mean the Congregational Churches, which they will acknowledge to be Churches, but none else; yet many of those, whom I write against, do not own them, for though they have opportunity, and may join with such Churches, yet they refuse to do so, being unwilling (I perceive) to come under, or maintain any Officers; I wish there be not too strong arguments to prove, that Covetousness and Ambition reign too much amongst this kind of Separatists, yet because the proving that there are true visible Churches in England, will be of great consequence to the following Discourse (as being the ground-work of it:) I will therefore produce one Argument to prove it, and if I can prove that, then it will necessarily follow, there is a true visible Church on the earth; which (as I said) I thought no Christian dares deny. But what da•es not the vile heart of man think, say, or do, if God give it up, to its own blindness, and wickedness?
I Will not trouble my selfe to prove that there is a visible Church upon the Earth, or true visible Churches in England, I thinke there are none that owne the Scriptures, who will deny the former, though there are some who deny the latter, unlesse I meane the Congregationall Churches, which they will acknowledge to be Churches, but none else; yet many of those, whom I write against, doe not owne them, for though they have opportunity, and may joyne with such Churches, yet they refuse to doe so, being unwilling (I perceive) to come under, or maintaine any Officers; I wish there be not too strong arguments to prove, that Covetousnesse and Ambition reigne too much amongst this kind of Separatists, yet because the proving that there are true visible Churches in England, will be of great consequence to the following Discourse (as being the ground-work of it:) I will therefore produce one Argument to prove it, and if I can prove that, then it will necessarily follow, there is a true visible Church on the earth; which (as I said) I thought no Christian dares deny. But what da•es not the vile heart of man think, say, or doe, if God give it up, to its owne blindnesse, and wickednesse?
Master Burroughs making mention of Schusselburgius, 1who collected the Sects, Opinions, and ways of men soon after Luther saith, There is not any one strange Opinion amongst us now, but you shall find it amongst them in terminis; only I remember not that one that hath taken some, who though they acknowledge the Scripture, yet think there is no visible Church on the earth.
Master Burroughs making mention of Schusselburgius, 1who collected the Sects, Opinions, and wayes of men soone after Luther saith, There is not any one strange Opinion amongst us now, but you shall finde it amongst them in terminis; onely I remember not that one that hath taken some, who though they acknowledge the Scripture, yet thinke there is no visible Church on the earth.
- 1Iren. pag. 236.
Many were the errors that were confuted, condemned in the first Synod in New England, which errors I find here in England, but there was not this error amongst them all (to my remembrance:) it was wont to be said of Africa, that every ⟨p. 2⟩year it produced a new Monster, but now it must be said of England, that it hath produced such a Spiritual Monster, as no Nation, that owned the Scriptures, ever did before. The Lord save us from our own hearts. But I will now prove the Thesis, as I said before, there are true visible Churches in England.
Many were the errours that were confuted, condemned in the first Synod in New England, which errours I finde here in England, but there was not this errour amongst them all (to my remembrance:) it was wont to be said of Africa, that every ⟨p. 2⟩yeare it produced a new Monster, but now it must be said of England, that it hath produced such a Spirituall Monster, as no Nation, that owned the Scriptures, ever did before. The Lord save us from our owne hearts. But I will now prove the Thesis, as I said before, there are true visible Churches in England.
Where there are many Societies of visible Saints, and true Ministers, consenting together to worship God in his holy Ordinances, there are true visible Churches.
But in England, there are many Societies of visible Saints, and true Ministers consenting together to worship God in his holy Ordinances, Ergo, in England there are many true visible Churches.
The Major is so plain, that none who know what a visible Church is, and what the Churches in the Gospel were, but must needs yield it.
The Major is so plaine, that none who know what a visible Church is, and what the Churches in the Gospel were, but must needs yeeld it.
Here are the essential causes of a Church; Ergo, here is a Church.
Here are the essentiall causes of a Church; Ergo, here is a Church.
First, here is the material cause, Visible Saints, the Ministers also, as visible Saints, help make up the matter; but as they are Ministers they make the Churches Organical (which is more.)
First, here is the materiall cause, Visible Saints, the Ministers also, as visible Saints, help make up the matter; but as they are Ministers they make the Churches Organicall (which is more.)
2 Here is the formal cause, their consenting to worship God, &c. he that yields the essential causes, and yet denies the effect, hath lost his reason.
2 Here is the formall cause, their consenting to worship God, &c. he that yeelds the essentiall causes, and yet denies the effect, hath lost his reason.
A Church, is any company of Saints in body, to set up what Ordinances of God they know; This is a true Church, and here God dwells, 1saith Mr. Burroughs.
A Church, is any company of Saints in body, to set up what Ordinances of God they know; This is a true Church, and here God dwels, 1saith Mr. Burroughs.
- 1In Hos. 8.1.